I stopped by Antonio's Restaurant & Pizzeria in Warren on a Tuesday afternoon around 3 PM while picking up my son from school before a long drive. We needed something quick, and since my son loves pepperoni pizza, we ordered slices. The first thing I noticed was that the place was extremely clean, including the bathroom, and the staff was very friendly and welcoming. As someone who lived in New York City for many years, I can definitely say the pizza quality was good. The crust had the right balance--crispy when folded, not too thick or doughy, and the cheese tasted like quality cheese. My son loved the pepperoni slices, and I had a mushroom slice that was also very good. The only reason I'm giving 4 stars instead of 5 is the pricing. Two slices were about $8, and between my son and I, we ended up spending around $16 just on four slices of pizza. I believe this is a little bit on the pricey side. Maybe whole pies are a better value (??) but for individual slices it felt a bit expensive compared to what I'm used to. That said, the food quality, cleanliness, and friendly service were all excellent. I don't know if I will consider going back, but I would like especially to try more of the menu because the sandwiches and chicken parm hero looked really good. read more

I love Antonio's white pie with broccoli and garlic. I ordered it all the time when I lived in Warren. I moved to Pa and can't find any that compares to it. Everytime I come down to NJ I always go the and get one to take home and freeze. Love having a piece now and then, it's such a treat. read more

Very nice man working the oven , picked up 2 buffalos because all the other slices looked like they had been sitting for quite a while. Shocked to see the price for these 3 items...$16.10..... it's okay to over charge but not when your dough is undercooked and even a few sold watery areas . First and last time there . read more

See all

Uber taking me places just dropped a family in New York driving back to Virginia was craving pizza could not find parking in New York so I stopped here at Antonio's Pizza I have to say it was impressively good eats coast pizza way better than west coast pizza I enjoyed every bite!! Service was exceptional ! Gracias por su servicio! I i trued to slices, convinced my self lol!! To buy a small for my way home hahaha! read more

Antonio's Restaurant & Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Warren, New Jersey

Racist. Avoid if you're a person of color. As I walked in the cooks/employees were sitting down watching tv. I asked for a menu, the guy pointed to one and proceeded to walk into the kitchen and started making pizzas. I ordered and he told me I'd have to wait until he finished making the pies and put them in the oven. About 4 minutes later a Caucasian male walked in and he stopped what he was doing to take the Caucasian males order. The customer pointed to me and said, "He was here first, take him". The owner just shrugged it off so I walked out. By time I got to my car, grabbed my phone and pulled up the Cheesecake factory location the guy who came in behind me was walking out with his order. I guess he didn't have to wait for the pies to go into the oven. read more

Family got food poisoning. Very disappointed in what we received. The pizzas that we received the cheese was sliding off of the pie. The pies didn't seem cooked through enough. Will not be going back there and being sick a complete weekend, was not acceptable. read more

Happy Tuesday Adventurers! So normally I don't post same day reviews but this needed to be said. Tonight my car battery died---before my Yelp Event over at Stone House at Stirling House. I stopped in because I was about an hour early. As I was getting ready to leave for the event I realized my car didn't start. I considered asking the several males that drove in to the plaza but being a female in a dress at dusk doesn't always bode well for civil results I decided to stop in and order food since AAA was going to be about 2 hours. I ordered the calamari and a Caesar then used the restroom. I got to taking with Victoria and she's like my sister, Ashley had jumper cables. Let's see what we can do. I happily said sure let's do this ! (My cables were with my stolen so if anyone wants to replace them please let me know). We connect the wires and after about 8 times do trying my poor car finally puttered to life ! Now I'm not saying that they'll do this for everyone but I sincerely appreciated their effort and consideration given what my night had been like. Carolyn was a lovely matriarch and I fully believe that she has raised strong females to continuously help other females. I also want to say that they were supper kind and nice to my agitated hangry state. I recommend this place solely on their integrity. The food I can't give a decent review being that I drove about 40 minutes to get home and it was cold. I shall definitely be coming to this location for sure! read more

We have been ordering from Antonio's thru The app "Slice" for several years now and they do an excellent job. I recently ordered tuna and provolone sub, eggplant parmigiana dinner, cheese pizza. Some of the best I've tasted in this area. Excellent food, reasonably priced. read more

We order from Antonio's weekly. Amazing pizza, great calzones and the BEST mussels marinara (as I scrape the sauce onto a piece of bread). Great job. Never disappointed. read more

Just tried this pizzeria for the first time. Hands down best pizza (and garlic knots) in a long, long time. Everything was consistently nice and crispy, instead of boring and doughy as seems to be all too common. Will be a return customer for sure. read more

I have ordered every week, since Covid, to support a local business. Antonio's had been excellent each time, but tonight was a wretched experience. I've order the seafood combo over ziti. Again, in past orders it was EXCELLENT. Tonight? 0 out of 10. The seafood used to be fresh jumbo shrimp, tonight it was the dime sized frozen shrimp. The calamari was frozen, tasted like rubber. The clams tasted like low tide. The mussels tonight were putrid. I had to spit it out so I didn't get sick. And the seafood combo came over penne, Not ziti. It was down right terrible. For $22. I called the manager, and he said "we changed chefs, whatd'ya wan me to do?" I said to not serve this slop as you will get someone sick or kill them with bad shellfish. He didn't reply. No offer to try to "make it right", just arrogance. Antonio's has gone down hill fast. I will NEVER order from them again. Clearly cutting corners on food quality and cooking. It's a shame. They used to be great. read more

Every time I get the pizza it is soggy and greasy. The workers are very friendly it is such a shame. The sandwhiches are also huge, although it is mostly bread and lettuce depending on what you order. They also always add onions without request and I hate onions. Hopefully they improve because it is a local friendly place! read more

Been waiting 90 min for my delivery. Apparently something happened to their original delivery guy and they had to call in a backup. Which is all fine and TOTALLY understandable -- but let me know. I've called twice and had the replacement delivery guy call me to say he couldn't find me. So frustrated. They charge a $2.00 delivery fee which is bullshit. You have to have a $25 max if you order online for delivery (also bullshit.) The pizza was awesome and yummy and worth the weight. The garlic bread had too much cheese (and was overpriced) and the penne ala vodka with chicken was blah. Stick to the pizza --- and apparently only pick up in store. read more

The place is under new ownership now. Everything has improved quite a bit. Even the ingredients are of a better quality.

The pizza here has been great 3/4 of the time, not so good the other 1/4. It depends who's making it. They deliver, but there is a $25 minimum charge PLUS a 2$ delivery fee. I noticed recently you can order online, so your food is ready for pickup when you arrive. The place is a little on the older side, but its always been clean. There's several booths if you choose to eat there. Its located in a strip mall just past Rolf's on the left (if you were coming from Watchung). Note that it is not just pizza, they have chicken, veal, sandwiches, pasta, shrimp, etc. read more

Been going here since I was a kid,home made pizza,decades old recipe. Family owned,fresh always everything.

Overpriced for below average food. I have tried their pizza, lasagna and puttanesca (pasta). Pizza was okay. The lasagna tasted like it was made from canned sauce, with a very small serving size. And the puttanesca was mushy and had a similar canned sauce flavor. Look elsewhere for better food and a better value. read more

Called for delivery and was told my Lg pie with extra cheese and a dozen wings total was 22.73 Delivery person insisted it was 27.73. I called to question it and owner told me pizza was 14.75 (3.00) for extra cheese!!! 10 for wings + tax and a 2dollar deliv fee!!! Pizza was OK but not great. I will be calling somewhere else from now on. Stick your 2 dollar fee and bait and switch tactics where the sun dont shine. read more

The pizza here is sometimes good and sometimes not. It depends who's making it. I've had pizza that's been undercooked and wet in the middle. The dinners are nothing to write home about. It's best to pick up your order but they charge you a "Service Fee" if you use a credit card. If Edgar, the owner, is making pizza then you'll get a decent one! The White Pizza with Tomato and Bacon is a good choice. read more

The pizza is beyond awful. I don't believe the owners taste what they serve. If they did they would have to be embarrassed. You can't even hold it. It's mushy and looks like undercooked dough. The restaurant is dirty and out of 1970. Hope someone new takes over and puts some effort since I live nearby and it would be great to have another option in town. read more

I've ordered from Antonio's twice in the last month and the pizza was great and delivery was prompt. Pizza arrived hot and in perfect shape (better than if I picked it up and drive it to my house). The online ordering is very convenient and has been flawless. Not sure why there are negative reviews, so I felt the need to share my experiences. Very satisfied! read more