I was in the store back in August and liked what I saw! I tried calling but the phone number does not work. Can someone please reach out to me? read more

This deli is a goldmine in the upper west side! I have been living here for years only to come to my favorite spot on a weekly basis. Everything from the coffee to the variety of sandwhiches are great! Homemade salads to compliment are one of my favorite things! Dont rely on the negative review from the ignorant ones here. The owners are the nicest family and have been around the blocks of the upperwest side for quite sometime. Overall, a great deli and very convenient! read more

Amsterdam Gourmet - Delicious Corned Beef rueben sandwhich with a side of avocado salad! Yum! - Delis Near Me - New York, New York

A Deli, with all the convenience items, sandwiches, meats, teas, and coffee! Little tins of candy and chocolate bars.....Great for a quick little stop... Hey wait... THERE ARE COOKIES!!!! By the door, there is a case full of the most wonderful assorted cookies. We came in out of the cold during the parade Balloon inflation, bought a sack of cookies, and we each enjoyed several with a cup of piping hot tea. Then we pack dup the rest of the cookies and enjoyed them for breakfast the next morning. Go in, get some cookies! You know you want to try them ALL! read more

Amsterdam Gourmet - Cookies - Delis Near Me - New York, New York

A really convenient spot if you're for something quick to eat in the area. I was surprised at the food options they have here. A lot of prepared food choices. Many drinks and protein bars are here too. The store is surprisingly large especially when you pass by on the outside. Overall it's a great corner store with a variety of options. read more

See all

Top notch local deli. The omelets are unlike any from a bodega or deli I've eaten. The veggie omelet is more like a souffle: it's packed with spinach, mushrooms, peppers. Just terrific. Pleasant enough to eat there at the bar seating from which you can watch life pass by on Amsterdam. I would go here a lot if I lived in the area. read more

Great neighborhood spot. Everyone is so friendly and food is good. This has become one of my go to spots and I have not been disappointed.

This deli is pretty close to me, so I e come here a lot. However, I don't think I'll be returning any time soon. I almost always order the same thing: peppered turkey sub with lettuce, mayo, and provolone. Pretty simple sub. Just about every other time I have come, they get my order wrong. (My favorite was when they completely forgot mayo, added tomatoes, and I had the driest sandwich ever.) At $8.95 for a sandwich (charged me $9.95 moray recently for the same thing), I expect something simple to be made correctly. I've given them many chances over the last year, but I think I have to move on and find someplace new. read more

This is your typical, smallish New York deli slash convenient store. The staff is friendly, the selection is decent and the food is good, though, to be fair, I've never tried the turkey burgers slathered in BBQ sauce. The stack of patties just sit in the deli counter gooped in sauce, staring at me like unused props in a horror flick. They seem a little unholy, but when I'm here, I stick to the routine: large coffee with cream and two eggs and cheese on wheat bread with a little salt and pepper. In my neighborhood review of escalating Coca-Cola prices, Amsterdam Gourmet comes in the middle-high range. Their 20 oz. Cokes are $1.50 -- compared to Duane Reade's $1.59 (Pepsi is suspiciously $1.49 at DR) and the staggering $1.75 at Andy's Deli II. Across the street at Amsterdam 24 Hours Express, Cokes are a $1.25 and Little Debbie Zebra Cakes are $.50 ... recession, schmession. read more

A good place to get a quick roast beef sandwich in a brightly-lit, clean store. Trust me, you won't be afraid to eat from this deli compared to some other local bodegas. ;-) read more

Such a bad experience, 100% would never step foot in here again. I had ordered my food and as I was waiting for my food a mouse ran right passed my feet. Immediately left the store. Store was dirty, unorganized and had an unpleasant odee. Do not go here. read more

Possibly eating the worst grill cheese that anyone can make. Over greased, limp - paid for it already and the boss is long gone so no point to argue with employees. Cures hunger -the only positive thing about this experience read more

Ahh... Amsterdam Gourmet. Surprisingly good, cheap coffee for a deli. Has just about anything you would need, at almost all hours of the evening (they close at midnight). Prices are higher than at supermarkets. Still, you are very convenient and for that I love you. read more

I come to this little place quite often either for a quick bite to eat, milk when Duane Reade is sold out (which is always - I only go to DR because I like my $5 off when I spend 100! :P), tasty baklava, or for my last minute ATM needs. They make really tasty sandwiches for a good price. Pretty well stocked in the grocery section. Never tried any of the pre-made food but I've always been scared of trying that in any deli I've been to... The staff has also always been very nice. read more

Worst sandwich and coffee in NYC. The worst bacon, egg and cheese sandwich I have had in NYC. The guy didn't toast the bagel, used one egg and one strip of bacon. You are not allowed to put your own cream/sugar in the coffee, so (despite telling the guy I wanted barely any cream) I got half a cup of cream with a splash of coffee. You can walk to any other block in NYC and get a better deal and better food. read more

A very wide selection to choose from! A little bit of everything! Service was good, but the utensils were plastic and there were few seats. Not much of a restaurant, more of a mini market. Pretty good food though! read more

My girlfriend got a tuna sandwich on Thursday (9th July) and is still paying for it today!!! Major food poisoning! Fever, and the whole works! Good thing I've got 2 bathrooms. read more

Sandwiches are good, bread is fresh and they give you a lot of meat. All of the beverages and convenience store items are way over priced. Go to Duane Reade across the street for chips and soda. read more

I live right by here and usually am very satisfied with the deli here. However, today the person making my sandwich accidentally made the wrong kind. Obviously this wouldn't be that big of a deal except for the fact that he then proceeded to tell me that it was my fault that he had misheard me, and that I was giving him attitude by asking for my original order. He was extremely rude and inappropriate, and frankly embarrassed me in front of the other customers. This behavior was completely uncalled for and needs to be addressed by upper level management. read more

There are not a lot of good, clean places in the neighborhood to order a sandwich and sit and eat it there. This is one of them. I have experienced both good and horrible there. The negative review here is not to bash them, it's to hope they read and adjust. I ordered two sandwiches there. Rather than go into detail on the fact that they repeated the order, questioned it, repeated it again and gave me two sandwiches that barely resembled what I asked for. When I brought it back they apologized, went to fix it and still did it wrong. When I brought it to their attention again, they simply said they "did not do it on purpose". For nearly $10 a sandwich you expect it to be fresh and to order. This was not to order and that's all I said. I didn't insult them, I didn't have a problem with them personally, I just wanted what I ordered and they took that very personally. I brought it up to the manager and he seemed confused that I had a problem with my sandwich as well. He offered to fix it....that would have been the third attempt. I said, I just wanted to let him know that his sandwich makers were not even close to paying attention and that does not reflect well on a "made to order" business model. I would go back for another try...it was fresh, clean and pleasant smelling...they weren't jerks....just incompetent. read more

Slow slow slow! If you want a quick coffee & muffin here it's not going to happen. Everyone here takes there sweet time doing anything! Worst read more

Great Deli...quality and quantity (sandwiches are huge). Good place for coffee and a breakfast sandwich to start the day. Has a small counter where you can sit and eat. Grocery items a little high but that what supermarkets are for. read more

coffee is excellent. sandwiches are excellent, especially breakfast sandwich.. yum! not only are they tasty, but they are good on my wallet. Staff is friendly and helpful.. and did I mention how great their coffee is? I prefer it over Starbucks. read more