For the last 4 years, Cake Plus has been our absolute go-to for Vincent's birthday cakes, and it's truly become a family tradition. Every year, Vincent and I sit down with Mario to design the cake around whatever he's into that year, and those memories alone are priceless. Mario is incredibly patient, creative, and kind with Vincent, and the cakes are always beyond amazing. Not only are they beautiful, but they are honestly the BEST tasting cakes we've had anywhere. Everything tastes fresh, homemade, and high-quality -- never overly artificial or too sweet. Every single year, Mario delivers perfection, and the cake always becomes the centerpiece of the party. We are so grateful for Cake Plus and highly recommend them! read more

See all

I used to go to the Linebaugh location a lot before they closed due to COVID, and I really missed them. This will be my first time coming out to this location, which is a little harder to get to than the Linebaugh location, but with a little luck and patience in the S. Dale Mabry traffic, I managed to get in. The outside of the building is quite unique and welcoming amongst the other surrounding buildings, triangle-shaped with a few cute cafe chairs outside. I got my order to go, but I did marvel at the adorable inside of the shop with more cafe tables that look homey and inviting. The lady behind the counter was nice and greeted with upon arrival, and was patient as I perused my selection. My favorite cupcake of theirs, the mocha cupcake, wasn't there, so I had to stop and REALLY look at the other choices in front of me, WHICH WERE A LOT and it was hard to really zero in on what I'd like. I noticed the poundcakes behind the case and immediately thought, maybe I'd try those instead of the cupcakes. They're a decent size, and I've never had them before, and the flavors intrigued me. I selected a coconut rum poundcake since it is coconut cake versus plain butter like the others and was feeling like coconut. I added the packaged cookies behind the case as well. I remember how great the cookies were, and though the selection wasn't what I remembered from the last shop, I still found what I'd like. I was not disappointed with either selection. The cookies were mildly sweet and I could really appreciate the almond flavoring in it, soft, buttery, and kinda crisp around the edges but dense in the middle like a very delicious shortbread. The sprinkles added a nice whimsical touch. And man, am I glad I went with something different. The poundcake was quite heavy and big, and for a moment, I was worried that I wouldn't be able to finish it (imagine that!), but NO. The heaviness is from the rum it's soaked in. The cake itself is very soft and buttery, with a delicate taste of rum and coconut. I enjoyed the coconut icing with flaked coconuts on top for an additional touch of sweetness. They do allow my Muffin there in her carriage, so I would definitely have to come back for a cupcake and latte (or of course, the poundcake). read more

See all

Firstly, Mario greeted myself and my fiancé as soon as we entered the store; hospitality didn't stop there, Love You!! The pound cake is incredibly moist and dense with a rich, buttery flavor that feels homemade rather than mass‑produced, and the crumb holds together beautifully without being dry. The sweetness is balanced enough that it pairs well with coffee or espresso, making it a solid choice for both dessert and a breakfast‑style treat. The guava drink is bright and refreshing, with a strong tropical guava flavor that leans more toward natural fruit than artificial candy. It has a pleasant sweetness and light tartness that cuts through the richness of the cake, so the two work very well together. The espresso is bold and smooth, with a strong roast flavor that complements the sweetness of the pound cake and guava drink. The shot has enough intensity to stand on its own but really shines when sipped between bites of cake, rounding out the overall experience. read more

Delicious cake, quick turnaround and easy to work with. Trifecta! Thank you Chef Mario. Also, buy a rum cake when you're there - you will not be sorry. read more

Cakes Plus - Delicious 25th Anniversary cake for Florida Boxer Rescue! - Bakeries Near Me - Tampa, Florida

Chef Mario does it again! Another year another Pusheen themed part! On google reviews you can find Halloween 2024, and here is Holiday's 2025, attentive to helping his customers in the order of arrival at Cakes Plus, Chef Mario finished making the gentleman he was with his coffee in the barista area of the shop and checked him out before bringing my beautiful artistic custom creation from the back. A holiday Pusheen Christmas tree ornament modeled Cake, a 3D fondant shelled marble cake with mint filling that was unbelievably perfect in every way, its sixlet beaded ornaments the perfect touch. Almost impossible to eat due to its sheer cuteness and design aesthetic! We found a way, we started in the back. Thanks for your attention to detail Cakes Plus and Chef Mario! You have my business and recommendations for life. read more

See all

I could not have been more pleased with my 20s themed cake . I attached a pic I found online , picked the flavors and hoped for the best . Cakes Plus really impressed me . The cake was gorgeous (unfortunately , I didn't think to take a pic of my cake until it was too late lol) the Mocha and strawberry tasted fabulous ! I'll be making Cakes Plus my GoTo for custom cakes The staff was great too Thanks read more

Cakes Plus - Bakeries Near Me - Tampa, Florida

This place was a 10/10. I ordered a custom cale for my birthday and it was by far the LEAST expensive I could find and they made my cake PERFECTLY!! On top of it they were super nice and friendly inside. They had a really nice conversation with me and my brother which made us feel really comfortable. We both wanted coffee and they gave it to us on the house since it was my birthday. I'm very picky with my coffee because im Caribbean and like it strong and it was probably the best coffee i've bought! I wish I had a better picture of the cake‍. It tasted amazing! i will definitely come back ! read more

Cakes Plus - Bakeries Near Me - Tampa, Florida

See all

What an amazing spot!!! I needed a custom cake for a 50 year retirement party. I found a picture on Google of what I wanted and just had a slight modification for it. I sent it over to them, and the cake came out better than I could have imagined. Everyone loved it and it tasted amazing. I was so nervous ordering from a new spot where I had never had anything done before, and was so happy that they made my vision come to life. read more

See all

My boyfriend surprised me for my birthday with a cake and told me it would be Nanalan themed, specially Mona, but told me nothing else. All I can say is, when I saw the cake I was absolutely speechless! Design wise - was so much better than either of us could've expected. They literally created the whole cake to look like her! I've included a reference photo along with the final product for comparison. Additionally, everyone agreed the cake was delicious. We went with a vanilla cake with a raspberry filling. The cake had a great flavor and consistency, but I must also add the fondant used was actually delicious. Everyone who ate it agreed they usually hate fondant and yet loved the fondant used on this cake. It was definitely a huge highlight of my birthday and we will definitely be ordering from here again in the future! read more

Cakes Plus - Nanalan Mona Cake - Bakeries Near Me - Tampa, Florida

See all

I just want to say THANK YOU for making our gender reveal even more memorable!! We had a last minute order because our other baker was out sick and THANKFULLY CakesPlus was able to fit us into their schedule! We put in the order on Wednesday and the chef was able to bake a beautiful 4 tier cake for the coming Saturday , we weren't too picky on design, we didn't know the flavor either but it turned out to be wedding almond cake flavor, my absolute favorite and the icing was beautiful! It was a great surprise to cut into it and see we were having a boy! It was a last minute order but everything went smoothly and they were quick to respond to my emails and calls! It tasted amazing, on time, friendly & I will absolutely be ordering all of our special event cakes here from now on! We absolutely loved our gender reveal cake thank you again! read more

See all

This was our first time ordering from cake plus and they did an awesome job. Our baby's first birthday cake turned out amazing! We had a football theme birthday party and everyone loved the cake! Not only did it look nice it also tasted great. Our little guy loved his personal smash cake :) When we first walked in we kind of had a vision of how we wanted the cake but not in detail. The owner sat down with us and made sure every detail was perfect. He made great suggestions as far as design and it turned out amazing! We will definitely be back. read more

Cakes Plus - First birthday superbowl theme - Bakeries Near Me - Tampa, Florida

See all

Was looking for a kid's birthday party cake but something over the top! I called cakes plus, they are amazing they said email us a picture and we can make anything... The only problem is we didn't realize once we went to pick it up it was so big it didn't fit in our car... Try to ask dimensions in advance. Not only did Elmo look fabulous, he tasted fabulous!!! read more

Cakes Plus - Elmo cake - Bakeries Near Me - Tampa, Florida

If you're in Tampa/St. Pete and need a cake done, this is the place to go!! I found out about Cakes Plus after I saw Chef Mario on the food network during the Christmas cookie challenge. I knew I needed to get a cake made by him for my sister's bridal shower. Ordering process- I met with him one afternoon about 4 weeks before the event and within 20 minutes we had decided exactly what design to get (he has an album full of old cake designs) and he had even sketched out the idea of the cake I wanted. We set a date and time for pickup and everything worked out seamlessly! Tip- order several weeks ahead of time. They operate on a first come first serve basis and have to block off certain amounts of time per cake to do a good job. If you're not entirely certain which design you want right away but you know you want them to make your cake, you can put down a deposit so they can ensure blocking off time for you. The cake- Since it's a family run business they're versatile and not that limited on what they can do. They have several options and do not up charge for different cake flavors (we had chocolate&vanilla layers with strawberry filling in between). We had so many compliments on the flavor and look of the cake! Pricing- again keep in mind this is a family run operation and what you're getting is carefully handcrafted by Mario and nina. Different designs and the work put into making them (like sugar flowers or incorporating real ones, or ready made props) will change the price. Our cake was $299 for the amount of decor (we decided not to have the entire cake full of flowers which would have been possible but more like $350). Overall it was expensive but well worth it. read more

Cakes Plus - Bakeries Near Me - Tampa, Florida

See all

I had found the perfect cake on Pinterest! Planning my husbands Navy Retirement ceremony which was taking place on the Starship Majesty in Clearwater while living outside of DC had me extremely nervous finding the perfect place to bake the cake. I found Cakes Plus online and sent them a photo of the cake. They had excellent response time and great communication through the whole process. Ordering and payment was easy and convenient. Now on to the cake. We were absolutely blown away by the amazing job they did on this cake. The detail was spot on! We chose the award winning white pound cake and it did not disappoint. Everyone loved it and wanted to know where it was from. I look forward to placing my next cake design with them and I would highly recommend them for your next celebration. Thank you so much to everyone at Cakes Plus who helped bring this to life! read more

See all

Yes. Yes. Yes. One of our favorite cakes in the Tampa/ Clearwater area. It' is my go to for personalized cakes. They always do an amazing job for my wife's birthday. Any pic I send they can pretty much replicate. If you haven't been, I recommend you go today for their award winning pound cake. Yummy!! read more

It's a Puerto Rican family owned bakery & coffee shop. My daughter wanted a succulent themed Birthday Cake coz she loves her succulent plants and I know Publix won't be able to make this cake. I walked in to Tampa Plus and talked with the owner about the cake which is going to be in 3 days. He made it happen, the cake was delicious, moist, and the design was perfect! I can't thanked them enough for accommodating my rushed request. By the way, they coffee was delicious too, not your typical Starbucks but better and catered to your liking! They have the best cakes, flans, and all kinds of desserts, you won't be able to leave without buying desserts coz they all look so delicious and it really is! read more

Cakes Plus - Succulent themed Birthday Cake - Bakeries Near Me - Tampa, Florida

See all

So, I'm a cupcake connoisseur. I know cupcakes. I bake cupcakes. I eat cupcakes. I'm OBSESSED with cupcakes. As such, I was excited to check out this Tampa staple, Cakes Plus, which has been around nearly 30 years. So they have to be amazing, right?! Wrong. I much say that the 2nd star is because the staff when I walked in to the Dale Mabry *new* location (they just moved in next to IHOP 2 weeks ago), I was greeted with a warm smile and a helpful staff member who when I shared with her it was my first time, she offered me a taste of their pound cake. Which was good... not great. It could have been a bit more moist. So I finally stared at the case of yummy cupcake flavors, I decided on the vanilla cupcake with the vanilla buttercream frosting. And then.. I took a bite. I should have known better when I realized that the cupcakes are REFRIGERATED. EWW!!!!! Cardinal rule #1 - NEVER refrigerate cupcakes. It just zaps all moisture out of them. The buttercream frosting was delicious, however. Light and fluffy and not too sweet. The size of the cupcake was also disappointing. Given standard American sizes of food and the cupcakes at my favorite spot, SmallCakes, this was disappointing. I won't be going back to CakesPlus, unfortunately. Maybe if they stop refrigerating their cupcakes I will. read more

Update: Ok, as promised, the cake tasted great! Good quality, fresh, and moist. I think the design issues arose from the chef not taking good notes when I ordered and waiting to the last minute to finish. _________________________________________________________ Old review: So, the staff is friendly and I'll update this when I taste the round birthday cake I ordered... If it's great, I'll say so. My initial impression of the cake was that it seemed rushed. Three problems: 1. I ordered a week ago and it was not ready when I arrived at the scheduled time to pick it up. Three staff members were all assholes and elbows running to the back to get it ready... That leads to the next point. 2. I asked for two numbers to be sinking into the cake with chocolate dripping down them. What I got, two hastily placed numbers stuck into the cake with chocolate smudged finger prints on them. Literally looked like a three year old was paying with them after eating chocolate ice cream. 3. The cake was supposed to have fresh raspberries. Instead, I got piped little blobs of red decorator icing instead. Not impressed for paying as much as I did. read more

Cakes Plus - The cake. - Bakeries Near Me - Tampa, Florida

See all

24 cupcakes 6 inch cake $170 Both the cupcakes and the cake fell short of being mediocre in both taste and appearance. The only thing worse than paying too much for a product that you disapprove of is seeing the look of disappointment of family and friends at your child's birthday once they tried the cakes. No one, to include the children wanted more or went back for seconds. Heck, we couldn't give it away... In short, avoid this place. Your money would be much better spent somewhere else... read more

Came here last minute for a birthday cake and tried the most delicious moist pound cake ever.. the owner is just as sweet as I he icing on her cakes . Would recommend anytime read more

Cakes Plus - Cupcake section - Bakeries Near Me - Tampa, Florida

Their wedding cakes are beautiful and delicious! Mario was great to work with and was able to create exactly what I envisioned. Not only was the cake pretty and tasty on my wedding day but it was still pretty and very tasty a year later! I was amazed! Their fried pound cake is pretty amazing too! I stop to get a slice every time I'm in town! read more

Cakes Plus - Top tier of our wedding cake looking fantastic after a year in the freezer! - Bakeries Near Me - Tampa, Florida

We went in to order a cake for my son's 5th birthday. They were very nice and we tasted a cupcake to make sure we liked flavor. We went with the confetti pound cake with the custard in the middle. Delicious!!! They helped me pick a decoration and color scheme as well as the color of board the cake would sit on. Also he helped me choose the appropriate size cake and didn't over sell me on the larger size... thank goodness bc we had enough. At kids parties most adults don't eat cake, but this cake was a hit and everyone wanted some!! Will definitely order a cake from here again when needed. They also have many cupcake flavors! read more

Cakes Plus - 5 year old's birthday cake. - Bakeries Near Me - Tampa, Florida

This is a bakery that also sells baking supplies. I went in search of chocolate chip cookies. I didn't find them, but I did find cupcakes and chocolate chip butter cookies. And I found a huge range of baking supplies and gum flowers. I tried the chocolate cupcake. The cake was flavorful and moist. The frosting was light and creamy. It was the right amount of sweet. read more

This shop is new to the area. Cakes Plus is also located on Dale Mabry in Tampa and this location has been open just about a month. They have everything you could ever want in this bakery. They have specialty cakes on display. So if you are looking for a cake for that special occasion, check them out. They have cannoli and muffins, pound cakes and cupcakes. They also have mini pound cakes that are absolutely delicious. They even offer free tastes on their baked goods. We had the gelato and it is melt in your mouth delicious. The size is just right because it is a sweet treat. I think the cost is a bit more than I would like to pay, but my gelato was frozen down to my last spoonful, no melting. My hubby got the pan fried pound cake with gelato on top, yes you heard me right, pan fried pound cake with gelato on top. He LOVED it!! And my son got the Tiramisu gelato which he loved. It was very creamy and just mmm mmm good!! The girls in the bakery were very friendly and so willing to help. They explained everything, and for someone who has never had gelato before, that meant a lot. They were patient as I asked my questions, and the guest were pleased as they left the store. Customer service is hugely important. You can have the best prices and great food, but if your customer service stinks, my money and I will go elsewhere. I don't think I will have to worry here. They are a small bakery and are looking to serve their customers and their community. I give this bakery 4 stars because they have sold me with the fresh baked goods and the gelato, and their customer service was so on point. They are a bit more expensive than I would like, but if you compare them to any other place that provides the same service, I think they have competitive prices and priced appropriately. They are a small bakery, but they are 'A' ok with this familia! Did I mention the pan fried pound cake with gelato on top??!!! read more

See all

Nina is fabulous! Family run place, which gives it a very authentic and amazing feel. The cakes... AMAZING! Literally among the best cake we have ever tried- her house specialty has own various awards, understandably so! We just booked our wedding cake with her- the woman is an artist. We couldn't be happier with this decision!! read more

Cakes Plus - Cake tasting for our wedding! - Bakeries Near Me - Tampa, Florida

Needed a last minute cake made without fondant. Only place I could find that could help. Plus they were able to take one the had and modify it for me. What could be better things that. read more

Cakes Plus - Plenty of desserts. - Bakeries Near Me - Tampa, Florida

I wish it would of been bigger for the price I paid and the designs honestly looked sloppy I paid 695$ for a cake and it sucks because they had amazing reviews and people recommended them to me. Update:I came in July 6th to custom order my cake with Nina and i showed her my inspiration pictures gave my deposit and had my pick up date for July 15th because they are closed on Sundays and we had a scheduled time to pick it up on Saturday morning I was not able to make it do to work so my mom and dad went for me. when i got home from work and saw the cake i cried because it was so sloppy and it looked rushed. this cake was $695 and for that price i EXPECTED $695 quality work but i got $75 dollar work back i went out of my way to go to Cakes plus They had AMAZING reviews online and family friends and fellow church goers had recommended me to them and i had seen a Minnie mouse cake they did for a little girls birthday, I don't think it was fair that I was given what i got. When I told people what I paid everyone was shocked because they expected something BIGGER or that it at least looked like the inspiration photo I provided. They make beautiful cakes don't get me wrong but what i got looked thrown together. I went in the day after the party had been with the CAKE untouched and uneaten i didn't want him to think i was trying to SCAM him so i brought in the whole cake. Going in I knew I wasn't going ALL my money back . I get it they used there materials to make the cake (eggs,flour,sugar etc) but i got $350 back. The morning of the party i had to go to publix and by a 85$ sheet cake for the party and the owner told me "well why didn't you just use the the cake for pictures?" no sir why should i promote your work for free. i still don't think it was was that i only got $350 back for a cake that was sloppy and no one ate from it. Then to top it all off he asked me to DELETE or CHANGE my review from yelp. read more

See all

There amazing wedding cake helped make our wedding day unique and memorable. They truly made our cake perfect with their attention to detail and true artistry. They really listened to us and the results were not only gorgeous, but extremely delicious!!! We could not be more pleased, Abbi & Shane Combs read more

Cakes Plus - Bakeries Near Me - Tampa, Florida

See all

I was looking for a cake for my daughter and we found this spot. They had cupcakes we could eat that match the flavors they had available. We loved the cupcakes so much! Also thinks place is more for weddings because the designs were so elegant and formal I felt fancy there lol read more

Guys, this place is amazing!! In fact I think that word might fall short. I ordered their house special cake for my daughters baptism that was in August and my family is still talking about their cake, so of course I have to order her birthday cake from them as well. Nina and her staff are extremely helpful and nice and they make your experience very memorable, of course the smell of her bakery is just mesmerizing. So head down to cakes plus for all your special occasions! read more

I am always amazed with Cakes Plus! This is my second time ordering a custom cake from them. First time was my husbands 30th birthday and this time was for our baby shower! Not to mention I stop in occasionally to get a personal size cake for myself and an espresso from the counter (they have multiple personal size options). If I lived closer I would be there more often! Back to this cake, they took my multiple visions and ran with it! They went beyond my expectations AGAIN. I showed Cakes Plus 2 different ideas and also incorporated some of their own decor and voila! Seriously not only do their cakes look good but they taste even better! - I'm serious. There was not one piece of cake left over from our party. No one said "oh just a little piece" no, no, I only got one slice. This cake melts in your mouth. My mother in law was like "just get a Publix cake".. no, this cake is heavenly and made with love. (Especially being pregnant this made my shower). Anyways! You will not be disappointed, GO TO CAKES PLUS!!! Also they are family owned and operated, mother son duo! What could be better? 30 years of family love in this shop. read more

See all

I live in another state and will be traveling to Tampa next week to celebrate a new arrival. I called to get an idea of what it would cost for a very small cake. The one I was inquiring about is on the first page of their website. The woman was too busy to not only listen to me for just a few seconds but to answer ANY questions of mine. As much as their rating and location as a good fit for me, there is never an excuse for poor customer service! read more

I have used Cakes Plus for two occasions in my life and they never disappoint. I used them first for my quinceañera, we ordered a bigger cake to be able to have some left over and the whole cake was gone by the end of the night that's how good it was. The second time I utilized cakes plus was for my wedding and the flavor was just as I remembered!! Nina did both consults and both occasions she recommended the house specialty pound cake and I absolutely agree it is their specialty! read more

Cakes plus did an amazing job with my bridesmaid and wedding date cookies. They were made exactly the way I wanted and looked and tasted great! Would definitely recommend. read more

Cakes Plus - Bakeries Near Me - Tampa, Florida

See all

I was just at Cakes Plus and I have to say Nina and Mario are the best, my son got married a year ago and we had Cakes Plus make the wedding cake which was absolutely amazing Brandy Rum and Cherry flavored (need I say more) lol Well I'm back today to get the 1 year Anniversary cake because there was no cake left at all last year. People are still talking about the cake Flavor, presentation and price unbeatable, highly recommend them for whatever your next event may be. #thankyouforadeliciousandbeautifulmasterpiece read more

Cakes Plus - Bakeries Near Me - Tampa, Florida

Horrible service. Ugly product. "Chef" Mario is nowhere near good enough to charge $600+ for his cakes. Atrocious fondant work. My cake looked like it was made by middle schoolers learning how to make a cake for the first time. It's practically a scam. You're sold and extravagant idea but delivered a butchered product. read more

What a deception. This was my favorite place not anymore. Lack of professionalism and customer care. My niece ordered a cake for my husband 50th birthday. She showed and emailed the cake's pic. Cake price 148. We don't mind paying it as long taste and design is our expectation. My niece went to pick up the cake what a surprise the ugliest cake i have ever seen. It looks like a 5 yr old bake it. The excuse, the lady that baked it she is been working for them for a week. Don't you supervise your new employe8es. We can give a 48.00 dollar discount. You should have plain cakes for this type of emergency. They did not care at all for our business. I had to call few place in order to save the surprise party. I will never recommend this place. Owner should be more concern with her clientele. I never had this kind of experience with Cake Plu and this will be the last. read more

Cakes Plus - The cake the baked - Bakeries Near Me - Tampa, Florida

I'm kicking myself because it took me forever to try this place. When the competition chain opened across the street I was really excited because it was a familiar name but my husband told me that I should try Cakes Plus. I wasn't crazy about the sign and couldn't imagine that it'd be much different from the competition. After a year or two I decided to stop by and I haven't looked back since. This place isn't super fancy inside. They sell cake stuff that I haven't taken a look at yet since I'd rather eat cake made from someone else. I've been able to try a few things and I'm pretty impressed. I really like their flan and Reese's peanut butter cookie. Their pound cake is pretty freaking amazing. I'm not a big pound cake person but this one is moist and has some almond extract or something that takes it to the next level. Be careful about the blue flower on top though, it'll make your mouth blue. read more

Two stars since Nina was a sweetheart and the cake itself tasted good (or so my husband says). The cake itself made me almost cry in horror. I was so disappointed in how the cake turned out, I didn't eat it. I had ordered a 3D grooms cake from Cakes Plus awhile back as a surprise grooms cake for our wedding day. When the wedding coordinator wheeled it out, my husband was like, "what's that?" I just wanted to cry when I saw how it looked. It was suppose to be a 3D car cake of my husband's very first car, a 2001 BMW M Roadster. It looked like a Volkswagen Beetle-and not a cute one. While email correspondence and in person contact was great with Nina in regards to a 3D grooms cake for my wedding, I'm not paying the hefty price tag for a pen pal and an ugly 3D car cake. You won't find a picture of our grooms cake on their website, because it's hideous. The wedding photos do make it look better than it really is (photos attached). The grooms cake theme was the car with minions in it to represent him and his buddies (the groomsmen). One of the minions was suppose to have a crown to represent him (no crown was made for one). In addition, the minions were smooshed as if they had been improperly stored and got crushed. They also had extremely long arms (see photos). The blue color on the car was streaked as if they didn't mix the color well when adding it to the icing, yet they still hastily iced the car anyways with the poorly mixed icing. Somehow with the internet being available to Cakes Plus and with me emailing them photos of a 2001 BMW M Roadster, they put round head lights and various off detailing on the car. Sadly, everything looked sloppy or smooshed.Thankfully they got the BMW emblem and stock tires correct (even if the tires are flat looking). I paid the full price for this cake a year in advance since Nina kept telling me she couldn't guarantee the price if I waited. While I'm not a sucker for pressure sales tactics (and it really irks me when people do that), I went ahead with it. I had already contacted numerous other places, and there isn't much options for 3D car cakes in the Tampa/St Pete area. Also at the time when I went in to meet with Nina and pay for the cake, they kept trying to sell me pre-made sugar gum flowers. No Thanks. Had I known I was overpaying for a hideous mess, I would have bought a sheet cake with an icing photo of my husband's actual car itself. Had I seen the 3D car cake before they brought it out, or had the time after the wedding, I would have refused it and taken it back to Cakes Plus for a full refund. It was such a HUGE disappointment. The wedding guests probably saw how disappointed I was, as did my husband, since everyone kept saying,"that's so thoughtful of you." No one complimented the 3D car cake, or even ate a piece of it. It sat in our refrigerator for several weeks untouched, when my husband finally decided to eat a slice. He loves sweets, and commented that it was very sweet-probably why it's lasted so long (sugar helps to keep cakes moist and stretch their shelf life). Not really sure what he did with the rest of the cake. I'm just glad he helped to get rid of it since I didn't want to look at it anymore. So disappointed in Cakes Plus. Shame on them for not even bothering to reach out and let me know they smooshed a few things (or several things), the color on the car came out very streaked, and would I still like the cake anyways with a partial refund, a do-over, or a full refund. I'm sure they have to make these kind of cakes a few days in advance. Oh well, lesson learned- never using Cakes Plus again or recommending them. read more

See all

Unfortunately, I can't review their cakes because I didn't order one. I don't live in Tampa and I was referred to Cakes Plus on So. Dale Mabry for a cake topper by a Tampa retail store. There was a young woman and an older woman working when I walked into the store. The younger woman helped me right away but the older woman was immediately critical and dismissive when I said I'd ordered the cake minus a decorative topper somewhere else. She was really lacking good customer service skills! I need to special order a cake for a Valentine's Day event next week but it won't be from Cakes Plus! read more