The service is good and food is bit bland, but fine. The later wasn't a problem until years ago they decided to eliminate salt and pepper packets. When I asked about it, I was told "our new distributor doesn't carry those". OK. I was expecting them to put out salt and pepper shakers. Nope. Find your breakfast sandwich under seasoned? That's too bad for you. I guess I should thank them as I found new place with better breakfast sandwiches. read more

Amazing food and service!! Hannah is a great server and makes incredible bagels and bagel sandwiches!

None of the workers ever seem like they're happy to be there but damn can they make an amazing bagel every! single! time!!

Brueggar's is my favorite bagel shop on the planet. I've been a patron my whole life and my mom was before I was born. Their bagels are always fresh, the perfect balance of soft and chewy, and the taste has been consistent forever across all locations. They have the ultimate bagel recipe and I don't buy them from anywhere else. As a kid I would get the Veggie Bagel Sandwich which is basically a salad on a bagel with cream cheese. It's been discontinued like many of their classic sandwiches, but they make them if you ask. Now I get the Salmon Bagel Sandwich on a Cinnamon Raisin Bagel. It's made of smoked salmon, red onion, cream cheese and capers. I always sub cucumbers for capers because I don't like them. Everything is always fresh and delicious and the service is fast. They often have great deals on a dozen bagels and cream cheese and have a great in app rewards program. I'm always thrilled when I get to work and someone has treated the office to a Breuggar's Bagel Bundle. read more

Bruegger's Bagels - Salmon Bagel Sandwich, sub capers with cucumbers - Bagels Near Me - Fairport, New York

See all

I think their everything bagel with cream cheese is the best bagel I've ever had! When we come in from Canandaigua to Victor we always stop for a bagel! never disappointed ! wish they had one in Canandaigua !!!! read more

If your a bagel fan, Bruegger's has plenty of locations to visit in Rochester. They offer 10-15 different flavored bagels including a good array of breakfast sandwiches. The selection of cream cheese flavors and different toppings is good. Recently Bruegger's has moved over to freshly cooked eggs and self service coffee which is nice and they have a good rewards program for frequent visitors via their dedicated app. They also offer fresh made deli sandwiches and soups which are always flavorful but I'll save that for a different review. read more

Way too overpriced for a bagel with some meat or egg and cheese on it. Wish there were more breakfast sandwich places around. Good concept of a place just doesn't need that price for not the best quality read more

Absolutely in love with Bruegger's now! Stopped in about a month or so ago and got a couple sandwiches for myself and my daughter. She got the "herby Turkey" and I a bacon egg and cheese everything bagel. Very very fast efficient and friendly staff. Great customer service and Very attentive employee with blonde hair. The sandwiches were amazing we loved them and the overall experience was awesome. Sandwiches always taste better when someone else makes it .Customer for life! read more

Bruegger's Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Fairport, New York

See all

Love this place. Great bagels but I just bought a batch today that was raw. WTF! Very disappointed... Might try them again soon but this was just not healthy. read more

I always come here and I LOVE IT. Today I went and a woman with an undercut was very rude after I asked if I could have a bagel toasted and messed up my order. I was very upset bc I usually love this place. read more

Bruegger's makes my In-Laws happy. Whatever makes my In-Laws happy makes my wife happy. Whatever makes my wife happy, makes me... well, happy! Whenever my In-Laws visit Rochester they buy two dozen Brueggers bagels & take them back to their Livingston County home. The Bruegger's in Bushnell's Basin is very accommodating... giving them extra bags so they can freeze the bagels in small batches. My mother-in-law is very particular when it comes to bagel tasting. She swears she can tell the difference between bagels baked in Bushnell's Basin and those baked in Pittsford. I am not as discriminating as she is... but who am I to argue with my mother-in-law? Best to agree. She like them both but prefers the ones baked here. Anyway, they've just left Rochester with another batch of bagels. I'm sure my father-in-law will be calling me soon so that I can help him take the online survey (they don't have a computer) & get the discount code for their next trip to Bruegger's! read more

I have a lot of respect for Bruegger's, they're like the Ben & Jerry's of the bagel world. Sure, there are other bagels out there, and there are a few that are better, but for honest to goodness decent bagels and sandwiches, Bruegger's is the place. They've added a few different sandwiches and soups over the years, but the bagels have remained the same. I love the cinnamon sugar with honey walnut cream cheese, but the pumpkin cream cheese is my true favorite (it's seasonal, usually from fall to winter). This location was recently updated from the late 80s nautical look to a more late 90s cozy coffee and panini bistro look. The dated portraits of "sexy bagels" and bright neon signs are all that remain from the original decor. Really, you can't go wrong with Bruegger's. read more

Bruegger's Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Fairport, New York

Clean store with friendly staff. Bagels are fresh majority of the time, especially morning. Good selection of donuts, cream cheeses and toppings. A great choice to start your day or grab a snack. read more

I come here quite a bit and everything is always good. But this morning I ordered a bacon egg and cheese and my god Ella done fucked this up. Bacon wasn't even on half of it and the cheEse is like half off the bagel. Very disappointed in this visit will definitely avoid Ella from now on. read more

Bruegger's Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Fairport, New York

Oh gross! What a sub-par forgettable experience this morning! Stopped at Brueggers for a quick bite. Less than pleasurable. Inside was not clean. Bagels seemed to have SHRUNK since I last remember being here! Honey, I shrunk the BAGELS, anyone? Coffee was weak. Cream cheese was bland, lacked "salt" and any other flavor for that matter. I noticed "new menus" and signage... A failed weak attempt to compete with Panera Bread. In the 90s, Brueggers was were it was at. Times have changed and Rochester needs a new bagel place. I love BALSAM BAGELS, however, its not always convienent or closeby. Brueggers, you failed to impress me today. And you were too expensive for the puny bagel, yucky creamcheese and weak coffee! #keepitmovinbrueggers #kindapissed #wontbeback #bye read more

Bruegger's has been my favorite bagel spot for years. Their selection of bagels is wonderful, but it's their sandwich options that set them apart. No other place does sandwiches on bagels quite the same way, especially their lunch options. The bagels are always fresh and baked to perfection, which is something many other places can't get a grip on. My only issue with this location is they seem to be out of product fairly regularly. Having worked for a similar company I completely understand that sometimes it's unavoidable, but it seems to happen more often than most other places. The coffee can also be hit or miss. Most of the times it's fresh & warm, but a few times I've gotten a cup that tasted stale. Overall, a good experience. Try the cinnamon sugar bagel, it is my absolutely favorite. read more

We frequent this bakery often. The staff is always so accommodating, friendly and love walking in to see smiles! It's a nice change to see people actually like where they work. Michelle and Crystal are always so pleasant in the mornings when I stop in. It's nice being treated on a first name basis. Bagels are always fresh and if they aren't they have new ones on the way! I have been to other Brueggers and the location on Mosley Road is by far the best! read more

We like Bruegger's because they are close to the house and the only place that has bagels except for Panera Bread across the street. Because we really don't like Panera's, we go to Bruegger's. The food is usually very good, but the cleanliness of the place leaves a lot to be desired. Everything always seems to be a little more messy than I would like to see. Also, the bagels usually lack consistency on how much they are cooked. We like ours a little softer and I have to ask for the softer ones since many will be overcooked. read more