Always a favorite for us since we moved here last year. Our dog is welcome, and the food and service are beyond reproach. It should be a given that seafood here in Key West should always be delicious and fresh, but we have found that not to be the case in some "seafood" restaurants. Blackfin never disappoints; try the fish special, whatever it is, and you will love it. The only downside is that they do not have a full bar, so we usually stop in to a nearby bar either before or after dinner for martinis. Blackfin has a good wine selection and the servers are knowledgeable so go with their recommendations if wine is your thing. read more

Their outdoor space was so romantic and cute, with socially distanced tables! Apps: We had the shrimp bisque and the sautéed calamari. Unfortunately these were our least favorite part of the meal, both needed salt and the bisque was watery with no flavor which I was disappointed in since bisque is my favorite :( Meal: Special of the day blackened grouper. OMFG. Grouper was super flavorful and well cooked so it was moist and flaky. There was some tropical cream sauce magic going on under it which was crack. Paired with their yellow rice and grilled asparagus it was perfect!!! Even the asparagus was cooked perfectly which I'm always afraid of limp overcooked asparagus. Service: service was always great!!! Very attentive and nice. Would eat here again but maybe get different apps! read more

If you are going to key west check out @blackfinbistro. We highly recommend the Wagyu Burger, it has been added to our list of best burgers read more

See all

Wonderful cozy romantic setting with great food and amazing staff. Truly the highlight of our 35th wedding anniversary trip.

Wonderful food and service. I had the tuna and it was cooked perfectly. My friend had the burger and also cooked to perfection. read more

Blackfin Bistro - Seafood Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

Absolutely fantastic service! The mussels were perfect. Tonight they had Golden Tilefish and it was fantastic and superbly prepared. The new owners are carrying on the previous traditions. And of course NYC connections. Only complaint was the cold served Pinot noir; they replaced it but still it was so-so. Great music, great ambiance. I could actually hear my date in conversation. Highly recommended. read more

Blackfin Bistro - Nice decor - Seafood Near Me - Key West, Florida

Discovered this little gem after having a horrible experience with over cooked $50 steak at another restaurant nearby. We were able to secure seating in their beautiful, lush, secluded patio under such a short notice. Wow! The NY strip was a perfectly cooked medium. Escargot was delicious and we ordered the freshly caught grilled yellowfin tuna! If you want something more filling, the carbonara pasta was yummm! read more

Absolutely wonderful restaurant that was recommended to us by a friend who is a local. The atmosphere was so quaint and romantic, the food was fabulous and the service was top notch! read more

We absolutely loved every single thing about this place. From the Sting/Police music to the genuinely friendly and warm staff to the AMAZING food. Will definitely be back the next time we are in the Hueso. read more

While visiting Key West we found Blackfin Bistro on our first day while exploring Duval Street. We were so glad we did! Wow! We had lunch here on that first visit and made it a point of going back for dinner during our week-long stay in Key West. For lunch we had the Yellowfin Tuna Tartar appetizer along with the complementary bread. We both ordered the Smoked Salmon sandwich for our main dish. It was served with fries and some fresh baby greens. The Yellowfin Tuna Tartar was fantastic! We both enjoyed the Smoked Salmon sandwich quite a bit. On our dinner visit we ordered Mussels in a Curry Sauce as an appetizer (there are few choices of sauces) and an Escargots appetizer served in a garlic/parsley butter. Complementary bread and butter was also brought to the table. My husband ordered the special of Hogfish with Lemon Caper Cream, Asparagus and Mashed Potatoes. I ordered the Grilled Yellowfin Tuna, which I asked for rare, served in a Ginger/sweet soy emulsion, Soba Noodles and Tempura French Beans. Wow! All of it was prepared to perfection and tasted amazing! We are still talking about this meal after landing back home. The service was top-notch, as well. Blackfin Bistro is definitely on our list of places to visit again the next time we visit Key West. read more

See all

Amazing food, beautiful garden to dine in and attentive service. Highly recommend for a romantic dinner.

This restaurant was awesome. So good. Nice cute patio. All the food was exceptional. The highlight was the special that night, the mutton snapper with coconut rum sauce and saffron rice and green beans. Wow. Amazing!! Soo good. The sauce was delicious. Kudos to these guys! Nice restaurant! Will recommend ! Delicious! read more

See all

Simply put, the food was super tasty. The truffle fries were crunchy and crispy, the ahi tuna was as fresh and tender to taste. The black grouper, was cook perfectly, not over cooked, with a nicely seared crust. The pasta was fresh aswell. Definitely worth visiting. The location has an outdoor seating and it has a lovely date night feel. read more

See all

The food is better than the ambiance. We ordered the Pork Chop which was out of this world tender and very flavorful. Great sides as well. My wife had the local shrimp which were also excellent. We started with the scallop special and were a little surprised at what they charged for three medium sized scallops (I believe they are somewhat local) pan seared, served with fresh corn and a nice pan sauce. 23.00. Seemed high. It also was a bit odd that they were out of or nearly out of so many drink items (my wife had her third option of local microbrew and I had the last bottle of the import that I ordered. They were reasonably busy but it was just odd as the menu is already limited so it's nice to be able to get what you want and not really sure what the issue was. No, for the ambiance issue. The restaurant is in a great location but has a fairly low ceiling and is exceptionally noisy. We had a table with three very loud couples next to us and were surrounded by a couple of other loud groups. Perhaps the ambiance would have been better if we had been seated outside. Just a few bits of advice as the food is quite good, a bit over-priced but good. read more

Amazing food! Get the carbonara. We had Tom as our waiter and he did not disappoint. Recommended the best and he was right on point with his guests. read more

(Note: based on a pre-lockdown visit) I had a lovely night out with the family at Blackfin Bistro after doing some research online. We were interested in something nice that: A) had outdoor seating, and B) had burgers per my daughter's request, and C) had nicer meals as well. I was also interested in a cocktail, since Yelp indicated there was a full bar here. Blackfin met our needs except the last part - ONLY BEER and WINE served here, so shame on Yelp for the misinformation. Setting - Their lovely back patio was ideal for us; we were in the shade of a large tree and had plenty of social distancing from other tables. Menu - Great variety here; and we were even able to customize one dish for a dietary restriction. I was a bit disappointed with the beer list, since they had only one good IPA on the menu. But one was all I needed. Food - We started with the mussels and escargot, which were on-point. My daughter claimed her wagyu burger was delicious. My blackened snapper in creamed curry sauce was superb. (It came with green beans and yellow rice); it was perfectly cooked and came in a sizable portion too. We finished by sharing a fantastic key lime tart. Service - The only downside. This started with a friendly greeting, but then they forgot one app (mussels) which were brought out much later, and only after we said something. And then service 'fell off a cliff' halfway through our meal, with no sign of any waitstaff for quite a long period. At the end, and after trying 10 minutes to get someone's attention, I had to go to the front to ask for our check. But the latter was a minor annoyance in an otherwise pleasant dinner. read more

Excellent food and attentive service by a caring staff. We sat inside but the outside seating was lovely also. read more

Service was awesome. Food was good! A little pricey and ambiance is lacking but very good overall.

THEEEEE BEST BURGER EVER. They created heaven in the form of a burger. Every bite I took put me more and more in shock that I'm eating something so delicious. We also tried the specials of the day; the shrimp bisque which was also really good, it wasn't to creamy or to lite it had a nice smooth flavor. Also the blackened swordfish was really had a great flavor. The staff was so nice and very attentive! The patio in the back was super cute & comfortable. Tom was our server and he was so friendly, attentive and honest! This restaurant deserves more than 5 stars. Thank you Blackfin for a great experience!! :) read more

Blackfin Bistro - Delicious wagyu burger with smoked Gouda fondue & truffle fries - Seafood Near Me - Key West, Florida

This is my favorite restaurant in the world. I love to come to Key West. And I love to return to this restaurant. On my most recent visit. I Traveled solo. I felt welcomed and the food as usual was delicious! I can't wait to return. I wish this restaurant was in my UWS. NYC neighborhood. The scallops were to die for!!'The staff is the best. read more

One of our favorite places in key west. Located off Duval st , Reservations were easy to make on a Friday evening , customer service was attentive and fast. Locally owned , serving fresh seafood . we spoke to the proprietor who seemed very nice and hands on with his guests. The ambience itself is very calm and quiet , candlelight and dim...more relaxed casual dining. This was my sons first time eating a wagyu burger 5/5 and unfortunately he's hooked , meat was soft and tender bread was fresh . Yellowfin tuna 5/5was very fresh and filling, came with tempura French greens and soba noodles which came out a bit cold ...not sure if that's normal but warmed up would have been nicer. The red blackened grouper 4/5 was very fresh as well , we liked that a lot of the food wasn't overly seasoned so you can taste the flavor of the fresh seafood . Calamari sautéed in butter and parsley was definitely different as we are used to getting battered and fried lightly, seemed to be cooked just right. Carrot cake 5/5 wow !! The best ...Must try ! We look forward to coming back ! read more

See all

Best waghu burger on the island. And humongous. This is a sweet little restaurant on Duval with a romantic vibe. Hand cut fries were also delicious. Nice variety of local beer too. Great service. Will be back. read more

Blackfin Bistro - Logo of Blackfin - Seafood Near Me - Key West, Florida

Absolutely delicious! We had the rib-eye and the burger and everything was flavorful and tender. The staff was very attentive and were constantly checking in on us and provided great wine recommendations. Would come back here any day! read more

The family and decided to try the Blackfin Bistro for dinner. We were told that it was a short walk from the hotel. It might be a short walk to some people, but, to my wife and daughter, it was a hike that they were not ready for. We arrived about 30 minutes later after stopping in various shops. The Blackfin Bistro is contemporary looking restaurant in Key West. It was decorated nicely, and felt very comfortable. I ordered a pan fried grouper, while my wife ordered the seafood pasta. While waiting for the food, they brought out some bread and butter for us. The food came out about 15 minutes later. The grouper was on a bed of risotto with some asparagus spears. The grouper also had some key lime tartar sauce on it. The combination of all the ingredients tasted good. Although, I would have preferred a different kind of fish. The grouper is what all the Florida Tourism board tells you to eat, even though there are better fishies out there. My wife's seafood pasta came with mussels and shrimp in creamy sauce. My wife and daughter liked the pasta. But, my wife commented that she has had better seafood pastas. Her seafood pasta was also very small. The Blackfin Bistro is a pretty good place in Key West. The food is good for Key West. Service was good. You will get a good meal here. read more

Blackfin Bistro - Pan fried grouper with risotto and key lime tartar sauce - Seafood Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

Service, food and ambiance were great. Great welcoming vibe from Joe and his team from the minute you walk in. Wagyu burger was outstanding!

The service was done very well here the meal was excellent. We sat outside a very quaint area in the back. This is definitely a do again.

Very attentive service. This was the best meal we had in Key West. The garden dining had a great vibe.

Incredibly delicious wonderfully relaxed atmosphere. Would come back here Ina heart beat! The staff were lovely and patient along with courteous and professional. Definitely a must for this area! read more

See all

Amazing seafood joint. All the tuna is flown in from Hawaii and is sushi grade. . We ordered the tuna tartare delicious. Conch cakes were crisp and light. Truffle Fries were delicious with a nice fondue. Pasta carbonara was one of the best I ever had. The grilled yellow fin was amazing. Calamari appetizer was different. Not saying it was bad just not for us. Mussels with Chorizo was good. Service was very good. Nice and clean and outdoor tables well distanced make it Covid safe. read more

See all

I had been to a restaurant like this before in Key West. Years and years ago, I was dating a man from the Midwest who settled in the bay area. One year I was coming here to SCUBA dive and he was in Miami on a business trip. So he flew down to meet me here. As a true gentleman, he took me out for dinner and we dined under stars in a restaurant that looked like this one. It was a romance doomed to fail, due to the obvious age difference and my lack of experience in life in general, though I remembered that evening: the stars were shining and we dined outdoors in a restaurant that served similar food. I had not returned to Key West for over a decade and I was happy that the first meal in town was at Blackfin Bistro, because the seafood here was supposed to be amazing. Walking on foot from Westin, I arrived at around 9:30 PM. The restaurant had a beautiful courtyard just like the one in my memory. I asked for a seating by the heat lamp. The food here was spectacular. Seafood pasta was quite incorporated with flavor profiles not seen in the west coast. Key West shrimp appetizer was amazingly fresh. It's the local shrimp as I was told. I'd been searching for grilled octopus that could take me back to Santorini, July 2014, and I found something like it here. Different of course but delicious nonetheless. Key West has been invaded by beautiful young Ukrainian women. Our server was no exception. We chatted about Ukraine and Russia relations, the ongoing war, and her upcoming visit back to her motherland. Very intriguing. There was a film crew to the left of us. There was also a group of 10, most likely from Brooklyn, New York, judging by the accent, finishing up a pre-holiday meal. Capped the meal with brownies and ice cream. Walked out of the restaurant at 11 PM. The Caribbean trade wind had picked up. I had come back to search for a piece of missing memory, one that involved a young woman engaged to a spy and was about to start a life with someone whom she trusted completely, but something happened that year in D.C., where the spy was debriefing in Pentagon before being posted to another country, and she called off the wedding and left the east coast for good. That evening some memories resurfaced, with more yet to come. I understand why Hemingway took a liking of this town. It's mystical and magical, restaurants filled with exotic foreign imports and food from the Caribbean Sea. Do come here when you are able. It's worth your flight and drive. read more

See all

First night in Key West and Blackfin Bistro was amazing. If you looking for good food and ambiance, it is a must.

Wonderful food and service in a relaxed and casual atmosphere. Outdoor seating under the stars on a warm night is delightful.

Perfect spot for a romantic date night (Even though I was with my parents). Food is spot on. Service is fast and attentive. Nice ambience. Highly recommended read more

See all

This place is just lovely and the food is Devine. We have dinner here every time we visit Key West and refer everyone we can. The goat cheese appetizer is so yummy. Blackfin has the best cheeseburger I've ever had. Outside dining at night is an added touch to the delicious food. read more

We stumbled across this gem while visiting Key West. On Duval street, this lovely little dining room has space for a handful of couples or two large groups. Tonight they had their seared diver scallops for an appetizer and they did not disappoint. I followed that up with their grilled yellowtail tuna while hubby had their Pinks shrimp dish sautéed with garlic and service over mashed potatoes and spinach. Our servers we super attentive. And made sure our glasses were never empty. We've just started our vacation here but I'm sure we will be back! read more

Blackfin Bistro - Grilled yellowtail tuna - Seafood Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

The food was excellent along with service. It wasn't cheap but you are going to enjoy it. It's a quaint and pleasant environment. I'll be back. read more

Great food, great service. Excellent wine- Hess bottle is my favorite. Eat in the backyard for an off the street experience

A welcomed change from bar food. (although bar food does hit the spot sometimes) High end, yet casual dress of course. FRESH ingredients. Exquisite combinations. Attention to details. Very nice wine selection. Individual attention. Not rushed. Delicious from start to finish. You will not be disappointed. read more

Food was good, service was also good nice outside dining area, apps were on point and plated well

Came recommend by the hotel- also the Number 1 place in Key West based on yelp reviews. Initial greeting was great! Super friendly and helpful staff; willing to answer all typical tourist questions. Service was fast but not rushed and the drinks were cold. The food... wow, the food. I opted for the more expensive special; it was a fish plate with curry sauce and it was absolutely incredible. Well seasoned and balanced. Portion was smaller than I would have wanted however, I'm leaving with a smile. 10/10 would recommend. read more