The flatbreads are always a great choice when we're looking for a quick meal, but what really makes this place stand out is the staff. We visited on a busy Friday night, and Sam behind the bar and Eleni, our waitress, were both phenomenal. Despite how busy it was, they were friendly, professional, experienced, and incredibly attentive. The bussers were also constantly working hard to keep tables cleared and ready for the next group of diners. Service was quick, the food was good, and the entire staff worked together seamlessly. We had a great experience and will definitely be returning! read more

Wanted a mid-day snack so I got a side of the focaccia bread, which I remember being good in the past. Along with the bread I got a side of mozzarella cheese (which they charged almost $3 for) to melt on the bread once I got home. Upon further inspection of the cheese there was MOLD. The bread was fine but I had no interest in continuing to eat. How does a pizza place serve mozzarella with mold? UPDATE- I sent an email after they responded to this review, and they never answered read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Moldy Cheese - Pizza Near Me - Wantagh, New York

Let's see now... Management, service, cleanliness and sometimes the wings!! At the bar, Jordan had NO clue what was going on, he only constantly looked at the computer. We ordered food and about 10 minutes after I ordered I asked him for 2 set ups, he looks at me and says were in the middle of a shift change and that was at 5:30pm WTF Nicole at the bar was amazing! She stayed till well after her shift, we left at 6:30 and checked out with her. read more

Stopped by with the kids #proudfatherof5! We got a margarita pizza and garlic Romano wings. And oh let me tell ya, there aren't enough words in the world to describe how immensely extraordinarily phenomenal these wings are. The pizza was rlly good too. But my boy little jimmy SCARFED down these wings. (he's the troublemaker). The service was very quick and they were nice pleasant to speak to. The ambiance is very cool, has a nice rustic vibe. I definitely recommend going!!! read more

Pizza was great. The meatballs were great but should be LARGER IN SIZE for $20 for 4 small but delicious meatballs. They used to do a bucket of meatballs in sauce which was when they first opened years ago. The sauce was delicious too. read more

I wonder if Anthony knows how far under this place has gone. Some of the food is still good but the service is atrocious. The hostesses, servers, bartenders, even the manager are all miserable. The service was the worst I've experienced and I typically give wait staff the benefit of the doubt, as a past waitress myself. Our experience today was the nail in the coffin. With so many other brick- and coal fired-ovens in the area, there's absolutely no reason why anyone should patronize this place. read more

I recieved a burnt pizza yes that is true, it would be helpful if they asked customers how well or not they would like their pizza . This would help disgruntled customers. They apologized and was very nice handling the issue. I definitely recommend a second try . read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - This is what their business deems acceptable when ordering Uber eats and spending $60 - Pizza Near Me - Wantagh, New York

Came back here and this time had the Mike's Hot Honey pizza. The pizza was excellent. I love the sweetness from the honey. The restaurant is nice and clean. There's plenty of seating space. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Pizza Near Me - Wantagh, New York

I'll gently preface this review by saying that I would have LOVED to try more, but we came on Pi Day and had to take advantage of the more economical choice -- a 12 inch regular pie for, you guessed it, $3.14. (Now that is math that I can appreciate it, hehe.) If you're craving a more nuanced style of pizza, the coal fired oven definitely delivers, and the cheese pull on the thin, charred crust was a thing of beauty, let me tell ya. I would like to go back and try their hot honey pepperoni pie or even one of their weeknight specials, which could save money, too. (Meatball Monday does have a nice ring to it, right?) We also shared a hearty order of their jumbo garlic/Romano wings, which were roasted, yay, and had that nice coal fired touch. (Plus, it switches things up to not always have the typical fried Buffalo wing -- I'm all about choices!) I clearly have to return for a larger sample size, but for now, I am feeling optimistic about Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings in Wantagh. It has a 'sports bar vibe' as well, so it's a laid back environment to hang, eat, and embrace all that the oven has to offer. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Regular 12 inch Coal Fired Pie :) - Pizza Near Me - Wantagh, New York

My boyfriend and I wanted to come here for a long time I mean months and we never got around d to it till one day we gave it a go. He has been here before it was my first time and I did think it was pretty good. We sat at a table and ordered a bottle of wine I thought the combination would be perfect. Unfortunately they do not have any merlot which is my preference so we got a Cabernet which is not my taste but I dealt with it, it was just ok. Our server was great she was attentive, kind, patient and gave us her opinion on items and some flavors which helped our experience. Her name was Jules really sweet girl. To start we ordered two different wings one original which comes with onions it was my first time having wings like this they have a burnt taste to them not my taste really. We also ordered garlic wings and they were so good even my boyfriend could agree this was a great choice. The wings come with a warm pita bread which I used to scoop up that sauce delishhhh. For pizza we ordered two different pies his pepperoni, mushroom, sausage and prosciutto. For myself I ordered a simple grandma with extra cheese. What I do like is the bottom of my pizza to be burnt and crunchy some part were it was alright. We said we would return for happy hour one day soon to give it a try. read more

See all

Had a great dinner tonight. Chelsea was my bartender and she was amazing. The wings were a 10/10 and the wine was served to perfection. Stop by on a Thursday night. You can't go wrong. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Amazing wings - Pizza Near Me - Wantagh, New York

First time at the Wantagh location and wasn't disappointed. The white sangria was delicious, and our food hit the spot too. We had a Caesar salad, garlic knots, and a half caprese half eggplant pizza. The pizza was, as always, incredible - cooked perfectly, tons of flavor and great crust. The salad was good - though the croutons were a bit chewy, and the sauce on the garlic knots was unreal - but the dough of the knots themselves tasted a little stale. read more

See all

Cauliflower Pizza with a side of meatballs. Cold draft beer. Very good service. You gotta love the well done crispy crust. Still a favorite after all these years. read more

We visited this restaurant last Saturday night. The food is light and delicious. The service is on point and the openness and airiness of the establishment is the icing on the cake. Not a huge selection, but the items on the menu are done right. I had the sausage sandwich with peppers, broccoli rob, and melted mozzarella cheese on a pita like bread; UNREAL!!! PS: They have a full bar with awesome drinks. Definitely a C O O L place. read more

Love this pizzeria and restaurant. The pizza is one of a kind you know when it's from Anthony's coal fired pizzeria. They were the first pizzeria I tried hot honey with and now I basically put it in all my slices the menu is simple and to the point and you can even customize your own personal pie. They also have salads and sandwiches. Our waiter was a sweetheart and I love all the photos of celebrities on the wall very fun and unique. read more

See all

Great pizza, cooked at 900 degrees, coal fired pizza have a great special flavor. Loved their chopped salads and their lunch specials are terrific read more

Great service. Great pizza. Staff is always courteous, professional and love the app. Deals are great. I only order pizza from here nowadays. Even the Garden City one location rocks like the WANTAGH one. read more

Good pizza and wings Ambiance is also good Friendly and fast service Definitely recommend this place for a good night out read more

Take out 4 meatballs to bring home to Hubby , NO RICOTTA with order. Come on, how hard is it ???? No one in the place but 3 dudes at the bar, and no one even acknowledged me standing there waiting. EVERY time I order takeout I have an issue, last time they didnt have my online order , so I am done . Its painfully apparent no one cares. read more

Server Michael is the reason for my review. His service, sincerity and hospitality deserve to be recognized and praised. We live locally and enjoy coming in for the variety of deals they offer - but the service is truly second to none. We love Wantagh Coal Fired!!!! read more

Finally got a chance to stop in & glad i did. Nice looking place inside, big beautiful bar, bunch of tv's, Convent parking lot also friendly service. The pizza was very thin, we had regular & the pepperoni / hot honey. Both were very good, we also tried the garlic knots.... I think they were the best G knots i ever had! Deff be back to try a few other things. read more

Needed a quick lunch fix and stopped in here for take out. Ordered the oven roasted chicken sandwich which comes with prosciutto, grilled chicken, roasted bell peppers and arugula and mozzarella. Honestly it's simple and flavorful. There's herbs on the panini bread and it's oven roasted which adds some flavor. I went an extra mile and dipped it into a little blue cheese dressing and boom. I'll come back and explore the rest of the menu another time. For me this sandwich was good enough. Customer service was quick and friendly straight to the point how I like it read more

See all

Visit Date: February 27, 2022 I came here with my two friends. We were hanging out for the day I didn't have my son he was with his dad. We bounced around a lot for the day but we ended up here for dinner. We were able to get a half cheese, half pizza with no cheese and garlic knots for dinner. So much carbs I was in love. The garlic knots were awesome covered in oil I love it that way. The pizza was pretty good although I'm sure if I decided not to be vegan and have the cheese it would have been better. I liked the decor here. If you're into pizza coming here to try the coal fired pizza is something to try. read more

Solid four star pizza-ish joint. Who knew partner Dan Marino had such vision to get involved in this concept. The pizza is superb if you're into a charred crust. I know it's not for everyone but Jesse and I love this style. The house salad is also very good. And they have a pretty good tap selection. Also tried the vinegar cherry pork ribs and wings. Not what you would expect, very good out of the coal fired oven. Bartender was super friendly and let us sit and watch the game from the bar stools. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Belly up to the bar and have some pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Wantagh, New York

Came here for happy hour and enjoyed it. The bartenders were super friendly. I had an italian margarita which was made with tequila and amaretto instead of triple sec. It was delish! My hubby enjoyed his IPA beer. We ordered a pizza to split- half white pizza and half pepperoni. They gave us complimentary wings to try while we were waiting. The pizza is thin and well done so a little different than your average pizza place. I look forward to another happy hour here! read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Italian margarita - Pizza Near Me - Wantagh, New York

See all

Just a quick share!! I use to live in Massapequa 8 years ago and would frequent ACP. Stopped in today for a small white Pie, Original Chicken wings. 2 observations. 1 wings were under done and need to rendered down and more char. 2 The Pizza was just awful in a time where there are so many good pizza shops. In fact behind the counter I didn't see one Anthony anywhere. The Pizza had no snap, the dough was made incorrectly. Also they put some much cheese on it, it was oozing all over. Maybe 3 x the normal portion of Cheese. Anyway this is the stuff that makes want to go back to a kitchen and Teach people the right way. read more

Unfortunately, this location was very disappointing today. We placed an order for pickup and arrived right at the time the website told us to arrive. Our wings and the bread they can with were burnt. Our pizza was very cold. Edit: once we heated up the pizza at home, it was very soggy and lacked taste. We've eaten at the Carle Place location before and their food has always been very good. read more

We moved into the area a little over 6 months ago. Since then, the search has been on for our pizza place. I think we have found it! It is a few dollars more than the others that we tried but well worth it! My mother, for her birthday, wanted to go out for pizza. She picked Anthony's after being told it was delicious. We started with appetizers of meatballs, wings, eggplant and salad. The meatballs were big and dense. The sauce was perfectly seasoned. The eggplant was cut thin, breaded and fried. Seasoned beautifully and with the same sauce as the meatballs so it was a hit. The wings are made in the same brick oven as the pizza. They get a beautiful char and are served with delicious sautéed onions. The salad was big enough for the 7 of us to share and had chick peas, egg, tomato and lettuce. Now the main course! We ordered one large pie, traditional cheese and sauce, and one roasted cauliflower. OMG! They were both fantastic. The regular pizza had the perfect balance of sauce to cheese. The crust was crunchy but not too crunchy and the sauce, as I said earlier, was fantastic! The cauliflower pizza had Roasted Cauliflower with Olive Oil & Garlic, Romano & Mozzarella Cheese, Topped Off with Bread Crumbs. It was insanely good! One of the best specialty pies I have ever had an I am a definite carnivore. Can't wait to have it again! Sorry for the lack of pictures. It was a little dark and we were all REALLY hungry! ;) read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Pizza Near Me - Wantagh, New York

I love the Farmingdale, Bohemia and great neck locations. This one repeatedly disappoints. Between completely wrong orders, pizzas semi-raw, and now terrible martinis I give up. The Wantagh location really needs to focus on quality control. I ordered a dirty martini with extra olives and this is what I got. One old gross olive and a yellow martini that definitely wasn't Ketel one like I asked. Please get some better management because the other locations function flawlessly. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - olives on a stick - Pizza Near Me - Wantagh, New York

See all

Went for happy hour at the bar. It was so inexpensive. We had a coal fire pizza and chicken wings. The cook them well done to perfection. 2 Peroni beers and a Tito's with cranberry. Only $32. It's worth the trip Monday-Friday at the bar 3-6 pm. read more

See all

We love to eat at Anthony's Coal fried Pizza. Great Pizza. The best Is Destiney our server. She is absolutely fabulous. Eat there you will love it. read more

As we all know im still struggling during this pandemic so any kind of deal i can get is a huge help. I found myself with no money at all this week to eat with and im tired of begging for help. I found out that with this app you get a free pie so i did. and OMG it was delish. I got the free pizza and yes i tipped and it will keep me fed for 2 days so im happy . read more

Food was amazing ..nice atmosphere...very good service ...our waitress was Abbigal and she was so wonderful....very attentive....never had to call her to the table to ask for something. Very reasonable in today's crazy prices.. and DELICIOUS.. HAD PIZZA ..THE WINGS AND THE FAMOUS SALAD ....that should not be missed read more

Good pizza though their dry rub chicken wings is a bit too spicy. Their original chicken wings are exceptional and the pizza is good.

The food was great. But the service not so much. They sat us at a table by the bar. I got hit 3x by servers coming in and out. They honestly should not put a table that close. I had drinks partially spill on me as well. Ironically it was hard to even get a refill. We did not receive even 1. As soon as the appetizer came out, not even 5 mins later did our pizza come out. The guy who delivered the pizza, immediately grabbed our appetizer off the table and our plates as we were still eating which was very rude. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Pizza Near Me - Wantagh, New York

See all

Just went to Anthony's. Had a great meal. My pizza was cooked perfectly but the service was outstanding!

I was just at anthony's and I have to say it was a great experience. My waitress was named Alexa ! How funny just like me! She was attentive , very fast and sooo nice. She made my dining expierence so enjoy fil! The food was great especially their salad! The bartender Gia was also awesome. She made me a tasty martini and was so nice as well. Overall I will defiantly be coming back!!! read more

This place is always busy which tells you How good tue food and service is. The pizza and salads are always fresh and tasty. read more

Wow, I am so disappointed as I was really looking forward to trying Anthony's and was hoping for a new fave. I ordered the meatball and ricotta specialty pie and visually it looked very good. Unfortunately the positives ended there as the pizza was void of flavor. The meatballs tasted like they were not homemade, the ricotta was nothing special and the sauce wasn't very memorable either. The coal fired oven crust was nice and crunchy but again not remarkable in the flavor department. Maybe I am being too critical as I did eat the whole damn thing so it couldn't have been that bad, but at $16.95 for a small 12" pizza I expected a party in mouth and this party turned out to be pretty lame. Sorry, I really wanted to love this place :( It was packed on Thursday night and felt more like walking into a popular bar then a pizzeria so obviously a lot of other people disagree with me but for $17 I can get a full size 16" or 18" large pie with at least one topping at a half dozen better pizzerias in a 5 mile radius. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Meatball & ricotta pizza - Pizza Near Me - Wantagh, New York

See all

This location always has great service and very nice waiter and waitresses. Occasionally my son will ask for all flats as he always gets wings and they tend to mess it up each time and give drumsticks and flats. Today they did exactly that and the waiter gave him an extra five of the flat wings for nothing. Very nice gesture . My sandwich was good and always freshly made. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Something different today for me. Roast beef with Italian vinaigrette dressing and I added some fresh mozzarella - Pizza Near Me - Wantagh, New York