The pizza here is so so good! Got a whole pie, and amazing fresh cesaer salad, and magnolia bakery…read morebanana cream pie. The service was fast the quality is excellent big communal inside tables or a few tables outside.

Wally's FINI Pizza Review: The One Time I Got Left Behind…read more Let me set the scene: normally, I go everywhere with my parents. Breweries? I'm there. Brunch? Obviously. But this time? Dad went off with his friends, and I got stuck at home with Mom, who was busy doing "important things" (whatever that means). I had a feeling something delicious was happening without me--and I was right. Dad came home with FINI Pizza from Amagansett--the one hyped up by the Barstool Sports guy. Naturally, I perked up. This was my moment. But here's the truth straight from the source (aka me, the dog who smelled it all but tasted none): They got two pies. * The regular pie (half cheese, half pepperoni) had great flavor, but the edges were well done. Like, bordering on burnt. The center slices were so floppy you basically needed two hands and a strategy just to get a bite. * The grandma's pie? Now that smelled like something special--thick, focaccia-style crust with a bread-forward vibe that Mom said was satisfying, but maybe a little too doughy for her ideal slice-to-bread ratio. Now here's the real heartbreak: I usually get a piece of crust. It's kind of our thing. But not this time. Too burnt, they said. Unbelievable. And the kicker? $40 for a pie. Yep, one pizza. Even for the Hamptons, that's enough to make a golden doodle tilt his head. Was it good? Yeah. Was it life-changing? Not quite. But between the charred crust, the greasy floppiness, and the lack of crust-sharing... I'm giving this one a soft paw up. Final bark: tasty, trendy, but next time--take me with you.

HomeSlicePizza has to be the best pizza in the Hamptons…read more These boys Terry Liam and Matthew know what they are doing. Take it from an Itaian born in Rome. The pizzas are made fresh to order then sealed then frozen. You can order right from the website and have them delivered to your door. You can stock up on them then when ready to eat simply defrost them and bake them at 375 degrees pre warmed oven for a few minutes. Watch them while cooking or you might burn them. Simply delectable. Thank you boys Maximilian Southampton, NY https://homeslicepizza.co

Absolutely the best pizza. Keep a few in the freezer for that night you just want a pizza. This…read morestuff is very very good!

Yesterday, I was in the area and I was starving. I ordered a chicken parm hero. It was $16.86. I…read morefelt that was tad too expensive. Five minutes later, my order was ready. It was so delicious. The only problem is that the hero was so ginormous that I was barely able to finish it- and I had heartburn afterwards (not the fault of the pizzeria). I hate wasting food. I highly recommend this pizzeria. And unless you're Joey Chestnut, I suggest sharing the hero with another person.

Short review: if you want pizza or chicken tenders/wings its a good option. Food quality above…read moreaverage. Attentive service. Feels like you are in nyc rather than east hampton. Only con is it's expensive for what is but that's to be expected given the location.

Great restaurant, locally popular serving up some good pizza and a fun loving bartender‍read more

It's old school Italian but just ok. The garlic bread could've been toasted more as the cheese was…read morejust barely melted and clumped together. Everything was extremely greasy.

Lucky the weather held up....dined under the trees & moonlight with romantic candle light…read more Ordered the whole roasted fluke- was absolutely wonderful. Cooked & seasoned perfectly. Richard was kind enough to come over and help me remove the bones- such a great guy. Pasta was homemade & delicious.

Having been to Nick & Toni's three times in the past, I believe that the service quality and…read moreatmosphere has declined since my prior visits. Our party was given what I considered to be an inappropriate table given our party size. A four top behind my father had been split into two tables, leaving my father with minimal room to adjust his seat without bumping into the closest table - the dinner was quite uncomfortable for him. We expressed multiple times that the lighting at our table had issues as the bulb kept flickering and staff struggled to adjust the lights repeatedly - the dining room was between bright and dim most of night. Our server was friendly, but did not offer the service we have come to expect from Nick & Toni's - we had to keep asking for water, the table was left dirty at times, etc. We were visiting to celebrate my mother's 70th birthday. She loved Nick & Toni's when she and I visited in the past and this was communicated when the reservation was made. I called to make a reservation as soon as the books opened, at 2PM one month prior, and do not understand why the table our party was sat at was so subpar whilst we passed various other empty tables at the same time as our reservation. In terms of the food quality, we felt that the entrees were hit or miss. The rosemary focaccia was wonderful, as was the Ribeye. The eggplant entree was overcooked/burnt and lacked flavor - this dish might need revision.

Was looking for a quick meal and ny style pizza. Service is fast and friendly with great prices…read more Easy to park in their own lot few tables inside few tables outside there is not service you order at the counter. My pizza was great and my pennz broccoli was even better than I expected.

We stopped here to grab some pizza late day - what an excellent choice for a gluten-free,…read morecauliflower-crust personal pizza! The service was friendly and prompt and the pizza crust had the exact right amount of crunch, yet was nice and thin. I recommend the margarita (I added onions). The basil and garlic it was prepared with took this to a next level of gourmet pizza. Yum!! Very casual atmosphere, great for kids. Outdoor seating in front. We will definitely be back! I foresee summer plans out east including this stop!

My husband and I stopped into this deli while we were in the area recently and really enjoyed our…read moreexperience. There is no sit down inside the restaurant, but we got our food sat at the picnic tables outside, which was very nice. Our food was very very tasty my husband had a meatball sub that he said was outstanding and he eats meatball subs often so I trust his opinion. I had a salad which was so big and that I had enough for the next day and then some and it was also very tasty. The service was friendly and preparation was relatively quick and it was overall very very good experience. Highly recommend when you're in the area.

I was really craving a caprese sandwich after a beach day. I got the F1, hot, and an H1 it took…read moreabout 15 minutes to get. My bf loved his- the said solid 4. I enjoyed mine but the focaccia bread wasn't like a thick puffy light foccacia, it was thin and not very olive oily. There wasn't enough basil or tomatoes to the cheese ratio and the cheese wasn't super melty, that being said bread and cheese is never a bad combo- solid 3 for me, next time will add pesto and I think it'll be a winner Staff was okay, not very friendly. Outdoor tables very dirty. Overall solid sandwich, I would call ahead take to go to the beach.

On vacation here in East Hampton and wanted pizza. Called in a pick up order to Springs. Friendly…read moreand easy conversation! Pick up was same. Pizza was delish.

This is a really great pizza place in the Springs. We've never dined in, but we order out all the…read moretime and their pizza is very consistent. Try the buffalo chicken pizza! It has just the right amount of buffalo sauce without being too overwhelming. Their mozzarella sticks are also great. Their service is good and they do have a small number of tables if you want to dine in.

I had dinner with two friends on a summer Tuesday night. The restaurant is large and sprawling…read morewith a modern vibe and, was full with large parties with families and children running all around. Good for them - not what I am looking for!!! We asked to change our table as we were given a tight corner table not comfortable for three men. They graciously accommodated us but, the transition was not smooth. At the second location, in a front room, a lady came and we started to order - appetizers and entrees. She said she was actually the manager and was jumping in as a waiter because they were short staffed. She took our order and asked if we would like every thing to come out at once - we said no - appetizers first then entrees. What an odd question. Do they usually serve everything at once? I am not looking for a strict conventional order of serving but, something is off here. We never saw her again and, never really knew who our waiter was. We were served by a variety of bus people, runners and finally the General Manager. We did not complain. One of the gentlemen is our party is a professional chef. He ordered a coke at one point from the GM which didn't come for 15 minutes - so, we sent it back. The food was just OK - pizza nothing special - service disorganized and, for those reasons we will not be back. To his credit, noticing that we were not happy - he took our drinks off the check. Generally speaking, this restaurant suffers from mediocre food at EH prices, and the staff doesn't seem to work together is a smooth way. Respectfully submitted feedback - with hopes for improvement

Beautiful ambiance. Terrible service. We started the night In great spirits and had to wait for our…read moretable. Totally understandable but upon reaching the picnic table there were not enough seats. After asking for another seat, they acted affronted that we would even ask. After we ordered for the table, they brought one salad with chicken. Then another 30 minutes later they finally brought the wine. 45 minutes later the entrees arrived so no one ate at the same time. Finally, they brought us the wrong check and charged us incorrectly. Again, when bringing this to the staff we were met with attitude and distain. Safe to say I will not be coming back...

great delivery food! taste homemade…read more.. the delivery driver forgot my salad and as a courtesy they sent me an extra salad and a whole apple pie! love pepperoni's!!!!

I called Saturday 8/1 to place an order, the total seemed very high, so I placed the same order on…read moreUber Eats and the total was $21 less. I called and asked why, they could not give me any good explanation, I spoke with 2 people and asked to speak to a manager, and was told they were too busy. I was then told that the $21 was for an automatic tip! I asked to cancel my order, they told me they couldn't, then it would take 48 hours, when all they had to do was void the sale that had been place 8 minutes earlier, but apparently no one knew how to do that. I was charged anyway. They are poorly run, poorly trained and very dishonest.