Stopped by for a slice and ended up ordering garlic knots as well. I loved that they used a ton of cheese but their sauce was lacking. As for their garlic knots, it was terrible. We threw them out shortly after taking a bite. Besides the fact that there was zero garlic flavor or pieces, the garlic knot tasted very stale. Most pizzerias have the garlic knots premaded and pop them in the oven when you order but I have never tasted them this bad. It was similar to garlic knots sitting out for days. They were not even warmed enough and the entire inside of the garlic knot was hard. read more

See all

Been here twice in a week. They opened in in May'15 or Apr'15. They look pretty fancy and clean so I thought their prices would be high, but heck how expensive can pizza be? $20 $30, so I gave them a shot. Toppings on a round pie is 3$ and 5$ for chicken. I got a cheese pie with pepperoni for $17. That's a great deal! It taste good and the pepperoni portion was generous. The slices were thin. He made the pie in front of me and took about 15-20 minutes. The owner or chef was very friendly. I went back a few days later and had a philly cheese steak slice for $3.50. I'm going back today, when they open at 11am. read more

See all

Not great pizza but not terrible. The slices left in the display seemed to be sitting around but nothing fresh was coming out of the oven and I was starving. The only slices that looked good were plain cheese. They got the job done but not worth driving out of the way. Sauce, cheese and crust...meh. The pizza man behind the counter had a case of the Mondays...that's fine but I came in on a Thursday. read more

Recently ordered delivery. My dish looked like it had been run over by a truck. Crushed will all the cheese sticking to the lid. My order of lasagna tasted over cooked and bland. I also think it was a bit old based on the leathery texture of the bottom layer of pasta. Will not be ordering from this business again. read more

Amazing pizza! Excellent service! New Management! Recommend the Square Italian Buffalo Chicken pizza! read more

Gusto Pizzeria Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

If you love pizza then this is the ultimate pizza lover's pizza. The crust is perfectly light and crispy.The sauce is like mamas Sunday sauce. All the topings are fresh and delicious, and the pizza is juicy and it doesn't drip oil all over you. read more

NO NO NO horrible. the place is nice but NO NO NO. don't do it. Delivery is never right, they are nasty on the phone and they have the stupidest delivery people ever. They stand in front of a house and expect you to be there, don't ring bells or bother to call just take the food away! Amazing! Not only that but God Forbid you complain they scream at you on the phone if you call and wonder where the hell your food is!!! Do not go! read more

Loved this spot when it was Decora pizza , now they're still pretty good too . Try the penne Alvodka pie

I love their pizza sauce, it's sour sweet type the most delish in whole bay ridge. The people who work there are very accommodating and nice even with 2 toddlers I bought about couple of times and they made a mess, they cleaned up after us with smile, very rare! read more

Okay we order a special 2 pies and garlic knots and soda , they was supposed to give us 12 slice Sicilian and got 8 and a large pie was a small and when we called to dispute this error the owner stated a 2 dollar credit or come get the pizza back we were missing 4 slices that is 10 buck not two, and it is advertised as 12 slices and a large, and he claims to be a new owner well with his attitude he wouldn't last long read more

The best pizza in Bay Ridge. The nicest people in Bay Ridge. Yummy. Large variety of fine Italian dishes are available here. I can hardly wait to go back there. read more

Update for new ownership: in addition to their terrible food you are also served terrible attitude. The blonde who works there is an eye rolling rude snob. I've never been treated so poorly by food servers. Just found a hair on my last slice of pizza. Pizza was also cold and one slice tasted horribly of bug spray (or what I think bug spray would taste like). Used to like this place, and now I'm clearly not going back. read more

Came here for a couple of slices. The buffalo chicken slice was really good. The place is really clean and the staff is very nice. They have a standard Italian menu which is also nice. I will come back here again. Update to first review: ordered pick up on a Friday night. Ordered online since I figured that would be the easiest. When I get there to pick it up there is a sign advertising a special for $12 pizza, the same thing I ordered online for $17. I asked the owner to give me the special since it was what I ordered and he would not honor the price. Unfortunately I will have to find another pizzeria in the neighborhood (luckily that is not a problem) but I cannot support an owner who can't honor prices advertised. read more

Let me just start off by saying that the (phone) customer service was terrible and the Sicilian pizza and garlic knots were the worse I've ever had! My friends and I are visiting New York for the very first time. We caught a later flight into town and once we checked into out Airbnb we were all starving. It was a Wednesday night after 10pm so not a lot of places were open. Since we were all eager to trying our 1st New York pizza, we decided to give this place a try. When we called, a lady answered the phone and she was very rude, was rushing us off the phone, was very short with us and acted like she didn't want to be bothered. You would thing this should have been our queue, right? When the order arrived, we noticed that both the garlic knots were burnt. The pizza was flavorless, did NOT have enough cheese, the sauce tasted like chef boyardee sauce and overall the pizza tasted like the oven - you could even taste the burnt bottom crust. DESPICABLE!! We couldn't even eat the garlic knots they were so burnt! My friend was so disappointed that she was almost in tears. She said she couldn't eat the pizza - it was THAT bad! NEVERRRRRR AGAIN!!!! I would rather enjoy a Jack's frozen pizza!! Unfortunately we were so tired and pissed that we didn't even snap a pic!!! read more

Hands down the best pizza in Bay Ridge. The prices are reasonable, the restaurant clean, and the owners incredibly friendly. Really, what more can you ask for from a place? It's brand new, and already the girlfriend and I consider this our go-to place for a delicious bite of pizza. Others have recommended it as well, and I'd have to agree that the Buffalo Chicken is amazing! read more

This place is clean, good prices and very descent pizza. The dough is really good although they need to work a lil on their sauce seasoning. The staff is friendly and they have fresh slices daily. Its good for Brooklyn pizza but falls bit on the average side. read more

Gusto Pizzeria Restaurant - Nonna or Grandma Slice - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

The best Pizza in bay ridge, best quality with excellent staff is not like the other pizzerias , just for bisness, they work with heart and everything is really delicious! read more

See all

I only gave them one star because I got a free soda I ordered calamari and it wasn't real, and my wife ordered chicken and it didn't even taste like chicken the food was horrible I would never order from here again read more

First of all, pizza is so tasty! I don't even live close by, but come here because it's so good. Place is fairly new and very clean. Very specious (for moms with strollers) and they have high chairs. Very friendly and polite staff. Never too crowded. Never feel rushed to leave. read more

Gusto Pizzeria Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Average pizza for Brooklyn. Would order from these guys in a pinch, but the ingredients (sauce/cheese) were pretty bland. Floppy crust, somewhat messy. read more

This is the place to go for Grandmas Pizza! So good! You won't believe how quickly you ate the whole pie! Friendly service and good prices, I'm glad this place is here! read more

Good pizza at an even better price. Get a drink and enough food to feed two people for around $10. Great deal in the neighborhood and I recommend you try it out. read more

Gusto Pizzeria Restaurant - Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Horrible phone service! Extremely rude staff. Im glad Im not the only one who has experience with their terrible delivery service (saw some other reviews below). Save your time and either go to Rocco's Pizzeria or Bay Ridge Pizzeria. read more

Lol this has to be the worst food I have ever tried, the pizza dough was raw and unedible, chicken parm tasted like it was microwaved, ordered 5 zeppoles with extra sugar and all 5 had no sugar. Took 2:15 minute for delivery and I live 7 blocks away!!! Dont order from this place!!!! read more

Got the Penne Alla Vodka, and the cheese fries. Amazing service, delicious food, and the owners are the nicest people you'll ever meet. Definitely will come back again. read more

The pizza tastes fine, decent enough if you are nearby, and they have a good variety of ready slices. They're not the cleanest though at handling the slices. The last time I went in, the people behind the counter were answering the phone and taking money, then handling slices without washing their hands or using gloves. I won't be going back there. read more

This is the worst place I've ever ordered take out from. They think customers are fools and dumb...!!! I ordered 1 seafood salad ($13.50), 1 cold antipasto ($8.50) and fried shrimp ($8.00) ...last night. When the food was delivered I opened it and I couldn't believe what I i was seeing . I thought it was a joke...... The seafood salad was all lettuce.. there was 1-2 pieces of 'brutally' chopped shrimp and 1-2 pcs of chopped calamari. That's it. That's what I paid $13.50 for... (If I wanted to have lettuce I would have gone to the grocery store and gotten some for $0.99 only..) Same thing with the cold antipasto... it was all lettuce and 1 slice of ham shredded in 4-5 pieces, 1 slice of cheese shredded in pieces...and 4 small pepperoni (the ones we usually use as a topping on pizza) .. and this was $8. Wow. Fried shrimps were over-fried. Now, I never ever complained about a restaurant before... and it's not about me not liking the food... what really got me upset is the fact that they try to fool people and they think you're stupid. If I'm ordering seafood salad, antipasto salad... I know how it looks like and how it's done... and it's definitely not like what I received. Sorry but this is the truth. read more

Gusto Pizzeria Restaurant - Cold antipasto... again (?) don't know what that... is.. - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

My boyfriend picked up 4 slices of pizza and a Greek salad. Pizza was ok. Can't believe they use CANNED MUSHROOMS, who does that anymore! Anyway, I put salad dressing in and as I was moving the greens around, I found a DEAD FLY nestled in one of the lettuces! We put the salad back in the original container. My boyfriend then took it back for a refund. My boyfriend tried to be discreet when talking to one of the clerks and tried to tell the owner about it. There were customers waiting for other orders. The owner had the nerve to tell my boyfriend he didn't know whether the fly came from salad. He implied that my boyfriend had placed the fly in the salad! This guy is a jerk!! He eventually refunded my boyfriend's money and told HIM not to come back!!!!!!!!!!!! AS IF WE WOULD GO BACK TO A PIZZA SHOP THAT HAS FLYS IN ITS SALAD! Who knows what other unsanitary stuff goes on there! K. Ferrari read more

I called ten minutes before my order. I was told it would be ready. Upon my arrival it was not put in the oven. I told him that I called and he stated that he didn't know if I would show up. His attitude was very nonchalant towards me and non apologetic. This was very frustrating as I was pressed for time. Being that this would take another ten minutes of my time I ended up being late picking up my son from school. Once my order was finished I asked for an extra sauce he told me I could only get one sauce per roll. He didn't even offer an alternative to pay for one. When I went to pay with my debit card he said it was a $10 minimum and that my order for a spinach roll and a Snapple was $10. read more

This place literally just opened, so I'm rating it based on what I've had. Their menu is quite extensive, with pizza, pasta, sandwiches, and even burgers on the menu. They have a special right now that includes two basic slices and a soda for $5, and I've had it twice now. I am very impressed. The crust is nice and crispy and not too salty, the sauce is well-seasoned, and they put a good amount of cheese on it. It's not greasy like some other slices end up. Overall, in terms of basic slices in the area, this spot is very good, if not my favorite. I'm looking forward to trying the other pizzas on the menu, since they all look very good. read more

Like dollar pizza in a nicer setting. Got two slices, totally mediocre and not satisfying. Yeh, it's a little cheaper, but so what?

Marco just moved here from Modena three months ago to work at Decora You cannot get more authentic Italian food in Brooklyn than this. The Sicilian slice is sweet and savory. The eggplant calzone was fresh melt in your mouth good. The vegetable slice had real calamata olives, not the tasteless black ones straight from the can. read more

I have only ordered pizza from here which is very tasty. The crust is not thick which is just the way I like it. I have not tried the other stuff on the menu yet. read more

I just bought a Lasagna Pizza Pie from Decora Pizzeria & this is what I received. They should be ashamed of themselves this is beyond disgusting, the ground beef is old & burnt, the cheese smells rotten. THIS IS A HEALTH HAZARD! I will NEVER order from this place again. I never write reviews but this was a MUST. Unfortunately I had to give it 1 star in order to write this review. KEEP AWAY FROM THIS PLACE ‍‍ read more

Gusto Pizzeria Restaurant - Disgusting Lasagna Pizza Pie Courtesy of Decora Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Always decent pizza and a good deal to buy 2 plus garlic knots and a large 2 liter bottle of soda special. Delivery quick and polite.

Okay, first and foremost. Terrible experience, first time ordering from this place, and fully regret it. Second, my mom ordered me a pasta primavera with chicken and broccoli, ONLY. I end up getting carrots, peppers, and mushrooms. With only a handful amount of broccoli. Last but not least, attitude, terrible attitude for placing an order. Completely unprofessional. It seemed as though they were aggravated from placing the order, saying "Minkya", which in italian means frustrated. Grandma, called back to tell them what happened, and gave her nothing but attitude. Shame on this place for feeling they can get away with doing things like this to paying customers. First and last time I will be ordering from this place. read more

Pizza pie was made in under 10 minutes. The crust wasn't up to par and the sausage wasn't either. (I like the long slivers of sausage.) Also, the sauce was too sweet. I'll give it one more try read more

Excellent Staff and New Owner&New Things and New Name Made Them One Of The Bests In Brooklyn.High Quality And Low Price

Placed an order today Vegetable stuffed pie,Chicken parmigiana,Chicken fingers and fries & Fried Calamari. First let me say the food was great but I placed the order through Yelp Eat24 and they messed up the order.I asked for Chicken Parmigiana and got veal parmigiana I asked for deliv for 5:00pm and It came at 11:30am and did not get my free 2Lt soda.This was not the fault of Decora Pizzeria I talked to a guy named tony at decora and he said not to use them which I will not be doing any more cause they make money off him and me.Happy with Decora. not yelp eat24 read more

Delicious, reliable and consistent! Our neighborhood favorite for lazy weeknights!