Ended up here because we were super hungry. The atmosphere and vibe was great, but my drink and food were so horrible and disappointing. The food came out cold - the calamari was chewy and uneatable. The snapper had no flavor and was barely 2 oz of meat. The best thing was the rice on the side. I ended up coming back to my condo and making chicken and macaroni and cheese. However, the waitress was extremely nice and understanding. She comped the food which I appreciated. read more

I got the trio and wasn't impressed by the spinach artichoke dip. The dips weren't hot. Sat at the bar and the service took a little while.

the food and service was amazing! I wish I could remember his name but I don't. he was too notched that's for sure

Beers received were warm. Drinks lacked alcohol. Food was ok, but overpriced. Restaurant was on the dirty side. Don't go here if you want to watch any sports. read more

Our service was great. Unfortunately after paying 26.00 for a surf &turf the menu stated 5.00 more dollars for the extra piece of grouper. I received my tab to find out an extra 10.00 was charged. The staff attempted to show me where the 10 dollar charge came from. My thoughts were a Surf& Turf is seafood& some kind of meat. How do you pay 26 dollars for a meal and get up priced for the meal? 41.00 dollars for a DRY sirloin and a BLAND piece of fish. Save your money, or at least get your total cost up front to avoid any discrepancies. Won't be back. read more

The downfall of Caddy's is the birds that stare, walk around, and eat leftover food off the floor and on the tables. It was very distracting and it grossed me out so much I could not even eat my food when it arrived. Maybe I am dramatic, but I wanted to leave as quickly as possible. The upside was that our server was very pleasant and nice to us. The food that we ate was decent -- no complaints; however, nothing to write home about. read more

Server was stretched thin, but managed. The food was mediocre. Great atmosphere. I would not recommend the watermelon appetizer. Maybe stick to frozen mixed drinks and apps while enjoying the view. read more

Didn't eat stopped in for a drink to go, $80 for two pina coladas and two rum runners. Weakest drink for twenty a pop. You can't even taste the alcohol in the watered down collectible cups. So I basically paid $80 for four cups to take home to remind me not to ever visit them again. read more

Not family friendly. Went walking in with our child, in stroller and was told by a hostess (with a bad attitude) that I could NOT bring the stroller onto the outdoor seating pier. I was headed to the pier as the indoor live music was too loud for our child. I don't see any reason why a stroller was unable to go on the pier that had fenced in sides and is completely safe, however the hostess talked to us like we should know all of this and embarrassed us. I took my business elsewhere and will not return. read more

We had a delightful dockside lunch...and Melinda was the best! Highly recommend the grouper Reuben (and the pretzel looked amazing). Thanks so much Caddy's! read more

Don't go!!! The only good thing about it was the waitress. I know when you're at the beach the drinks are always more, but a 12oz, rum runner was $18. No prices on the menu, which also should have told me not to order! Nachos, they say are huge, enough to share, they weren't bad size, but again, $15! Add chicken another $2! We ordered a burger at the same time as we ordered the nachos. It took another hour AFTER we got the nachos, we were ready to ask for the check and leave. The burger was not good, and definitely not good for $16! We ordered medium well, it came out raw in the middle. We knew when we went that it was just going to be bar food, but the food was not worth the $$$. 1 drink, nachos and a burger was more expensive than eating at the conch republic down the road. At least there you get what you pay for. read more

Do Not Order Surf & Turf. They not once but twice messed up the order and could not cook the steak to rare. They did not even offer a discount on the bill, just an apology which is horrible to do to someone on Easter Sunday! I would not recommend. Plenty of other great places right next door. read more

Middle of day, waited 1 hour for seating after being told wait time was 35 minutes. Our food was less than special, seafood Mac was served cold and the seafood in gumbo was absent of any seafood. And we waited 45 minutes for the food to arrive. We informed the server and manager of our delays but were only met with emphatic feedback. Can't comment on atmosphere as we were rushed and could not enjoy the location. Definitely recommend other spots. Nothing special about this place. read more

It's great food on the beach! Fabulous entertainment as well. Definitely need to go again!

We've come here several times over the years. Since it's now called Caddy's the food has definitely gone downhill. I think it would be a great place to get a drink and listen to music, just not eat. Our servers are always good. Just poor food quality in my opinion. read more

THE WORST PLACE EVER!!! Charged my card 3 times. Two of my friends puked after dinner. Burgers were hockey pucks. Was told my friend's meal was gluten free when it wasn't. Our waiter was drunk. And food was a solid -4/10. I'd rather eat out of a dumpster. Psh. read more

BEWARE drink prices are rediculous that's why there's no prices on the menu. So many ppl get sticker shock when they get there check! We asked before we ordered thank goodness. $6 a beer I can handle for the location but $18 for a mixed drink?????? read more

After waiting for our food and getting the waitress she didn't have our order. Dirty smelly place smells of vomit.

Great service and food! We had a large group of nearly 40 and we were taken without a hesitation. Zach was incredible and was very positive and upbeat!! read more

Kat T. was our server and she was helpful and very friendly! Good was good and the drinks were yummy!!

Bret and Derek are the best servers of all time!! 11/10 service, would recommend them 1000%

Heather was a top notch server!! Fun lunch on the dock crab cake was good but the burger was better! Yummy! The birds are annoying

food and service were alright, seemed overpriced for size/quantity of starters and meals. beautiful view right off the water

Excited to stop into this location after a great experience at Caddy's Treasure Island a few years ago. Ugh, not what we hoped for. Service was terrible. I'd like to rate the food but we were there for over an hour without getting more than our appetizer. He never even returned to take our order. Older bartender not up to the speed or personality for the location. Two huge thumbs down. read more

Best atmosphere anywhere. Unfortunately the food and drinks do not measure up. Mediocre at best. Food has very little flavor and the drinks tasted watered down. I was a bartender for many years and know a good drink or bad drink. Stick with the beer or straight shots! read more

I am a local well educated with finances. The costs now are absurd. Crazy high with no atmosphere. Don't confuse this with the former outfit, called THE HUT. Lost its vibe while jabbing you with astronomically high drinks and bar food. Sorry, I am not a hater and support local businesses but this place has gone corporate. read more

Meh. Service was meh, ambiance was meh, food was meh. I had high expectations since it's on the water but I don't think I'd come back again if I were to come back to Treasure Island. read more

I love this place. The grouper nuggets were great, the waiter was superb. I got a drink in a souvenir cup and, as a tourist, I loved that! They have a seating area on a dock over the water. The entire place is like an underground tiki theme. read more

Our waitress Tiffany was amazing. She handled our group of 13 with ease and a smile. She knew what everyone needed before we even asked. The only reason I gave it 4 stars was because the food was just okay. read more

We had a great breakfast and Val was a fabulous server! I love popping over ... a meal with a view! read more

Caddy's John's Pass - American Near Me - Madeira Beach, Florida

Service was fantastic a bit expensive but oh well lol I own my own Yahtzee yacht! The server with the cool bracelet I think his name was Derek was amazing definitely want more people like him on this planet and, here I go guys I'm going to say the forbidden word down here in Florida... GAY! They had a pride flag!!!! So you know they support basic human rights ANYWAYS keep up the good work! read more

food was great, waitress - Heather- was friendly and helped with us picking a dynamite lunch. saw dolphins as well. 10/10!

Looks a little touristy, but the margaritas were fantastic, service was great. Nice breeze and live music. Music was just right, not too loud, but perfect for hanging out and having lunch. read more

So this was our 1st time to the restaurant and it will be our last! The food is WAY over priced the alcoholic drinks where $14-16 and where not really that good! We just got apps and the one app was the Nachos that had to be sent back and even after it was sent back we still did not eat it! The chips were so hard you could break a tooth! The pork belly was dry and everything was cold! And this was after it came back out! Yes we did receive a refund on the nachos but that also was the correct thing to do considering we hardly ate any of it. Other then the super nice bartender there was nothing else good about it! There are much better places in the area. read more

so convenient right there on the board walk - yes touristy but has cold beer and seafood - so great 'island vibes' - had young kids and they catered to us well, appreciated the live music! great casual place! read more

Excellent food, great service, great location- right on the water. Servers were very attentive, pleasant and helpful. Always checking in to make sure we were happy and all set. We ordered the pork belly tacos and crab cake appetizer. Very impressed. read more

Absolutely terrible. We ordered the ahi tuna appetizer which had no flavor at all and the nachos. The nachos had barely any sauce, and minuscule amounts of chicken and cheese. Will definitely not return which is a shame because of the ambience. Go upstairs to Scully's. read more

We had great service from Kaytlin! She was fast and attentive and she was so friendly and sweet! Excellent service, great food, and great drinks! read more

My sister was visiting from out of town and I took her to John's Pass. I made the unfortunate mistake of choosing Caddy's on the boardwalk for our lunch. The atmosphere was rustic and boardwalk pleasant, just what we were looking for. We stayed even though the receptionist was unfriendly-bordering-on-rude. Then, even though the place didn't look busy, it took the wait staff an hour to bring us our lunch. Our food was almost cold. I had ordered seafood mac and cheese, which was a huge dish of cold dry pasta with virtually no cheese and only five small pieces of unidentifiable seafood. I was very hungry so I ate, though less than half. I'm giving it two stars because the server removed my portion from the bill. Never going back. read more

It's always been known that the food here is subpar and the drinks are overpriced, but we do come here every once in a while for a drink on the pier. We did so last night, on July 4th, to enjoy a unique view of the surrounding fireworks. My wife and I were enjoying the fireworks when some twenty something lower level management douchebag said we had to get off the pier immediately as he needed to close it down. I asked if we could stay a few more minutes to enjoy the fireworks. Nope. We're in our fifties, so we were obviously not loud or causing any issues. I hope that young man is proud of himself for closing the pier at exactly 9:12 instead of 9:17. What a hero. read more