Scallops were DELICIOUS, popovers were amazing, and carrot cake was yummy. My significant other did the early bird $25 special which was such a great deal. The only negative thing was that his steak was overdone and when asked if this is how they usually cook medium rare, the server replied yes. It was over done and should have been sent back but she was very busy with big table parties. We will be back but hope for a better steak next time and a server that's a little more attentive read more

CHOP - Steak - Steakhouses Near Me - Sister Bay, Wisconsin

See all

Good food, nice decor, solid choice for dinner in Door County. Would be a bit better if they improved and expanded the wine list.

Walleye had a lot of bones in it, ambience was nice, great bread and drinks. Service was poor, just got married and no complimentary champagne or dessert. Hostess new it was our honeymoon and we received no recognition. We also did not get any refills on our waters. May not return! read more

Famtastic service and amazing food! Great happy hour specials. The staff was wonderful!! We will be back on our next trip to Door County. read more

Wonderful atmosphere and service. On a busy weekend, our reservations were right on time. The server was very attentive to details and providing the best service. The plating of the food along with the cocktails are exactly what you would expect for a steakhouse. The food was wonderful and we will be back again. read more

Last night, a large group of us went to Chop. We had a fabulous dinner, and the service was excellent. Dorine, the waiter, was attentive and excellent. He did a great job of following through with all of our needs. I highly recommend the restaurant. read more

We had a fantastic dinner at CHOP. We made advance reservations and asked for a table on the top deck, which made for a great vantage point for the setting sun. Though the restaurant was operating under Covid-19 precautions, the ambience and quality were top-notch. The best: Our server, Adam, provided expert service and warm hospitality. He made our experience great! Don't skip the CHOP Old Fashioneds; the smoked maple Bourbon and cedar smoke made for a unique and refreshing take on the classic cocktail. read more

See all

Excellent craft cocktails. Highly recommend the spice trade martini. The filet and beef burgundy were both outstanding. Perfectly prepared rare steak with a flavorful sauce. The French onion soup was very beefy and will definitely be ordered again. The only disappointment was the Caesar salad. This is a must go to restaurant whenever we're in town. read more

Went back to CHOP and this time I was informed up front about the rice being cooked in beef stock (i'm vegan). I really appreciate this! They were unable to provide rice not cooked in beef stock, but they did offer to substitute a side of my choice. Though I was left basically eating two big plates of vegetables, they were so delicious I didn't even mind. Staff is always super friendly and attentive! read more

CHOP - seasonal salad - Steakhouses Near Me - Sister Bay, Wisconsin

See all

Love this restaurant. From the moment you walked in the door you are made to feel very welcome. They take reservations but walk-ins, like ourselves were well received and immediately seated. One thing that was obvious was how accommodating they were. The place is a two story building with a beautiful decor and very pleasant staff. Their outside patio downstairs and up have a beautiful view of Lake Michigan. The inside of the restaurant it's very comfortable and the tables are well spaced. The food was amazing, from their delicious home made bread (pop overs) to their salads and entrees. The desert was just as delightful. We had a variety of choices all beautifully presented. Our salads were work of art which were easy to the eye and the pallet, I had the seasonal salad with apple vinaigrette. Awesome! My food was great, I order the New York strip and my husband had the scallops. The scallops were nicely browned with a delicious topping of bacon specially cooked. My husband twice bake potato was flavorful and warm and delicious, loaded with everything you will expect but giving you that unexpected unique taste. When we first arrived we asked to be seated outside, however it was intolerably hot. Other people shared our opinion and asked to be seated inside as well. This created a challenge, one that the staff handle with grace and charisma. They were able to accommodate everyone who had change their minds. (4 families, us included) and the hostess was very apologetic even though it was not her fault. The place it's a bit pricey but perfect for that special dinner, anniversary or a date to impress. And the food and the service are worth every penny. In a world we're customer service rarely match the quality, Chop has it all. Thank you read more

Beautiful views and great outdoor patio! We enjoyed our dinner and the food was fantastic! We made a reservation online for our party of 6. Our server was attentive and provided exceptional customer service. The steaks were cooked to perfection. I highly recommend the banana foster cheesecake. It was delicious! Five stars for the food, service, views, and just overall atmosphere. We enjoyed our night out in town! read more

See all

Good service, good food. Nice people. Mixed up on one order but was corrected right away. read more

Loved the service along with a fantastic dinner, felt welcomed from reception to Dorian our server, Very nice decor with fantastic views of harbor and of course the Door County sunset read more

WORST SERVICE EVER! The tables are so close it isn't comfortable. Definitely try a different restaurant!!! The food wasn't even good. Very disappointing. read more

Great service and great food. Mushroom ravioli are amazing as well as the duck. Anything we tried was great and they also have great cocktails and very friendly staff. read more

We ate dinner at CHOPS on July 6yh. The food and service were excellent. Two problems. A service charge of 3.99% was added. Ridiculous. We took a carrot cake desert ack to the hotel. The next day,we opened it to find wilted salad¡! We will not eat at chops again until they remove the unnecessary 3.99 service charge. read more

Chop! Chop! Quick review: Décor (clean lines, slightly Door County modern--like!); Salad (Caesar salad--interesting take on croutons--like!); entrees (Whitefish--generous portion, fresh--like!); Dessert (flourless chocolate cake--like!). Chop read more

CHOP - Steakhouses Near Me - Sister Bay, Wisconsin

See all

We've been there twice. The first time (10/2021) my wife and I had a very good experience-good service, very nice steak done properly, excellent wine. Ambiance was Door County chic. Pricey but a good value. The second time (5/2023) was much different. Four of us were rushed through a mediocre dinner--this time my steak was tough and very overcooked, and my friends' dishes were all merely OK. Service was less than great. I'll take it as a bad day--given everyone's issues with help, I'm sure it's not easy. But I'm not in a hurry to go back. read more

Great food, great service, great atmosphere. My husband and I luckily snagged some bar seats since we walked in with no reservations and were pleasantly satisfied from start to finish. Drinks were great and they have a great whiskey selection. We ordered the goat cheese crostini which I thought was a tad bit too sweet but still ate it with no hesitation. We both ordered a steak that came with your choice of butter and both were cooked perfectly and seasoned very well. We ordered the bananas foster per the bartenders recommendation and it was a gluttonous and delicious end to the meal. The service was exceptional from the kind smile at the host stand to the attentive bar staff. Thank you for the experience. read more

As a recurrent visitor in Door County, I had been looking forward to trying Chop for the first time on this year's trip. My wife and I had made reservations for their rooftop, and called to confirm availability for our chosen section. When we arrived, there was a long line at the hostess stand where a number of walk-in diners were requesting tables. I let the hostess know that we had made a reservation and was assured that when they had worked through the line of walk-ins we would be seated. After about 20 minutes of waiting in line and watching numerous others seated at the rooftop, we were informed that they had given our table away and no longer had room for our rooftop reservation. We expressed disbelief that they had given away a table that was reserved and confirmed multiple times. After some debate with the hostess, we were told that they guessed they could stick us at a table intended to seat larger groups of 6. The service did not improve once seated. We were made to feel like an unwelcome imposition on the staff, who frequently rushed us in what I presume was an attempt to clear the table faster and make room for a large group. Our reservation was made to coincide with hours for their prix fixe menu, but we were told that we must order everything immediately as the wait for our table caused us to miss the prix fixe time. We had looked at the menu ahead of time and placed our orders. Our steaks arrived without the sauces we ordered and I inquired if this was still coming. The waitress was snooty and rather than simply saying they don't have our requested sauce, she made a fuss to argue that we had never ordered it and if we had we couldn't get it anyway as they don't carry them. She insisted on taking our steaks back, which we stopped her from doing as there was no point. When the time came for dessert the waitress was again quite pushy in trying to get us to take dessert to go; she asked if we would like a doggy bag for the dessert, and then again if we would like to just take our dessert to eat elsewhere. After being told no both times she again insisted that she pack dessert up for us despite our answers. After much back and forth she agreed to bring dessert to our table and left the check. At this point the rude service had made us feel more than unwelcome and I paid for our dinner without leaving a tip for the staff. My wife went to use the washroom but was accosted on the way by another staff member who made a rather public scene in scolding her for not tipping. She was told that we were not welcome back to dine at Chop - although given our experience I think we were at no risk of subjecting ourselves to this ordeal again. read more

Very good. Recommend by a friend. All 5 of us at the table ordered a version of the by 5:30 special. We all loved it. I had the 8 oz strip. And, it was not tiny (like lots of "8oz" steaks). Onion soup was good. Slightly sweet. Carrot cake was great dessert, icing was not too sweet, which is great! And, the staff was quick & friendly. read more

See all

We had a wonderful visit last night. I throughly enjoyed the ribeye, perfect medium rare with accompanying grilled asparagus. My wife enjoyed the special catch, which was Mahi Mahi. We shared carafe of house red wine. Service was attentive and friendly. read more

We visited in Mid August ... beautiful time to go .. not crowded. But we skipped lunch and had early dinner. Lucked into early bird special of 3 course meal for 25 dollars .. Great deal. I had soup, steak and dessert .. yummm. My friend had pot stickers, steak and carrot cake. She loved everything but the carrot cake. Nice place. I was on our list of places to try after reading reviews. read more

See all

It's a beautiful place. One of our favorites in Door County. Definitely the best steak house in the county, the food is delicious, service is awesome. We highly recommend this place. read more

CHOP - Blackberry Smash - Steakhouses Near Me - Sister Bay, Wisconsin

See all

Chop was not our first choice for our wedding rehearsal dinner, but after hosting our event there it was painfully obvious it should have been. The event staff was very easy to work with and made our evening very special and stress free. We had our event downstairs in their event space, and it was perfect! Large enough for all of our guests, yet still intimate and gave us privacy from the other people eating at the restaurant. The menu was great and the food was superb. We had the opportunity to offer five dishes to our guests (New York Strip, Farmhouse Pork Chop, Walleye, Salmon and Veggie Stir Fry) and all were AMAZING! Our guests are still commenting on how good the food was almost a month later. Chop ended up being the perfect place for us to have our rehearsal dinner, and it will be a staple for our future visits to Sister Bay & Door County. read more

The service was wonderful. Our waiter Dorin was thorough and so pleasant! The Cesar salad was delicious. I had scallops which with the bacon jam as fabulous. My husband said the duck was special! We will return to Chop next time we're in Door County! read more

Had a good dinner for my wife's birthday. Leaving we stopped for one drink in the bar and the bartender was so rude I'll never be back. Spent $500 and treated terrible. Spend your money elsewhere read more

Excellent food and service. Adam was amazing and always attentive during our whole meal. The popovers and sweet butter are so tasty. I had the white fish special with wild rice and both tasted so wonderful. My husbands filet with compound butter was cooked to perfection. The twice baked potato was a little over cooked, but the entire meal was amazing and we got the carrot cake to go and enjoyed later, very moist and the cream cheese frosting was also excellent. Go here, spend a little extra, you won't be disappointed with the food or service. read more

Nice place. Dog-friendly patio and efficient service. The whole experience was top-notch except the ribeye was just fair. Which was a shame given that the walleye, sides, soup and salad were all fantastic. The house red wine was not bad either, and the carafe a solid deal at $20. All in all, despite the steak being somewhat disappointing, given the price point, ambiance and service, I was very happy with this place and would most definitely return. read more

We were there a few days ago and while the food and drinks were good, the service was not so good. The female bartender was super rude and made our group feel completely uncomfortable the entire time. Very disappointing and won't be back. read more

We were staying in Sister Bay and decided to check out Chop. It definitely did not disappoint! This is a great spot for a date night- service is wonderful and food is delicious. I recommend the Petite Filet cooked medium rare or their Steak & Seafood special (steak of your choice with seafood of your choice). The dessert sampler is also worth it! read more

See all

One of the best meals we've had. Responsible covid precautions to start. The scallop appetizer and the ribeye will ensure my return as soon as I can! read more

CHOP - Steakhouses Near Me - Sister Bay, Wisconsin

This was our second visit to CHOP for the Early Diner Special, a special 3-course menu for $29.99 from 5-5:30. The bar was crowded when we arrived at 5. They have happy hour prices on drinks including a Wisconsin old fashioned for $5. We saw them lined up down the bar. I noticed that all of us arriving early were escorted upstairs. We had a very small table at the top of the stairs. Dinner starts with freshly baked popovers, which are delicious. They offer their signature CHOP salad (a deconstructed wedge salad), potstickers or a cup of the soup of the day as the first course with the Early Diner special. They used to provide the option of having two of the items from the first course menu and skipping dessert, but, unfortunately, they recently discontinued that option. My husband had the potstickers--three deep-fried pot stickers. I had the salad. Both were great. I chose the grilled salmon with wild rice for my main course. My husband had the beef burgundy. He raved about the sauce. I opted to take my key lime pie home for later, but my husband found room for the salted caramel sundae. The food was good. The only complaint I had was that we felt rushed. I think the Early Diner special is a warm up for the waitstaff and the kitchen so they can prepare for the evening. The Early Diner special is a great value, but it wasn't the dining experience I was looking for. We like to eat early, but next time I will order from the regular menu and insist on a leisurely meal. read more

Chop exceeded our expectations once again. Malto Grazia! I need to work on pictures of food and not drink. Our dinner included surf & turf, ribeye, walleye and NY strip with crab/Asparagus. I wish I would have ordered a steak and not walleye. When you eat at "Chop" probably should order a steak. I tried my wife's steak: It was seasoned perfectly, done correctly and literally was one of the best pieces of steak I have ever had. I have had Morton's, Chicago Chop House, Emeril's in Orlando and Bass Chop House among other famous steak places. Chop in Sister Bay nailed it. Dessert- Maple Creme Brûlée. Just order one and enjoy! Last item: Chop Old Fashion with Maple flavored Knob Creek Reserve. Again, just order one and enjoy! read more

See all

This review is long overdue. Took my wife to Chop for our anniversary dinner. We had reserved a table outside on the second level, so we could have a great view of the bay. When we got there, it was unfortunately raining. What did Chop do? They had reserved a table for us inside just in case, right by the window with a great view of the bay. We started out with the scallop appetizer, which was incredible. I proceeded to have one of the top 3 steaks I have ever had in my life. It was a special cut that evening, and so wonderfully rich. They cooked it perfectly, it came with a great crust on the outside. These cooks know what they are doing. At the end of the meal we were given a piece of carrot cake as a Happy Anniversary gift. I am a huge carrot cake fan, and this certainly did not disappoint. Everyone there made us feel special, and well taken care of. I can't recommend this restaurant enough if you are in Sister Bay. Great service, spectacular food, and awesome views. It is a can't miss! read more

See all

This was a wonderful experience. We were able to get a seat in the garden igloo. The food was delicious and we had great service. The scallop appetizer was my favorite! The lamb was perfectly cooked and the filet was flavorful and complimented by the whiskey pepper cream sauce. The portions are just right. They have a nice selection of non-alcoholic beverages and have mock tails on their menu. Excellent! read more

See all

Was really excited to try this place but was highly disappointed by the experience. Lots and lots of hidden costs in addition to the menu prices. Food was good but service and overall dining experience could use some changes. Look at your receipt as we had an extra charge of a wine carafe that we did not order. Be transparent on the menu prices rather than charge extra for "add-ons." Will not return and do not recommend. read more

Our experience at CHOP wasn't as spectacular as we'd hoped. We arrived for our reservation about 10 minutes early and were greeted by a hostess outside the door and told our table would be a little wait (understandable as we were early). We were not allowed inside, rather asked to wait outdoors (likely a COVID-19 precaution). On a beautiful evening, the outdoor area is nicely spaced with outdoor heaters but this evening was rainy. To make up for this, a very nice server asked us for a drink order and promptly delivered our wine & beer. The dinner itself was underwhelming. My husband's steak was well cooked but lacked in flavor. My salmon was delicious but the rice was cold. Our server did a great job and I'm assuming this was just an "off" evening. There was two rather large tables being served at the same time as us which may have effected our meal. We are open to trying in the future for a hopefully better experience. read more

CHOP - Saturday special - new york strip - Steakhouses Near Me - Sister Bay, Wisconsin

See all

Food and ambiance was good. The service was good too except- There was a notice on the menu that a service charge of 3.99% would be added to all bills. This was not an added fee for using a credit card it was just an added charge. First time i've seen this. There were five people in our group but when the server presented the bill I noticed a gratuity of 20% had already been added and it was computed based the total including tax and the 3.99% added fee. Normally a tip is added for larger groups. I'm guessing this is done because some people might reduce the tip to offset the additional fee the restaurant added. Additionally when the server brought the card reader to the table "add tip" was displayed. Luckily I had noticed that the tip was already added because I usually review my resturant bills for accuracy. So I question the arbitrary 3.99% service fee, the way the tip was computed and the server not telling me that the tip had already been added to the bill even though we had just five people. read more

We were spending our anniversary in Door County and wanted to go to a nice restaurant for dinner. After doing some searching we both agreed to try CHOP. Since it was a week night we got right in with no wait. There is limited seating, so I would suggest making reservations ahead of time. We both ordered a craft cocktail which were delicious and strong. The menu is limited but had a decent amount of variety. I ordered the white fish because it is locally caught, and a side order of crab legs, my boyfriend ordered a steak. We both go the potato soup, which was heavenly. Our food arrived at the perfect timing, giving us enough time to enjoy our drink, popovers and soup. The white fish was good, but I don't think I would order it again. The rice it came with was just plain horrible which is fine because I over ordered. The crab legs were good but super expensive for a side. I should have checked with the waiter on the "market price" which was $40 for 1/4 a pound. I can't imagine what they are charging for the dinner portion. But for that price would have rather had them be amazing vs good.. My boyfriends steak was very flavorful, and you can't go wrong with a good mashed potatoes and the steak Oscar style. After we finished our meals our waiter stopped by with the desert menu. I was full and didn't care to order anything. My boyfriend on the other hand can never pass up a sweat treat at the end. He ordered the carrot cake and OMG it is to die for! All I can think of is that cake which we ended up splitting because I couldn't stop at just one bite. read more

See all