I used to love the subs here, but they have become really bad. They are not unreasonably priced and they are big with an average amount of meat and cheese, and wide bread, but they are awful as far as seasoning. No salt, no pepper, no vinegar, and no oregano. None at all! There was a very slight drizzle of oil and it did not seem like olive oil. The lettuce was skimpy and the tomato was like one slice per half, and the tomato was completely yellow/white inside. Just a really bad sub. read more

Cammarata's Pizza - Sub sandwich, no seasoning, and underripe tomato. - Pizza Near Me - Livingston, New Jersey

Gave this place a try on Friday night after getting it a few months ago since I ordered tacos and enjoyed them I wanted to give the pizza a try. (Yep, they serve tacos as well!) My family was not disappointed! We really enjoyed our pepperoni pie. The crust is not too thin and not too doughy - it's the perfect in between. Overall a well made pie. Right amount of cheese, sauce and Pepperoni. Staff were friendly and our order was done as promised. After trying several of the local pizza places this has been our favorite pizza place in Livingston so far. We will make this our regular spot. read more

Cammarata's Pizza - Large Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Livingston, New Jersey

I heard the new owner is Brazilian but that doesn't mean Italian flair and doesn't shine good deal two slices for $6 plus a soda can't beat it. read more

Cammarata's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Livingston, New Jersey

Cammarata's has a special place in my heart. I used to order at least once a week during my undergrad student days. Their pizza hits the spot. I think it's also one of the more reasonably priced pizzerias in the area for what it's worth, in terms of sizes, toppings, and pizza quality. They have many many creative pizza and other menu items: there is something for everyone! Beyond pizza, for sure try the garlic knots. They are $4.00 per order. My mom who is relentlessly picky asks me about the garlic knots every now and then (even though the last time she had them was 5 years ago). I will be picking up some to surprise her soon. The service is very quick for delivery. Don't quote me on this but I think they have tables inside if you want to sit down for a quick bite. read more

The place is most reasonably priced place in Livingston the food is grate meatballs amazing sauce is great please try Livingston doesn't need another restaurant. That is overpriced and not deliver on taste give them a try read more

Where do you go on a Friday night when another pizza place has 45mins for take out? You go to Cammarata! We ordered a large pizza 1/2 pepperoni. Overall it was very good. The pizza was made fresh and came out piping hot! The dough was a little salty. Everyone in the place was accommodating and the service was quick for a Friday! If you live in Livingston try it out. read more

See all

Always in search of great NJ pizza, I happened upon Cammarata's for lunch today. You know what? I thought it was great! Nothing fancy here, not even a parking lot. Just a small little pizzeria on Livingston Ave. All the pies on display looked good, but I chose my old standby, the sausage slice! Nice and thin crust, great sauce, a good amount of sausage...it was excellent! Prices were great here and service was friendly. No problem parking on side street either. Give this place a try! read more

Cammarata's Pizza - First time here! - Pizza Near Me - Livingston, New Jersey

I come here 1-2x a week for a slice. It's nothing fancy but it's a solid slice of pizza. Super nice owner, quick service. Really great for just a quick on the go stop. Don't know anything about the rest of their menu but the slices are very good. read more

I'm currently in a rental in town and I just tried this place because it's so close and I am so glad I did. The pizza is delicious and the sandwiches and kids meals have been a hit as well. While the parking lot is one of the most awful things ever (is there even one?!), the food is fresh and tasty. Their pizzas are just the right amount of cheese and crispness. Their mozzarella sticks were so cheesy and the onion rings were a bit hit. I really was into their chicken cheese steak and there were a bunch of different options for pizza. The prices are super reasonable and we haven't run into any issues with waiting for our order. They have a cheap lunch special too where you get two slices and a soda for $5 and a dinner special with two pies and a 2-liter soda for $22.50 Monday - Thursday! read more

We are lucky to have great pizza selection in Livingston. These guys share the top of the list.

Delicious food. We have been ordering from here and the pizza and pastas are very tasty. Big portions.

Doesn't look like much when you walk by. The inside is clean. There are tables to eat at which is a big plus in my book. They have a special for two slices and can of soda for $5. Actually $0.50 cheaper than Livingston pizza and the pizza tastes so much better. One of my two slices was almost the size of two slices. I didn't get the special just wanted slices. I would definitely recommend this place. Friendly staff as well. Didn't get the impression that they didn't want me there like my last pizzeria review. And it's a huge plus that they have table to eat at. All these places should have eat in facilities. read more

Cammarata's Pizza - Pizza counter - Pizza Near Me - Livingston, New Jersey

See all

The calamari here is the best in the area as is the pizza. And the counter staff is professional and warm.

One of favorite Pizza places. Went here as a kid and they have only improved. Recently stopped in for a slice for nostalgia. They completely renovated the shop. Pizza: Great plain cheese pizza. Crisp crust and lots of cheese, good size too. Not too greasy and just enough sauce. Not the same as when I was a kid, a more modern version. A great NYC style slice. Buffalo Chicken Pizza: I had to try a slice. Didn't know it would be a meal. Loaded with chicken and cheese. A good amount of blue cheese but needed to be hotter ( I like heat) Still, I loved it. I would get this again. Scilian Pizza: Very Good. Not the best but very good. Good combo of cheese and sauce. Thick crust with a firm and crispy bottom. Very tasty. I wish they were closer to home. Midweek specials are a good value. The plain cheese pizza is one of my favorites in NJ. read more

1hr 33min for delivery (one plain pie and half sub) in July. The "new management" will be out of business within two years. They closed the doors. It was sad to see a Livingston icon "The Mountain" end this way. Vinny built an amazing small town pizzeria. His daughter took the reigns and kept things going for a few more years but when it was sold that was the end. read more

I had a horrible experience about a month ago Food is gross and people aren't any better Don't bother read more

This place has been through a lot (as you can tell by some of the older reviews) but I'm happy to say it is now the home of the best pizza in Livingston. The owner put a substantial investment in bringing the place up to date and cleaning it up... It's a nice clean restaurant now. The pizza is out of this world... The owner apprenticed under one of the masters from a long bloodline of pizza makers from Brooklyn. You know, the place where they take pizza very seriously. You will not find pizza like this anywhere else in Jersey. read more

Was a delivery driver for Cammaratas back in 1970. Pizza was always hot and fresh. They use quality ingredients. Haven't had their pies in over 50 years. Finally ordered a pie for Football Sunday and as usual pie arrived on time hot and fresh. read more

I went to visit Cammarata's pizza after 15 years and it is still as good. Even though it is under new management they still have a good slice. The pepperoni here is my favorite, they slice it in strips so they are long pieces. It is as good as I remember. They have also updated the inside with a few new tables and counters. Delivery may be an issue here, but for sit in or carry out they have a fresh slice and good wings. I also got the hot wings (hottest) and they were ready in 5 mins and tasty. I would come back again for a slice and hope they can fix all the delivery issues I read about below. read more

I ordered an Italian Hot Dog, which is usually pretty good. Not last night, I didn't want ketchup or mustard, my husband said potatoes, onions & peppers. They decided to put ketchup & mustard all over it plus additional ketchup. It was ice cold also, which made it worst!! Terrible, never again! read more

Talking about the basics, the pizza is mediocre at best. I am incredibly picky when it comes to Italian food. But, you cannot beat the prices and portions here! They give you an entire loaf of garlic bread rather than a piece. Not to mention, the penne vodka is pretty good (I'd pick it over any place in Livingston since I've tried nearly all Italian restaurants in this town and none are good aside from here). The portion is huge and price is unbeatable. Same goes for the baked ziti. Tastes great, looks great. Not outstanding but definitely worth the price. read more

Just had the best chicken bacon ranch slice I've ever had. Young bucks in there doin it right

I haven't had a pizza this bad in a very long time, how is this possible? For $16 I got a soupy tomato sauce with extra salty cheese. Nothing is sticking to the crust, watery canned mushrooms and frozen spinach, never again will I come here. read more

Cammarata's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Livingston, New Jersey

Usually Cammarata's is our go to pizza with plenty of pizza places in Livingston. We are supporting our local restaurants during COVID, but do expect continued customer service. Today we picked up our pizza only to arrive home and see that it wasn't cooked in fact doughy on the bottom. Their crust when crispy is supreme. We called to see about a possible solution the female owner said thank you for bringing this to my attention and hung up on me! Now my wife is cooking our pizza in our oven to see if dinner can be saved. Thanks for a soggy large pie that was supposed to streamline dinner tonight - we won't be back, read more

Came in late on a Saturday night and the staff was super nice. They took our orders and made it super fast. Pizza was delicious ... the chicken fingers were amazing ... soup was yummy and the chicken Caesar wrap was devoured. If you're getting the food to go or eating in ... you're going to get a great meal!!! read more

New owners are so nice !! Went in last minute for a sandwich platter and they had no problem putting one together ... love their pizza also order the old way if you want the way the use to make it so good ! I will be going there once again all the time read more

I think they're under new management. Food is great. Employees are very kind and cool and they are happy to accommodate requests to orders. And something that makes me very happy is they now sell pizza by the slice! Aww yissss! read more

I was very disappointed tonight for the first time in this plc. When the owners are there the food is fantastic!! Tonight my meatball parm wasn't . The meatballs are fantasic but the gravy was burnt and tasted old. The eggplant tasted like breadcrumbs. I was so shocked their food has always been so good. Who ever is working for them needs to go. They r going to destroy their business. read more

I have been going to this local takeout pizza place for over twenty years. It use to be my favorite place until the past few yeats. I enjoy a well done crust and order accordingly. Unfortunately, the prearation has been inconsistent. It has been underdone at least 50% of the time. being takeout, there is not much that can be done once you are home. My wife usually orders a salad. Last night she unfortunately pulled out a very long hair from the salad. The same situation has happened several times over the past year or so. It is sad to say, but I no longer can patronize this place. read more

Cameras is my all-time favorite pizza in Livingston when they were closed I tried every pizzeria in Livingston can find one that I liked Camaradas reopened extremely clean extremely friendly people and the food is fantastic read more

Very good pizza. Great place to come for a quick slice. Sometimes we get pies but mostly slices Highly recommended read more

the food is really big and grubby but also very cheap!! i recommend the garlic knots; they're such a steal for $2!

This is my favorite place for pizza. My choice is thin crust. Staff is friendly and remembers their customers. The subs are tasty, bread is always fresh. Meatballs are very flavorful. Baked ziti is like Moms. Salads are homemade. When I go to Cammarata's it is a difficult choice to make because I want everything all the time. Holiday Italian Specialities are so good. Reminds me of Italian Food from Newark and surrounding areas 50 years ago. read more

Horrible pizza!!! Order an hour prior to pick up. Got there and still waited another 45 mins.

Moved from Livingston to west coast thirty years ago, but this place isalways a highlight of my return visits to east coast the pizza and roast beef sub are among my favorite foods anywhere read more

This is probably the best pizza sub place 10/10 even though management changed its still great maybe even better in my Opinion. Would definitely recommend to anyone looking for a quick slice or a great pie. read more

The food quality is in my opinion on the below average level. I've stopped a couple of times to pick up a slice and every single time, I was unimpressed. I would have to completely disagree with other posters. Frankly, can't understand it since I've been here about 2-3 times over the past few years. The customer service is also pretty non-existent which is kind of normal when you hire minimum wage I guess. But, I still hate the treatment nonetheless. read more

Camaratta's has VERY good pizza. My daughter loves the subs(mostly because of the cheese). For its excellent quality food, the price is reasonable. Although the shop is small, it still makes great pizza and serves them quick. They also have an excellent variety which includes an option where you can buy root beer and chips along with their sandwich. My kids and I love this place and think that this is the best pizza and sub restaurant in Livingston, NJ. read more

Very Good pan pie!!!! Best in Livingston by far. Owner is a nice guy. Place is clean and has good service.

Ok this place was fucking amazing the most stuplendus pizza I've ever had absolutely fucking delicious