Black Iron Signature Burger is worth the hype! Cooked perfectly. Outstanding combinations of flavors to compliment tasty burger and delicious bun. Service is attentive and friendly. Sadie was a delight! Burger lover's best choice! read more

We came here this past weekend to grab a quick bite while running errands and the place was amazing!! The burgers were beyond delicious and definitely made us full! We got the American burger and a create your own burger and it definitely hit the spot!! The service was really fast and great, they made sure to take our orders right away and brought out our food in a decent amount of time. The ambiance of the place was also great, it's a long bar, with many seats and they play very relaxing music that isn't overwhelming you while you're trying to eat. We thought about our burgers all weekend and will definitely be coming back! read more

Black Iron Burger - Burgers Near Me - New York, New York

See all

First, let me say I'm so happy this place is around still! I had read it closed, and that is thankfully incorrect. They are alive and well! Second, the staff here is amazing!! When I first arrived, I did not realize they did not open until noon so I showed up at 11:30 but the door was unlocked so in I went. They politelyy told me that the kitchen was not open yet, but I was welcome to sit at the bar and have a beer You can't beat that on a cold snowy winter day in New York City. I couldn't stay fo lunch but I cane back for dinner. Wowwww, these are seriously good burgers. It was cooked to order perfectly, and the crunchy fries served with aioli were divine! Stop in to one of their two locations. You won't be disappointed. read more

See all

This would have been a five star review, however!!! We had a reservation for 5:15pm after seeing a show. The hostess was awesome and we were seated promptly!! The food was great and the drinks were delicious. We ordered three build your own burgers and a Black Iron Burger as well as a regular fries, Cajun fries and Ai-Oli Fries. The Ai-Oli Fries were the BOMB. But here comes the However!!! I was thoroughly enjoying my Black Iron Burger when I bit into something HARD!! When I took it out of my mouth, it was a nut, as in nuts and bolts!!! I immediately called the hostess over and she confirmed it and was extremely apologetic as was our waiter. She took it back to the kitchen and informed the manager who took it off the bill and offered us free dessert or anything else we wanted. At that point, I ordered another drink but was totally turned off on another burger. The staff handled the situation with the utmost professionalism!! My only disappointment was that the manager never came out to apologize, talk to me, or anything. That is not how you manage a restaurant or any establishment!! I may have returned and given them another chance had the manager at least shown some concern, but since they didn't care enough to check on a patron, I don't care to return. read more

I ordered The Black Iron burger. I loved the special horseradish mayo sauce. The burgers and fries had so much flavor! This is one of the most flavorful burgers I've had in NYC! I'll be back! read more

Stopped to eat burgers and fries before going to a concert planned. Got here around 4:30 during happy hour and there were lots of open seats. We got a build your own burger with the following; double patty, bacon, cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato, scallions, avocado and a fried egg. The burger was delicious but dropping the rating to a 4/(m5 as it came with pickles and we didn't order and i dont like pickles. We got the garlic herb fries which were great, thin and crispy. Since it was happy hour we ordered 2 cocktails, but were disappointed with the taste. We got the irish mule and the knock out. Not sure how to describe but the drinks weren't for us. The staff was great and very hospitable. The place was nice but not sure how it gets when its full. read more

See all

This was my second visit to a Black Iron Burger restaurant and my first visit to the Midtown West location. My previous experience at the Theater District location was outstanding, and I have nothing but positive things to say about that visit. Unfortunately, my experience at the Midtown West location was significantly different. Upon arriving, I chose to sit at the bar. It took approximately 12 minutes before the bartender acknowledged my presence. Because the menu did not list wine prices, I asked about the cost of a glass of wine. Rather than providing the information directly, the bartender asked which wine I was interested in and then had to reference the point-of-sale system to determine the price. After placing my order, there was an extended delay before I received my glass of wine. I also requested a glass of water, which was served without ice and without being asked whether I would prefer ice. Additionally, I was not provided with a straw and ultimately had to obtain one myself. When my burger arrived, it was undercooked. When I politely brought this issue to the bartender's attention, I found her response to be argumentative rather than helpful or solution-oriented. Throughout the interaction, she did not appear welcoming and failed to demonstrate the level of customer service I would expect from a hospitality establishment. Overall, I was disappointed with my experience at the Midtown West location, particularly given the excellent service I received at the Theater District location. I hope this feedback is helpful and can be used to improve the guest experience moving forward. Thank you for your time and consideration. Sincerely, Carl Crockett read more

Solid burger! Finding a good burger with as many "frills" as Black Iron offers is tough, but you can tell quality ingredients and care goes into their food. I got the Black Iron Burger and it was nice and juicy, the horseradish & caramelized onions gave a delicious sweet/tangy flavor but wasn't too overpowering. The lunch special is $20 (I think) is any notorious burger with fries.. a good deal in my eyes! Service was awesome throughout the meal, waiter was faced paced but continued to make sure we were good. The restaurant itself is a little dark, has a nice full bar, TVs, and is a bit tight but 100% gives tavern vibes. read more

Black Iron Burger - The Black Iron - Burgers Near Me - New York, New York

The service was great! Was instantly greeted at the door and seated right away. We were there while the World Cup games were happening so the energy and vibe were high! I had an amazing turkey burger that tasted homemade. The onion rings were crispy and tender all at the same time. Happy hour offered a Hennessy Colada that was refreshing and potent. Loved everything about this spot. I'll go back for sure on out next NYC visit! read more

Wow! What a hidden gem! I discovered this restaurant while staying nearby and was thoroughly impressed. The food was absolutely delicious, the ambiance was warm and inviting, and the service was exceptional from start to finish. If you're a burger lover, this place is a must-visit. I highly recommend it to anyone looking for great food, outstanding service, and a fantastic dining experience. read more

Outstanding burgers that will not disappoint. Wings were a great starter with some unique flavors. Fries were cooked perfectly and accompanied by a very nice sauce. This place was a little snug, but once your food comes you will forget all about it. Surprisingly kid friendly even though it feels very much pub like. The servers were experienced and friendly. read more

See all

Great food Great service The signature BIB burger was so good. Awesome burger. Ordered it with a side of fries as well Service was friendly and professional. read more

Black Iron Burger - Bib signature burger - Burgers Near Me - New York, New York

See all

I loved everything about my dinner here. From the drinks, food, and staffing, everything was top-notch. I have no complaints! Everything was 5/5. One thing I wanted to say was since I'm not from New York, it was super memorable because of the staff. Brenda was amazing in every way, super cool person to talk to. She made the dinner that much better. If I come back to the city, I'd love to visit again. Definitely would recommend! read more

This is a burger spot located around the Garment District area that is an ideal burger joint to unwind with a juicy burger, a mini mountain of fries, and a refreshing drink. I ordered a Coca-Cola, Truffle Cheese Fries, and Mushroom Truffle Burger. This is for the truffle lovers out there, the truffle fries were the right amount of truffle oil paired with parmesan cheese. It wasn't so heavy on the truffle oil that you could still enjoy the warm crispiness of the fries. The mushroom truffle burger was quite delicious with the mushroom and truffle pairing that didn't clash or overwhelm the taste buds. It was so good that after taking this photo, I was halfway through my burger and enjoying every bite. The servers were quite patient in explaining the menu as well as emphasizing that the signature burgers stay as-is with no substitution and that you can build your own burger. Also, their uniform/shirt would make you do a double-take and I got a good laugh with my server. The location is very lively with conversations throughout the bar and restaurant with multiple TVs playing games (ideal sports bar/restaurant spot as well). It is a very chill and laid-back restaurant to let loose and be a little messy while eating by yourself or with friends or even on a date. I would most definitely be coming back and trying more of the signature burgers as well as making my own burger. read more

Black Iron Burger - Mushroom Truffle Burger - Burgers Near Me - New York, New York

From the moment I stepped into Black Iron Burger, I was impressed with the prompt welcome and seating. Service was incredibly efficient and thoughtful. I opted for the Iberico Burger with a side of Cole Slaw and it was absolutely delicious. I also recommend the Ace Pear Cider for a refreshing change of pace. Great first impression! read more

Black Iron Burger - Iberico Burger with Spanish Ham and a Fried Egg - Burgers Near Me - New York, New York

See all

A great little place to duck into right off of Times Square. The burgers can't be beat. My wife and I enjoyed two different types of burgers off the menu and you can build your own burger as well. New York style not New York crisis. Definitely a good place to bring a day. read more

Eh. My stomach hurts and it was pretty lackluster; no seasoning, grill needs to be hotter, onion hand needs to be heavier. Sorta disappointed but also it is what it is... $16 not the best not the worst. read more

Black Iron Burger - What a joke. - Burgers Near Me - New York, New York

Came here on a rainy Wednesday 5:30pm with my girlfriend and there were tons of seats and did not seem too crowded throughout the night. Service was good and our waiter did a great job. Food was good, we got a chocolate shake, truffle fries, the mushroom burger and the master piece burger. Everything was pricey, but my complaint was that the prices for a large fries was not stated on their menu. The menu shows $9.25 for the truffle fries but I was charged $12.25, which no where on the menu mentioned a large would be +$3 more. If it was mentioned by the waiter or the menu I would've been fine but when I talked to the waiter who talked to the manager, all they gave was a discount for the next time I would come which I would not know when. The manager didn't even come up to us about the discrepancy and they didn't really do anything about this mistake. Overall the food was good but the way they manage mistakes is simply unprofessional. read more

Black Iron Burger - Side menu - Burgers Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Had the Black Iron and Herb Garlic Fries with aioli sauce and it was phenomenal. They did a great job cooking the burger to medium rare and the grilled onions added a nice hint of sweetness to the savory patties and horseradish mayo. It was juicy, flavorful, and melts in your mouth. The fries had a lot of garlic on them and the aioli sauce was a good addition to the flavor profile. It gets pretty busy, so expect some wait time. read more

Black Iron Burger - The black iron and garlic fries - Burgers Near Me - New York, New York

See all

A long and narrow space that serves good burgers with no extras included. You want fries with that? Pay for it. You want coleslaw or a pickle? Pay for it. I'm surprised that salt, pepper and ketchup wasn't an up charge too. My Guiness was on point. So was my Masterpiece burger. Just be prepared to pay. read more

See all

The burger and fries were excellent! My only complaint is the shake, it was watery/melted not good at all and paid almost $11 for it. Service and ambience were good. read more

Black Iron Burger - The Epic Burger (5 oz) - Burgers Near Me - New York, New York

See all

What a gem of a place! The burgers are to-die-for, and the atmosphere is excellent. A lively bar feel with very attentive staff, no matter how busy they are. We spent 4 nights in NYC recently, and went to this place twice. The American Burger is delicious! read more

See all

One of the better burger spots in the city. Didn't even mind paying $30 on my meal. I didn't expect the place to be a bar, considering the dim lighting in the place but I expect it to be a part or the atmosphere. When you come in, someone arrives to bring you to a table and that's when you can order your food. I had an All American Burger (Beef burger with cheese, bacon and BBQ Sauce in a brioche bun, truffle cheese fries and a Coke Zero. The burger was cooked splendid and the taste was as good as it's texture, the truffle fries were also delightful and my drink was refreshing enough after that meal. It passes as a premium burger and of course there is a premium price to pay for it but it's worth it. read more

See all

Awesome burgers and dirty martinis served in a lively fun atmosphere. The yuca chips and guacamole were stellar. Best onion rings EVER. The wait staff went out of their way to make sure we were happy. Highly recommend. read more

Last night in NY and was looking for a causal spot to grab some food and a drink and this was just a couple blocks from my hotel. Sat at the bar and ordered a double burger, medium with American Cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion and pickle while enjoying an adult beverage. Burger arrived quickly. It was up there with one of the better burgers I've eaten. My only complaint would be that the bun is a little thick and could have been softer but the flavor of the beef was fantastic and juicy and toppings tasted fresh and crunchy. Staff was friendly, tv's at the bar if you want to watch a game etc. I would definitely go back, but a softer, thinner bun would make this . If I could give 1/2 stars I would have given it 4.5 read more

Ambiance (4/5): The establishment is narrow and deep with one side with tall tables and the other with lower tables. We ended getting seated immediately at the bar in the back. Service (5/5): During peak dinner hours, our party of 2 had a wait time of 5 min. We were asked to wait at the bar in the back but we decided to fully dine there. Since we sat at the bar, we had instant beers and ordering service! The bartender was quick and attentive. Food Custom burger (4/5): Cooked to a beautiful medium rare. The broiche bun handled the weight of the burger without falling apart. A very solid burger! Aioli fries (6/5): we asked for them to be cooked well done and they delivered! Their fries are cut nicely thin and they were made with a perfect crunch. The aioli gave a nice umami to an already great fry on it's own. Portion is big enough to share with 2-3 ppl. Would recommend! read more

Black Iron Burger - The Classic Burger (5 oz) - Burgers Near Me - New York, New York

Anytime I'm in New York City I have to come here. It can get crowded. We got here before a hockey game on a Monday night and were seated immediately. The restaurant was decorated for the holidays and the Christmas music was bumping. Such a fun vibe. Our waiter was super friendly. I ordered the mushroom truffle burger, medium rare with into rings. It was cooked perfectly. It was juicy and the flavors were amazing with mushroom duxelle, Swiss cheese, caramelized onion and bacon bits. Just divine! Hubs ordered the Iberico burger. Apparently this is a smash burger type of burger. He felt it was a bit dry since it was so thin but still tasted good on real with the ham and egg on top. The food is not expensive but drinks are as is typical in NYC. read more

See all

Saw the good reviews and stopped in with a coworker for lunch. Cool spot atmosphere wise with a bar in the back. Seated promptly and drinks brought fairly quickly with the restaurant about half full on a Tuesday afternoon. Plenty of options on the menu, and I did the build your own burger with 2 patties, cheddar cheese, regular bacon, and the spicy mayo along with an order of onion rings and a Diet Coke. The burger was oddly flavorless and just noting special to write home about. The onion rings were flimsy, soggy, and looked like something I would have made when I was first learning to cook. My coworker got the Mushroom Truffle Burger and thought his was similarly bland. My biggest problem with the place is the price for the result. $35 plus tip for a bland lunch. I'd rather have payed half the price at the smash burger place around the corner (7the st burger) for a more enjoyable product. Not worth a second visit. read more

See all

We made a reservation for Valentines day. Got sat in a back corner with completely green lighting. Looked like Elphaba. Waited 30 mins and no one even came to take a drink order so we left. read more

The burgers were juicy and delicious and the quac and chips hit the spot as a starter.

Great service staff was checking on me. The food was amazing. The ambiance was on point and very inviting.

Stumbled onto this burger joint as we were spending the holidays in NYC. The burgers were on point, the place had an awesome sexy NYC vibe, music was on point...highly recommend! Oh, and the Epic Burger with the fried egg and red peppers, highly, highly recommend! read more

Black Iron Burger - The ambience.. - Burgers Near Me - New York, New York

Unless you eat beef and are going to have a burger, I don't recommend this place. I ordered their chicken sandwich and it was so bland. My friend ordered a burger and hers was pretty good, my boyfriend also ordered a burger and he thought it was alright. Also for the price it's ridiculous that they don't include fries as a side with the burger/sandwich. read more

The burger was charged perfectly and seasoned perfectly... And it was super juicy... Top five burger read more

Black Iron Burger - The Classic Double's crust was beautifully charred and seasoned with salt n pepper...super juicy...top 5 - Burgers Near Me - New York, New York

Food is just not so good anymore. I will not order from them any more. Their burgers used to taste better, now they are just a flat tasting burger. read more

subpar food, worse service.18% gratuity because 7 of use were dining, so why work hard if you know you're guaranteed a tip?!?!! read more

Black Iron Burger - What missing? Utensils. They seated us with no knife, no fork. We had to ask. - Burgers Near Me - New York, New York

Follow me on my travels and dining adventures. In NYC this week and our first stop was black iron burger. It was a good one too. Nice cold beer. Great burgers cooked perfectly. Thick bacon on top and fresh bun. I also had the onion rings and French fries. Our server was helpful and gave me his recommendation of my options. A cute small place but very comfortable. It wasn't crowded or noisy. read more

See all

I was in the Javitz Center and was looking for an informal and casual restaurant nearby and decided on Black Iron and I'm glad I did. There are other burger restaurants nearby that I have tried and this was my favorite. Burgers were very good and cooked as requested and sides were fine. Prices were as expected and service was good. read more

Absolutely INSANELY DELICIOUS!! My mom and I enjoyed our dinner, the best burger I've ever had. I got The American Burger and it was FIRE. The Espresso Sauce was so good. They are rated #1 burger for a reason. Excellent, welcoming staff. read more

See all

Good burger, good onion rings. The place was cozy. Comfortable. They have high tops and benches/tables. Really liked the food. I did think it was a bit pricey for the portion size. You order the sides separately. But.... It is a very good burger, that you cannot deny. read more

Black Iron Burger - The American Burger, Onion Rings - Burgers Near Me - New York, New York

See all