Not the best pizza but decent enough. We ordered half plain, half veggie. It cost as much as a full veggie; we thought it would've been less. The plain is very cheesy; I love cheese so it didn't bother me. I was not a fan of the veggie. It was loaded with vegetables, which I appreciate, but they definitely used frozen vegetables. I have no issue with frozen veggies if cooked well and seasoned. They fell flat on the pizza. My mom and I loved the pizza crust! They put sesame seeds on it and it gives it a really nice flavor. It felt like I was having a toasted bagel. read more

Pepperoni's - Vegetable Pie (half) - Pizza Near Me - East Hampton, New York

See all

Decent. We ordered a bunch of pies - meat lovers, pepperoni, and a grandma. The grandma was far and away the best. Pizza dough wasn't great, sauce was excellent. For a place called Pepperoni's they sure ration their pepperoni. I wish I had a picture, but there were genuinely 15 small pieces of pepperoni for the entire pie. Meat lover's pie however was packed with toppings. There was a woman behind the counter screaming at her employees when we arrived for pick up. Not sure who she was but it was uncomfortable to witness. Not sure I'd be back. read more

The most HORRIBLE pizza I have ever eaten. Don't walk away. Run ‍. They use canned spinach instead of fresh spinach. Pizza isn't fresh and has barely any flavor. Sauce looks like it came from a can. AWFUL read more

Pepperoni's - GF pizza with spinach, sauce, onions and artichokes. - Pizza Near Me - East Hampton, New York

Worst pizza in the Hamptons. Wouldn't recommend. Customer service needs some work on. Ordered a buffalo chicken. Tell me why each slice only has a few pieces a chicken. read more

I saw other reviews and I had to let people know that this is a fantastic establishment with some of the greatest and best priced pizza in the area. I've gone there many times I've never had a problem. I love the fact that it's connected to riders wings and things that you can stop in and have a beer while you wait for your pizza. This is delicious eating establishment and I hate to see other negative reviews about it. read more

Love this pizza! Always exactly how I order it! Thin crust and well done. I usually keep my oven on with a pizza tray just to heat the pie up. We like ours very hot! read more

Very good veggie pizza and service is speedy. Competition with Springs pizza for sure. More businesses in shopping plaza plus mailbox.

Very good pizza and always hot and fresh... I pick up. I can't imagine what the negative reviewers were expecting.... It is East Hampton, in summer traffic is nuts and yes expect 1 hr delay or you are dumb. Off season, I think most natives would agree it's tops! read more

Hadn't ordered from Pepperoni's in a while and was a little surprised/concerned to see the low reviews, but we needn't have worried. Their Grandma pie is as delicious as ever--perfect crust/sauce/cheese ratio, a good amount of fresh basil, and very flavorful. read more

Pepperoni's - a slice of pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - East Hampton, New York

I ordered pizzas/salad for delivery. I was told it would arrive within 45minutes. 1 hour, 15 minutes later, I called as my order had not arrived. I was then told that the delivery person was en route. I live 5 minutes away from the restaurant, yet 30 minutes later, it had still not arrived. I called again and after 15 minutes on the phone, was told that the order was not never processed and I would need to wait another 45 minutes if I did not want to cancel the order. I cancelled the order. 3 days later, I realized that despite not receiving the order, my credit card was charged for the full amount. Not only is this business not reliable, they are unprofessional, tell you lies and lack any business ethics. I received no dinner, no service and was charged $79 for it. read more

This place is great easy and fast specially for delivery the prices aren't that bad and the pizza is very decent in size. the toppings are great I would recommend this pizza spot over others in the area. We got the large build at your own pizza with pepperoni and mushrooms and they were very generous with the toppings read more

The most horrible pasta I ever eat, not even tomato sauce no flavor at all and seafood taste horrible.

this place sucks so bad. istg its terrible. the customer service is horrendous. some old lady answered fhe phone being all rude and sh!t. they also have a cockroach problem which is kinda gross. super over priced, garlic knots are kinda good though. when I walk in my shoes stick to the floor. read more

Fantastic white pizza. It was so delicious! The crust was good too. Thin and crunchy. The cheese pizza is good and so were the fried ravioli. But that white pizza with ricotta would keep me coming back !! And they deliver ! read more

Took two mf hours to deliver 1/2 extra cheese and 1/2 hawaiian. I'm super disappointed. They're lucky their Hawaiian KICKS ASS or else I wouldn't got there again. Just pickup tho cause if you're hungry order 2 hours ahead read more

Pepperoni's - a bowl of pasta and seafood - Pizza Near Me - East Hampton, New York

Love this pizza. As the other reviewer said, this isn't typical NYC pizza, but they're not trying to be. First: get the sesame seed topping for the crust. It's unbelievable how such a simple thing makes such a big difference. Second: get the tomato/basil/fresh mozzarella pizza. They marinate the tomatoes, they give you great big portions of basil, and it ends up being the most delicious thing. Everyone who has ever had it loves it, and I now bring pizzas to-go across state lines for friends. Their buffalo chicken pizza is delicious, as are most of their specialty pizzas, and I usually only try them by the slice (not the ideal way to try any pizza). I occasionally get a black olive/garlic/onion pizza that I request myself, and they put lots of black olives and onions on top, and cook the garlic in so that it goes extremely well together. Their Eppi rolls are delicious, even if the sausage/pepperoni one may kill you. Their salads aren't the most fantastic things in the world, but they're decent enough if you don't want to eat only pizza. For my money, this is the best pizza place in the area. I like the staff, love the food, and I won't go anywhere else. read more

See all

Ordered a calzone w pepperoni- everything was fine, tasty, and fresh. There were a few pieces of pepperoni, and a ton of ricotta. Although everything was freshly made, it was all a bit lukewarm. I'd be happy to come back- and will ask for things to be heated to 'hot'. read more

Pepperoni's - mini calzone - Pizza Near Me - East Hampton, New York

The name had me skeptical, but overall the experience was good. The pickup was kind of a mess and it was very chaotic inside. The pizza was yummy... we got mushroom, salad pizza, and a cheese pie. For appetizers, mozzarella sticks and fried ravioli. We were super hungry, so we definitely enjoyed the food. Customer service and process of pickup could have been better. read more

I hate to have to do this to you guys but it's simply out of control. I've been patient for a very long time as has my entire family but the amount of orders you guys manage to screw up is atrocious. It's gotten to the point where we're not sure if you're messing with us or you just don't care that much and decide to make whatever the hell your "chefs" decide. Either way, out of the +6 times and counting this has happened, and having had it brought to the staffs attention, the most that's ever done is a "sorry" or a greens salad. I'm done. Pick it up. read more

Not much more to say than their crust, is what I consider to be perfect. Thin, perfect chew texture, delicious. The cheese, fragrant, bubbling, and fresh tasting. Been in Springs a very long time, never ordered before, very pleasantly surprised. Very friendly service as well. read more

I have order delivery several times from pepperoni Grill yet 2 out of the 3 we were unable to eat our dinner on 1/29/2021 we order Grilled chicken penne a la vodka, on 1/30/21 we order a granma pizza both days the food was to salty. read more

I like this pizza. I really do. It has a good sauce/cheese ratio, and everyone in my house enjoys it. We live here all year, and this is our go to. Within the last month or two, the size of the pizzas have decreased exponentially. Not the slices you see when you pick up, but the whole pizzas you order to go. The first time, I thought it was just a smaller pizza, maybe not stretched enough.. made by mistake. Nope. The last FOUR times we have gotten small pizzas. Last night I paid, got home, opened the box, and found a pizza that wasn't even close to touching the edges of the box. I paid $22 last night for a pizza that was half cheese, half pepperoni, and 15" across. Unfortunately, they just lost our weekly business. Not cool guys, and not how you treat your yearly customers. read more

Surprisingly, I had a really good slice here! It seems like a random shop tucked away in an even more random, unassuming little shopping center (of sorts). They have a great variety of freshly made pizzas with all kinds of flavor combinations plus calzones, pastas, salads, and even desserts. I was pleasantly surprised and at the same time, a little pissed off at myself for not ordering more food, given all the choices. It's a casual, no-frills kind of place where you can sit down to have a bite, or get in and out quickly so you can devour your piping hot food in the privacy of your own home (or car, ahem). I like their thin, chewy crust and the sauce, cheese and pepperonis were really tasty. No complaints here. Bonus points for selling pizzas by the slice in addition to whole pies. Gotta love surprisingly tasty places when you least expect it! read more

Pretty bad pizza. Meat lovers slice was thick crusted and doughy, minimal cheese and the meats were dry and flavorless. Crust tasted frozen. 3 booths read more

To put it short this place has good food but bad customer service and is overpriced I called to place a order for pick up (this was during the winter, so not too busy) anyway I called I told the girl my order and I asked which pasta have sea food and she says "we have a lot and I don't have time to tell you I'm really busy" I was like ok it's fine, I placed my order went to go pick it up and the place was totally empty. Okay, in all fairness I could have been busy when I called but that definitely not how you treat customers and their menu online is not specific at all. Lastly, I was going to pay and the total was 55.99 and I gave 56 and any honest person would give the 1 cent that I was entitled to but no she kept it and that was honestly the last straw if their bad customer service. It's overpriced and not worth it if you are not being treated fairly. Really disappointed with this place. read more

I ordered a Sicilian pie from pepperoni's a few weeks ago and it was one of the best pies I've ever had. I figured it had to be a mistake. Pizza in the Hamptons, in my experience, is generally awful. So I had to come back to pepperoni's not once but twice to make sure they are legit. In both of my follow up visits the pizza held up! I tried their regular as well during one of these trips and it was solid, but the Sicilian is EPIC. It reheats well and you can feed a house full of hungry folks with one pie. I think the secret is the generous layer of sauce and just the right amount of cheese. I can't speak for the pizza by the slice, but as a Za expert I always advise to test out a new Za spot by ordering a full pie. Check it out. read more

Pepperoni's - Sicilian pie - Pizza Near Me - East Hampton, New York

I can confirm that this is no NYC pizza, but it is my favorite regular pizza in the hamptons and I have probably tried them all. The crust definitely is not frozen like Greg B. accused them of... but I would stick to the regular pizza as most of there specialty slices don't look like there all that. And how many booths does he need, 4? The five stars is for their shrimp parm hero---definitely as good as it gets. Ive had it many times and very consistent and delicious... garlicky and good sauce, piping hot. The shrimp are butterflied and sauteed not fried like most heros. They also have pretty nice specials using local and seasonal ingredients. I love the grumpy owner hes the man! Open pretty late. read more

I lived in Queens for a couple years and have eaten pizza all over NY. I'm a pizza freak. You know what a perfect desert is after a pizza dinner? Another slice. There are 3 types of pizza. The brick oven pie, the gourmet pie, and the slice pie (takeout, comes in a cardboard box, rules the Earth with it's mozzarella scepter.) Pepperoni's pie is authoritatively the best "slice pie" in the area. Sweet tomato sauce. Quality ingredients. Hot bubbly fatso heaven. (Sam's is more of a brick oven/bar pie.) Discovered something great tonight. We usually get a pie with onion and mushroom and the Gorgonzola salad which has a variety of greens, zucchini, and a delicious sweet red wine vinaigrette. By accident part of the salad got onto my slice. It was soooo good. I never thought Gorgonzola could work on a slice, but it works!! Fantastic combination. Mangia! read more

Best cheese pie . Very nice people that Deliver. I highly recommend them. I've been using them for years.

If you use a credit or debit card you will get charged extra - Very surprised to get $4 added to the bill...food is just ok read more

Pepperoni's - If you use a credit or debit card you will get charged extra - Very surprised to get $4 added to the bill...food is just ok - Pizza Near Me - East Hampton, New York

Just ordered takeout. Total was $117 over the phone. Went to pick us and was quoted $160. "Recalculate the total". Oh, it's back to $117. Watch out! Food was just ok. read more

Pepperoni's is open for pick up and their food is amazing. And so is their attitude - professional, friendly, fast, and safe. The pizza last night was the best - thin crust, perfect sauce, plenty of fresh mushrooms. Thank you more now than ever. read more

Placed an order over the phone, they called an hour later to tell me my order didn't reach minimum. No problem. I added more food to my order. Now an hour and half later I've called twice, hung up on once and the other no answer. No food. Over an hour and a half now and nothing. read more

By far the best pizza restaurant in East Hampton. I have ordered from these guys both physically at the restaurant and through ChowNow and every time it's fantastic. Friendly service, great food and great prices, if I could give them more than 5 stars I would! read more

I only eat here when I have to; when I am too lazy to drive more than 7 minutes from my house. Despite getting a basic slice of pizza I avoid this place. Staff is rude, the layout is awkward, and better tasting foods can be found i.e everywhere else... read more

Don't go there during the summer time. Their pizza pie is over cooked. They shouldn't cooked the pizza in 30 mins. I was watching them. I hope they get their shit together. read more

It is 2:30 on a Friday afternoon and they do not have any pizza ‍ my sister had been telling me for years she loves this place, no idea why. They told me I would have to wait 15 minutes for 1 slice of pizza, and longer if I want pepperoni (which I did) too bad, cause I work in the area year-round and could possibly have been a 'regular' .Good luck running a pizzeria with no pizza read more

Delicious Pie!! Nice people. Will definitely order from them again.Great crust , great sauce and delicious toppings! Fresh garlic slices !! Loved the pie! read more

If you like a greasy mess you will love the food at Pepperoni's! Ordered from the app for delivery and they brought one slice instead of a pie and forgot one of the dinners! Greasy food!! read more

The pizza is great! The seating area in this restaurant is not great. A small space to sit and usually not clean. But if you take the pizza to go it's consistently good. A little pricey for pizza. read more