Perfect place for breakfast or lunch near village hub & entrance to the beach. Hash browns & ham eggs Benedict and apple French toast our favorites. Super yummy, spicy Bloody Mary's. Great way to start the day read more

Visited on Dec 27 for a late brunch. The place was understaffed and waitress seemed disengaged and uninterested. The food took a long time to arrive and she never acknowledged the delay. Another, much friendlier waitress did apologize, which we appreciated. We waited too long for the check, even though the restaurant was nearly empty and our waitress was chatting with staff. I have worked in busy restaurants myself, so this level of inattentiveness is not excusable. The food was mediocre and there are plenty of better, healthier options in Sarasota. Several tables were left uncleared for an excessive amount of time, and when we were seated, our table was still unpleasantly wet from cleaning. read more

Nice atmosphere but this place is not what it used to be. The eggs Benedict had a barely cooked bagel, was dry and uneventful. The silverware was not super clean and the overall meal was overpriced and mediocre at best. read more

The waitress was so nice. The food and drinks were delicious. Sat out on the covered deck and enjoyed the morning. read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Bloody Mary and Salted Caramel Cold Brew - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Siesta Key, Florida

See all

Advertised fresh squeezed OJ, received, 1/2 of one not fresh squeezed, totally concentrated OJ, so, out of 2 ordered via Doordash - not sure what happened, it appeared someone drunk from one cup, and the other cup not received, so I through it out The food is not as specified, no quality check, Items ordered, do not match the delivered items, received - really, not sure if it is the kitchen or the driver, but something is switched and very off with every item delivered, and rarely the case with other restaurants. Dishes ordered not exactly or partially received and not quality expected. read more

Great service in a laidback beach town setting. Food is an updated fusion of old favorites and inventive twists. read more

See all

I was truly unhappy with my visit. When I arrived, I asked the host for a table for two along with a high chair. She kindly informed me that the wait would be approximately 15-20 minutes, which seemed reasonable, so I provided my name and phone number. After about 30 minutes, I checked back in and was told there were still several parties ahead of us. We continued waiting, and it wasn't until roughly 35 minutes later that we were finally seated. We were then greeted by our server, Steven, about 15 minutes after being seated, at which point he took our drink orders. Unfortunately, our drinks did not arrive until about 20 minutes later. When they finally came, he then took our entrée order, but our food didn't arrive until roughly 45 minutes after that. I would love to recommend this place, as this was our second visit and we truly enjoyed our first experience. The food was excellent, and we genuinely enjoy it. However, the service on this visit needs significant improvement. Overall, the amount of waiting throughout the entire experience felt excessive. Had we been given a more accurate expectation of the delays, we likely would have chosen not to stay. read more

Everything runs smoothly at Another Broken Egg even with lots of people waiting to get in and eat. If you don't like waiting for a table then get up early. If not, just leave your name at the hostess stand and you'll be called asap. We were there in the summer and didn't have to wait more than 10 mins for a table for 4. The employees work quickly and efficiently, getting customers in and out. You can choose to sit inside or outside on their large covered patio. All of our dishes came as ordered and we were all very happy with our choices. I ordered a Monterey Power Omelette that was delicious, my only complaint is that the omelette comes with avocado and the avocado slices were not the nicest. They were subpar. You can see in the photo. Other than that everything was delicious and we left very satisfied. read more

Service was very good, Nice friendly atmosphere and normally the food is top notch. However, I would not recommend ordering the Parmesan crusted Croissant benedict with asparagus. The bottom half of each one was dried out and wrinkled/shriveled up. So stringy, I couldn't even cut them with their sharp knife let alone chew it. A good chef would not have allowed it to be sent it out to a customer. I was a produce manager for 17 years and there are many ways to preserve the freshness of asparagus starting with cutting off the bottom 1/2" or so, (No white part left) then store it upright in a jar with fresh water, cover with a plastic bag, refresh the water daily and cut a small sliver off the bottom again every other day to allow it to drink and not dry out. Then the dish will get 5 stars! read more

Service was great, food was ok. Sausage was dry. Definitely worth a try, I probably just orders too heavy a breakfast read more

Nice cafe with a good variety of breakfast and brunch items. They weren't very busy when I came in on a Monday morning around 9am. I had to wait for a couple of minutes since there was no one up front then I was seated at the bar. I ordered some coffee to start and perused the menu. I decided on the crab cake benedict. Service was quick and friendly. It seemed, there were only 2 wait staff that day so they were both running around a lot but my waitress still had time to check in with me to make sure everything was well and good after my food was delivered. Delicious food but I sadly forgot to snap a photo. Outdoor seating are available here as well. They have heaters for your comfort while dining and since this is located off of the main drag in Siesta Key, you do hear a lot of the background noise from the street. The inside was fairly quiet aside from the normal restaurant bustle. Definitely a nice place for breakfast if you're staying in the village or somewhere nearby. read more

We ordered the biscuits and gravy with a side of fruit which was delicious. We sat outside on a very cute covered patio.

The atmosphere was cool, sitting outside was a much better experience as inside seating was a bit cramped. The bathroom line gets crazy and that could be a turn off to diners as people stretch the line through the dining area. The food was really good. The menu has a lot of cool options. Drink menu was decent. Prices were great. Good solid spot for breakfast/brunch. read more

See all

We started our day with breakfast. Been to one of these near where I live, and they have good food, so figured this was a safe bet, and I'm glad I was right. We waited about 20 minutes which is not bad considering their norm is longer. The hubby started with an iced coffee followed by salmon lox sandwich and I had the pancake meal. I knew it would be a lot of food but that's how they feed you. I had their medium roast which was their strongest and some orange juice. We definitely left with full bellies and always a delight. Service was great too, very attentive food came out at a reasonable time. read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Smoked Salmon sandwich - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Siesta Key, Florida

See all

The service was good. The food was exceptional. The Apple Fritter French Toast was my favorite. Small place on the inside with only two one person bathrooms but the outside had a large sitting area to enjoy the outside views and ambience. Would definitely go back again and try some of the other items that sounded interesting as well. read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Bourbon Street Pancakes - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Siesta Key, Florida

See all

Another Broken Egg? Something is broken, alright. Waited 45 minutes for food, not even during a rush. Served on dirty plates. Crab tasted off and definitely not fresh. Very disappointed. Will not go back. read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Dirty plates - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Siesta Key, Florida

See all

2 stars and only because the bartender was pretty special. So we go for a brunch and start with the biegnets. Waaaaaay over fried and almost burnt. Next up for the wife, eggs Benedict w grilled tomato, eggs poached medium and I got the Louisiana Benedict w andouille and shrimp. Her eggs are beyond not poached. They're runny-r than the Texas democrats leaving the state. Home fries were over fried, I think the fry guy was having a bad morning. And the tomato was present but not the grilled part. Mine you ask? I like my eggs runny but this was a bit much. The andouille still had the casing on and just meh. I also got a side of cold grits. Which was nice. The bartender was super apologetic but sometimes you just can't get it right. And with 100 locations I'm sure it's rough to be consistent. Oh well. read more

My wife and I tried most of the breakfast spots near the village on our recent trip to Sarasota and this was by far our favorite spot. Great atmosphere, service, and food. I also liked that the menu had some different things beyond the standard breakfast options. For my meal, I had the crab cakes benedict and loved it. Perfectly cooked eggs, great hollandaise sauce, and the crab cakes were delicious. read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Crab Cake Benedict - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Siesta Key, Florida

February 2026 visit and while typically busy, was able to get a table. Another fantastic meal at Another Broken Egg Cafe. The food is always on point, and the team works incredibly hard while staying friendly and upbeat. Highly recommend stopping in if you're visiting the area. read more

Good food, fair service but ac too cold. Be sure to bring along a sweater!! No wait what so ever, the earlier you go the better seating.

A good friend of mine had rave about this place so I was very happy to try it while I was in the area. When we got there they told us it was about a 20 min wait. Once we were seated I got an alcoholic lemonade and it was tasty but not strong at all. We decided to shared the beignets which were tasty but I wouldn't order them again. As my entree I got the Brie and lobster omelet, now this was the star of the show. The omelet was delicious and had plenty of lobster. I really enjoyed my breakfast. read more

We went to breakfast on a rainy Thursday at about 8:30. Hostess was very friendly. Only 3 tables filled when we arrived. Our waitress not so friendly. Maybe having a bad day. Placed order with decaf coffee, no creamer on table, asked for milk had to ask twice before we got and coffee was terrible. Ordered the pancakes with pork sausage and french toast with bacon. Pancakes were good but pork sausage like hockey pucks same color. French toast with bacon good. Should have sent back the pork sausages but we just wanted to leave. Didn't feel that for $43.00 the breakfast was anything to rave about. Can't believe a cook or a waitress would see that pork sausage and serve it but they figured we are tourists we won't be back who cares???? Stay away from the pork sausage unless you a need hockey puck. read more

This place was busy, when we stopped in for breakfast but the hostess and waitress were very calm and polite. Loved the coziness and family atmosphere of this cafe. Our food was sensational, the omelette was perfect and I wouldn't change a thing. So this was my first time trying a Bloody Mary, and I was indifferent. The Bloody Mary had amazing flavor, but not sure I loved the spice first thing in the morning. Also, amazing taste and flavor with the chicken and waffles but that chipotle sauce has some heat to it. The heat with the waffles paired with the Abe is too strong for my preference, but not the restaurants fault, still an exceptional experience! read more

See all

Went here over the weekend for a girls trip. We were seated fast and our server was sweet and friendly. Food was good but wouldn't say that it blew my mind. Bloody Mary was very good and was pleasantly surprised. I got the pepper one and added a bit more myself. Overall good but tend to try to stay away from chain restaurants I can get at home. Didn't have many other options so did the trick. read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Smoked Salmon Benedict - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Siesta Key, Florida

See all

Great service. Great food. Staff was nice. I would come again. Restooms/ debit/credit/kid friendly. read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Lucy - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Siesta Key, Florida

See all

Ordered the shrimp and grits. Looked like gravy over packaged grits. It was not a golden creamy grit dish with a scoop of gravy but a pool. Not for me. We thought we'd give Another Broken Egg a second chance ... !!! Food was amazing Server enjoyable Air conditioning appreciated!!! ... I would like to advise management, if you are going to have servers rolling flatware in dining room, please have them speak quietly( I don't need to hear about private life situations while I am enjoying my meal) AND not curse, while guests are present. read more

Only 15 minute wait. Nice staff. Sausage Pattie's was odd tasting. Ask for pineapple juice and they brought a mock cocktail. Didn't like it at all. Egg and crab Benedict was cold. read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Siesta Key, Florida

See all

Discovered this place almost a two decades ago and it is still a favorite! Making it even more special for me was getting to introduce my now how husband to it almost thirteen years ago the same week we got married on the beach. The food is always delicious and there's a lot of options available for breakfast and lunch. The serve is always great. The team is friendly and on-spot with refreshing drinks. Inside and outside seating options, both are good, but we love outside. There is just such a nice "FL feel" . It is popular with locals and tourists so be prepared for a wait, which is usually a reasonable 15-20 mins, but peak weekend hours can be a bit longer. It's worth the wait. read more

Great service. Love the food. In a great location by the beach. It's a beautiful place

Wonderful service & food was great! I'm from the south & had southern kind of cooking, not the same, but it was still good, atmosphere was good outside read more

Another great visit My visit today went very well, starting with easily finding a parking space. The restaurant was pretty busy, but they had an outside table for me without a wait. A cheerful hostess led the way. Within a couple of minutes, I had coffee in their somewhat small but cute coffee cups. For breakfast I tried their The Supreme Omelette, a more traditional sort of omelette with sausage, bacon, onion, mushrooms, and cheese. It was very good, subtle flavor, good size. For my side I had their cubed potatoes. I enjoyed this food while sitting in their large outdoor seating area on a beautiful morning. Most every day is beautiful on Siesta Key. There was an energy at the restaurant with the noise of the diners, beat music playing, and the activity around the restaurant. Another Broken Egg was an excellent choice for me today. read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - The Supreme Omelette - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Siesta Key, Florida

Yum! Er had a great brunch at Anither Broken Egg Cafe! My husband had the Santa Fe Salad and I had an omelette that was delicious. The location is perfect between being right in the Village and just off the beach. Friendly service and a kitschy atmosphere-we loved it! read more

See all

This place deserves even more than 5 stars! We opted for outdoor seating and the Christmas decor helps make the casual seating feel more festive. I wish I remembered our server's name but she was excellent. She was very attentive and joyful, and very knowledgeable about the menu. The orange mimosas were a delightful start.There were no bottomless option even in a Saturday brunch so we ended up ordering 2 pitchers of mimosas.The Lobster and Brie omelette stole the spotlight. The omelette was toped with a decent amount of lobster and the brie helped give each bite the creamiest consistency. Also impressive was the Tiramisu French Toast, the crab egg Benedict and the veggie omelette. Everything was seasoned to perfection. The Gingerbread Waffle was not overpoweringly sweet, and had well-balanced ginger flavor. This is a true gem! read more

See all

Even though there was a long wait to get in, the food was all good and so was the coffee. Our waitress was attentive and got all our orders right. There was nice outdoor seating with fans keeping us cool. My bacon and avocado sandwich was really excellent. We will definitely be back! read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Pound cake French toast. - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Siesta Key, Florida

See all

Food was amazing and the wait staff are very friendly. I would give it 5 stars but the door is broken and slammed shut about 100 times during or meal. read more

This is by far our go-to breakfast place in the whole Sarasota area. We've never been disappointed. And our friend's that we've brought also raved. Great coffee. Excellent Bloody Mary's and the food is exceptional. We've tried many items. Our house is 20 minutes away and we'd rather drive past other restaurants to come here. The vibes and staff make the experience memorable! read more

Not the best experience, it took an hour and a half for us to get breakfast here and it wasn't busy. We were sat right away which was great but the service was so slow. Our server Dana was not present, she barely checked on our table. Our food had to sit under the heat lamp and wasn't great. She offered the table next to us a free app for their wait and we got ignored. There are many other places in the area to get breakfast so make a better choice for breakfast. read more

Not what it used to be when I came here 10 years ago. Understaffed, slow service, cold coffee and underwhelming food. Omelettes were dry and stale (after waiting an hour), fruit previously frozen, overall taste was not enjoyable. Maybe new ownership?! Don't waste your time, literally. Not cheap either (~$200 for 9 people, including 4 kids) read more

One of our favorite breakfast places in Siesta Key! Always delicious! Mimosas are great too. The online waitlist is very convenient.

Short Staffed I Couldn't Eat My Eggs They came out Raw and Bacon tasted like Cooking Gas Save Your Money Go Somewhere Else