*SUMMER 2026 RESTAURANT WEEK REVIEW ONLY* Most places typically don't offer restaurant week menu on Saturday, but this place does & luckily for us, we were nearby so it worked out perfectly! My friend and I arrived late 11am. It was fairly empty, but people started to trickle in the later it got. We came exclusively for the restaurant week menu & got started right away. We were given an assortment of bread/crackers with olive oil/balsamic to begin. I personally ordered: IMPORTED BUFFALO MOZZARELLA This was 4 pieces of cut mozzarella & tomato slices. It was a good thickness size. The mozzarella itself was good & exactly what you would expect to taste of a piece of fresh slice. It was simple & light. USDA PRIME JUNIOR NEW YORK SIRLOIN I personally ordered medium rare. It was cooked almost the way I like it. The cut did have some stringy tendon parts in the meat that made it hard to cut, but overall, the meat was very juicy. At first bite, I was impressed. My friend and I also enjoyed their signature steak sauce - it added the right amount of flavor to the meat. The vegetables & mashed potatoes were also great. It wasn't too salty, which was seasoned to my liking. NEW YORK CHEESECAKE By the time dessert came around, I found myself getting quite full. So unfortunately, I didn't get to finish everything... but the cheesecake was good. The raspberry compote did add a tarty mix to the sweetness. The whipped cream balanced the sweetness/tartiness. Overall, I thought that the meal was worth the value. I enjoyed every course. I did leave the restaurant quite satisfied in fullness & taste. The service was also excellent. They were good about offering the dishes in a timely manner, filling up our water cups & checking in on us. I'm glad that I stopped by for their restaurant week lunch course. read more

See all

One of my favorite restaurants for NYC Restaurant Week every year. Always great food, cocktails, and service. Large space with plenty of seating. It was busy even on a Tuesday. (We reserved our table for 2 in advance). From what I could see near us, some tables were there for restaurant week and others just for the regular menu. There was at least one large group at a large round table. We shared a dozen oysters to start (separate from restaurant week menu.) Cocktails: Love potion #2 Paper Airplane Manhattan Everything tasted great and had great portions. We even had some leftovers. Our NYC Restaurant Week order: Sizzling Canadian Bacon Fried Calamari New York Strip Steak x2 Creamless Creamed Spinach Benjamin Home Fries NY Cheesecake Chocolate Mousse Cake read more

See all

ABSOLUTELY ONE OF THE BEST STEAKHOUSES! Ahhh love this Steakhouse!! The atmosphere is warm, elegant, and incredibly welcoming. Perfect place for a special dinner with friends or a romantic night out. The steak was absolutely perfect buttery, incredibly tender! Perfection. You truly couldn't ask for a better steak. I can't wait to come back! read more

Benjamin Steakhouse - Porterhouse and spinach - Steakhouses Near Me - New York, New York

I surprised my wife and son while in NY and they were beyond surprised. They said, it was their favorite steakhouse EVER! The ambience is high end business with the service to match! If you're really lucky you may see a celebrity or two. Definitely plan on reservations before you go. read more

Benjamin Steakhouse - Porterhouse Steak for 2 - Steakhouses Near Me - New York, New York

Service was wonderful as we informed them that this was our son's first upscale steakhouse experience. It was my husband's and my favorite steakhouse when we used to live in the city many years ago, but we remembered the steak being a little less salty and more tender. We ordered the porterhouse for two with creamed spinach, and it was definitely a big enough portion for two adults and one child. Love how the steak sizzles on the hot plate as the servers bring it out. It takes a bit for your eyes to adjust to the dim lights but all the more heightened senses to savor the taste! read more

Benjamin Steakhouse - Steakhouses Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Updating my review to give it more stars this time :) Came here for an event on a Tuesday night, the food was really good! Friendly staff too! Tried the scallops, tbone ribeye, lobster mac and cheese, creme brulee and some other sides and everything was good! Shishito peppers, mashed potatoes, creamed spinach, crispy Brussel sprouts, onion rings are all good read more

See all

I came for a lunch business meeting. I Had the lunch pre fixe meal and The filet mignon was amazing. Would def recommend! The ambiance was traditional and classy. The service was great as well. The waiters were very on top of everything. read more

Benjamin Steakhouse @ this location is on E. 41st St. in Midtown, close to Bryant Park, 42nd St. Grand Central Terminal & other hang-out areas & shops. I visited the week before to get a view of the place before booking the Christmas Eve Reservation. The lovely woman @ the front let me look around, answered my questions & completed my reservation quickly. We came for early Christmas Eve dinner, in order to start enjoying it before the later dinner crowd arrived. Benjamin Steakhouse Staff at the front give us a warm greeting befote fulfilling our request to be seated upstairs. We enjoyed sitting in their Balcony Area overlooking downstairs. Benjamin Steakhouse had a Christmas Eve & Christmas Day Prix Fixe menu option. It included a glass of Eggnog (you can choose either the alcohol or non-alcoholic option), an Appetizer, an Entree, a Side & Dessert. We both had the Liqueur Eggnog option, a Crab Cake Appetizer, Filet Mignon - one w/ side of mashed potatoes & one w/ broccoli (we shared to get a taste of both side dishes), & one slice of cheesecake & one slice of carrot cake for dessert. Boy, I know that I say things are delicious often because I have had some great food in my lifetime (lol), but when I say that every dish was delicious, I mean it! The Crab Cake, & the Filet Mignon w/ Vegetables....cooked so well. Fabulous bread basket, succulent steak, crispy broccoli, creamy potatoes, well-seasoned steak & crab cakes & heavenly dessert! .Eggnog, the dishes the desserts - everything was flavorful & fantastic. So much so, that I wish I had some of every dish in front of me now (lol). Benjamin Steakhouse had beautiful holiday-themed decor, a gorgeous Christmas Tree, coupled w/ elegant ambiance & overall wonderful service! They have a good Restaurant Week Menu & a good Valentine's Day Menu - this will be available on Feb. 13th & Feb. 14th. @benjaminsteak Benjaminsteakhouse.com read more

See all

We ordered the Benjamin's salad and porterhouse for two. I did NOT think we'd be able to finish it but I kid you not, this steak MELTED in my mouth. Hands down the BEST meal of our NY trip. On the pricier side, so this is more of a celebratory place for us, but looking forward to the next event my partner and I will be celebrating bc we will 1000% be back!!! read more

Benjamin Steakhouse - Porterhouse for two - Steakhouses Near Me - New York, New York

Really a very good steakhouse. I had lunch at the bar today and would rank Benjamin's high on the list of NYC steakhouse options. Got the sirloin from the regular menu, cooked medium rare. Also just a side of creamed spinach. That was a perfect portion. The steak was cooked perfectly and had a great dry aged aroma and taste. Service at the bar -- I believe it was from Angela -- was excellent. This is a very strong candidate for a good quality steak if you are in midtown. I would rank this in the conversation of Wolfgang's, Gallaghers, and Rocco's. Would strongly recommend this place. read more

Benjamin Steakhouse - Sirloin and creamed spinach. Excellent meal. - Steakhouses Near Me - New York, New York

I love steak. LOVE IT. This place did not disappoint. We ordered the Porterhouse for three. What came out was the most delicious, buttery, amazing steak I've had in the last ten years. It was just absolutely awesome. We ordered the creamed spinach and steak fries and those were delicious as well! All in all, this was an awesome experience! read more

See all

What an amazing experience. I would always go to the usual steakhouses but decided to give this one a try. WOW! Now I will not go to another steakhouse. The service was impeccable, the atmosphere was very good, the ambience outstanding and the food was SIMPLY DELICIOUS!!! Yes! We all enjoyed our steaks, sides and cocktails were expertly prepared. What an awesome time we all left saying we had! I highly recommend this restaurant. This is now my favorite steakhouse in NYC! read more

Benjamin Steakhouse - Steak. - Steakhouses Near Me - New York, New York

It's one of my personal traditions to dine at a steakhouse on Thanksgiving, and this year's visit to Benjamin Steakhouse may be one of my favorites thus far. The atmosphere was warm and inviting, even on a packed holiday. The Thanksgiving rush was handled with ease. Our server was friendly, attentive, and provided perfectly timed service throughout our meal. The first thing I had was the crab cake, and it was great: crispy on the outside, tender and flavorful inside... just right with the seasoning. No filler, just quality. For my entrée, I went with the Traditional Thanksgiving Turkey (turkey, stuffing, roasted yams, potatoes au gratin, and cranberry relish). Everything on the plate delivered! To finish, the pumpkin pie hit the spot... smooth, spiced just right, and it came with whipped cream and a scoop of vanilla ice cream. A perfect ending to a holiday meal. I left full, satisfied, and already thinking about returning long before next November. I recommend it whether you are on holiday or not. read more

See all

Came to Benjamin Steakhouse for our 6 year anniversary. Benjamin's is set up like a traditional "old school" steakhouse and has the great service you would expect at that type of establishment. No waiting with reservation, quickly sat, and even surprised with a glass of champagne for our celebration. Much appreciated. Our waiter was attentive, made great suggestions, and was always nearby. The porterhouse for two was cooked to perfection, the sides were filling and shareable, and they had a great lemon drop martini. This is a great steakhouse for celebrations, closing a deal, or meeting with friends. read more

See all

A true New York experience! Best service I've ever had anywhere. hands down! Incredible food and cocktails

I had dinner at Benjamin's this week with a group of 11 friends, and the entire experience was flawless an easy 11/10. Ambiance and Service We were seated in the upstairs dining area, which was perfect for a large party: roomy, lively, and still comfortable enough for conversation. From start to finish, the staff was attentive without hovering. When one of my dirty gin martinis arrived missing the blue-cheese olives, our server noticed before I even said a word and swiftly brought a fresh skewer which was a small touch but big impact. Drinks * Dirty gin martinis (with plenty of blue-cheese olives) * Espresso martinis to cap the night Both cocktails were well-balanced and generously poured, making them worth the splurge. Starters * Wedge salad -- crisp lettuce, thick-cut bacon, and a punchy dressing that stole the appetizer show. * Grilled octopus -- tender and nicely charred, but the wedge was the unanimous favorite. The Main Event We split three Porterhouse-for-Fours and one Porterhouse-for-Two. Every steak arrived medium-rare, perfectly seared, and remarkably tender with no chewing marathons here. Sides * Lobster mac & cheese (rich, with big lobster chunks) * Creamed spinach (silky and indulgent) * Onion rings, sautéed mushrooms, and broccoli (all solid) The mac and creamed spinach tied for crowd-favorite, and the staff handled all the plating table side eliminating any awkward passing or uneven portions. Value At roughly $240 per person, including 3-4 cocktails each, appetizers, steaks, sides, and dessert-in-a-glass espresso martinis, the price felt entirely fair for the quality, quantity, and service level. Bottom Line Benjamin's Steakhouse nails the big-group steakhouse experience: stellar service, perfectly cooked porterhouse, standout sides, and cocktails that keep the table buzzing. I can't point to a single miss. If you're planning a celebratory gathering, put Benjamin's at the top of your list. You won't be disappointed. read more

See all

Very expensive but solid food, fine. The low score is the complete lack of customer awareness at the bar. Between waiting 10 minutes to place a drink order because the bartenders are hanging out with cute girls at one end of the bar, or fighting thru the bro hangout ar the other end of the bar - if you don't know someone you're not getting good service. Sorry Benjamin - expensive and poor service is a bad hill to own. read more

Classic New York City steakhouse from the vibes to the food. Had the steak for two as recommended by our server and it was fantastic. Will definitely be coming back. read more

Benjamin Steakhouse - Steakhouses Near Me - New York, New York

Dark and cozy atmosphere, great servers- they all seemed to help each other. Steak seasoning was good but a bit dry. Could have used some fun and unique steak sauce other than there house made bbq/horseradish sauce that's on every table (I wasn't a fan of the sauce). Sides were bland and could have used more salt or seasoning. Not bad, but wouldn't come back or suggest to anyone to come here if they want to a nice juicy steak in NY read more

See all

My experience was unexpected. Made a reservation for a Sun morning before the shuttle and flight back home. I appreciated the hostess offering to check my suitcase. Country music flowed through the speakers during my entire meal. I distracted and detracted from the decor and atmosphere- it was weird. My food was average. Nothing notable. The onion ring batter had no flavor. The burger bun was huge so I tried to eat the burger with a fork- the meat just crumbled in tiny pieces like ground meat. I asked for bread when no one brought it. A group of 6 finished while I was getting seated- no one else was in the restaurant. I felt like a distraction as the servers were preparing for lunch or dinner service. Servers were friendly. Restrooms in the basement- only noting this for anyone with mobility concerns. read more

See all

Always a 5 Star!!! Tonight was not any different from any other night. My daughter and I celebrated our dining experience here after attending the taping of The Tonight Show with Jimmy Fallon. Our first choice was Benjamin Steakhouse on 41st. As in the many visits in the past, there was NO disappointment. The service, quality of the food, ambiance, energy were all 5*. We shared a Porterhouse for 2 after sharing a Shrimp Cocktail. Our beef was ordered medium and it was served sizzling hot, charred and sliced. It was done perfect for our taste as was the side of steamed broccoli. We also shared a Coppola Direct Cab bottle of wine with our meal and prior had a Tito Martini slighty dirty and a Buffalo Trace Old Fashioned prepared by G at the Bar. John, as always, was a most gracious host as were all his support people. Friendly, attentive, kind, and gracious as was our waiter. This is the culture of Benjamin's. We ended our evening with a group shot with Benjamin to top off a great night and excellent meal. Yes, I will always return and it is my personal NO 1 steakhouse in New York City. I hope you will share the same experience when you visit! Don't be shy. You will not be disappointed! read more

Here comes to celebrate sister's birthday at the great steakhouse!! Perfect timing for NYC Restaurant Week! Service was amazing and the ambiance was great for any kind of celebration :) steaks were very well done became one of the top steakhouse! Gotta go back there for another rib eye steak!!! read more

See all

Solid Manhattan Steakhouse with really good service! Three of us in a lunch meeting shared the two person porterhouse...the meat was excellent! Perfectly cooked! The environment was perfect for the important conversation...not too loud and not too quiet...the right energy level for getting done what needed to be done! Can't comment on the drinks...hahaha...had to stay sharp! read more

Went here for a business lunch. And it was restaurant week so we all had the fixed menu. The Caprese was delicious. The balsamic vinegar was sadly nonexistent and could have had more basil. Loved the mozzarella. The filet was cooked to a perfect medium rare. Sear was great and loved the level of salt. The mashed potatoes were heavenly. Loved the garlic flavor of the vegetables but they did seem like frozen vegetables and not freshly chopped. The chocolate mousse was a disaster. Way too sweet and not enough texture. The cream was just too overpowering and they didn't even need that on the plate. For the size of our group the service was fine. Vibes are cool but it was absolutely freezing in there with the ac blasting. My whole group was freezing. Would 100% recommend the filet and mashed potatoes. read more

Benjamin Steakhouse - Steakhouses Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Hubby took me here for a late night Valentines dinner and we both loved the pre-fixe selection. The bacon app was DELISH and a must-try for all the bacon stand out there. But the crabcake left a lot to be desired - it was just okay. We both got rib-eyes for our main entree and ordered creamed spinach and fries for our sides. The rib eye was delicious. It had the perfect crust on it and was super tender. The fries were great but the creamed spinach lacked flavor for us and tasted more like a bag of frozen spinach than creamy steakhouse creamed spinach we're used to. Lastly, both the cheese cake and chocolate mousse were solid desserts and super rich. The service was fast and pleasant and the ambience had an old world appeal as most steak houses do. Overall-our experience was lovely and we're excited to return and try other dishes on the menu. read more

See all

It's been two years that we came to this restaurant and I can't stop thinking about it. I been to so many places and they don't compare. We want to go to New York just to come eat here. I hope that explains how much I loved it. Oh, forgot to mention, we shared a porter house. read more

Finally got around to this place. One of my best buds has raved about it for yrs and we never took the time. I personally found the space a bit tight. The tables are laid out so close to each other... well, I guess, it is midtown. Sorta dimmer and much louder than I'd like when I am out for a meal with good friends. We had a serving of their thick cut bacon, each, porterhouse for 3 and a few drinks. I found the bacon to be quite good. Not too salty. Great consistency. I could have that and a couple of sides and call it a meal. The porterhouse; my friends felt was exquisite. I on the other hand, was not as pleased as they were. For me, I felt it was unevenly cooked. Too cooked on the outside. Some bites were charred, even; transitioning to well done and finally to rare. I believe this is depicted in some of my pictures. The sides, mashed potatoes and creamed spinach were what anyone would expect. Service was friendly and swift. I wished the venue would be quieter, slightly brighter, the steak not charred on the outside. A good time was had in spite of the observations I listed above. I feel this place is more like a 3.7/5 (but this site does not allow decimal grading.) read more

See all

Went there for lunch because a friend is visiting NYC and wanted to check out this famous restaurant where all the celebrities go. While the food was pretty good, I think it's pretty standard for restaurants in NY, didn't really find any wow factors (the only one being the pictures on the wall I guess?) read more

See all

This dish was outstanding and lived up to the high standards expected of an authentic steakhouse. We ordered the Porterhouse steak, which arrived steaming hot on a warm plate, instantly whetting our appetites. The cooking was perfectly executed, with a crispy, aromatic crust that was full of flavor. The server thoughtfully cut the first few slices for us and arranged them on the plate alongside fresh green asparagus. Even before taking a bite, a smile had already spread across our faces. This kind of experience is hard to replicate at home, and the atmosphere was fantastic. Sometimes, it's worth spending a little extra to enjoy professional quality service lol. read more

See all

Went to Benjamin Steakhouse Prime in Midtown, Manhattan, NYC near grand central station. Party of 6 with reservations. Chilled at the bar for a bit till we were interested in sitting down at a table. Got the bartender immediately and he made phenomenal drinks for us which came out quickly. Used the coat check which was handy. Seated immediately when we were ready. Chairs were super comfy and slid out easily. We ordered many dishes to share: apps, entrees, sides, dessert, drinks. They gave us complimentary port to finish the evening. Service was top notch: staff appeared immediately without being summoned to take away dirty plates, top us off, ask us about the meals, etc. A few minor drawbacks: food too salty. Meat cooked medium well to well be medium. Also the seafood tower was impossible for some of us to reach in the middle of the table. We weren't rushed as we were constantly chatting. Staff asked us about our experience several times. Highly recommend. We'll be back. Despite overcooked meat, it was quite good and tender and didn't need any steak sauce. read more

Came here for my birthday and the food was decent however felt it was a bit overpriced but could be just inflation. The porterhouse for 2 was good but lacked a bit of seasoning. The lobster Mac and cheese was quite good and the home fries as well. Service the waiter was a bit rude and felt like was rushing us a little but other staff were attentive and made sure water cup was almost always full. Ambiance is romantic however felt a bit too dark. Overall an average experience to me. read more

See all

I enjoyed the Benjamin cure cocktail and split the steak and potatoes with a friend. The bread was served promptly. Overall, good service, and ambience to catch up with a friend. read more

Benjamin Steakhouse - Benjamin cure - Steakhouses Near Me - New York, New York

We had dinner here at the recommendation of our hotel concierge at the Hilton Club Quinn the day before Thanksgiving 2025. The best Fillets we have ever had, and the Benjamin Potatoes with Blue Cheese - OMG. I was eating their steak sauce by the spoonful, unique ingredients. I left NYC and forgot to buy some of that Steak sauce. Got home to Alabama and the first thing I did was go online and buy 2 bottles of that Steak Sauce $40 including shipping, but its worth it. read more

Benjamin Steakhouse - Steakhouses Near Me - New York, New York

This place was absolutely divine! My sister and I went to celebrate her 40th birthday and we found ourselves here around 4pm on a Sunday. The gentlemen at the door greeted us and walked us down their small corridor into the dimly lit dining room. My sister and I ordered the filet mignon, lobster Mac and cheese and mashed potatoes. This meat was literally melting in our mouth. We both agreed it was the best steak we have ever had! Please do yourself a favor and dine here asap! Also, the manager John came to check in and when I told him we were celebrating my sister, he went out of his way to bring out a brûlée dessert and mousse (I think) and had his staff sing to my sister. She felt so special. Thank you for a wonderful experience! read more

Benjamin Steakhouse - Steakhouses Near Me - New York, New York

Was really looking forward to a nice lunch but the food quality was subpar. We ordered a burger - how wrong can you go? The meat was bland and the patty was over cooked. We requested a med-rare and it was well done. We also ordered a salmon dish and it was ok. We also had breakfast there the next day. Ordered pancakes. They got order wrong and had to remake. The pancakes tasted chemically. Service is also very slow. They tried to make up - manager said we will take care of it and all we got was a dessert (mousse cake) - took couple of bites and was not worth the extra calories - tasted like packaged mousse and not freshly prepared read more

We came to this lovely establishment last Saturday before our comedy show at MSG. My close friend Juan is a frequent flyer and always brags about the restaurant so we tried it out. We were a bit late and they still seated us. We let the server know we had to be out by a certain time and so he took our orders quickly and efficiently! They were absolutely amazing staff. I wish I had more food pictures of the porter house steaks and clams/bacon we ordered but I didn't to snap a picture. The food was amazing and their steak sauce is very delicious and tasty. Everything was cooked amazing. The restaurant definitely had steak house vibes and modern but dim and romantic place to go. The bathroom was gorgeous so was the whole place. I am so happy we took the suggestion to visit this restaurant, I will recommend it to everyone I know! Thank you for a great experience from the moment we walked in to the moment we left. read more

Benjamin Steakhouse - Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail - Steakhouses Near Me - New York, New York

See all

The food is a solid four stars, and the environment too. The service was a bit rushed. It's Restaurant Week, but that's not my problem. Entering and leaving the restaurant, you'll walk past cabinets of wines and photos of famous people. More photos in front of the building, where the Restaurant Week menu is advertised. Unusually that lunch is also three-course, but the portions are smaller (but more human?). The dining room is like what you'd expect from a steakhouse--traditional and elegant. The wood-looking floor is a bit oily, but the place is good for business meals and special occasions. Lighting is low and A/C will be on. The portions are what you'd expect, too. The beef soup was very good, and the traditional side of mashed potato and uncreamed cream spinach good choices to accompany the entrees. The salmon was not worth it. The desserts were very good, like the rest of the meal, but not everything was available and customers weren't told until it was served. The restrooms are downstairs. There was no attendant in the women's restroom, but one in the men's, who turns on the faucet and hands the towel--lavish. Bring a dollar with you. read more

I was hunting for a solid steakhouse near Grand Central Terminal where I could grab dinner after work and then casually hop on the Long Island Rail Road home. Stumbling on Benjamin felt like a strategic win. Full disclosure..... I'm a big fan of Peter Luger Steak House, and I've made it a mini hobby to try spots that claim former Luger chefs just to see how they stack up. So I skipped Restaurant Week on purpose. If I'm doing a comparison, I'm doing it properly. My friend and I ordered my usual benchmark: the porterhouse for two, black and blue. We kept it simple with a side of potatoes, their house version with a slightly elevated twist. The steak came out beautifully charred on the outside, perfectly warm and red in the center, and sliced with that classic steakhouse confidence. Flavor wise, it absolutely delivered. Rich, well seasoned, and cooked exactly the way we asked. No notes. Another big plus for me is that they take credit cards and are part of a credit card promo program I'm in, so I was able to use some of my restaurant credits. That alone makes it an easy repeat option compared to cash only spots. Convenience matters when you're squeezing in a quality dinner before catching a train. Between the location, the execution on the steak, and the overall polished atmosphere, Benjamin Steakhouse is a strong contender in the classic New York steakhouse arena. For anyone working near Grand Central and craving an aged porterhouse without the trek to Brooklyn or little neck, this is a very satisfying play. read more

I've been here multiple times and recently visited this place for Valentine's Day. They had a price fix menu which had many options to choose from. My guest and I ordered oysters and shrimp cocktail to start, salads, filet, bone in ribeye and tiramisu for dessert. Some of the best things I had were the perfectly cooked shrimp cocktail, the bone in ribeye was one of the best steaks I've had in a long time and the tiramisu which is my favorite. The restaurant is a classic steakhouse with good ambiance. Johnny Our server was efficient and nice and the manager had stopped by to say hi to us. Overall another great experience. 5 out of 5 stars read more

See all

Came here for an office lunch for the holiday. The ambiance was very old school. The waiter wasn't amazing but the rest of the waitstaff who helped us was great. We got the bacon and some apps to start. The bacon was so fatty I couldn't even eat mine. The shrimp cocktail was a little tough and not that good. I got the chicken parm. It was ok. My coworker got the king crab legs and it was absolutely disgusting. She sent it back and they were nice enough to take it off the bill. My other coworker got the prime rib and it was HUGE read more

See all