Ordered a custom cake for my daughter's high school graduation, and the whole process couldn't have been easier! I texted back and forth with them, explained exactly what I wanted, and sent a few reference photos to work from. We went with a marble cake with buttercream frosting, both on top and in the middle. When I picked it up, I was blown away -- it was gorgeous and exactly what I had pictured. Even better, it tasted just as amazing as it looked. Everyone at the party loved it! I'd highly recommend ordering your cake from here -- you won't be disappointed. read more

Cake Crazy Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Buffalo, New York

This bakery is CRAZy GOOD!!!! Such a huge variety!!! Simply delicious!!!! We ordered cupcakes for my daughter's birthday and everyone raved about them!!! read more

REAL Sweet Potato Pie!!! Soooo goooood. Big Back WARNING...as when you start eating it's hard to stop. We had toooo many sweet treats over the holidays but I looked forward to getting back to this. Now just a few days after Christmas my pie spoiled on the table. Good news!!! There aren't any preservatives or forever chemicals in it that would prevent it from spoiling on my dining room table. Bad news!!! IM OUT A PIE It was delicious! Pick yours up at Wegmans or direct in store. Reminds me of Gram's and that's the best compliment I can give. Tender, moist, sweet, but not too sweet, nice flakiness to the crust. Winner of you're not able to bake yourself. read more

The cake was good. It had a caramel buttercream frosting, very sweet. The inside was an angel food cake with cookie pieces throughout. It did fall apart when slicing quite a few times, but I think that is the nature of angel food. I ordered over the phone in advance, so excellent service. Pricey, but cakes aren't cheap... read more

Cake Crazy Bakery - Cookies and Cream Cake - Bakeries Near Me - Buffalo, New York

I was on the hunt for a bakery to get a few treats for me birthday. I found Cake Crazy Bakery thanks to Yelp, and set out to enjoy their delicious looking sweets! I arrived about 15 minutes to closing, which is a risky decision for most bakeries, but luckily they still had a decent amount of options left to choose from. The lady behind the counter greeted us when we arrived, and was patient as we tried to hurry and choose. Everything looked so good, so between my mom and I, we ordered the brownie, the chocolate, vanilla, cookies & cream, and caramel cupcakes. We both really enjoyed the brownies, and would try them again. My mom had the chocolate and vanilla cupcakes, and she said they were good. I had the cookies & cream and the caramel cupcakes. I loved the cookies and cream, it was light and fluffy. I was not a fan of the caramel, the bread was extremely dry and almost hard due to the caramel. I wouldn't recommend that flavor. Overall, we are looking forward to going back and trying different items. They had some cake slices on display that we both really want to try in the near future! read more

Cake Crazy Bakery - Available flavors - Bakeries Near Me - Buffalo, New York

See all

Yesterday I attended a beautiful baby shower and Cake Crazy Bakery's desserts were served. The darling cake and cupcakes were absolutely divine. So moist and fresh and stunning! read more

Went way out of my way for a gourmet cupcake dozen and was not disappointed. Each was unique, beautiful, and delicious.

Note-I didn't order this cake, my friend did. So I don't know what they ordered exactly. I just want to give a quality review of the cake: Love the presentation, clearly an oreo flavored cake. A chocolate cake inside with a thick oreo icing. The cake was moist, fluffy and flavorful. I don't know what my friend ordered/if the amount of icing was normal for what she had ordered, but the icing to cake ratio made the icing a bit overwhelming. Too sweet, too thick, overpowering the flavor of the cake. Loved the cake over all and like I said, I don't know what my friend ordered exactly. I just know they got what they asked for, in a timely manner. The only criticism I have personally is that I think just a tad less icing would really help bring the cake together. read more

Cake Crazy Bakery - Cake Crazy's oreo flavored cake my friend gifted me for my birthday - Bakeries Near Me - Buffalo, New York

Only thing I can say it is not a place to get a dozen donuts or a danish pastry , you would come here for a really special occasion. , very fancy cake or very fancy cupcakes ... super expensive for this neighborhood ! read more

I stopped in spontaneously while driving on William St. I bought 2 brownies, with and without nuts. OH MY! The brownies were by far the best in town!! Bar none!! Next time I'll try the sweet potato pie. There we also cakes, cupcakes and cookies. If I need a cake anytime soon, I'll be going to Cake Crazy bakery. read more

I had Cake Crazy do my wedding cake ,it was a white cake with extra lemon filling !! It was fabulous and it had so much lemon filling,whipped cream frosting I can't say enough how delicious it was !the service was amazing I've been back to get orange creamsicle cup cakes that were amazing !!this is a bakery that you should try out !!you won't be disappointed God Bless Debbie read more

When I have a sweet tooth and I'm in the area I will stop here, I can never just get 1 thing, everything is so fresh and displayed so beautifully. The customer service is great and the knowledge of the bakery goods is always on point. The bakery is very clean and welcoming. I highly recommend this bakery and just prepare yourself to get more than what you came in for read more

See all

I've lived practically right around corner from the bakery, Cake Crazy Bakery, for almost two years, yet I never went in. I finally rectified that and had a great experience! On a Saturday around 12:30pm, I walked in and was immediately greeted by the cases of cupcakes, cookies, and brownies, along with a cooler for cheesecake and regular cake slices. There's a little seating area to sit down and enjoy your treats to the right as we walk in. In terms of parking, it appears to be street parking only. As I walked in, I heard one of the bakers from the back say she'd be up in a minute as she was finishing something. Once she came up, she came across a little awkward, standoff-ish, but once I introduced myself and said this was my first time here, she warmed up. :) She did a nice job going over the various case and cooler items, as well as their grab-and-go selection, and what their daily specials are. I was craving a slice of cake, so I ended up picking up two slices and went about my way. For my treats, I ordered a slice of the 7-Up (Pound) Cake and a vanilla cake slice with chocolate frosting. The pound cake was excellent! It had a refreshing lemon-lime flavor that paired perfectly with the icing. The cake itself was soft, moist, yet dense, it cut very easily but never crumbled/fell apart. It made eating very clean and easy. I would totally recommend this to others and whenever I go back, will definitely order another slice of this! For my late-night snack, I enjoyed the vanilla cake slice with chocolate frosting (and some ice cream :)). This slice had nice flavor balance between the vanilla cake and, what I believe is, homemade chocolate frosting. The consistency of the cake itself was similar to the pound cake slice I had earlier - moist, soft, yet dense. Again, a very clean eating experience where the slice didn't crumble and fall apart as I cut into it. I really liked the chocolate frosting though; it was not too sweet and tasted wonderful - I was VERY happy with the amount of frosting on my slice. The size of my slices was perfect and left me plenty satisfied. I paid about $10 for both slices, which seemed very affordable to me. All-in-all, I really liked my experience with Cake Crazy Bakery! The baker was pleasant and did a nice job going over everything. The cake slices I ordered were fresh and tasted great and the prices seemed reasonable. I will most certainly be back to grab another slice of that 7-Up Cake and, hopefully, a slice of that red velvet cake or cookies and cream cake from their website - I would love to try those flavors. :) read more

See all

Had a very great experience at Cake Crazy Bakery in Cheektowaga. The ladies who assisted me were super helpful and friendly. I tried out a couple cupcakes right in the shop and then ordered a large round birthday cake for pickup in a couple weeks for my fiance's birthday. The flavor I ordered was caramel cookie. I asked for them to leave the cookies off the top and simply write the happy birthday message there instead. Note that you can see examples of all of their specialty cakes on their instagram and website. The cake was so perfect and beautiful when I came back to pick it up. It traveled well in its box back to downtown Buffalo and didn't shift at all. And I left it out until the party so that it would be room temperature and it was so moist, great texture to the cake and delicious flavors. The flavor I ordered is a very sweet cake, but the bakery has many flavors to select from. Highly recommend for a custom birthday cake or special day. And note that their cooler always has ready to go cupcakes, cakes, and they have boxed up cookies and other goodies ready made if you drop in. read more

Cake Crazy Bakery - The cake! - Bakeries Near Me - Buffalo, New York

See all

We stopped in today for some birthday cupcakes. The place is really cute inside and all of the desserts looked delicious! Not wanting to miss out on anything we got a dozen of the cupcakes and the ones we've had so far were all amazing! I can't even pick a favorite (maybe the red velvet). We'll definitely come back for the next family birthday. read more

See all

Ordered a custom cake for my husbands 40th birthday. The staff were helpful and the price was very reasonable. The cake looked awesome, just what I had asked for. But the taste was even better! It was so moist and the flavor was excellent. Not too sweet and totally decadent. Everyone at the party was asking where the cake came from! Happy we decided to get some cupcakes from the case while we there because we've gotten to sample even more of the bakeries flavors and we have enjoyed them all! Highly recommend this bakery for any occasion. read more

Cake Crazy Bakery - Custom birthday cake - Bakeries Near Me - Buffalo, New York

I had a chance to try some of THE BEST cupcakes I've ever had. My mom was in town for her birthday, so as a treat my friend grabbed some cupcakes. They magically blended 2 of my mom's favorite things, chocolate and coconut, for the decadent German chocolate cupcake. There was a red velvet cupcake with a rich cream cheese frosting. And my ultimate favorite, the cinnamon toast crunch cupcake. It melted my heart as it melted in my mouth. The cupcakes were reasonably priced and tasted amazing. I will definitely have to try other items from Cake Crazy. I definitely recommend checking them out the next time you would like to treat yourself! read more

Cake Crazy Bakery - German chocolate, red velvet, and cinnamon toast crunch cupcake - Bakeries Near Me - Buffalo, New York

Cake Crazy Bakery is the best bakery in WNY. They aren't your average bakery. They specialize in one of a kind creations. They pay attention to detail when designing your order. They're definitely worth the money. read more

WOW!!! I went here not once, but twice last Saturday. Finally made it here, got some cookies, this brownie thing and cheesecake. The cupcakes were beyond stunning but sadly I don't like cake. Well, as I drive away I thought of a friend nearby who is going through a tough time. So I turned around and went back for those gorgeous cupcakes to surprise her!! The young lady working the counter was also lovely! I hope she continues to learn baking skills . First of all, this might be the best cheesecake I have ever had my life!!! I even got a slice with the cherry topping. I hate cherry topping but figured this could be good/different. Amazing!! My friend loved the cupcakes. My only regret is not buying every last one of those brownie things. They had chocolate chips, caramel and pecans . Can't wait to come back! read more

Cake Crazy Bakery - Banana pudding, turtle, strawberry crunch and peanut butter cup. - Bakeries Near Me - Buffalo, New York

These are so good. Moist, full of flavor and not bad in price! Definitely recommend coming here. Also have cakes that aren't bad in price either!! Coming back forsure. read more

Cake Crazy Bakery - Lemon, Strawberry Crunch, White chocolate cherry and Red velvet - Bakeries Near Me - Buffalo, New York

These cupcakes are AMAZING they have fun flavors that are so yummy. I needed a last minute order and Tashiana was so friendly and helpful in making it happen. Really great cupcakes and super friend. The shop is also really cute. They have cakes and cookies everything looks great. read more

Ordered this mint chip cake for a friend's birthday. It was delicious (very moist) and beautiful! I highly recommend Cake Crazy! read more

Cake Crazy Bakery - Mint chip cake - Bakeries Near Me - Buffalo, New York

Purchased a cake and sweet potato pie. Everyone loved the pie and cake. The sweet potato pie is creamy and not overly sweet. The cake is moist and fluffy with icing. read more

stopped in here a week or so ago on a Friday she had $1.00 cookies the peanut butter ones were delicious perfectly made , Now if sweetness is your thing then the C.C ones will be perfect for you. She had a variety of cake slices I got the caramel it was good but too sweet for me, I will definitely be back for more P.B cookies though read more

Cake Crazy Bakery - Caramel cake Peanut butter cookies Chocolate chip cookies - Bakeries Near Me - Buffalo, New York

I am always skeptical of bakery cakes. Often, bakery seem to spend too much time on the appearance and not enough on the taste: beautiful flavorless frosting over dry cake can be the results. It is quite the opposite at crazy cakes! I had the lemon filled coconut frosted cupcake and it was moist and flavorful and the frosting covered the entire top of the cupcake, which sealed in the freshness. The next day I had a day old red velvet cupcake with, what I believe is, cream cheese frosting. It was still perfect the next day. After years of searching, I have finally found my cupcake place. Long live crazy cakes! Oh.. and they are pretty too. read more

Amazing cake! Thanks for making a cake with short notice. It was so beautiful and tasty!! Everyone loved it, including my daughter who's birthday it was for. You were so accommodating and made it so perfect for the occasion. Prices were reasonable and hours were good too. I will be ordering another for graduation coming up! Thanks so much for everything. You are a wonderful business woman and your talent shows in the presentation. read more

I've ordered several cakes from Cake Crazy and I've never been disappointed, however I wasn't heavy into YELP at the time of my visits so I don't have any pics. Any who, normally on a Thursday I'm working 16 hours so I'm unable to stop by for the Cake Special, which is 2 slices of cake for $6. Well today was the day and I'm so happy, this is a much needed treat. Every Thursday my friends text about which cake they got and how amazing it was and then they said she added homemade ice cream to the list. The ice cream caught my FULL ATTENTION. So today I was up early and ready to get my cake and ice cream.. Walking in I was greeted my a nice lady who let me know what the special was and told me to look around until I was ready, so I enjoyed the greeting and the customer service. Eventually I decided on a slice of Birthday Cake and a slice of Turtle Cheesecake on top of a order of the banana pudding ice cream!! Yummmmm.. When checking out the nice lady told me that if I wanted to eat the ice cream right away to microwave it for about 10 seconds and it will be perfect, but by the time I would've made it home from the bakery it would've given the ice cream enough time to soften up.. I've tasted the ice cream and it is delicious and I also tasted the birthday cake which is great! I haven't had the chance to eat the cheesecake but I will update my review at that time. My only complaint with Cake Crazy Bakery is that the desserts are often too cold to eat when you first get them, everything has to sit and get room temperature. When I've purchased cupcakes and eaten them right away they weren't as good as the cupcakes that sat around for a few hours. Other than that I have no complaints at all.. read more

See all

Only been for the cupcakes but they were delicious, moist and very flavorful, I will soon revisit to try the fish n grits in you can believe that! read more

Went for a treat and lunch, was NOT disappointed. Those grits and catfish!!! The jambalaya . Deliciousness all around. Had a caramel apple cupcake today and first bite was WHOA, all the flavors and mmmm. Cute sit down area to enjoy your food. Make sure you get a cupcake appetizer, pretty sure it enhances the actual food read more

Cake Crazy Bakery - Pink lemonade, strawberry crunch, caramel apple and chocolate. - Bakeries Near Me - Buffalo, New York

Today was the first time that I went to the Cake Crazy Bakery and my goodness; I fell in love with the atmosphere and the cleanliness of this business! I initially ordered a cake last week, but I ended up walking out with four cupcakes and four pecan sweet potato pies!! WOW 10/10 read more

See all

A friend of the family bought the strawberry crunch and Pineapple upside down cake for Thanksgiving dessert, OMG the best cake I have ever tasted. I have put in a order for Christmas. Unfortunately I cannot pickup cake myself because we are in New Jersey. I wish you did shipping. That strawberry frosting was out of this world and the yellow cake was super super moist, just delicious. I can't wait till she comes back to New Jersey in a few weeks so I can sink my teeth into that cake. read more

On my visit I purchased 2 lemon bars, a brownie with nuts, a cassata cupcake and sweet potato tart. Outstanding brownie, huge, nutty, not too sweet perfection. The lemon bars and sweet potato tart I purchased for others. I didn't get a taste, you know what that means! I will try the cupcake later but I have no doubt it will be delicious. The shop is small, cute and well stocked. It was busy the Saturday before mother's day but the staff was upbeat, friendly and accommodating. I even got a complimentary chocolate covered strawberry with my order! read more

Cake Crazy Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Buffalo, New York

Everything was so delicious! Pastries tasted good, service was good, I really have nothing negative.

This bakery has been on my list for awhile now and it did not disappoint! The staff was helpful and friendly, they told me about todays(Thursday) special 2 cake slices for $7 and the Friday special is buy 2 get 1 free cookies and brownies. This info was a game changer, and I had to try some cake. There were upwards of 10 different cake slices to choose from, I opted for the chocolate peanut butter and red velvet. The chocolate peanut butter was good(!) but the red velvet was next level good! I recommend anyone with a sweet tooth to make this shop a must on your list. read more

See all

I had a custom ordered cake made for a 50th Wedding Anniversary! The cake was beautiful. Exactly what I hoped it would look like. The cake and the frosting were amazing. The cake inside was chocolate with chocolate buttercream. The chocolate buttercream was almost an inch thick. We also tried a few cupcakes. Chocolate, German Chocolate, and Strawberry Lemonade. The ladies were very helpful. I easily was able to message them pictures of what I was looking for. I would order from there again. read more

See all

Cake Crazy is phenomenal!! Had to find a new bakery since Dessert Deli closed! This is it! Picked up a red velvet cake ready and waiting in their refrigerated display case! Not only did they have red velvet cake, but many others to choose from! The service was great as well! Sooooo glad I found Cake Crazy! Please, please move to Kenmore and Williamsville! Everyone loved the cake! read more

Bakeries and Diners. 2 of my favorite things. And 2 things I travel for. This review is for a bakery. On William Street in Cheektowaga, which is far from my usual path. But I saw a Groupon. And I bought that Groupon. And here I came. Open since Oct 2014 the storefront is in a house/ apartment space. It's a small storefront but each item in the display case looks very inviting. We picked up a sweet potato pie, cupcake, piece of cake and a lemon bar. The lemon bar has a touch of almond I think and it's spectacular. A touch of something anyway. Those will be in high demand here. The cupcake was also very good. Her flavors are typical of what you see in other bakeries in town. So you may have an expectation. I encourage you to ignore those expectations and taste it as if it's the first time. I think you will like it. We did. The sweet potato pie we warmed up. I gather usually people use a microwave for that, but being a household without a microwave (I know, but you don't miss what you never got used to), the toaster oven worked fine. Lower heat for 10 min should do it. We liked this pie. First time I had had one but others in the house who have been exposed to more than I, really liked it. The cake was a little dry and I probably would not pick that up again. But the frosting (not a huge amount) was very tasty. This a real sole proprietor. She knows how to bake. Worth a visit to the area. I think you will be pleased. Street parking. read more

All desserts were amazing but the raspberry cheesecake was my personal favorite. All slices were large portions. The workers were friendly and gave us free water when we needed one. The pink lemonade cake was refreshing and a nice contrast between the other rich and decadent desserts. The brownie was dense and fudgy, not overly sweet. Everything was amazing, would definitely recommend. They have a 2 for $6 deal on the cake slices on every Thursday! read more

Cake Crazy Bakery - Raspberry swirl cheesecake - Bakeries Near Me - Buffalo, New York

See all

What a great place! Friendly owner who makes everything from scratch and it shows. Highlight was the chocolate chip cupcake and got lucky and stopped in on Gumbo day - she worked for Emeril Lagasse in New Orleans. The gumbo was fantastic. Not far from the Galleria Mall and worth the trip. She caters as well! I will be back read more

See all

I felt so welcomed when I walked into the bakery! It's a very cute little place and there are adorable cakes in the window. The girl (possibly the owner?) came right up to me and made sure she asked if it was my first time in and then personally thanked me for stopping in and welcomed me to the bakery. From start to finish was the best experience I've had with customer service in a place like this. I mentioned I had a Groupon I purchased to try them out, and she treated me like every other customer and gave me A++ service. She took the time to explain each cupcake to me when I was trying to make decisions. Unlike other cupcake Groupon offers, she let me choose any flavors I wanted to try instead of giving me a premade box of flavors I don't like (which has happened at a few other cupcakeries I've gone to with a Groupon). I'm not a sweets fan for the most part, unless it's cupcakes. I have tried out several cupcakes throughout Buffalo and even across the states. Cake Crazy has to be one of the top around the area. (You should try out for Cupcake Wars! ... Big fan of my Food Network shows lol) All the cupcakes were moist and delicious, the buttercream was perfect, and everything about them was just the right amount of sweetness. I tried a variety of flavors and stuck to some of the traditional as well. My favorite by far was the chocolate chip cookie dough cupcake. I could eat those all day! And possibly get a dozen of just that flavor itself ... (Wouldn't even make it to the car) I look forward to trying more of the cupcakes and other products offered here in the near future! read more

Cake Crazy Bakery - Cute cupcakes! - Bakeries Near Me - Buffalo, New York

See all