Really good pizza. I picked up a large thin crust with a few toppings. It was delicious, and I thought that we'd have leftovers - we had very little left. And we were three - 2 being very light eaters. When I'm back in the area, I'd definitely go here again. read more

Arrived 20 minutes prior to posted closing time, sign said closed, went in, was told they could seat us, then were told, oh...sorry, "My mgr just told me we can't serve you, cuz the closed sign is already up." Just put a "?" as the closing time. Very upset by this treatment. read more

Service is horrible unless you ask for Tracy! She's great! Prices are WAY to high. 27 dollars for just a cheese pizza that's nuts. OUTRAGEOUS. The pizza isn't even that great. Don't ask for old over because you won't get it. They don't have an old oven. read more

BEST PIZZA EVER!!!! Wonderful service, great decor and the food is amazing. You can tell they buy quality ingredients because the pizza is so flavorful and my family just loves it! read more

Aurelio's has a place in my heart as it reminds of me of my high school days when I used to go to the one in Palos Heights. I have yet to go to one that tastes different than the others which is good because I know I'll never be disappointed. This particular location in La Grange is a lot different than the one I used to frequent in Palos. It's pretty big on the inside and able to accommodate large parties. I would love to give them 5 stars but their pizza can be a little pricey for some and back when I was in high school, pizza was all I could afford and they have a lot more on the menu today that I want to try so I will be updating this review in the future along with a dine-in experience. Right now I'm digging on the sausage and giardiniera pizza. read more

I love their pizza. It is my favorite in the western 'burbs. Also their chocolate chip cookie with ice cream and whipped cream is to die for. I ordered it one day because my granddaughter wanted it; the combination idea did not appeal to me. But when I tasted it, I was hooked. My friend says it is the best she has had. read more

Outstanding! Friendly private intimate setting. Great food and service! Must go!

The food is OK. The service is fine. Two stars are for the food and service - I want to be fair. The BIG problem is that you never know when there will be scores of unsupervised, screaming kids. Last time I was there, it was mayhem. By the way: don't count on the owner - he will do nothing. If you want to hear whoever you are with - go elsewhere! read more

Each and every time I have stopped by for a late lunch, often being the only person there, the service has been poor. This last time, while there were a few folks eating, I stood at the front waiting to be seated for 7 minutes( checked on my phone!) and finally just left. I/we won't be back. read more

Nice place to take your family for pizza. Service was great!! We enjoyed the sausage pizza. Prices are decent. Reservations recommended for larger parties. We will likely return. read more

This place has great customer service. The manager checks on tables to see how everything is going and he will be glad to help out with anything that you need. Their thin crust pizza is really great. read more

Fantastic pizza, friendly staff. This place can get pretty crowded/busy, so don't be surprised if you have to wait during prime hours. Good wine selection... I will be back here again! read more

Love this place. We are always treated like family here. Table staff are extremely attentive and friendly. From the mozzarella stick to the pizzas, everything arrives hot. Delicious. Very much recommended. read more

This is one of my favorite pizza place in town it's great the pizza. was thin crisp and DELICIOUS in all it is Amazing,delicious,and thin. I can't say this enough it is So Amazing if you come by you should definitely try it. read more

Went here for lunch this past Sunday. The place was mostly empty and the food took what seemed like forever. Pasta with meat sauce was delish! Pizza not so much. they use way too much cheese and cover the entire pizza (to the ends). Our bill for a pizza and a half order of pasta with meat sauce was $45 with tip. Kind of a lot for a lunch of Italian food. read more

Hands down best Aurelio's pizza in the area amazing pizza !!! We come out here all the way from Wheaton! Soo delicious!

We had a Birthday party here. This was my 1st time here. The appetizers were good as was the different topped pizzas. The decor in the restaurant was very nice before the party we had two alcoholic beverages which was over priced. Also the waitress never did bring back our change from the drinks wenever saw her again . read more

This was some horrible pie, I am a pizza connoisseur. I've had pizza from the north side Pete's Pizza, Father and Sons, Congress Bacci's. From the Southside Al, Falco's, Philz, Waldo Cooney's.... excetera, excetera. I heard all the hype about how good the pie is. Disappointed.... I found it to be horrible and overpriced. Throw the pizza way eat the Box it would be better. read more

Pizza was great big for a large we order the the signature six. The only thing that was bad was the services waitress was in a bad mood or not happy to be working there. She slam the menus on the table and gave an attitude every time she ask if we needed anything. Overall OK place service not so great. read more

The service was great, the place looks great but the thin crust pizza was not that good. Why was the pizza on the bad side, the cheese for one was just bland and test less, it failed the stretch test "that's when you pull a slice and the cheese should stretch for a good foot". The ingredients were not fresh or at least they looked like they came put of a can. I have had way better thin crust then this so I can't understand why this place was so highly rated for their thin crust pizza. I have not tried anything else so their other dishes might be good but for me if the pizza is not right then I'm not coming back for the rest. read more

Decent pizza but inconsistent. When it's good, it's real good, and when it's not, it's ... meh. When it's good, the crust is crispy and the cheese is just a little burned - and what's better than a little burnt cheese? When it's not good, the crust is soggy and the cheese is soggy and my spirit is soggy. So when I order from here, I pray to the pizza gods - please give me burnt cheese! read more

Ordered for delivery, and defenetly expected more for my buck. I mean pizza is pizza but this is not good at all. Might as well go around the corner to dinicos and get your money's worth and your tummy will thank you! read more

Love it. Wife is from Homewood, IL and every since going to the original location and getting our pizza's well done in the "old oven", I've been hooked. Love this location's feel and the pizza's are just as good. Bravo! read more

Great thin pizza, green olives are way too salty.

I can only assume that the positive reviews came from suburban diners who have never had good authentic pizza. We got the thin crust pizza with half cheese half veggies. Who puts cheddar cheese on pizza?? When it was served I was shocked, and when I tasted it I was horrified. This was the worst pizza I've ever had. We took the leftovers home; we shouldn't have, because we just threw them away anyway. Go somewhere where they know how to make a true Italian pizza - not some Americanized cracker topped with unappetizing cheeses. read more

Generally a nice place. But when I ordered carry out the total price seemed high. I questioned the total price by attempting to explain that the prices in the on-line menu are different than what the lady taking my order was rattling off. She loudly spoke over me, talked too fast to follow, wouldn't listen to me, and left me feeling disrespected. Finally, I ended the call by telling her I'll have to go over the charges with the manager when I got there. read more

The only reason why I'm not giving one star is because the staff was really nice and attentive (they forgot to refill our water though). Also they gave my boyfriend and I an extra starter salad since we were splitting our chicken parm. The reason why this review is bad is because he chicken parm was incredibly underwhelming. We paid $14 for what was essentially a bowl of pasta with a plain unseasoned chicken breast thrown in, thin jar-like marina, and a sprinkle of mozzarella on top. Chicken parm is supposed to be breaded or at least contain some parm. I could have made this at home for $5. read more

This place is great. The pizzas are tasty and you can't beat 1/2 off wine bottles on Mondays!

This is the best thin crust pizza we've found in the area. Service is always nice. Their six inch sized pizzas are perfect since my husband and I like completely different things on our pizzas...lets us have our own without breaking the bank. We tried the toasted ravioli last time we were there...delicious! read more

Barely edible pizza. The sauce is ok but the cheese and crust are terrible. The first time I tried it I thought maybe they have the wrong people cooking tonight. A few months later I tried it again and still terrible. So many better places around the Lagrange area. read more

We are 1.9 miles away and it took an hour and a half to get my order. When the pizza finally came, it was lukewarm and the $12 house salad was upside down (made of all iceberg lettuce - not romaine as advertised !!) Think twice before ordering! I will go never stray from prima la pizza in hillside again. read more

Did they change their pizza recipe?? It used to be a million times better before. Now it's too salty and the cheese just doesn't taste right. I was so disappointed :( it was my favorite pizza place!! This makes me sad! read more

Terrific pizza crispy sweet and especially good sausage. Fresh Mushrooms. I like the vintage and train decor as well. Great for kids

My freind took me here back in August for my bday and we ordered the pizza which everyone seems to brag about but when i tasted the pizza it was salty and didnt really seem to live up to all the hype that surrounds it. I would have to say ive had way better pizza than this and it was way cheaper too. read more

Very good experience over all. My girlfriend and I almost went to The bigger chain pizza place down the street but I am very glad we chose to go with this place. I got a stuffed pizza with sausage and mushrooms. The cheese and sauce were unique and delicious. The waitress was friendly and attentive but not smothering. I highly recommend this place if you're looking to get stuffed pizza while you're in the area. read more

This review is based solely off the pizza. The cheese blend is delicious I love the sauce. The crust is just perfect. One of my favorites pizzas ever. read more

Hands down best Pizza Ever!!! We ordered the every thing veggie pizza and it came out perfect. The combo of the suce and crust is my favorite. The service is always good and the food comes out right. A consistently good choice for a family pizza night out. read more

What happened? The pizza a year or so ago was good. Last night's thin crust wasn't. Didn't even taste like pizza. Totally neutral. If you closed your eyes, you wouldn't even know you were eating pizza. The restaurant was jammed last year and empty last night. Owners should go back to the drawing board. Frankly, I think one has to go to NY or Italy to get good pizza. Geno's East was good 40 years ago, but haven't been there in decades. I have given up on Chicago for pizza. read more

The pizza is delicious - the thin crust is the best we've had in Chicago. The waitstaff was attentive, and the owner even dropped by our table to ensure everything was great. In addition to the thin crust, we tried the spinach roll and the deep dish cookie dessert - everything was excellent! Can't wait to go again. read more

This was our second visit to this Aurelio's. The first time we went there we ordered pasta. It was good but not amazing. When we went back with our friends they turned us on to the thin crust pizza. We split their "works" pizza with our spinach and tomato. Both pizzas were excellent, especially the one with everything on it. We ordered two deep dish cookie desserts. Really good, but one would have been enough for all of us. Server was helpful but not pushy. We will be back! read more