Cancel

Open app

Search

Anejo Cocina Winter Park

4.2 (253 reviews)
Closed 11:00 am - 11:00 pm

Anejo Cocina Winter Park Photos

Business Info

ANEJO COCINA WINTER PARK ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?
Casual
Trendy
Moderate noise
Outdoor seating

You might also consider

More like Anejo Cocina Winter Park

Recommended Reviews - Anejo Cocina Winter Park

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Street nachos look great, but are salty and meats over marinated.
Sean M.

The service was great and the menu is huge. The food? It's okay, but we both said we wouldn't be back. The food is ok, but that's about it. Walking in at lunch today we were greeted with an in your face sewer smell. They said it was fixed and airing out, but it was still very offensive. The spicy guacamole sounds and looks amazing!! Eating it though, very challenging. Completely over engineered for looks and not consumption. My street tacos were ok. The meat was way over marinated and mushy - which is different than tender, lol.

Arroz con pollo
Angie M.

I always love coming to this little spot. The food is always super flavorful. Two rounds of complementary chips and salsa. If you can taste the homemade effort into every dish. Drinks are a little pricey and they don't do any specials. But you do get what you pay for so that's the upside. Margaritas are delicious and always poured correctly. The location on itself is super fun and vibrant. Come check the out

Anejo Burrito (big burrito)
Debi W.

Great food, service and staff. This is the first time we've tried the fried cheese tacos and although hard to eat with your hands. We did fine using a knife and fork. The flavors were so good--especially the blistered jalapeños. Our friends got the Anejo Burrito and sharing it they still couldn't finish it. Well worth the price.

Shrimp fajita
Mischita H.

I recently met a family member here for dinner on a Wednesday evening. They arrived before me and was seated right away as the place wasn't very busy. Our server came over right away and provided menus, water, chips and salsa. By the third time they came to the table, we were ready to order. I decided to go with the shrimp fajita with all of the fixings except the tortillas. My family member ordered the quesadilla. Our food came out in a reasonable amount of time and the orders were correct. I enjoyed the shrimp fajita, it was seasoned well. I didn't hear any complaints on the quesadilla. Our server checked on us a couple of times, which was cool. The vibe was more bar-like in terms of the level of sound. There were several tables and booths full of people but enough room for us to be spread out from each other. There 2 tables celebrating a birthday so that added some cheer to the atmosphere. Overall, I'd say it was good and I would come here again, at least for the fajitas.

Rebecca C.

The number one thing I was impressed by at this restaurant was speed. The speed our server came to check on us and also how quick our food came out. I always get worried by the quality of food based on how fast it comes out, but I was happily surprised the food tasted great. The queso dip was flavorful and smooth. The enchiladas were so tasty and the corn tortillas held up against the sauces. The restaurant layout is a bit tight but they do have a second layer back room. I went on a Friday evening and it was quite popping.

Victoria S.

Me and my coworkers ordered from here for lunch. I had never heard of this place before but the inside is so nice. Just from picking up the food quickly I got such a good impression of the staff they were so nice. Everything was plated nicely even though it was a to go order. Everyone really enjoyed the food as well. I think this is one of the best Mexican restaurants around here honestly. The food was really delicious. I would definitely come back here!

Diablo shrimp, white rice & salad w avocado slices & a purple orchid flower garnish (beautiful)
Katy M.

The inside of this place is very trendy and cool. On the menu is Frida Kahlo w a mustache. Was pretty funny considering she never had that & was a beautiful artistic woman. lol The food presentation was A+ and tasted very good. Both my friend and I were pleased with the food. Our server was very nice & attentive. If you go soon, order the Anejo chicken quesadilla w light cheese & sour cream on the side or more pico de gallo instead of the sc if you're watching your figure.

Cadillac margarita
Mandi S.

Service is really great. Friendly staff. The drinks are on point. We tried Cadillac margarita, the mezcal margarita, and the quesabirria tacos. Absolutely delicious! Everything is measured so the drinks come out the same every time. No worries on a crappy pour. They give a fair pour to price ratio. I did add a shot to make a drink a little more like home. We sat at the bar and our bartender never rushed us. She gave us all the time we needed but was attentive to anything we asked about or requested. Especially love the water glasses they provide at the bar. Noticed tables get plastic cups. Felt like a much nicer experience for us. The chips and salsa are really good. I'm pretty picky on both. In 6 years I've yet to find me a favorite salsa in Florida, I will say this is one of the best ones I've had in this state. Will be back to have more. I have to order the pizza birria next time. I'm so curious. One of the best birria tacos I've had. Top 3 ever. absolutely recommend. They even include a sliver of radish and 2, one quarter limes (1/2 total). The consume was really good, I rarely like consume. I usually just use limes. I used both. If I made one critique, I would ask for more radish. 100% recommend this restaurant and can't wait to come back!

choripollo, tacos, salmon, pollo loco
Martha L.

I love añejo, this is my go to spot when I want Mexican food which is high praise from a Mexican person. I have my order down which is a side of guac with the choripollo and everything is super tasty always. I brought my family to it and even my hard to please mom liked it. We always come back to this restaurant, plus they always have a good playlist playing.

Kennisha J.

I went for my birthday. Everything was yummy. The chips and salsa were free if I remember right. Really cute place. Lots of spots for pictures. I love the way it looks on the inside. Really close to me, a great spot for yummy Mexican food!!

Lunch special - carne asada
Jordain J.

I didn't even realize that this restaurant was here because I passed by it usually to go to the store that's right next to it. But it was good, I came here with two friends, and one of my friends decided to go with the lunch special rib eye and absolutely loved it. It was even better was my bowl, it came out super fast and it was absolutely delicious. And the cherry on top of all this of course was the drink, the drink was absolutely delicious and it definitely does his job. I ended up ordering another one and felt great. I would definitely come back here again for drinks and food.

House Margaritas and Guacamole
Deirdra S.

This place is unreal- just SO GOOD! Mexican is my go to genre of food and I love finding New Mexican Eateries! Our server, David, was the best! He was so personable and friendly and had such fun energy. The restaurant was full, but it wasn't loud or crazy. It still felt great for an intimate dinner. The dinner did NOT disappoint! We started with the guacamole and the house margaritas. The guac was so flavorful I had to keep myself from finishing the entire dish. The margaritas were well balanced and so yummy. This was their happy hour drink size and I couldn't believe how generous their portions were on the special. The food was served within minutes of ordering and was hot and fresh! My shrimp burrito was packed with flavor and was well stuffed. My friend loved her birria quesadillas and loved all do the elements of dinner. Thank you Anti for a great evening.

Dj D.

I ordered take out. The better was very nice and helpful. She gave me vegetarian recommendations, but ultimately allowed me to order a veggie rice bowl even though that was not an option on the menu. The portions are nice for the price. It is a casual eatery with a bar. There was a nice crowd for a week night.

entrance

See all

Photo of Rusty M.
123
42
4

1 day ago

Chips and salsa are top 3 in Orlando area. Great bar and happy hour. Fajitas solid. Adding to my carb mix

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 days ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

13 days ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 month ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Debi W.
281
927
5232

1 year ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 1

1 year ago

Helpful 9
Thanks 3
Love this 9
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 3
Thanks 1
Love this 2
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 2
Oh no 0

10 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 4
Thanks 0
Love this 3
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 3
Thanks 0
Love this 2
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

11 months ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 5
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 2

2 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 2
Oh no 0

3 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Cole D.
201
40
59

1 year ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 2
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

3 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Helpful 3
Thanks 0
Love this 3
Oh no 0

28 days ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 months ago

Amazing food and ambience!! Our server Ariana was superb. Will definitely be back again

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 months ago

Food is excellent! Friendly service and reasonable prices. Poblano peppers with shredded chicken and refried beans is one of my favorites.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Jason M.
102
11
1

8 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Helpful 18
Thanks 0
Love this 18
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Helpful 6
Thanks 0
Love this 5
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Helpful 7
Thanks 2
Love this 7
Oh no 1

1 year ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 4
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 2
Oh no 0

11 months ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

Page 1 of 7

Anejo Cocina Winter Park Reviews in Other Languages

Ask the Community - Anejo Cocina Winter Park

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for New Mexican Cuisine 499 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

The Courtesy - To go milk punch

The Courtesy

4.5(183 reviews)
1.4 miNorth Orange
$$

The Courtesy is a cute cocktail bar, though this is my first time ever here and it's specifically…read morebecause I LOVE christmas so much and I couldn't pass up the opportunity to experience the holiday greatness this place offers. The decor speaks for itself, this place is absolutely decked out to the high heavens for Christmas and definitely worth a reservation and stop in ! but... be SURE to make a reservation because you may not be able to get in if you don't (best do it a couple days in advance if you can!) Rudolph's Replacement: 10/10 for cuteness (got it for the TRex cup) BUT this drink tasted like chocolate grass. if that's ur vibe, you'll love it. Christmapolitan: Not the cutest, average for looks just in a normal cute little glass, but guess what.... it was thebest drink we had!! 10/10 for flavor, loves it. Dancing Sugarplumb: Again not the cutest it's basic, BUT THE FLAVOR 9/10 The Krampus: the cup is killer. love it. drinks like a sippy cup, but for a Christmas demon. there is mezcal in this it's definitely on the smokier side, but even the mezcal haters at the table love it. 8/10 flavor if you like a little smoky and a tad bit of heat. All we had to eat was the pretzels with pimento - i was skeptical but wow, super good! All in all, would definitely recommend, you just have to plan to come here in advance and get that reservation!

We came in for some bites and drinks and had a great experience. The bar is beautiful. Service was…read moreamazing! So friendly and attentive. I loved the soft pretzel bites with pimento cheese. It's a great dish to share. For my drink, I got the Beijing Bikini. It was pretty and delicious. My girlfriends all love the Day Dreamer and order it every time. They all got curly fries and loved those as well. One of my friends didn't like her cocktail and they enthusiastically switched it out for something she loved. Another one of my friends doesn't drink and didn't like the sound of the only mocktail on the menu. They were kind enough to create one for her. They made her a delicious NA drink with a flower. We really appreciated the extra effort to accommodate her. We love The Courtesy!

Photos
The Courtesy - Bar candelabra

Bar candelabra

The Courtesy - Mezcal drink with beets (right)

Mezcal drink with beets (right)

The Courtesy

See all

Forward Slash - Happy hour at forward slash!

Forward Slash

4.9(111 reviews)
1.1 miNorth Orange
$$

Chase and Julia (gosh I hope i got the names right) were fabulous hosts, guides, bartenders! Step…read moreinside the dimly lit tasting room and craft cocktail bar and relax! I've been trying to stop into this distillery for years, but my timing was always off. Either they were closed that day i was there or not opening before I left. But today, the starts aligned. If you know, John and I love going to small craft/ small batch distilleries & we have the bar to back that up. Years of learning what we love and what we (I really) don't. I was all interested in the bourbon! And they delivered! Every batch is a one and done, with every new batch trying to be better and more refined than the last. Reminds me of myself, I'm always moving forward & trying to do better! Loved the bourbon. The Winter Park Arts Festival blend was phenomenal! Then... I tried the Gincident and that was an easy yes, let's take that bottle home. Meanwhile, Chase was bragging about their Best Espresso Martini.... hmmm, prove it. Made with bourbon, omg yes please. Proprietary blend of coffee, vodka made in house and yes, it was one of my to three I've ever had! And now I want to start trying various bourbons to make one at home! And I heard they do a Halloween Yelp Event!!! Whhhaaaatttt! Please please, I must go this coming fall! I LOVE HALLOWEEN!!!

Came to this place and search of a popular food truck & stayed for the drinks and vibes. We were…read moreunsure really what forward slash was until we arrived. To be honest, we thought we were coming to a brewery and quickly realized it was a distillery. We walked in and noticed a bunch of outdoor seating. It was the perfect night so we looked forward to sitting outside. The atmosphere was busy, but laid back. We entered into the dimly lit establishment at Harry Potter playing on the TV (win!). It was a speakeasy-esque vibe and I loved it. We ordered an old-fashioned and espresso martini which were quickly brought to our table. They indicated that the espresso martini was the best one in town, so naturally I had to try it. I would definitely say it takes top five. We sat outside and had a great evening at this place. We will definitely be back and look forward to it.

Photos
Forward Slash - Gothic Revival

Gothic Revival

Forward Slash
Forward Slash - Bar

See all

Bar

Garp & Fuss - Shrimp and lobster bucatini.

Garp & Fuss

4.4(497 reviews)
1.0 mi
$$

Came here for a work event! The service was absolutely lovely. We tried the Brussels sprouts which…read morehad such a wonderful blend of sweet and savory, cooked perfectly. For my main I tried the mushroom gnocchi with chicken. It came with a super savory and creamy sauce, plenty of mushrooms, and the gnocchi were pillowy but not soggy. It might've been the best gnocchi I've had to be honest !! I would love to return for a date night!

While exploring downtown Winter Park in search of brunch, we stumbled upon Garp & Fuss, a hidden…read moretreasure tucked among the charming little shops. Once you find the beautiful courtyard fountain and spot the iconic royal blue door, you know you've arrived at the right place. Although we didn't score what I consider the best seat in the house, the stunning glass atrium surrounded by gorgeous brick arches and exposed wood beams, we were seated right next to it and still got to enjoy the beautiful atmosphere. Every room feels thoughtfully designed, with unique décor and plenty of character. There's even a pool table and a cozy, more private seating area above the bar when you first walk in. The cocktails were perfectly balanced, not too strong and not too weak, just right. Our waitress was amazing and knew exactly what our energy needed. Now, I'm not usually a burger person, but trying the Fig & G.O.A.T. was a must, and it absolutely did not disappoint. It was easily the standout dish of our meal. We also ordered the Park Ave Pesto pasta. While it had good flavor, it wasn't our favorite item on the menu. Overall, Garp & Fuss delivers a wonderful dining experience with great ambiance, creative spaces, and delicious food. I would definitely return and look forward to trying more of their menu.

Photos
Garp & Fuss
Garp & Fuss - Mushroom gnocchi

Mushroom gnocchi

Garp & Fuss

See all

The Chapman - Boneless roasted all-natural half chicken, lemon-herb rub, leaf spinach, butternut squash and farro risotto

The Chapman

4.6(155 reviews)
1.3 mi
$$$

This place is great! It's definitely popular on the weekend so try to get a reservation if you can…read more Our server was fast and had tons of recommendations for each section of the menu. We got a dirty martini and negroni to start. Awesome presentation and they came out pretty quickly. We were also given a free glass of prosecco, which was an excellent touch. For appetizers we ordered the Crispy Bang Bang Lion's Mane, which had a great texture and was extra crispy, and the Citrus Spiced Carrots. This sat in a bed of ricotta cheese and hot honey. The perfect balance of sweet and salty. I'd order this 10 times over again. For our mains we got the Fresh Grilled Fish of the day, which was a snapper with mashed sweet potato and broccolini and a pan to pour a lemon sauce over top. This was a perfect portion, the fish was grilled perfectly, and I could have eaten an entire bowl of their sweet potatoes. My husband got the Bronzed Florida Grouper, which had a risotto with shrimp in it. Both of these dishes were INCREDIBLE. To finish, we got the Sky High Citrus Meringue Pie. This kind of played on a key lime pie. It was rich, the portion was HUGE, and a great way to finish our meal. Overall, great food, great vibes, and great service.

So good I had to go twice! Had dinner here 2 weeks in a row because I had to come back to try the…read morethins I couldn't the first time. Ok starting from the top, absolutely the best espresso martini in Orlando! Secondly the little details like a purse hanger is just top tier hospitality. Third the food is absolutely to die for. The crab cake . I literally couldn't eat all my food both times and I still need to go back to try more. Also another hidden gem is the bar. It is a nice little hang out spot on park ave. It was soo good I forgot pics guess I have to go back for a third go!

Photos
The Chapman - Martini Tree

Martini Tree

The Chapman - Delicious housemade crab cakes with ancho chili rémoulade, fresh corn & salsa negro

Delicious housemade crab cakes with ancho chili rémoulade, fresh corn & salsa negro

The Chapman - Delicious Ahi Tuna Two Ways - Warm seared rare ahi and raspberry tuna poke, avocado, organic greens, bright mango vinaigrette

See all

Delicious Ahi Tuna Two Ways - Warm seared rare ahi and raspberry tuna poke, avocado, organic greens, bright mango vinaigrette

Noir Bar - Cocktail take on a matcha latte - delicious!

Noir Bar

4.8(65 reviews)
3.6 miUptown

We accidentally stumbled upon this speakeasy while dining at Talay. Although they're connected…read morephysically, NOIR is its own separate business and definitely has its own unique identity. The vibe here is dark, intimate, and gives off a chic city nightlife feel. They offer both a full cocktail menu and a happy hour menu. They also offer a Thai tapas menu, which we unfortunately didn't get to try because we were already stuffed from dinner at Talay, but the menu looked amazing and gives us another reason to come back! The drinks are unique, creative, and very well crafted. We ordered the Celestial Bloom, and it was absolutely delicious! It was beautifully balanced and left us wanting to come back just to try more of their cocktails. Definitely a great spot for drinks before or after dinner!

A hidden speakeasy inside of Talay Thai restaurant. Enter Talay and immediately go left. Then,…read morepast the bathrooms straight ahead there is a brown wall. The hidden door which you push is on the right side. Once inside the bar it is super small inside. The tables along the wall are squished together. I think you're better off at the bar. I could see lots of people bringing dates here. First up, I tried a $17 Tree of Life. The drink the bartender made me was maybe 2 sips. There's a giant ice cube and a bamboo leaf or something and very little drink to drink. Not sure what to make of this because as soon as I was deciding if I liked it or not, it was gone. Wouldn't order this again. Second, I tried a $17 Adam & Eve. I wish the matcha was much stronger. There's a place in Tampa called Tori Bar that has a super duper matcha tasting cocktail. This one was much lighter. It was fine, not my favorite. Maybe I'd bring a date here sometime, but wouldn't go out of my way to come here.

Photos
Noir Bar - Genesis, tree of life and Adam and Eve

Genesis, tree of life and Adam and Eve

Noir Bar - Bar area

Bar area

Noir Bar - Inside

See all

Inside

Prato - Diavolo Pizza

Prato

4.3(2k reviews)
1.1 mi
$$

Still trying to understand the hype about this place? The mustard spaghetti? A solid 6/10…read moreThe famous meatballs? 5/10? It literally tasted like it was frozen and reheated. Overly salty and on a bed of Parmesan cheese to make it look fancy? The diabolo pizza? Floppy mess. The rigatoni was probably the best dish we tried. 7/10 The service was also awful. How did we get served warm water on one of the hottest days of the season so far? We had a reservation and waited 20 minutes to get seated. Took forever to bring us a high chair for our baby. It was an awful first experience and will not be returning :/

The aesthetic of the tall wooden rafters, stone floors, mood lighting and peeks of natural sun, it…read moregives high class Italian in the best way possible. As you walk in there's a large bar with a decent amount of seating, and to the right a mix of tables. Take on the limited outdoor seating at your own risk during Florida's storm season. I started with the Sunshine State cocktail. The gin cocktail was a little more lime forward than I prefer, but I'm still a fan! To follow it, I tried the Negroni Bianco. It was on the sweeter side and had a lot of floral flavor. The Bruschette Caprese has so much flavor, I couldn't get place if the tomatoes were marinated, but I loved it! For dinner I couldn't resist the house special, mustard spaghettini. It was creamy, and mustard marinated noodles the perfect balance. As you'd expect with the setting and price point, the service was professional and attentive.

Photos
Prato
Prato - Mustard Spaghettini Cacio E Pepe

Mustard Spaghettini Cacio E Pepe

Prato - Well Wishes (NA)

See all

Well Wishes (NA)

Alfies Hifi - milk punch (left) and pink lady (right)

Alfies Hifi

4.7(106 reviews)
3.1 miMills50, Park Lake / Lake Highland

Kyle is awesome!!! Great service, ambience is amazing! Music choice sways with the crowd :)read more

After months of anticipation... I finally made it to Alfie's…read more It was exactly what I was hoping it would be: a slice of culture. Real people. Real life. Real youth. Real energy. Real good vibes. Orlando obviously has no shortage of places to eat, drink, and gather, but Alfie's belongs to that rare category of venues that feel equally at home in a major metropolis. It's the kind of spot that would fit seamlessly into Los Angeles's best neighborhoods: think Gold Line in Highland Park or the Vinyl Room at the Hollywood Palladium. Not because they're carbon copies, but because they share that intangible quality of genuine discovery and cultural curiosity. The crowd ( age range 25 - 35 mostly ) was genuinely engaged with one another. People were actually talking, actually present, not hunched over their phones. That alone felt invigorating. There was an undeniable spark in the room. Alfie's wasn't chasing trends; it was simply allowing them to emerge naturally. What impressed me most was how they brought it all together .. Retro stereo equipment and vinyl players from the 50s mixed with a bar area that's super sleek and modern. Conversations, music, the lounge itself .... all came together in a way that felt alive and IN THE MOMENT. When my LA friends visit, Alfie's is on the list. Go after 9 or 10 PM and plan to stay for at least two hours. That's when you really see the scene develop and come alive. Bring your ID: they card at the door. Even at my age, I still get carded. No complaining about that ! lol

Photos
Alfies Hifi - Alfies selector bar

Alfies selector bar

Alfies Hifi - Custom bar for the community!

Custom bar for the community!

Alfies Hifi - Milk Punch Alcohol Drink

See all

Milk Punch Alcohol Drink

Anejo Cocina Winter Park - newmexican - Updated June 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...