Had the best server ever! He was the kindest kid ever! Absolutely love this place and the friendly family vibes. Food is the BEST!!! read more

Attilios Pizza & Pasta - Italian Near Me - Pitman, New Jersey

Lesson learned: check the timing of any show at the Pitman theater before heading over. We put in a large order and sat down to wait. Big crowd then lined up and put their orders in. I realized they were headed to the show. All their orders of pizza slices and salads were filled before ours. Our final order took an hour to arrive and we got attitude when we asked about it. There are no fountain drinks, either cans or bottles. Don't ask for ice if the soda was just stocked and not cold - you won't get accommodated. Pizza was decent, wings were great. Parm sandwich was barely warm, not much cheese or meat. Will come back for wings though. read more

See all

We came in on a busy night, the owner was the only one working. He was so polite and took his time with us. Such a nice guy! We got a plain pizza, crispy fries, and cheesesteak Stromboli with added American cheese and banana peppers. The pizza had ZERO flop, and the sauce and cheese were perfection. The Stromboli was a cheesy marriage of cheese and steak and was crispy and not doughy at all. It was SUPURB! The pizza place itself is clean and cozy and the kids loved it in here. People were in and out and the atmosphere was fun and cozy. I'm thinking of the next time I'm going to come back and might get the same thing because it was so good read more

Attilios Pizza & Pasta - Italian Near Me - Pitman, New Jersey

My cousin and I were in town visiting for a Yelp event. We were not sure of the food to be had at the event. To err on the side of caution, we stopped in for slices. The restaurant was not crowded and there were plenty of seats available. It wasn't rowdy or loud at all. Nice place to sit and enjoy a meal with family. The menu options were many, but we didn't have much time to spend. My cousin and I both ordered a slice. I ordered Cheese and she ordered a Vegetarian slice. The pizza was not too oily and cheese was just right!! The crust was thin and had a nice crunch to it. The young people behind the counter were super friendly and patient as we decided what we wanted to order. They had a variety of drinks (I wish they sold SmartWater or even Deer Park but they don't!) and snacks available by the counter. Oh and there's a Hair Salon connected so if you get your hair done, you can walk through the connecting door for something to eat!!! read more

Attilios Pizza & Pasta - Cheese Pizza -- Slice - Italian Near Me - Pitman, New Jersey

i usually don't enjoy sicilian pizza, but theirs is to die for. crispy bottom and a fluffy center. so freaking delicious! if you go in person though just be warned they have a little baby toddler running around the restaurant sometimes who opened the door on my boyfriend going to the bathroom read more

Finally a great "nyc slice". Crust is thin with the base crispy thin. Cheese is real and topped upon a fresh, bright, not overly sweet homemade tomato sauce. It's heated to perfection and when you bite into the crust, it's a perfect bite!! They are super friendly and accommodating and after searching and trying tens of pizza slices after moving to south Jersey from nyc, I was so excited that I ran to the counter and thanked them profusely!! The younger proprietor (I unfortunately forgot to ask his name) said he's been making slices for 35 years! I couldn't believe it as he looked so young. This will be my go to when I want a great nyc style slice! Ambiance is casual and friendly. read more

Attilios Pizza & Pasta - Best slice in area! ..Sorry for the bite! That's when I realized I finally found the perfect slice! - Italian Near Me - Pitman, New Jersey

Usually we have no complains about this restaurant, owner is super cool and nice but today we came to pick up our order that we ordered through their website and order said 35 min till pick up so we waited 40 min and came inside to pick up and one of the employees was on his phone sitting away from register and not paying attention and comes to register and says we never put the order in it , came in right now so we haven't started it yet and we than had to wait an extra 30 min for food. Also employee didn't honor price on my receipt through their website which made our order more expensive. I hope this gets fixed it in the future. read more

We have been out of state since 2018 and have missed Jersey pizza terribly! We tried Attilios on Saturday night and it was so so good! The sauce is perfection and the crust is delicious with a great chew. I can highly recommend and will be back soon!! read more

This was an all together weird experience. My friend ordered, then we went to order and the guy taking the order aggressively asked "was this supposed do be added to another order" we clarified and let them know it's a new order. We got our pizza fairly quickly- we were told that there would be a wait for the garlic knots. They ended up coming out 45-50 minutes later. I wouldn't call the service the friendliest. The pizza and knots were fine. read more

Attilios is good. Staff is usually very nice and welcoming. I always get pizza with bacon. I've always enjoyed it though I wouldn't complain if they did more than just a slight sprinkle of bacon. read more

I work at the Theatre down the street and after a show I will usually wonder down there to get a slice and its often pretty late. No matter how late it is, the staff is always courteous and extremely friendly. Pizza is always amazing too AND the place is really clean! Go eat there. Promise you'll love it!!! read more

Yes, went to the Pittman Theatre for a show afterwards we went to Ilio's and that the owner he's a hard worker. The cheesesteak was exceptional. Fresh roll. Good price good customer service a solid place to go. I highly recommend it. read more

10/10 best pizza place I've ever been to really love the quality and I love that they have wings and cheesesteaks. I really recommend and the service is great. And the place feels cozy. read more

Good place for pizza and sandwiches. Tonight we tried the chicken pizza steak, regular pizza steak, plain steak, and mozzarella fries. Sandwiches we're all good, not show stopping, but tasty! Mozzarella fries were good, but they're steak cut so keep that in mind. read more

Went here to kill some time before volunteering at the theater and to get a bite to eat. Got there a little after opening, so it wasn't busy. Place was clean and nicely decorated. Staff was pleasant and took a quick second to see whether ot would dace me money to buy slices vs a whole personal pie. Food was good and prepared fresh. Only downside is that the place charges you a little more if you lay by card. Seems to be a theme with places nowadays. We are slowly becoming a "cashless society" but we will charge a little more if a customer pays by card? Overall, was worth the price despite the slight uncharge for using a card. read more

the food is fine. I have ordered pizza from here three time. on average delivery took an hour and a half. two of the three times the pizza showed up cold. I complained and the only reason I was given was the employees taking calls were busy. unacceptable read more

Safe to say won't be back. $20 for raw pizza dough. ShopRite Is $3/ball....disappointed is an understatement. Hard to support local businesses if they screw their locals over. Was in a bind and didn't have time to prepare/go out and buy so was trying to pop in and give it a go. Big L. read more

Attilios Pizza & Pasta - a pizza in a box - Italian Near Me - Pitman, New Jersey

See all

When I'm In pitman it's my go to place for pizza Staff is always very friendly Prices reasonable I'd cook the pizza maybe a minute or two more but it's a good product Real cheese!!! The place is almost always busy read more

Just paid $7 for basically a side order of fries. No wonder this place is empty these days. Their "pre-Covid" price? $3. Won't be bringing my family here anymore. Update: my kid didn't even eat half of them as they were overcooked. I think they mix in old ones. read more

Attilios Pizza & Pasta - Yes, these are $7 fries, folks. - Italian Near Me - Pitman, New Jersey

Ordered food several items went to pick it up and only the pizza was ready half the order wasn't even made we even gave them an extra few minutes before picking it up if you're going to have kids attending customers at least have them trained and be responsible fooling around in the kitchen when there are orders to be worked on so much for impressing a new customer had to ask for a refund of the rest of my order ridiculous read more

this is the most terrible service i've ever experienced. i have ptsd from bad pizzerias, and this establishment really triggered it. THERE IS F****** PARMESAN CHEESE IN THE GOD FRIGGIN RED PEPPER. IM GAY *UPDATE* second day coming here, still sucks read more

Attilios Pizza & Pasta - mark and atillios cheese fries,,,,,, only snack here is mark and these fries are ass - Italian Near Me - Pitman, New Jersey

Tonight, I ordered 3 plain slices of pizza for my husband and a chicken Caesar salad for me. The man at the front counter was nice, but that was just about the best part of the whole experience. My husband's slices were all burnt. He took one bite and immediately threw the box in the trash. That says a lot, because he is not picky at all and will eat just about anything. My chicken Caesar salad was okay, but nothing to write home about. The chicken was fresh, but was really lacking flavor. The supposedly "homemade" Caesar dressing that is advertised is most definitely not. It tastes exactly like the Caesar dressing you get at most other pizza shops. Most of the kitchen staff were young men cursing and gossiping while working. I really don't mind, but considering the rest of the experience, I decided to note that. Maybe it was just an off-night for them, but I won't bother returning here. read more

This was such a disappointment! My GF and I were here more than an hour before our show's start time across the street. We ordered stromboli and 2 cans of soda, $27.55 total. We waited, and waited, and waited...and after 30 minutes, I went to the counter to find out what was going on. I was told that the stromboli they made needed to be remade and it was already in the works. So we waited, and waited, and waited. Finally, after almost 50 minutes since we placed our order, we had to leave to go to the show. We went to the counter and said we need a refund, and we were told that the stromboli was now ready for us. Too late! We had no time to eat at that point. If they had come to our table after the initial issue, we would have ordered some slices instead so we'd have time to eat. So our refund was in cash, and when we got outside I saw that it was only $22! So we paid $5.55 for 2 cans of soda (and wasted almost an hour of our time). Terrible! We would have been fine with some slices and our soda if we had known that they messed up our order when it happened. So we left hungry, and we had popcorn at the theater for our dinner. And on a minor note, the cans of soda were marked as $1.25 on the cooler. On the menu, $1.29 for cash and $1.34 for credit card. But although I was not given an itemized receipt, I did see "2.98" flash by on the register when my order was taken. There might have even been a credit card surcharge on top of that, but we certainly weren't charged the $1.25 listed on the cooler!!! All in all, a terrible dining experience. With so many other options near the theater, we'll go elsewhere before our next show. And after getting a partial refund for the stromboli, we paid $5.55 for 2 cans of soda!! They messed up our initial order, they never informed us of the delay, they never served us our food in a timely manner, and they only gave a partial refund, leaving us with a $5.55 charge for 2 $1.25 cans of soda. Poor, poor customer service. read more

I drove 40 minutes to get pizza there and they did not disappoint!! Salvatore was very nice & friendly as were all the employees. The pizza was still warm when I got it home. read more

Busy Family restaurant. Wings and curly fries that I had one nice and fresh and made to order. Unfortunately the pizza. My son want it would have taken over a half an hour. My son was satisfied with sausage and cheese Pizza. Nice two beverage cases full of bittled drinks Nice snacks and candy choices for a treat. Also a small selection of fresh groceries. I was kind of confused on how we order when we came in there were three TV screens that were not working probably due to upgrade I was handed a paper threefold menu to pick from. Which was a quick and easy read. Unisex bathroom located. Very spacious I'm comfortable in temperature control. Only do three stars due to obviously repair work that there doing. Looking forward to visiting again let me come back for Fall Festival. read more

I have celiac disease and am extremely sensitive to any cross contamination. Not only was the owner very well versed in the disease and the seriousness of the dangers of ingesting gluten but also knew that having to eat gluten free doesn't mean sacrificing delicious pizza. I highly recommend this place! read more

Attilios Pizza & Pasta - Gluten free meat lovers - Italian Near Me - Pitman, New Jersey

Classic good pizza my wife loves it. They have gluten free pizza also I believe. The staff can sometimes be not the best but the one guy is awesome and super friendly read more

I Hate to put bad reviews on about anyones business.I use to go to this location when it was Venice Italian Eatery and loved it.It was clean, very friendly and the food was always very good. So,I thought I would give this place a try. Well, I won't be back!! The food was average at best, the workers all looked like they were lost ,dressed in jeans and clothes that looked like they slept in them, The service was bad and the bathroom looked like it haden't been cleaned in weeks!! Oh how we miss venice!!! read more

Ordered online, it said it'll be ready in 30 minutes. So I get there 30 minutes later and they hadn't even started my order yet due to an employee mistake (they were clearly not very busy). They told me it will be ready in 10 minutes. So I came back 15 minutes later and it still wasn't done. After standing there waiting another 15 minutes, my order was finally ready. So after an hour, I finally got my food. Got home and noticed my pizza didn't include the toppings I paid for. Staff was careless and misleading. I understand times are tough right now, but the staff did not appear to be very busy (standing around, staring at their phones) and made no attempt to make things right. read more

I have been here for 43 minutes, and just NOW received my order of cheese fries and mozzarella sticks. Waiter only brought 5 sticks and retorted that he had dropped the 6th, and took 7 more minutes to replace it. Not to mention, food is beyond horrendous. I've been here twice and both times have made me late for upcoming excursions and I will NOT be returning! read more

I pride myself on living in an area with typically great pizza. As far as normal pizza shops go, Attilio's makes the best pizza hands down. Their other that I've tried, like wings and cheesesteaks are pretty good too. Do yourself a favor and order from here. read more

My favorite place to go for take out dinner! The owner is amazing, always willing to make customers happy. The buffalo chicken egg rolls are my absolute favorite EVER! When I attended beauty school I ate them so many times a week. My fiancé loves the Stromboli there. Buffalo chicken pizza is also really great. You can't really go wrong here! And the delivery guys are always super nice. Definitely recommend! read more

We were walking down broadway and decide to have pizza for dinner. It was the best pizza in the area. We will be back for sure. The desserts were so enticing, but I was full from the salad and pizza. I forgot to state the soup is home made not the frozen food service you get at a lot of places. read more

On Broadway in Pitman, there are three pizza joints. I have not tried the brick oven place yet. I have only ever had slices here. I like their slices. The dough holds up. It's always fresh. The owner is personable. The prices are good. Two slices and a can of soda is $4.00. Excellent price these days. They aren't the largest slices I have ever been served, but they are tasty. I come in here whenever I'm on Broadway and want a quick bite. read more

This place was just okay, Nothing great. Nothing awful. I can probably get a cheesesteak somewhere better that was terrific. Fries fries were mediocre. Please was immaculately clean. read more

This place has really good pizza!! I am from a popular city and this is one of the best pizza places in NJ! Sauce is delicious! Crust just right, crispy! The pizza is thin which I love!! Cooked to perfection! read more

Our families favorite pizza shop by far! We love the friendly service and the pizza is amazing!! Definitely try their pineapple pizza!!

Standard pizza and pasta place. Close the the children's theater in Pitman so the location is great. Pizza was a bit salty.

Stopped in here for a quick slice before the Ambrosia concert.. Good customer service..

The food needs lot of improvement subpar is understatement. Cheese steak barely had any meat. The Stromboli undercooked. Place is filthy and the 3 guys working look lost. Didn't see anyone who represented themselves as owner or manager. Rumors from locals maybe not good. Don't see this place making it with food they serve the filth and workers. Won't be back. We now wondered why there are very few Yelp or other food app reviews. Place is dead. read more