I can't believe I haven't been here yet. The Coach Meeting House absolutely blew me away from start to finish. Let me start with the spiked hot chocolate -- unreal. Rich, smooth, and topped with a massive toasted marshmallow that basically deserves its own review. If you're coming here in the winter, it's a must-order. The food was exceptional. The roasted chicken was cooked perfectly, juicy and full of flavor, and the stuffed artichoke special was one of the most unique, well-executed dishes I've had on the Island. Everything came out hot, beautifully presented, and you can tell the kitchen takes real pride in what they serve. The atmosphere is where this place really sets itself apart. Between the fireplace lounge, the cozy tartan walls, and the overall warm vibe, it feels like a place you settle into and don't want to leave. I didn't sit in the igloos, but they looked awesome -- perfect for a group, a date night, or just a different experience. I'll absolutely be booking one next time. Service was friendly, timing was on point, and the entire experience felt elevated without being pretentious. read more

See all

Food- The mozzarella sticks and wings were average. The potato skins were kind of dry. The rigatoni with chicken parm I really enjoyed, rich flavor and pasta cooked well. Drinks- The Martini tower was cute and very original. Keep in mind that it just might tip over when placed on the not so steady wooden tables that have a home in the igloos out back. Try the Mezcal martini, it will not disappoint. Ambience- I loved the cozy feel of the igloos. I swear they must be sound proof! They come with a TV and fireplace, so you really feel like you are right at home. The staff was very accomodating, they gave us a chance to overstay our welcome (2 hr limit on the igloos), which was nice. I definitely want to give this place another visit soon, I think it has a lot of potential and charm. read more

See all

Saw the igloo themed outdoor dining on IG and was very intrigued. Knew just had to come check it out with the kiddos Space is limited so make sure to make reservations for one of the igloos for a 2hr time period. They take card info in case anyone doesn't show up. It was a nice insulated igloo with a TV, fireplace, and couches. On the outside, there is a firepit in case you want to roast marshmallows. The kids had burgers, fries, and mozzerella sticks. The cheese was very cheesy We also ordered a steak/avocado sandwich and a chicken parmesan penne. That was also very cheesy for all you cheese lovers! I absolutely enjoyed the tuna steak burger. Very juicy. 10/10 TV's have netflix, paramount, and hbo max. We had a good time relaxing and watching TV while enjoying our dinner. Interesting experience! Give it a shot if you are ever in the area. read more

See all

The parking lot is a pain. Only a few spots and it's pretty tight. Outdoor seating is really cool. There is a bunch of cabanas with TVs, fans, table and chairs The food and drink is top tier The staff is very friendly and professional read more

See all

Coach Meeting House is tucked away in the obscurity of what the Oyster Bay area seems to people from elsewhere on Long Island. Once you park in their lot, you'll spot their enclosed igloo area, and then walk to the main door, greeted by an outdoor fire pit and seating. The inside reminds me of a high-end ski lodge, and there is both table and bar seating available. The last time I was there, we decided to sit at the bar, share two apps, and try their specialty cocktail. It was a quiet weeknight, so it wasn't busy, but the service was immediate and thorough. We shared the mushroom caps and fish tacos. The mushrooms were loaded with goodness, and it was a generous serving. The tacos came as a trio and contained blackened fish and all the toppings. The highlight of our meal was the Dubai espresso martini. It was like dessert in a glass! This is the sort of place you can organize a special dinner out, or stop by and grab some apps or a burger while watching the game. I definitely recommend it and plan to return to make use of those igloos out back! read more

See all

Had a nice meal here after a hike nearby. It feels like a local place and the service was friendly and down to earth. I had an artichoke appetizer and chicken parm, probably too much food but it got the spot. There are some igloos outside that seemed very popular--and raucous. read more

Coach Meeting House - New American Near Me - Oyster Bay, New York

See all

Beautiful interior decor - small but decent size dining room. Went for the holiday storytime and singing with Frozens Anna and Elsa; with Santa also reading a book. Anna and Elsa were both amazing with the kids, reading and beautiful voices...Santa was just basic and seemed bored. Brunch menu - Bagel 1/10, munchkins 3/10, muffin 8/10 French toast and pancakes 8/10 Espresso martinis 8/10 Rigatoni vodka 8/10 Caesar salad 8/10 Fries 9/10 Chicken nuggets 8/10 Hot cocoa was made very cute and the kids loved it Food was great and interior very welcoming - it's just too bad the service was not up to par 1/10. I would give it a negative if it wasn't for the fact that the girl actually got my order quick and with a smile. But seriously understaffed - only one server for the whole inside dining room. Every time we needed or wanted something - I had to get up and go to the bar to ask her. I made this reservation so long ago and took the last igloo but when I called to confirm and change the head count from 10 to 12 the whole reservation changed and they have no record of it ever being igloo. I get it - tech can be glitchy or mistakes happen but the owner had no signs of any empathy, no sorry and definitely didn't offer anything to help. Just said matter of factly that the reservation was made for inside dining room- showed me on the computer and walked away...I had to be like so can we sit down after a few minutes of just waiting after discussing and deciding with my party to stay. The pancakes, bagels etc all came with no condiments...no syrup, jam, cream cheese nor butter. We had to ask for these...by going up to the bar... Really unfortunate, as otherwise we would have been frequent diners...and we go out a lot... May you have better luck should you venture there. Happy holidays! read more

See all

We had a 6 PM igloo reservation on a Sunday in December. We were seated right away and the igloo was nice and warm and cozy. You also had access to the outside fire pit and table if you wanted to sit out there. Everything is QR code that you order through, which was super convenient. We started with mozzarella sticks, Caesar salad, and a French onion soup. And then for entrées, we did the steak sandwich and a cheeseburger. In the igloo, there is a TV with access to certain channels and streaming services as well. We enjoyed our meals, drinks and the ambiance. Definitely would recommend! read more

See all

The service was terrible and our dinner was ice cold. Server was no where to be found to complain and came back 40 min later. The drinks were terrible as well read more

We reserved an igloo. It was fantastic experience and a ton of fun ! It's a great date night or with kids. read more

Coach Meeting House - New American Near Me - Oyster Bay, New York

See all

Such a cute, cozy spot! Visited in December for their outdoor igloos, 2 hr time limit, awesome setup. TV, fireplace & Bluetooth speakers. The staff is very friendly and attentive. Espresso martinis $18 comes in a variety of flavors. Food menu is basic & limited. Great spot for date night or happy hour. read more

Coach Meeting House - New American Near Me - Oyster Bay, New York

Food was great!! We loved the outdoor dining in the igloos!!! Great service. Very reasonably priced menu. Definitely will return!!! read more

See all

Picture this: fried food and alocoholic slushies with your friends in a heated igloo while reality tv plays in the background and you have servers on call to bring you anything you could possibly want via an app. There was an igloo of drunk moms in the igloo next to us who had been karaokeing for 8 hours and if that doesnt scream long island, I really don't know what does. The food was delicious, the drinks were perfection and the service was phenomenal. Make sure you order the miami vice frozen slushie!! SUPER DELISH. They also have a gorgeous bar inside and offer a slushie drive thru (atleast in the summer) Highly recommend this place for a fun and unique meal! read more

See all

Great food. A bit pricy but big portion. Fresh pasta can't beat that! Friendly staff though they tend to cater to regulars but so you gotta make an effort to catch them. Reminds you of olden days read more

We came for the Aperol spritz trees and they delivered! We got to sit outside in a tent with a fan and tv. The wait staff was Amazing considering they had to come outside to Serve is in the unbearable heat! They were so pleasant & personable. The Aperol spritz trees were so good and refreshing. We also ordered the fries Alla vodka That were amazing read more

Coach Meeting House - Aperol spritz tree - New American Near Me - Oyster Bay, New York

See all

Coach Meeting House is a gem of a find located in the beautiful Oyster Bay. We had reservations for an igloo on New Years Day. Each igloo has a fireplace and tv which was really nice and brought great vibes. The food was delicious and we had great service as well. I was very pleased with this experience and would definitely go back. read more

Absolutely one of the nicest establishments I have been to in a very long time .. I found this place on IG and gave it a shot for "date night" Everything from the esthetics of the inside to the hospitality of the staff gets 5 stars.. we were greeted right away taken to our own personal igloo and shown how easy it was to order drinks and food.. we had two hours of a uninterrupted experience.. you order drinks off their app and they arrive promptly by staff to your heated igloo.. we ordered a hot apple cider drinks that was to die for and a classic espresso martini.. for food my boyfriend and I had their French onion soup and shared a steak sandwich.. but.... Dessert was the best part .. a rainbow cookie cheesecake YUMMM. I really can't say one bad thing about this restaurant.. I will be going back It was like stepping into my own personal "ROM COM" I loved it .. read more

See all

Let's meet! I mean if we're going to meet at the Coach Meeting House then I might just take you up on that offer. That's just what my fiancée and I (with our parents and her sister) in toe) all did last week with relatively tasty and positive results. I'm going with relatively because there's a lot to love about Coach Meeting House with a few small chinks in the armor that knocks down the possibility of a five star experience. Though let's start on a positive note in saying that the igloo aspect is what makes CMH so awesome. You heard that right (and by now it probably doesn't sound so weird). Coach has a bunch of plastic dome igloos (with fire pits next to each one) for reservation only. The fact that the igloos are free-of-charge (you just pay for what you order) is awesome. Even better is that you get them for two hours and can order a full menu of eats, drinks, and even watch a movie on the streaming-enabled TV you'll find inside your little insulated hut. With ideas of both eating and drinking, that's just what we all did once settled in our cozy-ish alcove. Everything is ordered through QR scan on a phone with the bill able to be broken up later by however many people order (a pretty cool and helpful part). We started with drinks and the spiked hot chocolate sounded like a winner (it was!). Not sure what alcohol was in it (maybe peppermint schnapps?), but it packed a nice little kick. From a food aspect, my parents wanted some mozzarella sticks which turned out to be tasty and had a proper gooey cheese aspect to them. I ordered the Cajun chicken sandwich which was truly delicious (so were the side of fries) while I also snagged a creamy bite of my fiancée's rigatoni alla vodka and chicken cutlet. It was a tasty start and finish to what we ate. So why four stars? Where are those aforementioned chinks? Well you'll notice plenty of wear and tear (hence the chinks) on the furniture (missing leg on the heater) and even the igloo itself (a tear in the doorway which brought in a little cold air). Speaking of the igloo, it's supposed to hold up to 10 humans, but it felt a little cramped with just 7. It also wasn't the easiest for us all to eat at the same time inside such a low and small table so a few headed out by the fire pit to chow down. And one negative of said chow? Prices weren't the cheapest. I did love my chicken sandwich, but at $20 it seemed a little steep. These are just a handful of things to know about the igloo setup, FYI. Overall though, I'd still say Coach Meeting House was cozy and fun enough to enjoy for those two hours. It might be something you wouldn't want to do very often (consider it as a special event-only type of setup) or maybe it works just for drinks and say 4-5 people. In one of those scenarios you might be looking at a full five star review. For me, I'll happily stick with four and say despite the small chinks (just loving that word right now), I'd return to meet right back up at Coach Meeting House some time soon. See ya there! read more

Coach Meeting House - Indoors is just as cozy. - New American Near Me - Oyster Bay, New York

Husband booked us a reservation here two weeks ago for an Anniversary date this December, they called and canceled on him because another party increased their party size so they decided to kick us out to accommodate. Extremely disappointed that even after hearing this was booked to celebrate such a special occasion they decided to cancel on us. We specifically made this reservation so early in advance to prevent this exact thing. They take your credit card information so they can charge you if you don't show up but certainly do not care if they leave you hanging. If a reservation and my card info doesn't reserve you a spot, what does?? read more

Food and drinks always amazing! Feels like home, where everyone knows your name! Love the chicken Parm, hamburgers and potato skins. Highly recommend! read more

Visted last night. My friend booked one of the globes. It was a very cool experience. We ordered food and drinks from our phones. The food was brought out as ever-one ordered. The fire-pits were a nice touch. It was nice evening and we will be visiting again once the weather is warmer. A great cozy Saturday night. read more

Coach Meeting House - a plate of fries and a bowl of ketchup - New American Near Me - Oyster Bay, New York

had the best experience celebrating a friends birthday, the ambiance was perfect and with the igloo it made the experience not only cozy for the winter but perfect for celebrating with a group of friends! the SUGAR COOKIE ESPRESSO MARTINI was absolutely too die for!! and the portions for the food was awesome read more

Absolutely delicious ! Ambience inside was cozy with a fireplace ! Saw the igloos outside j looked like fun to book with friends . Interesting good selections / Turkey burger with goat cheese and lingonberries yummy read more

Finally tried this place as I've been trying to come here since the summer for the drive thru daiquiris & happy I waited for winter for the igloos! You definitely don't feel like you're in LI. Located 5 mins away from my house I will definitely be visiting here often. I booked an igloo for a Monday afternoon due to always being booked on the weekend. Such a cute & cozy vibe. The espresso martinis are sooooo good & I can't wait to go back with my girls for the espresso martini tree! I did order some food. The chicken parm was ok & the wings were ok. I would more visit here for apps & drinks not dinner. read more

Coach Meeting House - Espresso martini with baileys - New American Near Me - Oyster Bay, New York

See all

Found this place by chance and it's definitely bookmarked for a second return. Cozy restaurant with friendly wait staff. The food was amazing. I ordered the chicken Parmesan ala vodka and it was by far the best chicken Parmesan I've ever had in my life. Highly recommend that dish. read more

Fabulous. I love his place. This is the second time we came here and the ambiance inside is just great. The food is great and the drinks are perfect. If there was something to give guidance on i would, but it's all great. The waiters and the bartenders are helpful and friendly. This is going to be my new favorite place. read more

Been coming here for years. Besides the owner Rustan being a great guy. Theh have some awesome food here ! During beginning of Covid he had a drive though setup with frozen drinks. Burger her is awesome. Rigatoni A la vodka better here then some Italian restaurants. If they have the Ahi Tuna get it ! Your welcome ! It's insanely good ! Black and blue of course. read more

See all

What a fabulous find ! We went to Sagamore Hill to do Teddy Roosevelt tour and popped in here to eat. Great food. Lovely drinks even though we didn't get their famous Espresso Martini ! I had a Guinness hubby an old fashioned app was yummy good empanadas Dinner French onion soup and a Rueben We will be back ! read more

Went with a group of 5 for an igloo reservation and the process was seamless, orders came quickly once we ordered through their online website, drinks were great and overall the food was good. We went on a Wednesday for the $5 espresso martinis and they did not disappoint! Such fun holiday options. The igloo was very warm and private, definitely worth the reservation. The staff was welcoming as well. I plan to go back and reserve another igloo slot before the season ends! read more

See all

So awesome and so great the drive thru service. Thank you for your Courage. Loving the banana baileys colada!! read more

Coach Meeting House - New American Near Me - Oyster Bay, New York

Visited Planting Fields in Oyster Bay and was looking for a nice lunch spot in the area, the coach meeting house was the perfect fit! This cute little spot had everything from a beautiful interior, a gorgeous bar, and charming little touches. The outdoor area with the igloos in the back and firepits was so nice and cozy too. The drinks and food were both phenomenal, great comfort food and especially loved the fun slushees. Highly recommend checking out this spot! LI gem, the staff was also very friendly which was an added bonus! read more

See all

I love their raw oysters, baked clams, berry nut Goat cheese salad and chicken parmigiana with penne alla vodka. Our waiter Jordan was very awesome. read more

Coach Meeting House - Chicken Parmigiana and Penne Alla Vodka - New American Near Me - Oyster Bay, New York

You would think a place that offers a Sunday brunch package for $30 a person ($50 if you include bottomless drinks) would actually include what food was listed on the brunch package menu. My friend made reservations weeks ago. When we arrived we were seated outside in a cabana which was cute but balancing my plate of food on my lap wasn't what I imagined. We were sent outside because there is a bridal shower inside. After about 30 minutes they finally brought out little egg McMuffins, pancakes and French toast. We ate that and wondered when the "good stuff" was coming. Finally, after another 30 minutes, one of our party went in to inquire only to be told that they didn't have any more of the rest of the menu but they would bring more and a fruit bowl. They did bring out more pancakes and French toast that were ice cold. The fruit bowl was a bowl of strawberries and chopped apples. I should also mention that not once was a drink order taken so we went and helped ourselves to the slushies. Probably not allowed but at that point nobody cared. If they can't handle a private party and having people for brunch they shouldn't have accepted our reservation. There are many places we could have gone for brunch. We made the WRONG choice. In addition to the food being cold, it wasn't even that good. The egg McMuffin knock off didn't even have one full piece of bacon. I want to give ZERO stars! What a huge disappointment! I know a restaurant that I will never patronize again. I will say that if somehow they make it right I will edit my review. The experience we have had so far will not change so my review is needed. At this point, we are tempted to have grubhub or Uber eats deliver us son real food. read more

See all

5/5 for ambience - we did the outdoor igloo experience which was amazing. The igloo itself is super cozy and warm. There was a space heater, as well as a heated blanket which made it super warm and comfortable. The couch was also comfortable to lay on and watch tv. There's also a fire pit right outside your igloo which you can enjoy! The food is "good" but nothing phenomenal - it's more about the experience here in my opinion. We got mozzarella sticks which were great, and vodka chicken Parmesan which was flavorful and had generous portions. We got the rainbow cheesecake for dessert which was "just ok". The way you order is pretty cool - you do it through your phone, and multiple people can order through their phones so in the end, you can pay for only your portion of the bill automatically without having to calculate it. The only two things I wasn't thrilled about were: the drinks are a bit overpriced in my opinion. And it was kind of annoying that our TV was really slow and kept crashing. Otherwise, really great experience. read more

This place is the best for brunch! In the summer they have cabanas and in the winter they have igloos. Such a cute vibe for a brunch!

Great food! Friendly staff. Beautiful atmosphere. Love the decor. Highly recommend and will visit again when in the area. read more

See all

We came here last night with friends and it was amazing. Igloo was awesome my son had a blast and watched Disney plus as we got to catch up with our friends. Then everyone could order and pay for their own food! No figuring anything out at the end lol. Honestly can restaurants start doing this in general? It was just a perfect night out. It started to snow as we left so even more perfect. Food was very good. I of course forgot to take pics but it was because we were all having such a great time. My son loved the alla vodka I shared with him. I'd highly recommend this place. read more

See all

After working in oyster bay for two years, and hearing so many good things, we had to try it. All i have to say is "Don't go hungry. " Made reservations 12pm for brunch weeks ago because the brunch menu on their website says: $30 per guest and an extra 20 for unlimited drinks. This is what your supposed to get as advertised on their website. Buttermilk Pancakes, Eggs Benedict, Bacon, Egg + Cheese Sliders, Home Fries, Crunchy French Toast, Scandinavian Gravlax, COLD Cured Wild Salmon, Fresh Berry + Nut Salad, Assorted Bagels, Muffins and Pastries, ADD BOTTOMLESS MIMOSA, BELLINIS AND SLUSHIES. We got the pancakes, French toast and poor excuse for egg sliders. We were told they ran out of food, at 12 on a Sunday? Yet the private party inside had everything. Nobody even came to get us drinks, we had to go help ourselves. And keep walking back to the kitchen to request them to bring food. Not worth the price. Don't go. The service sucks. We had to go to a diner after. read more

We came for the frozen drinks, but we were BLOWN AWAY by the food! Wow it was unexpectedly good. We got french onion soup, clam chowder, eggplant parm, and sauerbraten, and all of them were legit delicious, I would have been happy getting this quality at a nice sit-down restaurant (the last time I had an eggplant parm this good was at Parm in Soho). Also the staff we interacted with were super nice and friendly and kept everything safe with masks. A+++++++ read more

Coach Meeting House - a hand holding a cup of orange juice - New American Near Me - Oyster Bay, New York

See all

We went for Christmas lunch. Had one of the igloo enjoyed that we had our own space. Martinis were amazing and worth the $17 a piece. Food was bad food wish there were more sharing types of food. Loved the experience overall read more

Coach Meeting House - Espresso martini - New American Near Me - Oyster Bay, New York