What a pleasant surprise! I've lived in Holbrook all my life and I've never been here before…read more Ordered a bacon egg and cheese on an egg everything bagel (after reading the revised on their BEC)... it was excellent! Bacon cook well, bagel was fresh, the customer service was wonderful! PS comes with either OJ or coffee!

Stopped in to grab a bite around 1PM on a Saturday. Ordered a Sausage, Egg, and Cheese on an…read moreEverything Bagel. Pros: The staff was nice. The bagel was large. Cons: The bagel felt dry. The sausage & egg were not large enough for the bagel. This was also one of the more expensive bagel sandwiches I've bought in the area and I don't think the quality matches the price. The place also felt messy and unclean. Maybe the quality and cleanliness would have been better if I got food first thing in the morning, but I don't think I'll be heading back here anytime soon given the other options in the area.

Stopped here on a Saturday to get a Sausage, Egg, and Cheese on an Everything Bagel. The line was…read morelong, but that normally means you're at the right place. Service was friendly and I don't feel like I had to wait too long. My bagel sandwich was tasty! I feel like it was a good size and cooked well. Great place to grab a bagel and will go back if I'm in the area.

Second time here today …read more The first time I came here I got a dozen bagels to bring to Florida with me. My cousin described them as euphoric. They were very good. I don't know why I haven't been back in so long. I decided to stop in today for an egg sandwich. I got BEC with hot sauce on an everything bagel. It was so delicious. My fiancé had SECSPK on a seedless roll. He said it was really good. Staff was very friendly this morning (7/11/25 around 830am) too. Service with a smile. Definitely coming here more often and driving the extra few minutes from my apartment to do so.

I've been to Bagel Brothers a number of times over the years and they are consistent. Their…read moreeverything bagels have barely any seeds on them, there is always a line, service is good, and everything has good flavor. This is not my favorite bagel shop in the area but it's one of the only ones close for the people who live over here. I've had worse and I've had better, Bagel Brothers is middle of the road for bagels on Long Island.

I come here because the food is good. The prices are ok and the staff is friendly. They always get…read morethe order correct and I do appreciate that. With that being said, sometimes in life you must close your eyes at what you see, this place needs a good deep down cleaning. Floors are disgusting and bathroom door is filthy so it is a visual turn off.

This is one of my sisters favorite breakfast sandwiches spots that she's blesses me with when I…read morecome into town! And I must say they do have the best bacon egg and cheese rolls!! If you're from New York you know, nothing beats B.E.C from New York! 10/10

Something seems off here, this bagel spot has been extremely busy for years…read more Today I walked in at 8:30 am and only two people on line and staff is sparse. Something felt completely different. The was NO cream cheese in the display case and staff seemed confused on what they should be doing. I ordered egg whites and bacon on a roll. When the server went to ring me up I asked if it included a juice or coffee or tea, she replied yes. It's a pet peeve of mine that if something is included in the price the server should offer it to you. Bad business in my opinion. The sandwich was ok, definitely smaller portions than before but still ok, the coffee on the other hand was horrible. Tasted like a dirty pot of grinds. Not sure when I will be back to try again.

Not sure if I would call this a hidden gem. It is a very small bagel shop in a strip mall located…read moreoff the side of Rt. 112. The longish sort of line seemed promising, but the hold up wasn't because everyone needed a bagel from here, it was only because of a discrepancy of some sort. The staff was hustling, and eggs were being flipped right behind the counter and everything looked like it was kept clean. The service is a bit subpar. I was skipped over, which seemed to be an honest mistake so I didn't fuss. More pissed at the dude that speak up to say I was next. I guess chivalry is dying. The bagel itself was also subpar. I ordered an everything flagel with olive cream cheese. It wasn't bad by any means it just wasn't anything special. The star of the show was the cream cheese. Wasn't too olivey and you can tell it was pretty fresh. Nothing was labeled so I couldn't tell you what other cream cheeses they had. The menu was digital and was hung on the wall behind the counter. It didn't have much besides the list of bagels and before I could try to read more it would flash off. This place is fine in a pinch, but I'm not running back any time soon.

staff is very friendly, the bagels are really fresh so soft with that touch of light crisp so softread more

Such kind employees & most delicious bagels!! Always my go to bagel shop, they never disappoint!read more

There is not one bagel I ate from BL and not like it! Soo good and the coffee is always good too!…read moreMy kids love the same stuff usually but I'm happy they add some for me to try out. I'd add pictures but I remember that on full happy stomach next time (maybe)

Firehouse Bagels in Holtsville is by far the worst bagel spot I've ever been to. I ordered a bacon,…read moreegg, and cheese on a roll with an orange juice, and the experience was appalling. While paying, I noticed the staff handling money and food without washing their hands--a major health violation. That alone was enough to make me uncomfortable, but it gets worse. After eating, I experienced severe stomach pain that hasn't subsided. This place is unsanitary, disgusting, and far below the standards expected in New York. Someone needs to call the health department because this level of cleanliness is unacceptable. I will never return, and I strongly advise others to stay away.Health department needs to check this place. Ordered a bacon, egg, and cheese but got just egg and cheese with old, nasty bacon cooked in dirty oil. Not fresh at all. Upset my stomach--beware!

The building it's self could use a little TLC but I'm here to rate food and service and both were…read moregreat.

I want to be so mad at this place because of the prices, well I'm still mad about the prices!…read more The breakfast sandwich was really good, like really good. I won't come back unless someone else is paying lol. Spacious inside with seating and service is suspicious I felt over charged.

My go to place for a well made bacon egg and cheese! The…read morefood and service are amazing.. the girls are friendly and their chef makes the food with much love.. Highly recommend.