I had never heard of Toft's until this past spring, when my son's baseball team informed us about…read moreToft's running a promo for little leaguers. Apparently they're a popular ice cream place up near Sandusky, and this location in Grandview is their first shop in Central Ohio! So the biggest impression I've gotten from this location is that they have the nicest people working here. They're always really cheerful, helpful, and patient. My kids sometimes take forever to decide what ice cream flavor they want... Their prices seem kind of high at first glance, but it's actually reasonable considering their standard order is a large scoop each of 2 different flavors. They have a large assortment of classic and specialty flavors. I haven't tried it yet, but their made to order ice cream cookie sandwiches sounds amazing too-- we are definitely getting that on our next visit. Writing this review has gotten me craving Toft's actually... I may have to go again this weekend!

I really liked my ice cream flavor which was coffee with some chocolate like pieces. It was…read moredelicious. Service was quick except the cash register broke down and there was a line of people who were waiting to pay. There is some outside seating but it is rather limited inside. There were some funky flavors. Very ice cream parlor like atmosphere.

Such a great selection of flavors and so many toppings to choose from. The employee even offer…read moresamples. Cute & clean little frozen yogurt shoppe.

It's been soooo long since I've had froyo! As I was scouring the internet for national frozen…read moreyogurt day deals I came across orange leaf and it seemed promising. Walking in was pure nostalgia, taking me back to my middle school days in the 20teens when froyo was all the rave. Personally I think the vanilla based flavors are the best so I went with birthday cake and cheesecake. They have a wide variety of toppings to throw on top of your yogurt like cheesecake bites, brownies, sprinkles, m&ms, fruits, and so much more. The whole concept of fro-yo is self serve so you can choose as many or as little toppings and yogurt you would like. The only thing that was a little annoying was there were no sample cups to try the flavors. It was a little annoying having to go ask for it especially when they only give you one cup to try different flavors. I definitely preferred my experience at orange leaf compared to menchies. I can see myself coming back for my annual fro-yo fix lol! P.S. they have no weigh Wednesdays now during the winter!

Quick service. Love the Elena's Blueberry Pie Ice Cream. So…read moreflavorful! Respect the Cure and donations for charity. Busy place! People inside and outside enjoying their ice cream. Yum!

While visiting Columbus, OH, I asked a few locals for their favorite ice cream spots, and they all…read morepointed me to Graeter's Ice Cream. I am so glad they did. It was so good that I found myself thinking about it all week. The shop has a charming old school vibe that makes the whole experience feel nostalgic and special. The customer service was fantastic and the staff happily let us sample different flavors before we made our final choice, which made it even more fun. Every flavor we tried was rich, creamy, and full of flavor. You can really taste the quality. I will definitely be going back again and again. Highly recommend if you are in the Columbus area and craving amazing ice cream.

On the way home from a recent trip to the Cincinnati area, we stopped at Handel's for a sweet…read moretreat. We used to have a location closer to us in Pittsburgh, and we very much miss it, so we make sure to stop anytime we are on a trip and come near one! This specific Handel's Ice Cream location is on Feder Road, just down from the Feder and Hilliard Rome intersection. It is close to the business district on Hilliard Rome, but just far enough off that it is not too loud or busy. The building sits by itself, and can be accessed via Hartford Village Boulevard, or an unnamed road to the right of the store. There is a large sign that sits near Feder Road, so you will know exactly where to go. Since the building sits by itself, there is dedicated parking on both the right side and in the rear. I can see potentially at peak times this being full, but there are other parking lots adjacent to Handel's that potentially could be utilized. Some Handel's locations have an inside, but like most in Ohio, this location is completely outdoors. So, to place your order you simply walk up to the windows, and can then enjoy their bench seating or take your items to-go. When you approach the windows, you will see all of the signage, menu items, and flavors. The overall ambiance here is nice. There is a lot of bench seating and grass area to socialize and enjoy your ice cream at. There is also a fence at the front of the property to prevent anyone getting too close to Feder Road. The building itself is a classic, older Handel's design, that is very recognizable if you are familiar with the brand. They have a very nice, bright mural painted on the right side of the building that brings a lot to the space. Our visit was on a Sunday evening in September, around 6:30 PM. It was not too busy, as it was lightly raining when we stopped. We briefly waited for the few groups ahead of us to order, but then got waited on less than 5 minutes after arriving (including the time we took to look at the menu). The menu had a lot of different flavors to choose from. There were some fall options being that is was mid-to-late September, including Pumpkin flavors! Like all locations, they had cones, cups, milkshakes, sundaes, novelty items, cakes, pies, and much more. My typical order at Handel's is a 4 Scoop Sampler. This is a takeout-like container with four singular scoops of up to four different flavors. It is a great way to try several different kinds of ice cream, or simply when you cannot decide what you want to have. It is a good size if you are wanting a large sweet treat, or to split with someone else. You are able to get anything that is scooped in the 4 Scoop, which includes the sherbets, ices, and other non-traditional flavors. We were not super hungry when we stopped, so my mom, sister, and I shared the 4 Scoop Sampler. For the flavors, we chose Confetti Brownie Batter, Frosted Animal Cookie, Knot Your Average Dough, and Blueberry Cobbler. I had never tried the Knot Your Average Dough before, so I was excited to taste it. The Confetti Brownie Batter and Frosted Animal Cookie were new to my mom and sister, and then the Blueberry Cobbler is a personal favorite for my sister. I really enjoyed Knot Your Average Dough! It is a Cookie Dough-flavored ice cream with a Salted Pretzel Ripple and Cookie Dough Pieces. The ripple was my favorite part, and I would definitely order it again. I am not a huge fan personally of Confetti Brownie Batter (nothing wrong with this one, I just believe there are much better flavors Handel's makes) and Frosted Animal Cookie (in my opinion, does not taste like Frosted Animal Cookies except for the actual cookie inclusions), but both were made well. Blueberry Cobbler had a ton of Blueberry Ripple, and was great. No complaints about the quality or taste of the ice creams! We all enjoyed getting to try some new-to-us flavors. Since it was raining, and were were trying to get back to Pittsburgh, we took our ice cream to-go. Though, I would love to come back and enjoy the outdoor area on another visit. Pricing here was fair. A small scoop will run about $5 after tax. Our 4 Scoop Sampler was around $7 after tax. Most single-serve items are less than $10, so very normal as far as ice cream is concerned. Considering they make all of the ice creams in-house and with high-quality ingredients, I definitely believe the value is there. All of the staff we interacted with were friendly and helpful. As stated, our service was very prompt and quick. I have no complaints about anything relating to the staff or the overall customer service here. Had a great visit to this Handel's location! Service was excellent, the ice cream was all very well-made, the location is clean, and the overall atmosphere is great. Glad that I got to have some delicious ice cream, and check out a different Handel's location. I highly recommend stopping at Handel's if you have never been, or are simply in the mood for some incredible ice cream!

Personally I think the best ice cream place around! Great service with a friendly staff.read more

One of my favorite places for a treat…read more Diamonds has an array of handcrafted Mexican ice creams. Traditional flavors like piñon, mamey, or rompompe are always available, but they also have super yummy flavors they rotate in line leche quemada (burnt milk) or fruit-forward sorbets. Don't forget their Aguas Frescas. My favorite is their Jamaica, but their Horchata is top-notch too. They also have a variety of Vaso de Frutas at their second counter where you can get mango slices topped with lime juice, chamoy, and Tajiín. This is my favorite menu item of all! If you're with some friends and feeling crazy, get a Sandía Loca to share (practice safe COVID protocols of course) If you're not sure where to start, grab a paleta (Mexican popsicle) or chocolate covered banana. In the last few years, they've added tons of Mexican candies, snacks, and trinkets which are fun. The workers are always super nice and happy to give you a sample. Definitely check out this place and support them!

Great Mexican ice cream! The blackberry cream cheese and queso ice cream is a must try and one of…read moremy favorites! Don't forget to get a selfie with Frida Kahlo real size mannequin! They also have a big variety of delicious Mexican snacks!

Rolled ice cream at its best! New management as of January and this place is definitely a place to…read morecheck out! There are a ton of toppings and drizzles to choose from and they even have smoothies and bubble teas! The owner told us they also have Dubai chocolate, strawberry cups, and Kulfii as well! There was plenty of parking and there's additional parking in the back of the shopping plaza. The owner was very kind and friendly and our ice cream was great! We will definitely be back!

Good flavored ice cream with a multitude of flavors and combinations. If you pick a flavor you…read moredon't like then it's more of a you thing than them as most of the stuff here is customizable. Flavor profiles of the various ice cream combinations are there like if you choose s'mores then it'll have the classic s'mores ingredients such as marshmallow, chocolate, graham crackers. One drawback to this place is little to no staff. Not one did the one worker have to take all the orders but he had to stop and make each individual item himself. We waited 30-40 mins before eating our treat from the moment of entering, waiting behind 6 people, ordering ourselves, paying, staffer making it, and then giving us our ice cream. Also there is little to No seating inside or outside. 3 Stars for the wait, one staffer, little to no seating inside or out. This is the type of stuff you've kinda gotta eat while you're there or you'll have a soupy mess trying to get it home before it melts. Are you supposed to walk back in forth in that busy parking lot (cars do a clean 50 or 60 mph through the parking lot NO CAP) chomping on ice cream? Outside of this the product produced is VERY GOOD

Hands down the best ice cream in Columbus. The out of the box flavors are out of this world and…read morestaff is so friendly! The piffle is an absolute must especially if it is your first time. Honestly the ice cream is so fantastic that the toppings aren't even needed (but why not go crazy right!!!) Love it so much we always have to take a couple pints to go when we make a trip. Highly recommend the coffee flavor, biscoff cookie (try it mixed with coffee!) or if your really up for having your taste buds go wild go for the fruity pebbles flavor (thank me later!).

Honestly was kind of throne off with how empty this location was, no tables or chairs but a lot of…read moreopen space. I got the matcha ice cream in a waffle cone and it was a really subtle matcha taste, but perfectly balanced. I'd definitely try more flavors!

This was my first time ever having Rita's. The folks working here are great. Fast and friendly…read moreservice, even with a long line. I ordered a peanut butter cup Concrete and it was a letdown. It didn't taste like peanut butter at all and had hardly any hot fudge or mix ins. After two bites, there was no more hot fudge. Boooooo. It was basically just a cup of vanilla ice cream. Custard did have a nice creamy consistency, but this is no DQ Blizzard!

I love having the custard! Everyone is so kind and the service is very fast! Very clean as wellread more

Boy have I been missing out! I'd never tried Whits until this day. At first, I was overwhelmed by…read morehow many choices they had on their menu. The worker was kind and didn't rush me into making a fast decision. I ended up trying the "Hilliards finest" and it was delicious. It had brownie pieces, nuts, and hot fudge - perfect for a warm sunny day!

I have been going to Whit's since it came to Cbus a few years ago!! I love it here & it is…read morehealthier than top competitors! That makes me feel a bit better at least lol. The parking gets a bit congested/difficult here in the summers with only street parking, so get ready to walk a bit! This location is adorable with the cutest, hardest workers! Whitsers are my favorite thing to order, which is vanilla custard mixed with different toppings. I got one with butterscotch, pecans & chocolate shavings last night and it was to die for, I will be back for another & definitely add it to my top flavor list! The prices are ok! Everything is always fresh! I always have to add in a doggie sundae as well with vanilla custard, peanut butter and a chocolate dog biscuit!! It is only a few minutes away from my home, so this is a very bad thing for my health, but good for local business!

Service was good and actually really fast! Our pasta came out in like six minutes... so something…read moreto keep in mind if you're trying to extend date night. The ambiance was good too! And the food -- yum!

Absolutely wonderful waitress, Calista! She explained the…read moremenu and the restaurant, can tell she takes pride. Food was wonderful. We ordered two bottles of wine and three dinners plus a pizza as appetizers. Pizza was perfect.