We live in Carmel and decided to check out Amore Mio after seeing it on TikTok and boy, did it live up to the hype! Everything we tried was absolutely incredible. I ordered the Sicilia, which is apparently their most popular choice, and it is easily one of the best sandwiches I've ever had. You could taste every single ingredient, and it was incredibly fresh. My girlfriend loved her Caprese Panini, and they were nice enough to let us add turkey to it! To drink, the Mango Passion Fruit juice was so tasty and refreshing. We capped off lunch by sharing a slice of tiramisu, which was the perfect size to end the meal on a sweet note. Heads up: for what seems like a quick walk-up shop, there is a bit of a wait (definitely longer than 10 minutes), but it is 100% worth it for food this high-quality. We will absolutely be back! read more

See all

Imagine stepping into a cafe that instantly transports you to Italy with the Aroma of coffee & and delicious Italian sandwiches! If that's the vibe looking for you have to take a a trip toAmore Mio Café in Clermont (between Speedway and Avon) This hidden gem is tucked away but I promise you it's worth the trip! I had a Carmel latte and the espresso was so smooth and rich! Next was the perfectly layered Turkey & Pesto Panini! The basil pesto was just right topped with fresh mozzarella & tomato! Simple yet every ingredient was just right and it all blended with each bite! Simple perfection! 10/10 Both times I visited everyone was helpful and welcoming! This is going to be in my monthly rotation for a delicious pick me up! read more

See all

Wow ! This place is in Clermont? I thought this town only had gas stations and CBD shops. Im impressed ! Top notch pastries and desserts coupled with fancy coffee drinks. Amore Mio really adds some class to our cute little town. They have subs too. I got the Siciliy which was spicy cold cuts, moz, and fresh basil and Ciabatta. Insanely delcious. Had to get some of that cheesecake too. Hours are limited to morning and early afternoons. Hopefully that will expand if they get more popular. Welcome to the neighborhood ! I'll be a regular. read more

See all

I have stopped in here a couple of times to coffee, but met up with some friends here today for lunch. Staff are friendly and helpful and the food is made fresh to order. They had a couple of people in front of with to-go orders, but then the inside seating area filled up after a while with a late lunch rush. I got a canned Pellegrino and a half Florence sandwich today and loved the pairing together. The half sized sandwich is a VERY good portion. I had originally wanted to get a half sandwich and soup and take any leftovers back to work for tomorrow, but it was a little bit warm inside so I decided to skip soup this visit. They have a delicious assortment of desserts in their display case. I was very tempted by the carrot cake, but I decided I'll try it on my next coffee visit. The parking lot is a little on the smaller side, yet on the bigger side when comparing it to other Clermont businesses. There is also additional parking in the nearby Clermont shops area. I can't wait to come back and try another sandwich. read more

See all

Yum! Decided to bring my husband here since he's a big sandwich guy and he was pleased. The cafe is cute. The service is fast and friendly and the food is fantastic as well as the drinks. Will definitely be back for another very filling sandwich soon. read more

See all

Amore Mio is an adorable cafe in Clermont, serving Italian style sandwiches, soups, desserts, gelato and coffees. I was lured in by great Yelp reviews and my love for Italian food. The cozy dining area is cafe upscale with an Italian vibe. Italian love songs play in the background. Seating is comfortable. It's the kind of place that friends meet for coffee or a sandwich. I ordered the Milan (meatball) sandwich for lunch. You order and pay at the counter and take a seat. The sandwich is huge and shareable. Wow, the ciabatta roll is crusty and soft inside. The sandwich is delicious, filled with mozzarella, sliced meatballs, marinara and pesto sauce. There is a case filled with fresh treats such as cheesecake, tiramisu and flan. I was hoping to have a gelato or tiramisu after my sandwich, but I was just too full. (Next time, I start with dessert!) Rigo, the clerk, was quietly friendly. The unisex restroom is clean. Limited parking surrounds the building. read more

See all

The ciabatta sandwiches are wonderful. The ciabatta is so good, not too chewy or crusty. The sandwiches are generous in size. The fillings are quality. It was amazing to see a vegan option! The Palermo Giardano (fresh tomatoes, sautéed mushrooms, vegan cheese, peppery arugula, and house-made pesto on a crispy ciabatta) felt like I was having just as quality a sandwich as the rest of my group who ordered the meat sandwiches. I especially liked their take on "vegan cheese". I think it was thinly sliced tofu, with a texture mimicking fresh mozzarella. Don't let it deter you if you're not a tofu eater. It didn't taste like tofu at all. Flavors for each sandwich filling were as described. It could have used a bit more salt overall, but still good. read more

This was our first visit to our new neighborhood deli. We were quite impressed with the quality of the sandwich. We ordered a whole one to share, but literally could have shared a half. They are quite large and so flavorful and fresh. The dessert counter looked very tempting so I'm sure we'll be returning soon, and often. read more

Amore Mio Café - Sicilia sandwich - Italian Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Wanted to get out today for something different and had seen a recent mention of Amore Mio and thought we'd give it a try. My dining partner had the Sicilia sandwich (half size) which had Italian meats with pesto and cheese. She said it was very good, the bread was excellent and the pesto was not overpowering the other aspects of the sandwich. I had the pick 2 with the Milan (meatball on ciabata with mozzarella and sauce) and minnestrone soup and chips. I opted out of the pesto that would normally be part of it. The Milan was also really good. The meatballs were sliced fairly thin and the cheese was excellent. The minnestrone soup was good. They offer various desserts and coffees but we did not try these today. Restaurant was clean, and easily accessible. Parking was not a problem. Drinks are either canned or bottled. read more

See all

Cute cafe/ coffee shop in Clermont serving up coffee and Italian sandwiches. It has become a neighborhood favorite for it's array of sandwiches and excellent customer service. read more

See all

Had carryout out: Florence and Sicilian. The ciabatta was soft and the meats were flavorful. A half size us very generous and enough to fill me up. Definitely a unique sandwhich its hard to find anywhere else. Worth checking out. read more

My first visit to Amore Mio and I absolutely cannot wait to get back. They have soooooo many Italian dishes, from breakfast paninis to lunch sandwiches to dessert. And their coffee, so good! I opted for the Turkey Pesto Panini and a cold brew, and it was so filling I sadly didn't have any room for their tiramisu or gelato, but no matter what you choose, you can't go wrong! They're so friendly too and the atmosphere is great whether you need a WFH spot, a lunch date, or easy dinner with the family. Thanks again for a great experience and wonderful service! read more

Amore Mio Café - Italian Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I read a review for this little gem on Facebook and the food looked so amazing I had to give a look see! We tried the Milan meatball sandwich and it did not disappoint. The meatballs were sliced so you get some in every bite. The red sauce was unbelievable. The second was the Florence with Italian meats and balsamic and honey sauce and arugula for a nice peppery flavor. Both sandwiches were served on Ciabatta bread that had a very nice crust. The staff was very friendly and provided excellent service. The restaurant was very quaint and inviting. I had a chance to speak to one of the owners and he was quite friendly. read more

I ordered 2 sandwiches ,one bag of chips, one cup of soup and and ice tea. They didn't have many chips options. I had to remind them that I didn't get any drink and soup. The sandwiches were most bread. Very little meat or other stuff in the sandwiches. The ice tea only came sweet. The food was just average for the cost of everything. The restaurant was clean and the staff were nice but probably won't be returning. read more

Great sandwich and service, the half sandwich was very filling. Al of my group had different sandwiches and sides. I had just the sandwich and it was plenty filling . Fresh bread and ingredients. The iced tea was clear, an important aspect for me. I took a carry out dessert. I'm sure it is as delicious as it looks. Eat in or carry out. read more

Walked in, gorgeous set up. Decided to do soup & sammies. It took a little bit but once we got our food, we understood. These sandwiches were huge & gourmet - stuffed to the brim. The broccoli cheddar was rich & cheesy. The tiramisu will be a part of my dreams. I highly recommend this place!! read more

See all

Good bread makes a good sandwich and the bread here is killer. The portions are huge so a half is plenty for most people. Their iced coffee was excellent and I'm a sucker for mortadella so they had me at hello. We live on the opposite side of town and drove 30 minutes to get here and I gotta say it was time well spent. I'd come back anytime. read more

Super cute little place. I got the half Sicilia and cup of minestrone. Probably best sandwich ever. The tiramisu is a huge portion and delicious read more

I found out about this place on Monday and been back since everyday. The owners are super sweet and welcoming. The food is so delicious!!! Can't wait to have my family try it. read more

I just ate here today. The food is excellent as always. They have adjusted their hours, so check their website for the latest until Yelp is updated. Please support small businesses. read more

See all

Went here today with my husband and parents, we ordered the mochachino, affogato, and full Milan & Sicilian sandwiches. Everything was 10/10 delicious!! The ciabatta, the mozzarella, the pesto, everything was incredible! The portions were generous - a half sandwich was definitely plenty of food for each of us. I can't believe it took me so long to try. We will all definitely be back! read more

Food portions are big but desert portions were robbery. And the staff kept calling me the wrong name. 7 dollars for this tiny piece of cheesecake hurt, and I didn't notice how small it was until I opened my "to go bag" at home. Looks nice inside, but probably won't be back. read more

Amore Mio Café - 7 dollar slice of cheesecake - Italian Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Popped in for a little coffee/pre-exam study date. Only two times have sandwhichds made me cry, until this one... the Roma had me speechless. The peach with the pesto, holy cow. We tried that, the ham croissant, cappuccino, iced caramel latte, and finished out with coffee gelato. We will absolutely be back, for the food and ambiance! Ps the full sandwhich was larger than my head so be starving, share with someone, or expect leftovers:) read more

We tried three different sandwiches from this business and they were all pretty good: the Milan, the Florence and the Roma, also a pistachio ice cream to die for; we got our food to go so we were in and out quickly but the place is really nice inside. We also ordered a cheese cake tiramisu but they forgot to put it in the bag and no longer after arriving home they had already called us to apologize and we will be stoping by this week to get it since it's already paid. We will be back to try more desserts and the soups. read more

YUMMY!! Went tonight to grab sandwiches. First off, this is the cutest place. Comfy chairs, great decor. Ordered two full size Milan's and a Roma. Very very good. The Romania's the most amazing flavor...a great blend of taste without any one flavor overpowering it. The Milan was a huge hit with my family. Great size portions. The gelato looks amazing....but we didn't get any this time. We will absolutely be back. These folks are so kind and helpful. Breakfast items and coffees look great too...that may be our next visit. Give them a try - it's totally worth it. read more

Amazing sandwiches and excellent service!! Can't wait to go back soon! Make sure to get extra napkins!

this is our new favorite local restaurant. it's a bit of a secret as it is new and in a small Indianapolis suburb. The owner has taken great care to provide an authentic Italian atmosphere and the menu is deep and the recipes authentic Italian. we frequent Europe and appreciate the delicious authenticity and flavors that most Americans will love. the coffee and desserts are to die for. the staff is kind and friendly. give it a try! read more

I have been back to Amore Mio about once a week. I've been bringing family and friends to introduce them to the place. That sample I received of the Hot Capocollo makes the Sicilia Ciabatta one of my favorites. The Milan (meatball Ciabatta) is also very tasty. None of the sandwiches cost more than $8.75, and that's for a half sandwich. It is very filling. My teenage son said that he couldn't see how anyone could eat a whole sandwich. I told him that they could eat half now and the other half later. I feel that the prices are good for the quality and quantity you are getting. They also offer a 30% Police, Fire and Veteran discount when you show an ID. I give most of that back to them in tips. read more

This place is super cute and the food is amazing. I've 3 times for sandwiches and every one has been delicious. The staff has always been friendly and helpful. I'm so glad to have this spot in town. read more

Very good! Half sandwich was huge! Staff was very nice. I will be returning. Atmosphere was mom and pop.