This is a historical Diner, 126 years old! Also the smallest I've ever seen. The walls are filled with celebrities pictures that visited the place. Amazing! Food is super fresh. Excellent service, the waitress was very nice and had a great smile. Parking is perfectly proportional to the place. read more

Blue Point Diner - Entrance - Diners Near Me - Blue Point, New York

See all

Very overpriced won't go back ordered to go eggand cheese on a roll a English muffin toasted and 2 med coffee 27.oo what a rip

This place has the best decorations the best waitress and the best service ! Hands down ! The food is fresh ALWAYS and we love coming here . Try the delicious home made soups as well a must try for sure read more

There are specials that I look forward to and wait for. Generally the soups are too salty to finish. I think all the food is salted when being cooked. The service is very nice but I things I am not charged for in other dinners, I am charged for in this diner. The meals on a chalkboard seem high priced. The places nicely decorated for the monthly holidays. They should have a bowl of mints like other diners to overcome the raw onion or garlic. read more

Cutest little place. Always love coming here with my family to have a perfect breakfast. It's nothing fancy which is exactly what we want when we just want to have a coffee some eggs & corned beef hash & not spend a zillion dollars. Always awesome. Thanks for making us feel at home. read more

Retro cute diner gem in suffolk. Service was exceptional, had a little mishap with the order, but they made changes swiftly. A little pricy for diner food options. Food was yummy and came fast. Only diner open on Easter! Can't complain :p Good experience! read more

See all

Food was excellent. Been going off and on for years. Sometimes the staff can be a bit aloof but I know they have worked there for years and I'm Sure they have their days...But you can never go wrong with the food and hometown feel. read more

Cute little diner... nice vintage vibe with excellent food and service. Easy to get to from the highway.

Great retro diner with good food and friendly service! Classic breakfast, Greek Salad and gyros. read more

Blue Point Diner - Diners Near Me - Blue Point, New York

Food is always good! No matter what u order. They have great soup, and sandwiches, breakfast items are the best, eggs over easy cooked perfect ! Home fries are not greasy Service is the best. Cute place to meet a friend for a bite to eat. read more

Enjoyed a real delightful meal and everyone was very attentive. This was not the first time we were there and our friends appreciated the experience read more

Look up "small local diner" in the dictionary and you will find a picture of this place. Counter service and booth seating available. Had an old school vibe. Ample parking on site, free wifi available. When I walked in I was immediately greeted by the one waitress on staff (like I said, the place is small. Also, it was a weekday). There was one other table of diners. The waitress told me I could sit wherever I would so I sat myself. This place is definitely not fancy. As I was seating myself, she asked if I would like coffee and I replied in the affirmative. The waitress swiftly brought me a cup of piping hot fresh coffee, along with a menu. My order of a short stack with sausage was very good. Standard diner fair. Pancakes were yummy and dusted with powdered sugar, and the sausage was the thick links that I enjoy. Both cooked perfectly. The meal was accompanied by prepackaged Smuckers pancake syrup and some butter on a plate. The syrup was "ok". I'm kind of a fan of maple syrup myself, but if you like regular pancake syrup this will be fine. My coffee was refilled promptly and when I was finished and asked for a check, it arrived on my table quickly. A little on the pricey side, over $15.50 for a short stack with sausage and coffee. I don't get out much for breakfast lately, but I felt that was a bit high for this type of establishment. Maybe I'm just behind the times.... That being said, the service was very good and the food was very good as well. If you're in the area, I'd definitely recommend. Just don't go in with a party over 4, 5 people the most. This place is TIGHT inside. read more

the food is good but doesn't justify the high prices. This place belongs in a rural town upstate New York The atmosphere is cozy and reminiscent of times gone by. The staff are friendly, but like I said overpriced. read more

Hi My friends, and welcome to Blue Point Long Island. For over 10 years I lived in this peaceful maritime area. This beautiful Waterfront community is situated on the East End of the South Shores of Long Island. Bordering Western Patchogue. Boating, beaches and fishing are just a few minutes walk from this spot. For years, The Blue Point Diner has been a wonderful neighborhood local spot where my friends and I would enjoy breakfast, lunch and dinner. You'll always feel welcome in this little roadside Diner where everybody knows your name. The daily newspapers are available.. but usually not needed here at the Blue Point Diner. Early in the morning it's alive with neighborhood activity, it's is the center of gossip and conversations for this community. You can find out who's getting divorced, who's selling their house or who just got a brand new speed boat. Wake up and find out all the morning town gossip just by having breakfast here. The owner and head chef George, usually knows what you'll want to eat without you needing a menu, he knows all of his customers and Friends by name. And he knows what you usually get. Everybody in Blue Point has been coming here for years. It was great to have breakfast at the Blue Point Diner again, I have missed my peaceful, waterside community since moving to Flushing 5 years ago. Walking in this morning, the owner George, remembered me immediately. My absence of 5 years was like moments, and he filled me in on all the neighborhood gossip. And of course, he knew what I wanted, the deluxe pancake special. The food was wonderful fresh and delicious as it always has been. The quality of the breakfast sausage and bacon is a little better than some other breakfast places you might find. Everything here is made with care from scratch. I'm very picky about my food and read some of the other reviews. For this spot. I'd like to say that I've been in here over 50 times in 10 years. I've never seen anything other than a spotlessly clean establishment serving fresh, top quality, homemade food. I just loved coming here to start my day. Some of my best memories. For breakfast lunch or dinner folks, You can't go wrong at the Blue Point Diner. Owned and operated by a local family of hard-working, caring people. See you again soon folks. read more

See all

The diner not honest and try to scam customers on weekends. Putting the bill with lots of add ons instead we order 3 breakfast combos but was charged for the add ons. Just not a great experience. Go to other diners instead. With better service read more

This place has been around for quite some time and although it is tiny the atmosphere is very nice especially around the holidays. The food is always good and staff are very friendly and polite. Overall a great go to place for some good food good service read more

Really cute diner. I live down the street and always passed it and finally decided to go in. Had the Philly cheesesteak and was pleasantly surprised. It was so good. The fries were really great too. Extra crispy! We also got pancakes the were massive and super good. Definitely will be back :) read more

Used to go there all the time, reasonable. good breakfast and Greek salads and burgers..used to go for pea soup in winter,, until one day, found cardboard in my pea soup! Ugggh read more

This is a tough review to write because I enjoyed my meal and loved the ambiance. However, I cannot figure out how I was charged over $37 for a cup of soup, a tuna melt, an iced tea, and rice pudding. I have no idea what I was charged for the soup or sandwich bc the prices weren't listed. I'm not one to complain, so I paid and left. I'd return, but cannot justify that amount of money for something I can prepare at home. Oh my goodness, I'm editing this review to mention that when I finally tried the rice pudding, the rice was not properly cooked! It was hard and very chewy so I had to throw it out. I had originally given three stars; now I'm giving just two stars for this terrible (and extremely overpriced) experience. Stay away! read more

Decided to give this cute, little diner a try in our travels. Let me start off by saying when we walked in the door we felt like family. The owner and his wife greeted us as we were sat to our cozy booth. The food was delicious and fresh and with a beautiful presentation! Kudos to the cook! Our server was very attentive which is a plus in my book. Give this place a try! You won't be disappointed. read more

Blue Point Diner - My fresh spinach and feta omelette ( I sprinkled hot sauce on top). I opted for fresh fruit instead of potatoes. DELISH!!! - Diners Near Me - Blue Point, New York

Staff & service are second to none. Always treats my family like gold. Amazing banana pancakes, omelets, French toast & soups! Love this place!! read more

The staff are attentive enough. Parking is limited. Decor is not anything special. Cheeseburger Deluxe plus a cup of coffee nets with tip $25. That much for a mediocre meal, you can decide for yourself. Everyone knows their costs have gone up, but this is egregious. I plan never to return. read more

Small town diner. Blue Point diner is one of those places you could drive by and never see- it just has a small profile and is tucked back from the road a bit. The place is larger than it looks and we were seated quickly. The decor is something from back on the day with loads of old photos (mostly of hollywood types that have never been there) adorning the place. Booths were cozy and the place is well lit. WE hit it for breakfast generally and they make a decent omelette and the coffee is hot and quick to be refilled- my kind of place. Prices are average and the waitress is efficient and gets the job done. A solid place for a warm start to the day. Parking in front and a few spots in the rear. read more

Small old fashioned diner with great comfort food! I was surprised to see that my favorite diner only had two reviews so far. We come here all the time. First let me say, that the place is small. This is not one of those big diners that has pages and pages of menu items. It's a small place but we always manage to get a booth. Single people often sit on one of the counter stools. There are always specials, with a lunch special which includes soup, and an early bird special too. Prices are reasonable; it is a diner after all. What I love about this place is the food. I always order a soup. Their soups are the best I've had anywhere. A cup comes in a bowl, so there is plenty enough to have on it's own. Today, I had the Navy Bean soup since it's something I wouldn't make myself. It was absolutely delicious! I often get the lentil soup which is always good. Their soups are never too salty with chunks of celery, carrots and other vegetables. When you order two eggs for breakfast, they usually give you three. I've tried to tell them I won't eat three, but I'm told that I can just leave it if I want. Their homefries are simple and perfectly cooked. Never over-spiced and crispy on the outside, soft on the inside. Perfect!. Their other menu items are typical of what you find in a diner: open-faced turkey, club sandwiches, burgers, Greek salads with grilled chicken. You get the idea. Would I go back? Of course! I've been here many, many times. (Sometimes I get soup to-go!) It's a casual, neighborhood place, I don't have to dress-up and the food is good, just like home-made. read more

See all

Quaint, old fashioned diner. Love the atmosphere. Clean, well kept. Quiet, no TVs blaring :). Wait staff nice and attentive. Yummy, crispy bacon perfectly cooked. Would return and recommend read more

Blue Point Diner - a man sitting at the counter - Diners Near Me - Blue Point, New York

See all

Tried them for breakfast and was badly disappointed. Simple bacon and eggs order, hard to screw up, right? Wrong. Home fries were cold with under cooked pieces of potato that felt almost raw. Bacon was overcooked and ridiculously crispy-one bite and you were wearing the rest of the piece! I asked for the eggs to be cooked over light, and got over well.Toast was drenched in so much butter that it had a sponge-like consistency. And to add insult to injury, check came to $15.70! Fully a third more than other diners around. Stay away! read more

I got a gyro and fries. First off I want to say this place is super cute. It's a really quaint little diner with really nice people working there. The gyro was definitely pretty good. If I had paid, maybe $8-10 for it I would have said this was great. $23 for a small gyro with a handful of fries is disappointing. The gyro was good but not worth $23 read more

This is my favorite diner.... if you are not eating here you are losing out. Upon entering you are greeted by George and his lovely team. Every dish is better than the next. I also had a Lamb shank here that was unbelievable! read more

Blue Point Diner - Diners Near Me - Blue Point, New York

See all

Was driving to another place when we passed this hole in the wall diner. Made a quick u-turn, and boy were we happy with the results. Upon first appearances this place needs a full makeover. I mean it's a time lapse decorated mess, with jelly and other storage boxes all over the sit-down counter top. Really, you can't store that stuff out of sight? But with all that said, when breakfast came out piping hot with made to order eggs over easy (and you get 3!), crunchy French fries, snap crackle pop delicious sausages (2), and butter dripping well done sandwich size toasted English muffin, you got my attention & my table mates! It was throwback greasy spoon of the gods that will drive me back for the hamburger test. Can't wait! read more

See all

Went for breakfast for the first time and we really liked it. The food was very good and the waitress was so helpful and nice. We will be going back soon. read more

Gyro under cooked and chicken sandwich over cooked. You can tell the french fries were cooked in old oil.

Great food great service very clean I love the Greek salad here and the souvlaki is very good

BEWARE: just spent 17$ for a turkey and mushroom omelette with tomato instead of potato/toast.... in total two simple omelettes, 4 slices turkey bacon and coffee came to $45! Food was typical diner fare nothing to write home about. Better options in the vicinity read more

Great place to go to eat!! The food is delicious. Portions are huge. The owners are fantastic. They make you feel right at home when you are there. We even had my birthday celebration there. Everything was perfect. They made me feel like I was a princess all night. I can't say enough about how delicious everything was. They went above and beyond to make my day perfect. Couldn't thank them enough. read more

First time here for breakfast. Food was very good! Service was great! Very friendly! Great coffee! I had to minus one star for price, a bit steep, $40 (without tip) for breakfast for two. However, will try again. read more

Walk in the door and walk back in time. This historical (to me) diner in the heart of a little town called Blue Point brings back nostalgic feelings of less stressful, easier times. The food is amazing and everybody knows your name. Early bird specials are so good they almost make me want to fast forward my life to 75 when I'll be here eating dinner alone. Try the soups, chicken francaise and stuffed flounder (real crab stuffing) they're all very good. read more

Blue Point Diner - Diners Near Me - Blue Point, New York

See all

Solid local diner. Locals and regulars are always here. I've enjoyed everything I have tried. We usually stop here for breakfast when we are in town. Their blueberry pancakes are deeeeelish. I wish they had maple syrup to do them justice, but as its a diner it's not uncommon to have the containers of syrup. Can't go having crazy expectations while also looking for diner fare. Their challah French toast is also pretty awesome. The boss man usually gets an omelette to make me look unhealthy. I'm ok with that. Their omelette and potatoes always look to be cooked perfectly- and there are never any left so they must taste good too. Their potato salad is very tasty and fresh, I recommend it as a side for lunch. I look forward to trying some of their Greek dishes. Staff is always friendly and welcoming. read more

Outrageous prices. Monday(weekday) 10am bacon and eggs w home fries $9.45 and coffee NOT included. Total cost $13 + tip. No specials. I stopped going here a couple of years ago because of the pricing. Nothing changed. I'll never go back. FYI. Food is good and owners are friendly. Tom read more

Of all the diners i've visited on Long Island this just might be the worst. I wanted to give it a try because I had heard from many people that this place was really good. Sorry I wasted my money here. The place just had a dirty feel to it and as for the food, I can make a better omlet at home read more

I genuinely NEVER go out of my way to write negative reviews. Especially being in the hospitality industry, we all know how yelp has drastically impacted our line of work and not for the positive. How ever I was very disappointed to see a live insect crawl out of my girlfriends wrap when dining here this afternoon. It was disgusting. And then to be handed a check after we sent the food back was even more upsetting. I will never go back to this establishment. Repulsive. read more