We ordered a large pizza (half sausage, half cheese) online along with wings and garlic rolls. During checkout, we selected a side of hot honey, assuming it would come on the side. Apparently, according to the employee, that actually means they put hot honey all over the pizza, something that is not clearly explained anywhere during the ordering process. The receipt even reflected the confusion, and when I called, the employee repeatedly said, "I know what the receipt says, but that's not what it means." That alone should tell you there's a serious issue with how orders are presented online. When the food arrived, the pizza was completely undercooked and soggy, and the hot honey had been baked into the entire pie, making it taste awful. The wings were also undercooked and soggy, and the garlic rolls were just as disappointing. I called to speak with a manager, but one never came to the phone. Instead, the employee spoke with the cook and came back offering a $2 discount on a $56.67 order. That was their solution for an inedible meal and a clearly misleading ordering system. To make matters worse, she admitted multiple times that: * The receipt is misleading * The website is confusing * The hot honey caused the pizza to be soggy Yet they still refused to remake the order or provide a proper refund. This place lost a customer and earned a well-deserved negative review. read more

Friendly staff and fresh and tasty pizza! Loved the ninja turtle decor inside and the fast and friendly service. Will definitely be back! read more

Coley's Pizza - Cheese Slice - Pizza Near Me - Pembroke Pines, Florida

See all

Best pizza i have had in SoFlo. Full to the brim with toppings. Not drowning in sauce. Crust perfect. Employees were freaking beyond awesome and courteous. Julian needs a raise. Nice to see good customer service. Relaxed inside. read more

Coley's Pizza - 2 slices and soda for 10$ up to 4 toppings per slice. - Pizza Near Me - Pembroke Pines, Florida

Came in here based on the reviews, they have the 2 slice special here but it's $10 most expensive I've seen in soflo. Now the pizza isn't bad the cheese and sauce were decent enough to eat but it had no backbone whatsoever. The employees are very nice and it's clean inside. 6.9. read more

Coley's Pizza - Teenage mutant ninja turtles - Pizza Near Me - Pembroke Pines, Florida

See all

Coley's Pizza not so cool. At least for me that is. Gave the local spot a try as heard mix reviews about them. Cool decorations and theme! Employers were helpful and friendly. But was not a fan of the food quality as I ordered a cheesesteak and the portions were really off with the steak meat to bread ratio with shrinkflation in full effect. Maybe about a small 8 inch loaf of bread with very little meat thats unsatisfying overall. read more

See all

I love Coley's, however paying $38 for 6 wings and 4 meatballs is crazy!! They need reevaluate their pricing on Uber eats. No way is that worth it. I will still be loyal but will never use Uber eats with them again!!! read more

See all

Randomly was in the area and a friend brought me here. Was great! Service was awesome and there are video games inside for kids to play on. Philly cheesesteak was not greasy but perfectly made. Lemon pepper wings extra crispy were flavorful and good too. Also tried their homemade buffalo wings and they were delicious! Affordable, was pretty packed at 8:30/9 too! Will be back! read more

See all

I discovered this little gem a couple of months ago. Recently moved to area and checked it out. Great New York style pizza, garlic rolls and Zeppoles! I'm from New York so I'm picky about my pizza. Thin crust, perfect sauce to cheese ratio, I haven't Zeppoles on years. These were fantastic! Light and airy with the powdered sugar, delicious. The restaurant itself is small with a Ninja turtles vibe. The staff are also so nice and friendly. Definitely recommend. read more

Excellent pizza!! It was our first time trying Coleys, based on recommendations from several friends, and they did not disappoint! The pizza was fresh and flavorful, with plenty of toppings. We ordered takeout, so I can't rate the service or ambiance, but we very much enjoyed our pizza and we will definitely be back again! read more

Coley's Pizza - Mean Supreme - we had already eaten half of it before I took the picture - Pizza Near Me - Pembroke Pines, Florida

The pros: the pizza was extremely large. It was also very cheesy and pretty tasty as well. Cons: I wanted the Chicago style which is typically deep dish but it wasn't deep at all. The garlic rolls were a wee bit dry. Overall, it was pretty good. I would eat there agai read more

Pizza and wings were both amazing. Ordered online through door dash. Haven't been inside the establishment in a while but it's my #1 in the area. read more

Coley's Pizza - 14" 1/2 cheese 1/2 pep - Pizza Near Me - Pembroke Pines, Florida

See all

Both workers scrolling on their phone then I walk in they take payment then start making the pizza without washing hands or putting on gloves then touching their hair, clothes, sneezing all without putting on gloves or washing hands. Gross read more

We've ordered from Coley's many times as we love to support local businesses. This time, we ordered online and it was promised in 29 minutes (which seems like a lot to me). I arrived right around the promised time and they said it would be ready "soon". More than 45 additional minutes passed before I got my order. No apology. No legit explanation. They told me "maybe somebody else got your pizza instead". No offer to make it right either. Do better, Coley's. read more

Ordered a pizza for delivery at 6pm. Called at 7:40 to find out where it is. Told it's not even prepped yet! Would have appreciated a call or text to let me know! This is ridiculous! read more

I didn't know "well done" pizza means burnt. It's dry as a bone. This is the second time this happens, so it's not an accident, just badly done. I'm not planning to order from this place again. read more

Coley's Pizza - Burned pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Pembroke Pines, Florida

Service is very disappointing, they got my order completely wrong and when I spoke with the woman that is part owner with her brother she lied to me. read more

Seriously so cool inside with the Ninja Turtle Lair theme! The staff were friendly. The pizza??? AMAZING! Well done is a must. The toasty bottom gives it the perfect crispy bite. Thin, tasty, and just perfect. My go to South Fl spot from this point on. read more

See all

After all these years, they are still amazing! Love the vegan options for me and my family LOVES the pizza, chix alfredo parm and the breadsticks..... omg! read more

This is hands down the best pizza spot in the west pines/miramar area! We have tried multiple pizzas and is always are go to spot for every birthday party! Our absolute favorite is the Wingin' It pizza, delicious cut up chicken wing meat with their Buffalo sauce and blue cheese drizzled on top, perfection! We have also ordered the spaghetti and meatballs for the kids at times and it is also very good. Love this spot! read more

we arrived at 11am and the place was popping. People in and out getting their order, that's a great sign. The entire staff was friendly and helpful suggesting their specialties. We got the inside out pizza and buffalo chicken Philly sandwich. Both were delicious. The inside is cool with a splash of retro games from the 90s and tons of ninja turtle stuff around the place. Very clean and organized. We will definitely be back! If you're around Pembroke Pines come get yourself a slice. Say I sent you, nothing will happen just awkward silence. Lol read more

See all

Solid NY pizza in the 954. Coley's makes a great pie. My go to is the Hearty Party pizza which has tons of meat toppings and a "meat lovers" vibe - only better. If you're looking for crispy, crunchy and enough chewy in a pizza - give Coley's a call. read more

My husband found Coley's pizza and saw that they had vegan options. We didn't realize that it isn't really an eat in shop. We did get lucky and were able to sit at a family style table and eat our food in. The service was good. We enjoyed the pizza - my husband and I shared the edgy veggy, minus the black olives and my daughter had a slice with mushrooms. It had a nice mix of veggies. We also had some jalapeño poppers and mozzarella sticks. All in all, I think we would get take out next time, but we will definitely return. read more

Coley's Pizza - Edgy veggie (no black olives) - Pizza Near Me - Pembroke Pines, Florida

Cheap ingredients. Thin sausage flavored disks obviously highly processed. I could have gotten the same quality from Hungry Howies for a quarter of the price. Very disappointing read more

My friends often order wings and pizza from this place. By now I've had it twice in a row on one weekend lol I enjoyed their wings. We liked the variety of sauces and flavors they have to offer. You can always do sides. Loved the chipotle ones. And the others were good too! Their Hawaiian pizza wasn't my favorite, but I did liked the ranch sauce one with chicken and bacon I believe it had. One of their signatures Once I came in for pickup, the bussiness/store seemed clean and welcoming, and so did the staff. Everything was on point, I know we'll be ordering from here a few more times. read more

Coley's Pizza - You can order online - Pizza Near Me - Pembroke Pines, Florida

We've ordered delivery from Coley's many times before but today was the first time we actually ate there. The pizza is amazing when it's delivered but it's even better eating it there. We got the cooler ranch this time, spaghetti and meatballs, and a couple of slices for the kids. It's decorated with all ninja turtles and has arcade games that the kids (and us 80s adults too) absolutely loved. The service is okay, no frills there. It's not really a dine in kinda spot since they have very few seats, but we had a party of 8 (4 adults and 4 kids) and it was perfect. Definitely give it a try. read more

See all

The food was poorly made and missing ingredients ordered. Their website/ordering system is confusing. Josh, owner's family member/manager agreed that it was confusing. Still, he refused to offer a refund without me returning the pizzas back. Went on to hang up phone very rudely as well. When I returned the pizzas and asked what they will do with them, an employee literally said they would probably eat it or throw it away. First, that's a health code violation if they eat it. And second, if they were going to throw it away anyhow, why make me drive 25 minutes for that. In the end, a refund was issued but no apologies and a total waste of time. Very disappointed and will never be back to this place. read more

See all

Hands down the best pizza! Can we talk about the Mama Alfredo pizza?! I'm completely obsessed! Every bite is amazing. From the friendly staff to the seamless delivery, everything is top-notch. Thank you for always making our pizza nights so perfect! read more

Solid local Pizza spot in the heart of West Pines. I've had several of their pizzas and all have impressed. I really loved the Hearty Party as I am a carnivore at heart. The pie is always loaded with toppings, however has a bit more flop then I would prefer. Their Philly roll and Dali Lama Wings were also quite tasty. Don't forget the 18" Cheese Pizza for $12.99 on Wednesdays! You won't find a better pizza for that price point. read more

Coley's Pizza - 18" Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pembroke Pines, Florida

Best pizza in Pembroke Pines. I grew up in New Jersey and have been in Pembroke Pines for 30 years and this place is great. It does not have a large sitting area and is more of a take out place but you won't be disappointed. read more

I've been getting pizza from Coley's since they've taken over this spot. The vibe is always chill and the staff is always nice, friendly and polite. Their pizza use to be amazing but the past few years we've been less impressed. It's still good pizza and definitely a great deal for dinner with the weekday specials on Mondays & Wednesdays. The honey bbq wings were tasty but next time I'll get my go to honey garlic. If you haven't tried Coley's I'd give 'em a try because great pizza is really hard to come across especially in Pines. read more

See all

Stopped in for a pizza and came across Coleys. Their service was fast and prompt I was greeted and my order was taken upon walking in. The shop reminded me of an authentic pizza shop with joy stick games and comic like illustrations around the store. I got a XL pizza which was a good size for my buck. I ordered half veggie and half chicken and there wasn't much going on. The flavors were pretty bland and no flavor from the chicken or cheese. I had big expectation for Coleys. Overall 3 G's. read more

Coley's Pizza - Veggie/Chicken - Pizza Near Me - Pembroke Pines, Florida

When I'm around the area with the kiddos we always order take out, we get the Chi-Town and it's never a disappointment (delish!!!!) .... Cool looking trending place with the old school video games while you wait read more

Came across Coleys Pizza after seeing it on channel 10s clean plate. It was well deserved as the restaurant is spotless from the dining tables to the kitchen. When you walk in you are greeted by the kind staff and the ninja turtle statues on the side. The place is small so not meant for big parties but there is some seating available if you would like to dine in. The garlic rolls were tiny but mighty as the warm dough had bursts of garlic. The pizza was to die for, the crust is soft and perfectly thin and crispy. Toppings within each bite. Do not miss out on coleys pizza super yummy read more

See all

Costco frozen pizza is 10X better than the shit these kids are selling here for $5.00 a slice of cheese pizza.

Just giving another shout out to this wonderful place. Loved the restaurant aesthetics which is ninja turtle themed. As I waited for the food, I was able to play turtle in time ninja turtle arcade game. I ordered take out and they were quick. The food is amazing. I mean look at that 18' at $23. It's already almost gone and it's a couple minutes haha. read more

Coley's Pizza - Maui pizza. Ham and pineapple. - Pizza Near Me - Pembroke Pines, Florida

Great place for take out or if you are just having a slice or two. As far as if you're looking forward a place to go out for dinner, this is not quite the place to go. Seating is very limited, there is a bar along the front and on one wall with one table in the middle. Also there is minimal service. But if you're looking for some really great food togo this is definitely a place you need to try. Lucky for us the place was basically empty at the time we were there so we were able to eat there. So we started with jalapeño poppers and mozzarella sticks. The poppers were stuffed with cheddar cheese and served with ranch dressing, I personally like the ones stuffed with cream cheese, but were very good. They had great flavor and weren't to spicy. And the mozzarella sticks were served with tomato sauce, but were so good we never even tried the sauce. After that we had pizza. My daughter had two slices of mushrooms and my wife and I shared a medium edgy veggy pizza with no black olives. It had to much stuff on it for me to list it, all I'm going to say is it was really good. read more

See all

This was one of those random finds. One evening, two of my boyfriend's friends ordered from Coley's Pizza and it was a smash hit. Since then, we've ordered from there a few times, each time sans problems. The latest order was this past Saturday for Yelp's Big Night In. We figured we'd order from Coley's Pizza, seeing that we had had prior great experiences and we were celebrating a now seven-year-old's birthday. I mean, what little kid doesn't love pizza? That said, between the four of us, we ordered three pizzas and some chicken Alfredo. The pizzas were varied: one cheese, one custom meat, and one spinach. The custom meat apparently only comes in one size, a note to any who wish to order it. I believe the size is a small, seeing as the cheese pizza ordered was a small and both pizzas were the same size. The spinach one, though, was a large. I cannot comment on the meat or cheese pizza, but they were devoured. Ditto with the chicken Alfredo. I can, however, say that the spinach pizza is divine. I've had it twice or thrice now (I don't exactly remember) and it never disappoints. It's light yet filling. I usually have to restrain myself from overeating. It's THAT tasty. Other items I've tried are the garlic rolls. Eh, you can take them or leave them. The pizza is the main attraction. That and the customer service. Not to mention one tidbit: they're selling toilet paper. It may not be the fancy stuff you're used to, but hey, more reason to try them out. Please note that their toilet paper sales are cash only. Happy eating and shopping! read more

See all

We stumbled on Coley's looking for a great pizza for family that (believe it or not) was having pizza for the first time. There was one long table inside and a few barstools by the window. I think most of their business is take out. We ordered a large pepperoni and an order of curly fries. Great pizza, really crispy and lots of pepperoni...the large was really big and plenty for a family of 4. The fries were delicious too. Friendly staff, loved the pizza. Two thumbs up for Coley's. read more

Customer service terrible. It is what happens when kids in a playground are in charge and the pizza is not even that great. Overpriced. read more

Love finding places like this. Simple, Delicious and friendly staff. Some of the best pizza in the area to give a try. read more

See all