It is obvious that this is not the old Anthony's. New owners don't have a clue what they are doing! Pick up order was over 40 minutes late. While sitting and watching the staff the right hand doesn't know what the left hand is doing! I will not return! Along with the terrible service the price has increase considerably! read more

Whatever you do don't go here! They're saying we can't buy a normal pizza bc of covid. So they're only selling small pizzas for a fast turn around. So we had to sit outside and wait 45 mins for a small pizza with one pepperoni on the entire thing. There wasn't even cheese on 90% of it. Well let's hope bc of covid you go under you greedy jerk! read more

Very friendly staff and helpful. Difficult to locate if you follow GPS. Nice to be able to order pizza by the slice. read more

Anthony's Pizza and Pasta - Pizza Near Me - Brighton, Colorado

We were in brighton and decided to try out Anthony's since the one on colorado blvd has always been so great, but i was very disappointed the girls in the front are so rude. Don't bother them or else you'll just get starred at. This situation made me laugh more than upset will never be back here. It was like ordering my pizza from a high school cafeteria. read more

Most of the toppings slid off the pizza. We contacted the restaurant to let them know about the issue. They lied and told me the delivery driver said a "kid" accepted the pizza and put it under their arm like a book. My adult husband did no such thing. So, he called them back to see what the misunderstanding was. He was not given an apology. We used to love Anthony's. We are very saddened to not be able to support this business any longer. read more

Anthony's Pizza and Pasta - Most of the toppings slid to the edge. - Pizza Near Me - Brighton, Colorado

I ordered bread, ravioli and wings. Everything was cold!!! I also didn't get any bread! Instead I got some cold uncooked mozzarella sticks. I also got lasagna instead of ravioli and even my receipt said "ravioli" If they ran out of something that is understandable, but I got no phone call being asked if I wanted to take it off the order. So not only was almost my entire order wrong, but the wings seemed like they were barely cooked. I will not ever order from here again. You guys should hire some new people! read more

The foods okay. Nothing special. I'd say it's a bit pricey for paper thin pizza that's just as good as any other pizza place that makes their pizza with thicker crust. They have one of those awesome Cola machines with the touch screen to choose your soda.... But they were out of diet Coke and Coke?! Their location isnt ideal; it's immediately after a roundabout and right before two lanes merge. I had to circle back to get to it because I was too busy watching traffic. Also, the parking lot is quite small. On the bright side, the one person that talked to us seemed nice. read more

Great NY Style pizza. Great Service . The Family Meal was good of enough for all 8 off us. Thank you

The way the owners and staff are handling this pandemic is phenomenal. The restaurant is always clean, the staff is always friendly, and the service is always quick. Best pizza (and salads) in Brighton and I'm SO happy they're still crushing things. I will forever recommend this place to anybody visiting town or hungry for pizza. read more

I finally got around to trying Anthony's in Brighton after living less than 5 minutes away for 3 years. I wasn't impressed and won't be back. We order a half order of mozzarella sticks and an 18in Neapolitan pizza with pepperoni, sausage and 1/2 w/mushroom. I ordered online and it said it would take an hour. I went a few minutes early and the place was dead and the pizza was ready. Great, but also a little worried about why it took an hour. Got home and the cheese stickers were burnt, all the cheese fried on the outside and hard. Move on to the pizza. It tasted like it had set under the heat lamp for awhile, which I'd believe since they didn't seem busy. The 1/2 with mushrooms seemed like that's all it had as you couldn't see the other toppings. There wasn't much sausage on any of it and even my 6yr old said it was hard. Not worth keeping the left overs which for the price, you'd hope to eat it all. Very disappointed and won't be back. read more

EDITED: I'm revising this from my previous review in 2012. New ownership works for this place! The employees there seem really nice and professional. The pizza was really good. Gooey cheese and all that. :) Customer service - spot on. We stayed there to eat, and a young guy from behind the counter couldn't have been nicer. Checked on us a few times, and was very helpful. I have no problems revising the stars from a 1 to a 5. The new ownership here has made a difference. ********************* PREVIOUS REVIEW***************** They get one star because the option for zero stars doesn't exist. Customer service and the Sicilian pizza were both a big fail. My husband picked up 2 sicilians for take out. He came home and they were undercooked inside. He called to let them know. In addition, one of the pizzas had cheese stuck to the foil they put on top. Had to scrape it off back on to the pizza. I show back up there with the pizzas and they tell me they can't refund me because, "They don't know what I did to the pizza". What does that mean? How can you UNCOOK a pizza. Then they tell me we already ate some of it. Uh, ya....three people took three slices and found out it still needed to be cooked. I was treated like I was trying to scam them I had pizza in hand for proof it was bad. Employees are very rude. I was told to leave. Called corporate the following business day. The person I spoke to acted as if he cared. He was supposed to call me back and never did. Customer service: FAIL Sicilian pizza: FAIL Save your money and brain cells. read more

I have had Anthony's only a couple of times and I am not fully sold on it. First it's pretty expensive if you want more than cheese. $2.25 for each additional topping on the large. This last time we went we got the white pizza with onion and spinach. I was pretty disappointed by the amount of spinach on my pizza. First of all it was chopped spinach and a small smattering was all that was applied. I guess I am used to whole leaves and at least a good handful of leaves at that. Especially for $2.25...c'mon people. I'm not bitter or anything... The pizza was good though and we both enjoyed it the next day for breakfast. I don't know however how often I would actually order from there? read more

I'm glad we finally got an Anthony's somewhat close to home. I'm so sick of living out in the middle of nowhere with nothing but a Subway and Sonic within a reasonable distance. Although no Anthony's can compare to the downtown location as far as the food (For some reason the pizza tastes better there, maybe it's because the oven has been in service for a lot longer? Dunno.) and atmosphere go, you can always count on a quality slice at a decent price at this location. If you have time, do the eat-in large pie, as opposed to delivery or carry-out. The eat-in large pizza is freaking ginormous, much bigger than carry-out size. The salads are decent, although it seems they're not as generous as the downtown location. The restaurant itself is nicely decorated on the inside, being that it's a brand new location. There's a couple TVs on, usually showing ESPN or news, sometimes cartoons. Parking at the Brighton Pavilion is hit or miss, depending on time/day. I don't mind parking a ways away and walking, but some people get pissy if they can't park right up front. (Wah) The only thing missing here is fresh brewed iced tea. All they have is the fountain crap. I'm giving this one 4 stars, because as far as Anthony's go, the downtown location sets the bar. read more

Just tried to order pizza from the Anthony's Pizza and Pasta in Brighton,CO. I was told they had too many pizzas to make and we're not taking any orders. Put I could call again in an hour to see if they could make my pizza. So, we ordered from someone who wants our money. read more

Wow. I ordered pizza at 5:50. They quoted me 45 minutes. An hour and a half later I called to get the status. The staff was very very rude. Still waiting for my pizza two hours later. Terrible customer service. I should have stuck with Pizza Hut. Save your money and order somewhere else! read more

Love Anthony's! Our delivery drivers are always courteous and the food is great quality.

Can't say that I was too excited, AFTER waiting an hour, (which was expected!), to get a HORRiBLY BURNED Pizza! Can't even believe the cook let this out of the kitchen... Mistake on part to order from here. ALSO... The Delivery Driver got an EXCELLENT Tip. I feel TOTALLY BURNED with this experience/transaction!! read more

Anthony's Pizza and Pasta - The entire bottom of pizza was BLACK!! - Pizza Near Me - Brighton, Colorado

These guys make some pretty good pies and offer several styles which is great. The downside is the price. They are defiantly the highest priced pies in the area. The service is so-so, usually high school kids. read more

Love the calzone and always great service when we come here and not to mention the great deals they offer. 2 slices and a soda for only 5.50. Wow. If yiu want great pizza in Brighton yiu need to come here. read more

Anthony's Pizza and Pasta - Outstanding pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Brighton, Colorado

Love this place for their lunch special but was disappointed when I brought 14 friends out and the pizza was dried out and tough! Generally an awesome pizza and salad with great prices and friendly staff. read more

OMG, I had a Calzone with pepperoni, black olives, and jalapeños. It was absolutely amazing. Literally one of the best calzones I've ever had. read more

Good place for an affordable lunch or dinner. I usually order pizza, but they also have a good selection of sandwiches and pasta. The best part of the meal is the "Italian" salad dressing - the dressing is a GREAT red-wine vinaigrette that reminds me of the dressing at an Italian restaurant from back home. The service is always friendly and speedy - I've only had them deliver once and the meal arrived within a reasonable amount of time. read more

Let me be the first to say - I love New York style pizza. Especially from Anthony's. I especially love being right across the street from them. However, I have a few issues with it. The pizza for one is bland sometimes and undercooked. Would it kill them cook it a little longer and actually have spicy Italian sausage? I have to say that I would not get Italian sausage again. The second issue is the price. 40 cents for a substandard topping? And the cost of the salads - huge for how small they are. My last problem with it is their website. It's always malfunctioning and not letting me order, saying it is too late. I call and they send it out, saying the website malfunctions often. It's not that expensive to fix a website - why haven't they? Otherwise, I like them. They're close, friendly, and fast. read more

I had ordered a Caesar salad with grilled chicken and I also ordered chicken Parmesan it did not come I called them the owner gets on the phone with me and start yelling at me that I'm asking for freebies yeah they were going to give me a free salad next time but I paid for my chicken Parmesan I want to today and he says I'm not gonna drop everything to her in a lunch busy lunch hour to send over a dollar piece of chicken to you I will never order from there again you can take your salad and put it where the sun doesn't shine read more

Don't bother, went inside the Brighton restaurant and tried to order 2 slices. They said they just opened and had many to go orders in front of me and that I couldn't get the 2 slice special but could order a full pie. Order taker was down right rude and when I did order a full pie it took over an hour to get it. I was being punished. Will not go back, period. read more

Ordered Calzones the other day and just not good. Not enough filling and dough was soggy on the outside. Definitely not fresh! First time impression meh. read more

Ordered a pizza and two fettuccini Alfredo with chicken and garlic bread with cheese. I got two pizzas an one Alfredo, garlic bread that was over done with little or no cheese. (Didn't see it) Last time I'm ordering here. Very expensive to get it all wrong. I'll haven left overs for years! read more

Disappointed! They're pizza used to be great. Crust was terrible, very dry and cracker crunchy. Overall, I've had freezer burned frozen that was better. read more

This location in particular is incredible! We have been in eating Anthony's since we moved to Colorado 6 years ago and have never had an issue with anything. Their pizza, pastas, salads, everything is always amazing. Today though I was so wowed by their already amazing customer service I just had to tell anyone that would read. My 7 year old daughter had surgery on Friday she can't eat, can't hardly drink anything and whatever water she does get down won't stay down. She's sick from surgery and pain meds with little to nothing in her stomach. I told them what was going on and when our food arrive to our house the chicken in the chicken Alfredo was cut up so small for her she was able to eat a little (way more then I thought she would) and she said it was absolutely delicious! Also I ordered garlic bread for my other kids and the garlic bread that came with my 7 year olds was way softer then the one I ordered for my other kids! How incredible is this team! They have no idea what this meant to me.I am and always will be a forever Anthony's customer. read more

The pizza is ok. But the service is more than reproachable. I received a called from their "delivery" driver stating he would be at my place shortly. 20 minutes later he was still not here. I called and was told he got lost. Mind you, Brighton is not a big town single cell has a gps. When I complain that by the time he got here my pizza would be cold I was told "their bag keeps the pizza warm". There was no "sorry for the inconvenience ", "we apologize". As I write this review the pizza is still not here. Fun, isn't it? read more

I have done everything I can to help support local businesses during covid and this is one of them. But some of them don't want help or business and Anthony's in Brighton is failing. They are only open for 4 hours from 4-8. Tonight I called at 728 and was told they no long take delivery or pick up orders. I will much rather drive further to support companies that are trying to serve their community and employees. For a pizza place to stop taking orders at 728 on a Saturday is not helping their employees make enough money to support their family. Shame on Anthony's. read more

We have called there two times now at 6 PM and they have been out of pizza. They quit selling individual slices because of Covid? Not sure how Covid affects individuals slices but we used to use them once a week now we are not. read more

Amazing place! I highly recommend Anthonys Pizza in Brighton Colorado. Always a smile and always amazing PIZZA! YUM!!!!

Love this restaurant. Best pizza in town hands down. Great service. Delivery is great too! Very good menu selection.

Love their wings and pizza. Haven't tried anything else from their menu but have ordered from them 3 times in 2 weeks of moving to the area from all over, New York and NJ being home area, they have good food. Wings were made just right and pizza is pretty good. I would recommend them. read more

Ordered pizza to be delivered. It arrived burnt. Could not eat it or the cheese sticks. Never eat hear. The Managers are unprofessional and so is the owner. I've talked to other friends in Brighton they quit eating at Anthony's Pizza too because of the same experience. Save your money go somewhere else. will never eat here again. read more

If I could give this restaurant no stars I would. The owner is very rude, condescending and aggressive and the quality of their food has gone down. Will never go back. read more

Total rip off, 2 carolis no toppings no cheese. Smelled like weed, Every body working looked stoned. Called manager to complain, acted like he did not care. Bad service, smelly and crummy food will NOT be going back. read more

Love getting pizza from here. They deliver and always show up on time with the complete order. The staff is friendly and easy to deal with.

cassy was a great server and the overall food was was amazing. once again cassy did an amazing job and i was excited and happy the whole time cause of her. read more