So nice we dined her twice. We love good Mexican food and Casa Mezcal does not disappoint. The huge margaritas and delicious shrimp ceviche were a refreshing start to a hot summer dinner. Don't miss the veggie burrito with salsa verde and fantastic Camerones Veracruz. Chips and Salsa are tasty and fresh. Service is top tier! They also found and return my man's lost cell phone. Gracias! read more

Solid Tex/Mex style. The flavors and execution are there. It's just less chili punch to things. Service is excellent and prices very reasonable. If in the Finger Lakes area I would check this out. read more

Loved the street tacos and burritos! A bit of a wait but well worth it. Affordable meals with quality ingredients! Fun atmosphere with a lively bar. GF options and friendly service. read more

See all

Loved the mexican joint in a former Pizza Hut! The sharable fajitas were delicious and plentiful. Waiter was nice and was quick with our drinks and food order. Chips were good but the salsa was mid. They did a solid job transforming the joint into a friendly, open atmosphere. read more

Excellent food, great service, fun atmosphere. Definitely one of our favorite restaurants in the area.

This review is for the take out. I ordered from here the pancho loco burrito and the tacos supreme. Sadly I have to say Taco Bell tastes better. The tacos came in a hard shell and barely had any toppings. It was literally some dried shredded chicken with some diced tomatoes and lettuce. The burrito also lacked flavor and I had to dunk it in the salsa they provided for the chips. Not to mention afterwards, worst stomachache of my life. I also asked for hot sauce and utensils and none were provided. read more

Casa Mezcal Reserva - Pancho loco burrito, tacos supreme - Mexican Near Me - Penn Yan, New York

My wife, two teenage sons, and I enjoyed our dinner here on a Sunday at 4:30pm in early July 2025. Lots of pluses. We were seated promptly as the dinner rush had not yet arrived (it gets crowded by 5:30pm). First, this is a great option if you like Mexican food. Second, it has a cheerful interior space that is inviting and family-friendly. Third, my wife enjoyed the organic margarita (16 oz. version) with lime, which was refreshing on a hot summer day. My sons each devoured their tacos carnitas plates. My wife and I shared the fajita parillada for two (including chicken, steak, shrimp, and chorizo). The latter dish was a ridiculously large amount of food (we requested carry-out boxes to bring leftovers home to enjoy the next day). Overall, this is a solid option for dinner in Penn Yan (especially on a Sunday evening). read more

See all

First time customer. Got the carnita steak tacos that came with refried beans, tasty chips with salsa & rice. Was impressed with the food & the amount you get. While the cost was a bit more than I was hoping, everything is more pricey these days. I definitely will be back when I'm in town. My only suggestion would be a bit more flavorful sauce for the tacos. The sauces were good and spicy, though I'd personally prefer one with a bit more flavor (maybe a siracha or chipotle type of sauce?). read more

We visited on Saturday 6/13 and had the Fajitas Texacanas and Carnitas and they both were great. Drinks and Beers were cold. Good service sitting at the bar. We'd recommend this as a stop going thru Pan Yan if you like Mexican food. read more

Another Saturday night in Early January at Keuka Lake. Not really wanting to cook, we decided to go out and try this relatively New Mexican restaurant in Penn Yan. I have eaten several times in their Bath location but only for lunch. Always good and I had heard good things about this new location. So off we went to give it a try. Glad we did. Very good service. This is a converted Pizza Hut building, and they have done a good job of not making it look like a Pizza Hut. My wife and I both ordered the enchiladas. She had the chicken and I had the beef. Both were very tasty and it filled us up. While we were there more and more people were coming in to eat. Always a good sign. We enjoyed our meal even with a screaming kid in the background. read more

Food and service were great! Very busy place, definitely not a quiet restaurant on a Saturday!

Cafe Mezcal lived up to its excellent reviews! We went last night, a Sunday, and the place was hopping. Grabbed two seats at the bar, admiring the artfully plated food we passed along the way. Complementary chips and salsa came quickly, along with ice water. We started with the ceviche appetizer. Fresh, balanced, and a good amount for two. We shared a margarita flight.... refreshing and delicious, a great complement to the heatwave outside. Entrees were the Cameron Yucatán, which was loaded with succulent shrimp and fresh sautéed vegetables, along with rice, warm tortillas, guac, and finely chopped tomatoes. Freshness was consistent across all items, and all staff weee upbeat, knowledgeable and friendly. Planning our next visit! read more

See all

Food are delicious and friendly staff and the energy is good and environment is good excellent service

Fast, friendly, and clean. Don't be put off by the obvious Pizza Hut building turned into a Mexican restaurant, it is worth stopping at if you like Mexican food. Food was great and as my wife and I frequent the area often, we'll be back. read more

Casa Mezcal Reserva - Wife's Taco Salad - Mexican Near Me - Penn Yan, New York

See all

Great service and quite tasty. Open when a lot of other restaurants are closed. Do serve local wine. read more

Casa Mezcal Reserva - Quesadilla - Mexican Near Me - Penn Yan, New York

What a wonderful Mexican restaurant! The food and service were perfect. We stopped while driving through Penn Yan. We ordered chicken street tacos and a veggie burrito. The burrito was made with fresh mushrooms, zucchini, bell peppers and rice with a light sauce made with green chiles. The server, Dayna was exceptionally helpful with choosing the items we did and providing 10 star service!! Overall, the best lunch! Would highly recommend stopping if you are in town. read more

Casa Mezcal Reserva - Veggie Burrito - Mexican Near Me - Penn Yan, New York

See all

Solid Mexican food! We had pretty quick service and the food was tasty. Definitely price conscious- we got a burrito for around d $12 and a dinner combo with 3 tacos for around $11. The margarita was average in my opinion, but there were lots of drink options. Many people for a Sunday night... plan ahead on a busy day/night! read more

See all

Don't let the exterior fool you, this place is awesome. The service and food are top notch. I got a margarita flight - coconut, pineapple, and watermelon and they were all delicious and exactly what I needed on a Friday night. Don't sleep on this place! read more

Casa Mezcal Reserva - Mexican Near Me - Penn Yan, New York

We went here tonight for the first time and were very pleased with the service, the atmosphere, and the food. We each enjoyed the meal and were pleased with the prices. I got the chimichangas and my wife got the tamales and the taco and we also got the fries appetizer which was very good also. We will definitely return. read more

Tried this Mexican cantina for lunch with a group of friends. The food was fresh and well made. They were responsive to dietary restrictions of some of our party and no one left the restaurant hungry. read more

Great food and drinks - reasonable prices. The portions are a bit small but again the prices are fantastic.

Outstanding place. We were going to go somewhere else decided on coming here. The service was amazing. The food was outstanding. We will definitely be coming back read more

See all

Amazing Mexican restaurant around Penn Yan! We went there on Saturday night for dinner and we manage to get a table right away. Service and atmosphere were great. They provided chips and salsa to start with before we ordered drinks. For drinks, we ordered the Santa Victoria and La Catrina mezcals. For food, we ended order fajitas, one steak and one fajita Texana (mixed of steak, chicken, and shrimp). For dessert, we ordered churros. Food and drinks were flavorful. Overall, would definitely go back when I'm around the Finger Lakes. read more

See all

Best Mexican style food in the region. Hands down the best. It wasn't sloppy and thrown around. The food was well prepared, creative and you could tell it was fresh. We will be back! read more

Food was great! We ordered takeout and the food stayed nice and fresh. Highly recommend.

We are regulars at Casa Mezcal and find the food and service to be excellent. Fajitas are delicious along with burritos. Always have found service to be top notch and the quality as well as quantity of food to be outstanding, read more

Great, friendly service & good food! I've visited four different times and found the quality & service to be excellent.

Great food, friendly staff and an exceptional value with a relaxed atmosphere. We definitely will return.

Great atmosphere, really great choices in the menu. We weren't expecting much but were pleasantly surprised! The bartender was out straight on a Wednesday night! We would go again when in the area! read more

Excellent. Fast service, huge portions, authentic. Would highly recommend, can accommodate larger parties. Margaritas a little weak, but after drinking all day at the wineries that's probably a good thing!!! Prices great too!! read more

What a great option for Mexican food. We visit Seneca Lake every summer for a few nights and were pleasantly surprised with Casa Mezcal. Our server was super nice, food was great. Festive atmosphere. Hope CM is around in 2025! read more

Thoroughly enjoyed the food and the service at this restaurant. Friendly and upbeat atmosphere! read more

No wonder it was so crowded,fast service . Not your average Mexican, would definitely go back!

Their vegetarian selections are amazing! I had the veggie quesedilla. My partner had the chili relleno which was even more delicious than mine. Also the blackberry mojito was great. Highly recommend! read more

We loved our lunch here. Most of the menu revolves around meat dishes, but we ordered the spinach potato enchiladas and were so pleased. Super delicious. The beans were also yummy, as were the complementary chips and salsa. We will visit again! read more

Casa Mezcal Reserva - Cute decor. - Mexican Near Me - Penn Yan, New York

We placed an to go order later Saturday night for a steak Quesadilla and churros and a mango margarita. They food was good. Later that night about an hour after we ate my wife got very ill and was sick all night and the next day. I would not eat here ever again after this incident. read more

Chips and salsa were great. Queso very tasty. Enchiladas Rancheros and Taco Salad were good. Recommend...

Very good food and drinks, excellent service. The Tacos El Pastor were delicious and the enchiladas were very good. Chile Rellenos were on the spicy side and delicious. The ambiance was cute and the meal was very affordable. read more

Love everything about this place. Have eaten here several times and never been disappointed. Good menu selection and service, best value in Penn Yan. read more

Great food & good portions. Customer service was quick & friendly. I check for dust in the ceiling corners & saw none! I could not give a 5 because of the noise. Low ceilings & close quarters make it difficult to have a conversation. Will go again! read more