Ate at Cap City Olentangy Road last night. I always get their meatloaf.I do not like mushrooms but usually they are ground up so fine in the meatloaf that you cannot taste them. But last night there was actual slices and big pieces of mushrooms in the meatloaf instead of being finely ground up. Needless to say I did not eat much of it and took the rest home to try to pick out the big pieces. I guess I won't be ordering meatloaf again. read more

I can't say enough good things about Cap City. All of Cameron Mitchell's restaurant are based on consistently delivering an above average meal. No matter what you order you want it to taste like it did the last time you ordered it. Cap City is that old school diner that never lets you down. Meatloaf or Wednesday's Liver & onions (yum) you'll not regret your decision to dine with them... read more

Sammy K was an amazing waitress. She checked on us numerous times and continued to bring out refills without being asked. She was cheerful and friendly too. Food was great, especially the dessert"Mug of Chocolate" it's life changing lol read more

Cap City Fine Diner and Bar - Mug of chocolate, its freshly baked and served hot, it's this hot fudge pudding cake, w vanilla bean ice cream!! - Diners Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

I visited Cap City Diner with friends for someone's birthday. We all ordered the dragon fruit daiquiris which were light and summery. For my meal I got the Romano crusted chicken. Two large pieces of chicken with spaghetti and a roasted tomato cream sauce; it was delicious! Our server was very friendly and did an excellent job! The place has a diner area that feels like an old school diner, but they also have a more formal dining room that was a little more upscale. The menu is broad - burgers, salads, pastas, soups, etc. Give it a try! read more

My group made a large reservation for Monday lunch which the Cap City staff accommodated very well! We were split into 2 tables and were able to each for our own checks. They were certainly busy, but our wait staff was on it and food came out promptly. I enjoyed the barbecue chicken salad, which had lots of the tortilla strips on top. read more

I was surprised how busy it was on a wednesday evening but they were able to seat my party with a short wait (i would recommend a reservation for weekends though) my pasta tasted great but it was like 65-70% sauce, would like more pasta and add-ins next time. The absolute highlight of my visit was the chocolate cake. For 10$ a slice, i wasn't sure what to expect... but boy howdy was i pleasantly surprised. The cake is about as tall as a standard glass cup, definitely worth the price! read more

Cap City Fine Diner and Bar - Seriously Big Chocolate Cake - Diners Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Michael (bartender) & Jenn (host) are always solid staples of my experiences at CC. My friend Courtney and I LOVE the staff, environment, & menu. We are always loyal customers & will remain so. :-) read more

This has become one of our regular spots during our annual visit to Columbus. Upscale diner food that everyone enjoys. Not incredible, but always good. The blue cheese potato chips are worth at least one visit. read more

Cap City Fine Diner and Bar - Meatloaf - Diners Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

I came in town for work and my local coworkers raved about Cap City. We arrived for our reservation and were quickly seated. Our waitress came by and was quick and attentive for such a large party of 12. I was told the portions were large and they did not disppoint. I ordered the Cap City Meatloaf which came with garlic bread, mashed potatoes and broccoli. The meatloaf is a really good hearty portion. When I saw it I was surprised. It was a tad bit on the cold side so I was a little disappointed. The broccoli was fresh and steamed. The mashed potatoes were absolutely DELICIOUS!! Overall I had a good experience and would return. read more

Cap City Fine Diner and Bar - Cap City Diner Meatloaf - Diners Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Amazing diner with so many wonderful food and drink options. The service is fast and friendly. The ambiance was nice and both retro and modern. Had a chicken tortilla soup, Juicy Lucy burger with fruit, and one of the local beers. It was a the Thursday night before Thanksgiving and mostly full but no wait. They are on InKind as well. read more

See all

This place is sooo good! We came in and it was busy so we decided to opt in for the bar area. We were greeted right away and provided drinks. We ordered the blue cheese chips and I ordered the meatloaf which seemed like everyone was ordering. The blue cheese chips came with fresh potato chips, topped with massive amounts of Alfredo sauce and blue cheese. Topped with fresh chives. I will definitely be ordering it every time. The meatloaf was massive. I tried the meatloaf alone at first. It had good flavor but was a little dry. Eating the meatloaf with the rest of the dish was the perfect balance. Then we ended it with a blueberry cheesecake and it was soooo good and perfect end to our meal. I already want more! I'll definitely be back to try more! read more

See all

Ambiance: -Nice red seats, classic diner vibe with a darker lighting twist -Lots of space and seating Service: -Phenomenal service! Super nice and friendly waitress who checked on us at just the right times Food: -Bread they gave as a starter was super soft and had the perfect amount of butter brushed on top -Spicy shrimp pasta texture was great--bouncy and not too hard/soft. Could've used more spice and chorizo pieces. 8/10! read more

Cap City Fine Diner and Bar - Spicy Shrimp Pasta - Diners Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

This is my first time here. I'm heading to OSU but didn't want to eat there. I did last time and it was just to expensive for such a small amount of food. So I found Capcity Diner. I ordered the Tamarind glazed chicken wings. Wow! Where have these been my whole life!? Wings are my third favorite food group. Octopus, escargot and then wings. These are not small wings either! I'm not easily impressed but this came close. So taking a page from Arnold, I will be back read more

See all

I had not eaten at this Cap City location in years and I recently found the food here to have sadly gone downhill. The atmosphere and service are still fine. I ordered a margarita and was told they no longer carry Patron tequila. Strike one. The margarita they served me was lime green. It looked, and kind of tasted, like battery acid. Meatloaf entree was described on the menu as being served with "mushrooms, broccoli, and chili onion rings." What I received had no mushrooms, two pieces of broccoli, and some soggy onion straws thrown on top. Meatloaf was very salty. Mashed potatoes saved the dish. Pies are still very good. read more

Cap City Fine Diner and Bar - Banana cream pie - Diners Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Everything was delicious!! We got the meatloaf dinner and balsamic chicken dishes. So good and flavorful. Reminds me of back home and dinners from my mom. We loved the choice lava cake for dessert- it was really good to split for two. Will come back again!!! read more

See all

I was staying at the Aloft, which was a quick 2 minute walk door-to-door from the hotel to Cap City Fine Diner and Bar. I arrived around 7pm on a Tuesday night. I was surprised to find how packed the place was! There were no available tables at the time, so I decided to take a chance on a seat at the bar. I managed to snag one of the limited seats, but the bar was pretty busy too. Service was OK. My food came out in a timely manner, but it was hard to catch a bartender's attention. That said, they were nice and friendly when I was able to make eye contact. The food at Cap City was like a cross between a diner and a pub. They offered everything like a diner (sandwiches, burgers, meatloaf, fish & chips, etc.) but elevated the dishes like a gastropub. I was going to settle on the chicken Romano, but the guest sitting next to me sold me on the Tuesday special: chicken pot pie. I guess the daily specials are the way to go, because I really enjoyed my entree. The flavors were everything I wanted in a traditional chicken pot pie, but it was unique like a deconstructed chicken pot pie. The "pie" part was like a flaky puffed pastry. read more

Cap City Diner: A Solid Comfort Food Meal I finally got around to trying the famous meatloaf at Cap City Diner. I opted for the Meatloaf Melt, and it was exactly the kind of hearty, satisfying meal I was hoping for. The meatloaf, which is what they're known for, was served on Texas toast and covered with plenty of melted Swiss cheese. The addition of onions and pickles cut through the richness nicely. It was genuinely delicious--a perfect comfort food sandwich. For the side, I chose the sweet potato fries. They were thin-cut, perfectly crispy, and tasted great. They made for a light, flavorful counterpart to the melt. I finished the meal with a slice of the 24K Carrot Cake. It was a robust cake, absolutely packed with good mix-ins like pineapple, walnuts, and golden raisins. The flavor was fantastic, but be warned, the cream cheese frosting is on the extremely thick side. It's almost a layer of its own! Overall, this was a fantastic, straightforward meal. Highly recommend the meatloaf and the sweet potato fries. Far as the ambience it was low lid but not dark, and although busy the noise level was low enough that you could carry on a conversation without having to raise your voice. Our server was attentive without be intrusive. I would recommend cap city diner to anyone looking for an upscale comfort food restaurant. read more

Cap City Fine Diner and Bar - Diners Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

We had a ladies Christmas get together here tonight. I had the fish sandwich with lettuce, pickle, tomato and tarter sauce. I had fries with the sandwich. They were a thin shoestring fry. The sandwich was absolutely huge with a good serving of fries. The sandwich had a crispy outer and tender flaky inside. The sandwich was good. The server was very good. We had 15 in our party and she was on top of everything. The restaurant was busy. read more

Cap City Fine Diner and Bar - Fish Sandwich with fries - Diners Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Service: wait staff is friendly and attentive. Jacob did well serving myself and my family. Waters were kept full and any questions we had were answered throughly. Ambiance/Atmosphere: inside is a nice classic style diner with a modern touch up. Spacious with a nice bar and a beautiful "outdoor" heated patio. Food: Blueberry pancake fritters weren't great. I'm not sure why this is so heavily praised. I found them pretty mediocre and not all that enjoyable. I actually enjoyed their complementary brunch bread service more. I wouldn't recommend. Stick to the given bread service. Herb crusted chicken was great. The herb crusted chicken was well seasoned crispy, tender, and juicy. The butter noodles had a good flavor, but could've had a little more seasoning, but when mixed with that house made sweet tomato sauce it did make for an enjoyable meal. That sweet tomato sauce was honestly the highlight. I'd recommend. Eggs on hash was good. The eggs were well cooked. The potatoes could've had a little bit more crisp, but they were very well seasoned the braised beef was tender, juicy flavorful. I'd recommend. Banana foster French toast was delicious. Beautifully made French toast with whip cream, a crunchy pecan topping and a beautiful banana foster caramel sauce. The fresh bananas added of a nice banana flavor. I'd highly recommend. Chicken and biscuits was phenomenal. This was honestly the highlight of the meal. The chicken was crispy and that honey, sweet sauce it was tossing was beautiful. The biscuits were soft tender. They weren't too cakey didn't stick to the roof of your mouth. The gravy is possibly the best that I've ever had. I have to insist on this order. Carrot cake was great. The yellow raisins, pecans, and pineapple all added a nice texture and flavor to the carrot cake. The crumb was moist and tender. The white chocolate cream cheese frosting mix wasn't too sweet but still decadent. I'd recommend. read more

All the food was delicious!! I am still thinking about the Walleye special with crab. There is plenty of parking but it looks busy since it shares the lot with the aloft. We got seating fairly quickly and we were given ample time for dinner even with us finishing a little after they closed. The outside seating is cozy and the inside is like an intimate old school diner which I loved! A very unique take on a diner and I'm here for it. Overall, I would take guest back here when they come to visit. The food was delicious. read more

See all

My husband and I renewed our 10th yrae wedding anniversary and had dinner here. The service was top tier and we enjoyed the ambiance. My meatloaf dinner was very delicious and Im happy that I ordered it after reading a few reviews about how good the meal was. I also enjoyed the strawberry basil lemonade. read more

Cap City Fine Diner and Bar - Meatloaf dinner - Diners Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

We just stopped in for dessert this time it was very good . That banana bread pudding was amazing it's a must have . The carrot cake and chocolate cake never disappoint! We had a great server too . read more

Cap City Fine Diner and Bar - Deseeet banana bread pudding this weeks special the carrot cake and the chocolate cake - Diners Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

My son and I ate here last Sunday with a group of friends for a birthday celebration. They were super busy as it was Sunday at 11 am. My son did not want anything on the kids menu but they were nice enough to get him a couple of plain pancakes and I had the Romano Crusted chicken. Everything was great and our server was excellent! read more

Cap City Fine Diner and Bar - Pancake aftermath - Diners Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Always delish! Service was great. I got the grilled cheese with a cup of soup. They sure know how to jazz up a grilled cheese. read more

See all

We had a nice experience last night. We had a table for 6 in the middle of the restaurant. The service was good. I had the beef kabobs. They were very tasty with peppers, onions and mushrooms. The chimichuri was delicious. The meat was a bit bland, but with all components together, it was great. Hubs read more

See all

We went to Cap City after moving in my sister to Ohio State! There was a good crowd at the time but still plenty of room for us! I love the feel of this place, a perfect mix of diner & restaurant- truly a "Fine Diner"! The roles for starters are so good, perfect amount of butter & so fluffy! Everyone loved what they got to eat- the burger was phenomenal and my parents said this was the best blue cheese dressing they've ever had! Great tomato soup as well. Excited to visit the Cincinnati location that just opened up! read more

See all

Met up with a group of friends (total 15) on a recent Tuesday evening. Might not have been my choice (I'm semi-regretfully an E. Coast snob who SCOFFS at anything called a "diner" outside of the NY region...) but it was a good... restaurant!! Do what I did, and check out the menu ahead of time. DON'T do what I did and ignore the TEMPTING daily/"Blue Plate" special, which was a chicken pot pie that looked WONDERFUL. I went with the meatloaf sandwich, which was ok, but DRY... While their meatloaf seems to get rave reviews, I think I could have made a better version myself. Others at our table enjoyed bountiful chicken, fish, and pasta dishes, and we shared some tasty apps, but all I could see (covet...) was my neighbor's chicken pot pie!! Looks like I'll have to make a return trip!! Good service, our group was well-attended, and the setting is cozy without being "kitchy." An a-ok choice if you're in the area, staying at the hotel next door, and/or NOT looking for a NY-style diner!! ;-) read more

Cap City Fine Diner and Bar - Meatloaf sandwich - Diners Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Awesome Comfort Food at Cap City Fine Diner. This place nails the comfort-food classics with a fresh, creative twist--here's what stole the show: Appetizer: Blue Cheese Potato Chips OMG. Hand-cut, perfectly crispy chips dusted with tangy blue cheese crumbles and smothered in Alfred sauce. I seriously couldn't stop popping them in my mouth. Dessert: Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie This was the hit of the night. Imagine a silky-smooth peanut butter mousse layered over a chocolate cookie crust, finished with a dollop of whipped cream and chocolate shavings. It was light, fluffy, and just sweet enough to hit the spot without feeling heavy. A must-order. Entrée: Buffalo Chicken Sandwich (No Bun) with Coleslaw I opted to skip the bread so I could actually finish this beast. The chicken breast was breaded and fried to golden-perfect crispiness--think schnitzel vibes--then smothered in blue cheese and topped with melted Muenster, plus a side of refreshingly crunchy, vinegar-bright coleslaw. The combo of spicy, creamy, and crunchy textures was next-level. Service was friendly and attentive, checking in just enough without hovering. The diner's retro-modern decor--bright booths, vintage signage, gives off a fun, casual vibe that's perfect for lunch or dinner. If you're craving comfort food done right (and crave-worthy blue cheese chips), make a beeline for Cap City Dine Diner. read more

See all

Visited tonight with my mom, wife, and brother for an early Mother's Day . We have been here (& the Dublin location) many times over the years and I've often gotten the veggie plate, so I'm pretty familiar with it but tonight was disappointed the plate barely had any hummus , pretty much the only source of protein nowadays (I think years ago there was some nuts in there somewhere). Also, my mom noticed (after our food was served) other tables had rolls and asked about them. Our waiter said he thought we thought the plates were too big and we didn't want them I'd said we weren't up for appetizers, because we had enough to eat with our meals, so I hope he was joking but not really sure. Hopefully just an aberrant experience, but not like it's been read more

Cap city never disappoints. Food is always very good. Great meatloaf fabulous pork chops and delicious appetizers. Service has always been fairly quick and friendly at both the locations we have been too several times. read more

So, my first impression of Cap City Fine Diner and Bar is that it looks like a 1950's swanky diner. The dress code is casual. I love a good, Ole fashioned diner! During this visit, I ordered the triple-decker grilled cheese. I was very excited to try this grilled cheese sandwich. 4 cheese blends, oven roasted tomatoes, and bacon on texas toast. It was delish! I got 2 eggs over medium on it. Those fresh, complimentary rolls are so buttery, soft, and delicious! We also got the Philly cheesesteak with buttermilk, chive mashed potatoes, and a side of the Chipotle mashed potatoes. All very yummy! I wish that I could remember our servers name. He was excellent! I would definitely go back for some comfort food! read more

See all

We have dined here many times over the years. The food has been consistently good and the service excellent. The place is noisy and crowed, but who cares. At the most recent visit we ate at the bar. The server was prompt and friendly. The meatloaf dinner and fish and chips were brought out promptly and delicious. We were in a hurry to get back on the road so we got a piece of the huge chocolate cake to go. It hasn't changed-still good. Like visiting an old friend. read more

Cap City Fine Diner and Bar - Meatloaf dinner - Diners Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Casual & fun atmosphere Nice variety of food options & delicious hot rolls with butter as well waited, Tried the chips & blue cheese appetizer- very decadent & unique. Friendly & efficient wait staff. Quite a few groups yet service was good. Had the soup of the day-chicken tortilla & side salad- nice sized portions & both were delicious. My friend had a sandwich & was pleased with the entree. A few locations so convenient for meeting up for a quick meal or leisurely conversations! read more

See all

Seafood shrimp cocktail meatloaf steaming hot!!! Mashed and slaw very tasty..served piping hot! Crusted chicken pasya also good!! read more

Awesome upscale diner! Ask for Hannah she was amazing with the suggestions! An Old-Fashioned with the proper cherries! Romano Crusted and Balsamic Chicken were great, and we added horseradish to juice up the shrimp cocktail. read more

See all

I can not stop talking about how good that chicken was! The honey covered goodness was so delicious. My wife and I renewed our vows on our 10th year wedding anniversary and came to this restaurant for dinner. The service was very good along with the ambiance. We really enjoyed ourselves at this restaurant. Highly recommended! read more

Cap City Fine Diner and Bar - Diners Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Visited June 5th. Food, service and ambiance was great. Surprised ro see it packed on Friday afternoon. Celebrating my birthday with one of my best friends, received a slice of key lime to take home for dessert. Was disappointed that it tasted more like a regular cream pie, had a dough crust and coconut shavings on top. read more

This place has a fantastic energy! The best way I could describe this place is comfort food with a new school twist. The food man managed to accomplish the impossible and that it is both inoffensive and also somehow fun? The service is incredible, you will feel like you are a regular, even if you're a tourist like me. They always seem to have really solid beers on top as well, most of them from Ohio. This place is so good. It's a great reason to stay at the Aloft if you're in town for work or pleasure! read more

See all

I was shocked when my nephew who has lived in town for a couple years reached out and suggested that hubby and I meet him and his GF for dinner. I figured there was an ulterior motive as he's too young to take money from a trust and I'm the trustee. Regardless, I wanted to encourage this new relationship as I otherwise would only see him at family functions. He lives over UA and we are eastside near Easton. We like to eat early and I had a feeling that they would want later - given their job schedules. We landed on a Wednesday to meet up and I offered to go to their side of town - hoping for an earlier start time. I looked for restaurants and read a list off to hubby - but none of them were of interest to him. So I looked to nephew to decide. He suggested Cap City on Olentangy and I said fine. I had not been to this location in at least one - more likely two - decades. We had been to the Gahanna Cap City as it's very close to us. Nephew offered to make a reservation which was a nice thing to do. I like that reservations were possible as I really hate to wait to be seated - not that it was likely on a Wednesday night at 6:30. We were seated right away after finding parking in a somewhat confusing parking lot - it seems to share space with a long-term hotel. Anyways, the waitress greeted us right away which is a good thing. We've been ignored all too often. We ordered water as I didn't want a diet cola and caffeine so "late." Understand, I go to bed at 8:30 PM and get up bright and early. Nephew and GF got there pretty soon and their drink orders were taken. We took a minute to look over the menu - which I had already done online. Normally, I get a salad entree. However, I've recently pivoted to soup if I don't want a full meal. The steak and bean chili looked good - so I ordered it. Hubby was shocked as he hadn't encountered this new me. He got a spicy chicken sandwich. And I honestly forget what the other 2 got. It seemed pretty quick that our orders came out - but we had been talking and were in no hurry. We all dug in. My chili had a lot of steak and beans - nice and thick. However, it was only luke warm, but I didn't want to complain. It was fine for me to eat. I'm a slow eater and I didn't want to have people wait while it was heated - or wait even longer after they were done. As I turns out - they still had to wait on me to finish my chili as they ate their complete meals before I was done. And I wasn't a big talker - that didn't slow me down. I guess I just eat slow. Hubby enjoyed his meal but said it could have been spicier. The GF took home some of her leftovers so it was clearly good. And nephew ate every bit of his food. This was an excellent choice for our gathering. I was shocked when we had paid our checks and were walking out the door at 7:15 - which made me incredibly happy. I also think my hubby has a much better opinion of Cap City now. When I had suggested it - he had said NO - that it wasn't that good. But I think we just might eat at the Gahanna location again. read more

Cap City Fine Diner and Bar - Steak and black beans chili - Diners Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Stopped in for a work dinner on a Monday night. Easy parking lot which is a plus in Grandview! Cozy, diner vibes for sure - better for the winter than if you are looking for a summer patio. Service was friendly and prompt throughout! We ordered the chips and pretzel off the appetizer menu - both were fantastic and I would highly recommend! I got the shrimp pasta (made not spicy)- very good and a HUGE portion! Others in the group enjoyed the kabobs, chicken and pasta and fish and chips. Everyone had great things to say! read more