Carys pizza is the best for our family. The pizza is made like mom used to make. Great sauce and toppings. Will be back. Love it the Arnold family. read more

Great place if you like to eat out & you like a more relaxed & private space. We are hearing impaired & we were able to carry on a nice conversation the whole time we were there! Pizza was delicious!This is an old home that has separate rooms with tables & comfortable chairs in each space. It is best described as charming! read more

Love coming to Cary's for pizza, not pictured was there cheesy garlic wedges which I highly recommend. I enjoy dining in for an intimate dinner since it's not usually busy inside... maybe don't come here if you're in a rush though they have lots of take out orders. Prices are unbeatable. My go to is the Hawaiian pizza with jalapeños! read more

See all

Wow! Winner! Thanks, Yelpers, for leading us here. Hubs and I each ordered 10" pies: robust and full of toppings. meatlover + jalapeños for him, Hawaiian + grilled chicken for me. Pix tell the story. Next time, I'll probably order 6-1/2". Would be plenty of food for my usual appetite. read more

Cary's Pizza - Regular Hawaiian with grilled chicken added. - Pizza Near Me - Wickenburg, Arizona

See all

Good pizza that's not a chain restaurant. Tried several pizza styles and they're always good.

This has probably become our favorite pizza in Wickenburg. The Mega Works and the taco are our favorites. Be ready for a wait on Friday night, they seem to get pretty busy. read more

Always a delicious meal, super crust and fresh toppings. Worth the wait, truly the best pizza in Wickenburg read more

Cary's Pizza - Garlic pizza with pepperoni and artichoke - Pizza Near Me - Wickenburg, Arizona

See all

We had takeout here while vacationing in Wickenburg. The pizza crust was interesting in the sense that it was more of wafer style then new york style. This was polarizing in our family as some did not like it but I found a nice change. The place itself was very cool with multiple rooms and quirky furniture. Seems like it would be a nice place to dine in. The counter service person was very nice. read more

Excellent food and service. Cary's a chill dude and the ambiance is nice. Highly recommend the tomato garlic supreme or the chicken cacciatore. read more

I've been going here since they opened. Always amazing pizza and don't forget to try the garlic wedges. You won't regret it.

What a delightful experience! After an impromptu drive from No Phoenix, we ended up in Wickenburg. We hadn't eaten dinner and found Carys Pizza on Yelp. What a great find. We had the Tomato Gatlic Supreme pizza. Thin, crispy crust, flavorful tomatoes, and excellent sauce. Cary was at the front when we arrived, cooked our pizza and served it. Great guy! There was a young lady there who was also super friendly. The restaurant building is a converted charming house. Wonderful experience! read more

Don't be fooled by the hours on Yelp. Cary's is not open for lunch. At least not today (Friday 20th Jan) - and watch the roadworks; lots of street closures. read more

Cary's pizza was just a delight. We phoned in a take-out order on the way back from a paddle at Lake Pleasant. The food: Our "house" pizza fave is sausage, onion, artichoke, and feta. Cary's doesn't have feta but that's not unusual as things go so no problem to forego the feta.The cracker-style crust is a very nice change of pace from the breadier crusts we usually find. Quite tasty as my waistline can attest. The staff: Warm, wonderful, and friendly. The most welcome I've felt in Wickenburg in our entire time here. The place: In different (ie not pandemic) times, hanging out in the different rooms would be amazing. The place has so much charm. Being a history dork, I couldn't help but investigate the reason for the historic places registry. It's a tough research project but the building itself seems to be of architectural value. That's as much as I figured out. But still cool nonetheless for my cursory research. The uncomfortable details: Wickenburg is generally not mask-positive in the two months I spent there. So mask-wearing staff and customers at Cary's was an amazing surprise. Most other places we've stopped into to tend to our full-timer RVer needs were, shall we say, quite a challenge. Cary's was the exception to the rule in the area so if you have a chance to support a local business, this is the one. Great food combined with social responsibility. That's about as good as you can get right now. And even after we've weathered this pandemic crap, I will totally be back for great pizza and to soak up the great vibe at Cary's. read more

See all

Can't review the food because we sat for 15 minutes in a restaurant with only 3 tables of people. No one took our order. No one acknowledged us. Nothing. This was a Thursday at 530. read more

We called in for a pizza pick up. The pizza was ready when they said it would be. Very busy little place. I loved the crust nice and airy and great flavor. The toppings were fresh and the sauce was tasty. Very friendly staff. read more

Pizza taste and texture of cracker. I ordered double the pepperoni and it had less than a normal pizza ordered elsewhere.

When all is said and done, Cary's Pizza is by far the best place for pizza in Wickenburg. Fresh local ingredients, friendly staff, and perfect pizza every time. Eat in, take out,or delivery. Meat Lovers Pizza read more

I'm giving this place 2 stars, mainly because the person I spoke to on the phone was friendly. I ordered delivery and was told it would take about an hour, which I thought was fine. However, it ended up taking an hour and 45 minutes for my pizza to arrive. I ordered a gluten-free margherita pizza, but unfortunately, it was incredibly disappointing. I've been gluten-free for a while and have had some great pizzas elsewhere, but this one was inedible. As someone visiting from out of town, I was really hoping to support a local restaurant, but I couldn't even enjoy the pizza I received. read more

This place is such an gem. Upon walking up to the house, it was so charming, then walking in and seeing the main front living room area, which looks more like a pizza parlor, was told we could sit anywhere we liked, which meant we could go further into the house into different rooms. One even was a cozy little nook with books and board games. We decided to eat in the dining room, family style. It's a 1920's home and you can look from the dining room into the kitchen, which has the pizza ovens and everything else! They have so many choices for pizza. It was overwhelming in the best way. Everything we ate was absolutely delicious!! We cannot wait to come back! read more

Our first time visiting Cary's and we were not disappointed! Parking is a bit rough, but the restaurant is nicely decorated with several separate rooms in different decors - cozy and private, should you choose. Cary greeted us and we sat in the main area. The menu has a good selection, and we found everything we were looking for. The pizza was amazing! The crust and texture are very European - I don't know how he does it! read more

Freshness is there first name and DELICIOUSNESS is there second. Best pizza we've had in a long time!! GB and priced right

VISITORS BEWARE!!! Wow!! If the pizza was freakin great and the best of all time I still wouldn't give it more than then the one star I gave. We waited an hour for a pizza, and people (who apparently are familiar with the one and only person working) get their order 1/2 hour after they arrive. I should have followed my instinct and left when we waited 10 minutes for anyone who worked here to come out. Kinda felt sorry for the elderly gentleman working by himself. Not sorry enough to come back. VISITORS BEWARE! If your not a local you won't be served on a first come first served basis. read more

Great pizza! Cary is awesome.a great asset in Wickenburg.. great job to all thanks for everything.

Place is still as tasty as I remember it from years ago. I used to come during lunch and always enjoyed a personal pizza and this time was no different. I always enjoy the chicken pesto pizza and the Margherita. Both are delicious! Unique place to dine in and it's always quiet and relaxing. Service did take a little long but they were short handed, was in no rush so it worked out for us. Can't wait to be back next time in in Wickenburg. read more

Don't be fooled when you drive up. It's a little old house with a neon pizza sign out front. It looks like the kind of place that you would drive on by but don't. Only 3 tables inside but Cary serves arguably the best pizza in Wickenberg. I think he does most of his business as carry out. We were driving through town and looking for pizza. Cary's had good reviews. Now I can add another. read more

This is a one man show. Don't be in a hurry. The pizza was pretty good but we both had bad indigestion all night afterwards. We might return for a second try. read more

We were able to walk into Cary's this week, grab a booth and enjoy the smells/atmosphere as we waited for our pizza to come out. The beers were cold and reasonably priced, pizza - wonderful. Loved it all! read more

Drove here to go try this but was not open on a Sunday at 445 ‍ Please update hours of operation read more

I've been searching for a thin crust pizza for 23 years when I moved here to Central Arizona and I have finally found it here at Cary's Pizza!! My new place for thin crust pizza!! read more

Have to say this is probably the best pizza I've had and I've had a lot of pizza. It's thin crust which I love and the cheese was plentiful. I know leaving five stars for a one time visit is risky but I'm doing it anyways. They were very nice and accommodating and hopefully I will be back someday soon since I don't live close by read more

We have ordered take out twice so far. Being new to the area I was anxious to find a place for pizza and wings and omg this place is awesome! Prices are super reasonable and so far everything exceeded our expectations! read more

Great pizza and super friendly staff, we came in late and our waitress Pauly was AWESOME. She was helpful and enthusiastic, really took care of us! The pizza was so good, the crust was fantastic. Highly recommend. read more

We stopped by yesterday. We ordered a 13" Hawaiian and Mozzarella sticks. The pizza crust was thin, crunchy and tasteless. The marinara tasted liked a canned red sauce with no seasoning. The cheese sticks were nice and hot, but the beading had no seasoning either. The young man who served us was not excited about being at work and slow. read more

Great place to go when driving to Las Vegas or Grand Canyon. Has great sizes plus great prices. All homemade. The place is also super cute since it is certified as a historic place. read more

Ordered a pizza to go. It was delicious and the guy behind the counter was super nice. Will definitely be getting all our pizzas from here!

Cary's has been Our go-to Friday night delivery for years!! Everything is fresh, flavorful and delicious! I especially love that Cary has Gluten Free pizza that tastes amazing and doesn't leave me feeling left out of the pizza party. read more

Carys seems to always deliver anytime we've ordered from them. Delicious pizza I love that they put green olives on their pizza.

Truly the best pizza in town. Gary's has served pizza to hungry Wickenburgers for years. The sauce is made with herbs and spices grown in the local area. It just does not get any better. Dine in, pick-up, or delivery--take your pick for a great pizza. read more

We were out of town for Christmas vacation and decided to give it a try. I'd say we came in right at dinner rush at 6:30 ish. The pizza and calzone were fantastic I'd say 5 of 5 on the food for sure. The service was 4 of 5 only due to how busy it was at the time we arrived. The place is very unique, it's a commercial home conversion to a pizza shop with big screen tv's and tables/dining areas. Very different from the usual pizza place. Great good, very fresh ingredients and family owned. read more

I just had one of the most infuriating, inexplicable experiences at this place. My third time in because the pizza was good, I brought my family this time on our way back home from Alamo Lake. Got in between 5:15 and 5:30. 1 or 2 other people in the entire place. We order two kid sized pizzas and two 10-inchers, and two side salads. An hour later, still without our food (and only one other customer left in the place), I approach the wait staff about our wait time. She has no explanation and says she'll send the owner out. 10-15 minutes later the pizzas arrive, with the owner. He asks if we need anything else and I tell him an explanation for the wait would be nice. He tells me, "it's the nature of the business." I say, "...to wait an hour for a pizza?" He gives me a curt "yep" and that's the end of the conversation. No additional explanation. No remorse. Not even recognition that something is amiss. We're charged full price. We're out the door at 7:15. Does this seem to any of you to be an appropriate response to a dissatisfied customer? Having worked in the industry, I know mistakes happen. Orders get misplaced, things get burned, orders are sometimes just plain forgotten. It's understandable. But let the customer know. And if that's not the case; if there were no errors and the delay was simply a result of call-in orders, let your dine-in customers know there's an extended wait. Especially if they have a 3 year old and 5 year old in tow that need to be maintained and entertained while they wait for their food. "Nature of the business" is not acceptable. And not honest. If you can't be honest with your customers, you won't keep them very long. read more