Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Borgata Pizza Cafe

    3.7 (297 reviews)
    ModerateItalian, Pizza, Salad
    Closed 11:30 am - 10:00 pm
    Updated 3 months ago

    Order Borgata Pizza Cafe Takeout or Delivery

    Borgata Pizza Cafe Photos

    Business Info

    BORGATA PIZZA CAFE ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Casual
    Moderate noise
    Good for groups
    Good for kids

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Borgata Pizza Cafe

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    BYOP - Tuscan style pasta

    it's pretty cute the pizza and calzone portion sizes are very proportionate to the size; but i'll say this is definitely not a pasta place. for about the same price as the other entrees you're getting a way smaller portion size. Chocolate cake was also really good

    Supreme pizza with no sausage
    Sara I.

    Very nice and friendly service and not very crowded place. Came here for the first time, they have NY style pizza in a fire oven. To me it's a stand-out pizza, but not bad. If I lived down the street I'd come back, but since I don't I wouldn't go out of my way to.

    Happy Hour
    Marianne R.

    Met friends for dinner. Had the happy hour drink was nice and fruity, Husband ordered the spicey peppers and loves them. Says nice kick of spice with great taste. Friends ordered pepperoni bread. Big plate with sauce to dip. Very good forgot to get photos of those items. Pizzas came out looking Amazing. The crust is the star on these pizzas. And it marrys well with cheese and sauce. Will be back!!

    Roasted Mediterranean Vegetable
    Danielle H.

    The service was excellent!! And I really enjoyed the side salad with the delicious homemade Italian dressing. My sandwich was okay. Not great, but also not bad. The night we were there it was VERY loud. It was me and my son and at times it was hard to hear him talking from across the table. There is a decent draft beer selection and a cute patio. I think I'd try that if we return.

    Meatball, Onion, and Mushroom pizza
    Patrick P.

    Stopped in to meet some friends. The service was awesome The pizza was good The wings were good (for baked, not crunchy) We enjoyed our drinks. What gives this place the advantage was their happy hour prices - I was very appreciative.

    Margherita pizza 14"
    Johnny J.

    Great place for a simple pizza! Unfortunately, they relocated farther west on 161, but still worth it to drive! I highly recommend it for NY-style pizza lovers...

    12" NY Style pizza with pepperoni and black olives.
    Michael B.

    This was the first time I've eaten in here, & the first time everyone else had been there. I got a NY style 12" with Pepp & Black Olives. It was really good! Definitely recommend Borgata for pizza! Every one else ordered pasta & seemed very happy with their dinners. We experienced no problems at all. Don't forget to get the Tuscan Pesto Bread for a starter! Cannolis were great too! Service was friendly & error free. Professional, yet down to earth. Prices were reasonable as well. Definitely a nice place to go & get a good dinner in a welcoming atmosphere. We were pleasantly surprised & will definitely be back! Check this place out for your next pizza night.

    Borgata
    Anton K.

    The Borgata Pizza Cafe is a Happy Hour destination. I got there a little bit before 4 pm. There were a few people at the bar and one patron at a table in the restaurant area. With $4 drafts and wine pours between 3pm and 6pm, things filled up fast. I had the homemade meatballs and mozzarerella appetizer ($13.95) Each of us had one delicious meatball in a marinara sauce. Can you say pricy? I ordered a 16" pizza with extra cheese ($23). Everything is made from scratch here so it took over 20 minutes to be delievered to the table. This time delay only encouraged me to have another draft, The pie was cut into 8 pieces as are the 12" ($16) and the 20" ($29). It is featured as a New York style pie with a semi-thin crust. Beer and pizza, what could go wrong?. In this case, NOTHING. Borgata's owner/chief Roz cooks Italian specialities, his famous cannolis and lemon ricotta cake. There is something special about getting drunk in a crowd.

    Interior
    Sarah N.

    I've ordered takeout from here previously, but this was my first time dining in. It was what j expected where they seem to cater mostly to carryout but the inside was very nicely done. And service was quick and friendly. I love this style of pizza where it's nice and thin, super flavorful, and the right amount of sauce for such a thin pizza that it was not drowning in it.

    Grant P.

    I tried going here the past week with my girlfriend as the patio looks nice and I've heard good things from the pizza connoisseur's Facebook group. Well, she forgot her mask and I didn't have any extras. I asked the front desk if they had any extra masks or if we could sit on the patio but instead instructed to leave until we both had masks. I will commend them for enforcing their covid rules, but find it absurd they don't have any accommodations for their guests. Today, I ordered takeout to try their pizza finally. I was quoted 1 hour 45 minute wait as they were apparently busy on a Friday night. I showed up at an hour 30 minutes, 15 minutes early to ensure I could try the pizza as fresh as possible. Instead, the restaurant was dead and I could tell my pizza had been in the pizza warmer for awhile. The pizza warmer left my box very warm though, so I thought nothing of it. As I go to try a piece in my car I can instantly tell my pizza has been sitting out for quiet sometime as the cheese had completely gained that stiffness look to it. The pizza was completely room temperature with no heat to it. Absolute waste of money. I would rate the pizza a 5.4/10 which may be an unfair score but it's what I was given. I wish I had a better experience, but it's the customer experience you can expect to get when you go to Borgata's.

    Spaghetti with Chicken

    See all

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Delicious food, some of my favorite pizza in town. 4 stars because of the price, but still worth it when you have the money to spend!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of CJ B.
    25
    102
    13

    8 years ago

    This is some of the best pizza I've ever eaten! My family loves it! The wings are spectacular too! Borgata's is the best!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    If you like conversation and good pizza, avoid this place like the plague. Loud hard surfaced box with mushy, under baked pies. Yuck

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Hal 9.
    0
    20
    4

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 8 of 8

    Borgata Pizza Cafe Reviews in Other Languages

    Ask the Community - Borgata Pizza Cafe

    Tried to order and couldn't get through... always said busy... do they not have any call waiting?

    No, they do not unfortunately. You just have to keep calling. There pizza is fantastic and they get overwhelmed. You can have it delivered but you have to order it through Amazon prime or a third party delivery service like grub hub, etc.

    How far are you from Sheraton Suites at 201 Hutchinson Ave. Worthington, OH 43225?

    about 7 miles, or a 15 minute car ride. you could easily uber there and back if you don't have a car. it will be worth it!

    Don’t See Your Question? Ask Away!

    You might also consider

    Pies & Pints - Worthington, OH

    Pies & Pints - Worthington, OH

    3.9
    (339 reviews)
    2.2 mi
    $$

    I schedule places for a group of us women over 50 to meet for lunch on a monthly basis. A variety…read moreof restaurant options in different areas of CBus was provided to me. I picked Pies & Pints from that list this month. I'll share the good things first. I loved that they took a reservation for me as there were 11 of us coming. Granted, once I got there, I realized it probably wasn't necessary as they had a long row of tables against a wall that easily accommodated groups. Regardless, it's nice to tell the group that we have a spot waiting for us. We were seated right away and service was good. They were fine with us having separate checks. I think that's become easier with the POS technology now, but it's still nice to not get the side eye when you ask for separate checks. The menu is limited - which we all should have been aware of prior to arrival. I sent the link out to the restaurant menu with my monthly invitation so women know what they are signing up for. My case - I only go for the fellowship and just get a diet soda. I intermittent fast and don't eat until after 2 PM daily. Regardless, some of the women must not have paid attention to the menu - even when ordering. At least one was shocked when she got a pizza. It had spinach and other vegetable fixings so when she ordered she was clueless. The food looked excellent. Not traditional pizzas but many white flatbread style pizzas. Even so, most women picked at their food. Maybe a few got boxes to take home the food. No one complained. No one said a word about the food. If they are like me, they are there for the company - not so much the food. I gave three stars based on a bunch of old ladies non preferring pizza. Objectively, the food looked good but do not go here if you're not a pizza person or you're looking for a traditional red sauced pizza.

    Pies & Pints - Worthington…read more Mushroom Garlic Feta: Roasted & fresh garlic, roasted mushrooms, caramelized onions, fresh herbs & olive oil. Black Bean Cheddar: Jalapeños, seasoned black beans, salsa, cilantro & crème fraîche. Rosemary & Roasted Garlic Flatbread: With warm goat cheese & balsamic reduction.

    Photos
    Grape Pie - red grapes, gorgonzola, and fresh rosemary
    Grape Pie - red grapes, gorgonzola, and fresh rosemary
    Spinach Garlic Pie - Spinach, red onions, gorgonzola, fresh garlic & roma tomatoes
    Spinach Garlic Pie - Spinach, red onions, gorgonzola, fresh garlic & roma tomatoes
    Chicken Gouda Pie - Marinated grilled chicken, bacon, smoked gouda, red onions with chipotle crema & scallions

    See all

    Chicken Gouda Pie - Marinated grilled chicken, bacon, smoked gouda, red onions with chipotle crema & scallions
    JT's Pizza & Pub

    JT's Pizza & Pub

    4.4
    (277 reviews)
    0.2 mi
    $$

    1st Time here & Definitely coming back for more. Saw the…read morereviews online & we decided to give this a try. Boy we sure we're more than satisfied with the experience. Great Friendly Staff Members & Great Vibes here. Lotsa people here enjoying the grub & pub Multiple TV's with various Sport's On along with more stuff. Keno game's. Lively atmosphere with mix of couples,families & solos.... Nice specials plus variety of spirits & food's. We had the BIG AL Pizza which was Delicious, Crispy Thin Crust, Saucy & Melty~Gooey Yummilicious Pizza with lotsa flavors Also had some incredible delicious garlic parmesan pretzel tots with tasty sauce.....very yummy My Wife also had a Ceasars Salad that was Huge & Fresh* Excellent customer service rendered & engagement from the Entire Staff. Super attentive & warm,genuine interaction with us & other's within the Pub. We've been to Fancy Schmancey Joints that didn't attend to us as nicely as this place did as a "Pub" Kudos to the whole Staff & we shall be returning for another flavor packed experience.

    We've used JT's for take out for many years before we started dining here. Since then, we're here…read moretwo or three times a month for pizza, pasta, last minute lunch or dinner or just to drink. Pizza and other dishes are always good and the service even better. The back part of the restaurant has a "chill sports bar" ambience. Lots of tv's, a good bar along with good food. This is where we like to sit. During nice weather, the back garage type doors open to the outside with lots of outdoor seating available. JT's is pretty much of a go to place in this area. I can see why.

    Photos
    Bar on the patio
    Bar on the patio
    12 Boneless Wings - barbecued. 1/2025
    12 Boneless Wings - barbecued. 1/2025
    Naked wings - Cajun rub with a side of Greg's sauce.

    See all

    Naked wings - Cajun rub with a side of Greg's sauce.
    Gallos Pizza

    Gallos Pizza

    4.2
    (20 reviews)
    3.3 mi

    Stopped here to get bubble tea felt like I really needed to eat something so I decided to veer away…read morefrom getting bubble tea and chose pizza Maybe not the smartest thing to do at 3 o'clock because pizza was probably out there since 12. I chose the bridge park special, which was a pizza with an olive oil base mozzarella cheese with a basil pesto over it. Grilled chicken and grilled onions. The chicken taste like rubber. I did not eat it after the first piece didn't trust it. It's very hard and chewy. The rest of the pizza had a good flavor. It was served a little too hot, but considering it was 3 o'clock, I was glad it was heated thoroughly. There was a lot of olive oil on it. It was a very greasy piece of pizza you needed an extra napkin. Service was excellent. The man that took my order was pleasant and he even brought my pizza to where I was sitting that was appreciated and a surprise. As far as ambience, there's like patio twinkle lights on the top. It's a big food hall so the seating is shared among all the vendors again I was there at 3 o'clock. There was maybe two other patrons it's not a very popular time. Would it come back? Sure I would just come back closer to 12 when the pizza was guaranteed fresh I feel this might've been sitting for a while. This would've been a four or 4 1/2 star piece of pizza had the chicken, thin tender Instead, I had to go with a three cause it was neither wonderful nor was it awful. It was just good. Again, I would come back... And will. And when I do, I hope I can give it a higher score.

    UPDATE: After since I ate (only some) of this, my stomach has been upset for 2 days. I regret…read moreeating any of this weird food. Not food poisoning, just stomach upset. I want to start by saying, normally this is a pretty good spot. Lately, man idk what is going on. I got the strangest margherita pizza I have ever had, and a cheese and pepperoni that was also kind of weird. There is almost no cheese whatsoever on the margherita, and it was dehydrated too, which was also unusual. The cheese and pepperoni one was fine I guess, but there was a solid layer of pepperoni beneath the cheese, which made the texture benefit super wet. Again, all just kind of off. Service is good; not a freestanding location and it's inside the Bridgepark north market. I can't say if I would come back or not? Perhaps if I saw a tastier looking item walk by that was ordered from here. Posting a photo of one of the slices.

    Photos
    Gallos Pizza
    Garlic bread
    Garlic bread
    Interior

    See all

    Interior

    Borgata Pizza Cafe - italian - Updated July 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...