We moved from massapequa, we really REALLY miss our old bagel place so this on had some big shoes to fill. The service is friendly and super quick. They for some reason do not like toasting bagels lol every time I ask they always forget. The coffee is alright, they do not have all the good international delights creamers I love. The prices are about 20% more than our old place. The wait is much longer here than at the place across front street by Marshalls, Cafe something-they are the same prices and same quality so we go there mor. It's just a minute more down the road. read more

Very nice people but the kitchen is the slowest thing I have ever see. Waited for over 20 minutes for a bacon and egg on a bagel.

My fiance and I frequent this establishment quite often.. With that being said, my fiance and I have frequented many a bagel places. None of which even come close to how exuberantly expensive one their menu is. With bagels aside, one Sandwich is $7.49 WITHOUT THE APPLICABLE SURCHARGE FOR ONE SLICE OF CHEESE, which Jay the ringer, will never forget. You cannot get rolls after 10:30 on a weekend. They charge extra surcharges for every condiment. You want mayo, add 50 cents. Extra pickle, 50cents. Every time we go in, we see Jay at the register working feverishly over the cash register... Adding so many extra surcharges that his fingers are wrapped in gauze. We have even noticed when one of the other workers at the establishment begins to take charge on the cash register, Jay will swiftly move in and regain command to optimize the profits at bagelicious. read more

Love this place for bagels and breakfast sandwiches. The girls behind the counter are always so sweet. They get pretty busy during the morning breakfast hours, especially during the weekend, but it's so worth it. Get your spreads somewhere else though. Too expensive here. Bagels are super reasonable. Buy 12, get one free! There's also plenty of parking. Def give this place a try if you're in the area. Makes not living in Brooklyn anymore just a little better. read more

I got a catering order of a basket of bagels and a tray of spreads delivered to someone today. The staff was so nice when I called up this past weekend. So accommodating, willing to work with my budget and get me exactly what I was envisioning in my head. To top it off the feedback was great, everyone loved everything! I defiantly recommend this bagel place! read more

The only place locally to get a bagel. The quality of the food is always great. The staff is friendly and the wait time is usually right on point. I do all my catering for work and holidays there as well. read more

This place is great. I love the bagels and the derive. Good prices too. Can't beat that combo. I recommend it. Especially since the place across the way in sub par. This place blows it out of the water. read more

For some reason in the past year every time I've gone the cashiers always have an attitude. I love their bagels so I tolerate it. This morning everyone had an attitude. I ordered an egg, ham and cheese on a bagel. When I got home and sat to eat I unwrapped my sandwich, bacon, egg and cheese on a roll. This was the last straw. read more

The most efficient, convenient, and delicious bagel place to go to. Busy mornings you'll see a line out the door, but if you go after about 10 you're in the clear. Huge variety of bagels, wraps, omelets, muffins, cookies, etc. would recommend read more

Always great bagels and they put lots of cream cheese which I love! Have been coming for many years

Fantastic experience. I was in town for a lacrosse tournament with my 17 year old son. I was in charge of lunch. From start to finish they made it as easy as it could be. I ordered 6 foot subs, they allowed me to switch sides for fruit, they met me on the field to deliver AND they were some of the best subs I have ever had. The presentation was excellent, the subs were as fresh as could be. I kept it simple, the American and Italian. The team and the parents all loved it. Thank you!!! read more

I really wanted to like this place, the food is not bad and the place is nice. But they have MESSED UP my order every single time I have been there! So frustrating! read more

The filthiest bagel store on Long Island. Period. If you'd like to get sick, then by all means go eat here. If you'd like safe bagels and such, try one of the many other options in the area. This place is simply disgusting. read more

One of the best bagel stores around Long Island Best vegetable tuna salad and great variety of drinks- desserts look ok only tried the chocolate rugelach and it was not great because I am comparing it to The Bakery rugelach (circa 1998)Prices are a bit high for the tuna bagel sandwich so that was the only bummer read more

I usually stop here to get breakfast and the breakfast food is always sooooo good. The bagels are great. However, today I stopped by for lunch and I was craving a cheeseburger. I figured since everything else I ever had there was good, I should give their burger a try. They told me I had to wait 20 mins for my burger and fries and I thought that meant that I was getting a fresh burger. Well, when my 9 month pregnant self got home and was ready to enjoy a cheeseburger, I was shocked to see that the burger was on a roll and not a bun and the fries looked like they had been in the bottom of the freezer since '98. The pattie was dry and tasted like it was cooked with freezer burn. There was no lettuce and no tomato.. just cheese, the dry pattie and the big sandwich roll. I am highly disappointed in this place. You should not have burgers and fries on your menu if you are going to serve people crap like that. I lost major respect for this place. read more

See all

Food was ok but the prices are out of control. I got 3 egg whites and turkey and iced coffee for $10.50. I had no idea these guys were so pricey. This same order costs 7.50 tops at other locations in the area. Last visit for m read more

The food here is good. But, the staff works very slow and I always find myself waiting extremely long before I get my meal especially around breakfast. Not to mention they are very overpriced. read more

A solid choice for breakfast. Clean place, nice staff, good food. I've only had bagels and breakfast sandwiches, which are great. Very tasty cream cheeses, and the mini bagels are popular, so give them a try. Pretty fast service, decent prices. Coffee and bakery items are not great. Recommended! read more

By far the best bagels in the world! They have two other locations...one of them is actually in east meadow as well, so you can imagine how good the bagels must be to have two locations in the same small town. I'm sure you can get kosher stuff, but you don't have worry about being refused a bacon, egg, and cheese or even a chicken salad like in bagel boss...also they do not ever close for holidays (from what I have seen). You can ship bagels to anywhere in the world! read more

Sorry but after close to 15 years of coming for breakfast sandwiches I have to complain, even when order is taking and items on sandwich noted the two sandwiches took close to 20 minutes to came and they ding do a good job, too small pieces of cheese (after complaining) it looks like one scramble egg and by this time very cold any way may be a new cook, no manager supervision, we will like to continue our patronage but not at this conditions,... read more

Lox and cream cheese bagel was very skimpy and definitely not worth the $$$ price. Also purchased a Twinkie that was likely well over the stale date and was starting to fossilize. I definitely do not recommend. read more

When you ask for an everything bagel,you get everything on both sides.Paulie likes that!

Don't go here. Saw one of the workers put 2% milk into the whole milk bottle don't even want to know what else they do behind their customers back read more

Never fails, always good. It gets really busy on the weekends so if you plan on going be prepared to wait or go on off peak hours.

This is my first time coming here. I always get my nails done at Angel Tip Nails but never noticed this small place. I ordered there tri color pasta which was delicious. Very creamy and full of flavor. I also had chicken cuttlet with bacon and american chesse with ranch dressing on a toasted roll which was absolutely finger licking. The chicken was so tender and fresh. I also wanted a few fresh bagels to go and the cashier gave them to me for free since they were going to be thrown out any ways. read more

Great breakfast and great coffee in the morning. It gets a bit busy inside but the food and coffee are worth the wait. the breakfast bagels and wraps taste great and consistent. Recommend this place for a great breakfast and great self serve coffee.. read more

Great Bagels! However, the line on weekends can be out the door! It's best to try to get there a bit early to avoid the line. All and all worth the wait. The have a salad bar and make great sandwiches read more

HORRIBLE CUSTOMER SERVICE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Went into the store and waited on line while 2 managers and an employee spoke with each other for 8 to 10 minutes while I was just 2 feet away from them at the counter, Totally ignored me, I did not make a scene or say a word, I will just never set foot back into your business. If this is how they treat their customers then imagine how they treat the food they serve??? I WILL NEVER RECOMMEND THIS CAFE TO ANYONE!!!!!!!!!!! I worked in the food industry for over 14 years and this was just down right unacceptable!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! One star is way too much for this café but it would not allow me to post my review. read more

Been going there since I was a kid, and never will I ever go back. They never seem to get an order correct if it goes back into the kitchen, along with Hair being in my food several times. But the one that got me was when I ordered a pound of cream cheese and there was hair in the middle of it. From that day on I refuse to go back. read more

This is the best bagel place in the area. I always get the egg bagel with vegetable cream cheese and it is amazing. It's the best vegetable cream cheese I have ever had; and the staff is usually pretty generous with the amount of cream cheese per bagel. The coffee is pretty good too. I look forward to having my bagels each weekend. read more

Just moved to east meadow trying to find a good breakfast spot and this is definitely not the spot. Food very unsatisfying and over priced. Not an actual New York bagel place. I'll be looking for some place better and won't be back. read more

My boyfriend and I walked in today hoping for fresh bagels but got the complete opposite. We both ordered bagel sandwiches, mine was an everything bagel and his was a salt bagel. Both of ours were completely stale and hard to bite through. Don't expect freshly made bagels here they will give you yesterday's stale bagels. What a disappointment that this is the "NY bagel" experience some people are getting. Also, how do you have pastrami specials listed on your menu and no pastrami? Will definitely not be returning. read more

Thank you John, Josh, Jay, Neil and all the wonderful staff, for making our Yom Kippur break fast and delicious event. The food was outstanding as usual. The bagels are the tastiest on Long Island. White fish great, baked salmon and whitefish salad just delicious. Lox...expertly sliced and melt in your mouth fantastic. The platters of cheeses and fishes looked beautiful on my table. Thank you so much for all the effort you put in during this holiday and all year round. read more

Great bagels and an excellent staff. Melanie helped me..she was fantastic, quick service and a friendly smile.

I've been coming here for the past few years the service has always been fast and friendly. There selection of bagels and spreads are good and woukd recommend stopping by if you are near... read more

One of the worst places I've ever eaten. The bagels were drier then the sahara desert and they just started making hashbrowns, which tasted like vomit. Also, the service was heinous I shouldn't have to wait 20 minutes for a toasted bagel with cream cheese when no one was even in front of me in line. And the bagel wasn't even toasted! I would highly recommend to never eat at this place, ever. read more

Egg sandwiches are decent but not the best I ever had. However they are highly overpriced. 2 eggs with cheese on a bagel is $7. Service is slow. I found a better place. read more

Girl at the counter has an attitude and couldn't handle three customers. Only reason I got helped sooner was because the person in front of me left. And they clearly don't know what a CHOPPED salad is. Just threw everything into a bowl and NOT mixed. Was going to sit outside but couldn't because had to go back to my job to get a real knife and chop up everything myself. Thought this place was decent the first time but probably won't come back now. read more

Bagelicious is beyond over priced, they constantly mess up orders, and always take forever just for a simple order. I've been going to Heavenly Bagel in Levittown because it is MUCH cheaper and beyond delicious. Just because Bagelicious is the only bagel place around, doesn't give them any right to have overpriced food. read more

Favorite bagel store hands down. Have never been disappointed and the service there is impeccable. Cheers to a great business.