Stayed nearby for the night and ordered the crab stuffed mushrooms. No flavor on the crab stuffing, not good at all. The mushrooms were also undercooked! Not good. Got the steak sandwich, It's huge! Con: lots of large slices on the sandwich. It should bec1" or smaller read more

This is the best place for authentic pizza all their food is fabulous..been coming here for years.. The service has always been fabulous and did I say the food is out of the world delish..ok now I'm hungry and need to get one of those unbelievable fresh toppings pizza or mmm hot soup or maybe an unbelievable chicken salad with fries and melted cheese on top.. Oh man I can't make up my mind now..the hot pizza pockets full of veggies and more...SEE YOU ALL SOON!!! read more

The pizza is massive and delicious. Tons of fresh toppings. Small place and seating area is tight but ended up meeting and talking to some really nice people. Service was great. Side salad was delicious too. The pizza is crave worthy and reheats well. You will have leftovers. read more

we just love this place...I admit, we may have an addiction, but what a great way to satiate the need for great pizza!

I so love Conforti Pizza Food Everyone is so nice The Service is awesome Can't wait to go Back Michell read more

First time I went here with my fiancé food was excelllent I had an Italian house and she had a steak. Second time here I went with my mother for an early dinner... the bun on the hoagie was as crisp as a cracked.. crumbled trying to bite it.. pizza was paper thin in the middle the rest was while the crust was two inches tall, sauce was also tasteless. read more

The best pizza I have ever had in my life Never fails to disappoint! Love the freshness of the crust,the pepperoni, and cheesy goodness! Don't use salt on it as its salty enough with all the pepperoni on it.But bland pizza to me always requires salt .This pizza reminds me of deep dish pizza I had in Chicago. So sorry to hear of Mr.Conforti 's passing ad he will be sadly missed. read more

Pizza comes in paper bags rather than boxes, so it becomes cold immediately. Underdone. Center was almost raw. That is, of course, the first bite of each slice. Found a large hair embedded into pizza. Never again. read more

The pizzas are huge the toppings are fresh and plentiful. All the dishes are great there. I love the stuffed mushroom, and I hear now they are doing bbq now on the weekends witch I need to try. Only thing I will say is the pizza is very greasy so get it to go or make sure you live close........ or know where a bathroom is if your over 5 miles because you might not make it. read more

Never thought I'd say pizza was bad. Until today. I ordered a large white pizza, small plain, and bread sticks. Absolutely awful. All of it. No flavor whatsoever on the white pizza. None. Not at all. Not a spice to be found. How?? I couldn't eat more than a bite. The plain was "eh" at best. Both covered in an obscene amount of grease. The bread sticks literally disgusting and the "sauce" smelled rancid. I swear to god it was from a jar of plain tomato sauce...with a glob of cheese floating in it. WTH??!! The only reason I give them 2 stars is for the friendliness of the workers. How they have 4 1/2 stars is unbelievable. I want my $ back. read more

The best pizza around! The crust is fantastic, the toppings are SO plentiful! The flavor of the sauce is fantastic! One of the areas best kept secrets! read more

LOVE LOVE LOVE this place. Had Bbq, burnt ends for lunch here. Service was wonderful and the bbq was perfect. Really enjoyed our first meal here. Look forward to many more. read more

First time getting this pizza. Always liked Vincent's but it had gone down hill. Conforti's was really good. Will definitely get again! Service was excellent! read more

Comforti's pizza is excellent and non traditional. Stemming from Vincent's Pizza park style, it's an experience all it's own. The pizza is large, full of toppings with a massive fresh crust. Plan to use a knife and fork, you won't be disappointed. Take out is always a good option. read more

There take on pizza is overwhelming. They load the huge greasy pizza with a plethora topping (whichever kind you ask for) and wrap this monster of a pizza in a larger thick piece of paper (for take out). I like the pizza every now and then. When we buy it I end up eating one or two slices because of the size of the pizza, whereas I normally eat 4-5 pieces of other pizza. Also, their pizza is very greasy, so too much of it makes me sick. I have only tried there pizza, and have only bought take out in the past. I am unsure of what the inside of their restaurant looks like and the other items on their menu and how they taste. This is not my favorite pizza, and not my go to pizza, but I am a slight fan of it every now and then. read more

Vincent's-esque pizza! Good when you want a huge, greasy pizza loaded to the point of overflowing with toppings.

I had a "mini" sausage hoagie and the size of the sausage patty was very generous, basically the size of two burger patties. It tasted great and they put just a small amount of cheese on it for me like I asked. My husband got a half sized chicken parmesan hoagie. Again, lots of meat! In his case, a ton of cheese as well. He took half of his hoagie home because it's gigantic. Pleasant staff and nice, quiet atmosphere. read more

Our favorite pizza in the world, so far. We order the pepperoni, but my dad swears by a plain cheese, not extra. Order a medium for the right ratio of crust to toppings. I eat the crust first, like a breadstick. I love the family that owns Conforti's and enjoy dining in the cozy place. We always bring one back to DC when we visit family in North Huntington. It freezes and reheats well, even in the microwave. Probably better to reheat in the oven, but we're not that patient. read more

Love this place. Best pizza in Irwin. Better than the old Vinnies' crew that was in the same location. One of these pies is a must every time I'm in town. Admin note: get rid of the Google text ordering option if you're not going to use it. read more

This is the for real Pizza place around. Not a great place to try and impress a date but the place with a true Chicago. New York type taste from yesterday..Its greasy because they use real fresh meat toppings and the crust is made by recipe that day. Compare to this other local places it's so much more old style rather than the fast food little stands we see popping up. Its my favorite and I'm a pizza guru lol.... read more

I grew up in the area but never had a pizza from here but when I finally did...OMG!!! this was an amazing pizza.

I ordered take out. They do not even have boxes for their pizzas. I ordered 3 pizzas and they put in the brown paper bag and told us to hold them flat, you can't even put them on top of each other. I don't understand what kind of pizza place doesn't have pizza boxes? Very average pizza. The white pizza didn't taste good at all. read more

This is our favorite pizza place. The pizza and hoagies are delicious! We used to drive to Beechview for great pizza but since trying Confortis we no longer have to. It's very neat and clean inside and the owners and staff are very nice and courteous. Highly recommend this place for sit down or take out read more

Service was not great. The pizza was subpar. Breadsticks were doughy and bland. Their sauce tasted like it was right out of the can. I was really hoping to like this restaurant as a pizza lover but this was just terrible. read more

Pizza is awesome! Big hunks, big chunks, lots of toppings and a done crisp crust. Never miss a chance to stop in. Thanks everyone.

better than that place in forest hills. hoagies are amazing as well as the pizza of course

Best Pizza hands down! Dont let the name fool you. It's the same fantastic recipe as Vincent's in Forest Hills...a.k.a the undefeated king of Pizza. read more

I grew up 1 mile from the original Vincents Pizza on Ardmore Blvd. Joe Conforti was trained by Vince himself and still makes the same great pizza from the same great ingredients and suppliers that Vince always used. And he's been in busness for almost 30 years. Now Joe's son runs the business. I've eaten at Vincents in Plum Boro as well. Conforti's is as authentic a Vinnie Pie as either of the other 2 locations. Just as good. Anybody who says otherwise is full of it. read more

I know it's not Vincent's, but daaaang is it good. Loaded with cheese and a perfect crust, the pie is always fresh and hot. DO NOT GET THIS PIZZA FOR TAKE OUT!!!!! It is only good fresh, so you must get a table and eat it there!!! I would not like this pizzeria if we only ordered take out. But, it is a great place to sit down and split a nice pie. The dark and quiet restaurant also gives a nice aesthetic. read more

When back home visiting in Irwin we always order a par baked large everything but pizza to take home with us. Have loved the pizza for years and look forward to it every visit back .. however this time we were dismayed when we got home to Maryland and unwrapped it ... it's no longer the huge misshapen oval pizza but instead a smaller round pizza now. Still good but for approx $38 it is definitely not worth the price now read more

Try the Italian Hoagie it's huge it's delicious and it feeds a family of 4-5. Excellent!

This is one case where there was way too much pepperoni on the pizza and I like pepperoni. I couldn't taste anything else. I ate part of the second piece and threw the rest of the pizza away. It was also $17 for a small pizza with mushrooms and pepperoni. A small is pretty good size but that's pretty pricey read more

OUTSTANDING! This spot hits all the buttons. Professional and courteous staff. Clean Restaurant. Large portions. And absolutely fantastic quality food and preparation. Nice job. I look forward to our next dinner. read more