Great spot for a casual lunch or dinner by the water. They had great live music going & the place was pretty packed on a Saturday afternoon. You order at the window, seat yourself, and wait for the buzzer to go off when your food is ready. Everything was pretty tasty- the fish & chips are a good option, but I would pass on the fried fish sandwich next time. They also had a decent shrimp po boy but the tails were left on the shrimp which was a tad annoying. Other than that, prices are decent and service is friendly. read more

See all

Food was just Ok. The views amazing, the staff excellent. Greenport is absolutely gorgeous little town. Definitely worth the trip. read more

See all

9/24/22: Afternoon: A group of us went to the Greenpoint Maritime Festival. We decided to find a place to have lunch. All the restaurants were packed. We managed to find out door seating at Crabby Jerry's. You order food at a window. Think the prices are overboard for the quality of food. We had ordered tortilla chips, clam strips, and Mahi Mahi tacos. Food was just fair. Live music is performed in the evening. That afternoon, you could hear live music from across the way at Claudios. Lots of outdoor seating available. Crabby Jerry's is more of higher end, shore type hangout with a "Cool Bar" and "Stupendous Water Views". read more

See all

So happy to see Crabby Jerry's back for the weekend! Evan and Mike were amazing behind the bar. Great vibes as always. Bring it back full time!! read more

Great news Crabby Jerrys is back! Good food and drink service! Thanks to Evan at the bar for a great day

Probably 2.5 stars. Very expensive for so-so food - tuna taco entree was appetizer- sized, tortilla chips were stale (but guacamole was tasty), and lobster roll was below average. On the positive side: comfortable seating, pleasant staff, no wait time for a table, and that beautiful waterfront view. read more

Nice, outdoor seating and pet friendly. Parking is insane. Claudio's has 3 parts and the private parking in the back is packed. You have to stop at the attendant at the front of the spaces and pay them $10 to tell you where to park. The spot I got was tight but made it in. The food is excellent but very pricey. You're pretty much paying for the ambiance and seafood. All reasonable, in my opinion. My husband and I ordered: - 2 orders of fish and chips - 1 order lobster roll - dozen clams That was a whopping $110. This did NOT include the drinks we ordered. My parents ordered: - shrimp cocktail - 2 clam chowders - half dozen mussels - half dozen (cooked) clams - 1 lobster roll Their order was also $110, not including drinks. We just wanted to have a good time with great food. That's what we got. So it was definitely worth it. You order at a window and they give you a pager. When it goes off, you pick up at the window. Seating is easy to find, cuz with the type of food you get, you eat it then bounce. A plus: the restrooms are clean. Seems like they clean it after each use! read more

See all

Live music on the water is always a good start. It's a walk up causal service and cash only. The food came out quickly and was fresh. My clams was not the best but pretty decent and my niece said the smash burger was delicious. Definitely would come back just for the ambience. read more

Crabby Jerry's - Clams - Seafood Near Me - Greenport, New York

A very nice low key setting for lunch by the water. No table service, walk to the window and order, receive a buzzer when the food is ready. Lobster rolls (both ways) were good. Clam strips, however, were barely there. The basket came with 4/5 fries and hardly any strips. You're better off ordering 2 app portions (no fries) for $20 and getting your money's worth that way. Lunch for 11, including 3 beers and lemonades for everyone else came to $450. read more

Came here after a couple of beers at Greenport Harbor and had a nice seat outside under the tent-like structure on the pier. This is the type of place where you place your order at the window and then get a buzzer so you can pick up your food when it's ready. We picked a table, checked out the menu and then I went up to order. It's fresh seafood so it's not cheap, but it was sure good. We had shrimp two ways (fried and boiled) and then each had a hot lobster roll. Shrimp was great and the portion sizes were good. The lobster roll was really great! Fried shrimp came with french fries, which were just so-so. The view and the ambiance were great. We were in the shade so even on a warm day, we were comfortable as there was a nice breeze off the water. A Rolling Stones cover band was jamming next door at Claudio's and we were able to enjoy that as well. I liked this place a lot and could easily spend an afternoon here listening to music and stuffing my face with seafood! read more

See all

This outdoor restaurant offers beautiful water views, shade from the sun and summer breezes while you eat. You order and pickup at the counter. Usually packed and hard to find a seat. The food was ok. I ordered the seafood platter - some of the food was unrecognizable after the deep fry - for example I couldn't tell you if I was eating popcorn shrimp or fried clam. I may have just ordered the wrong thing. My table mates looked like they enjoyed their meals and had better food. A tiny can of water for $4 seems a bit much, but I do appreciate the recycling factor and not adding more plastic to our earth/ocean. Tables could use a bit of cleaning and service could be warmer and friendlier. I guess order anything but the seafood platter or other deep fried stuff. read more

Beautiful views from this outdoor, order at the counter place. Not cheap and no service as you pick up your order yourself. I ordered a mahi mahi wrap and it was a bit on the bland side. My creamsicle alcoholic drink was less than frozen and didn't taste of much alcohol. The best part of the meal is definitely the views of the marina. Owen by Claudios, which was closed on this day. read more

See all

You come here to grab drinks while waiting for a table at Claudio's or if you don't want a wait long for a table at Claudio's. Both businesses are owned by the same establishment. Same menu for the most part, but Claudio's offers a wider array of entries that Crabby Jerry's doesn't. Claudio's is also more of a resteraunt environment and feeling, while Crabby Jerries is more of a bar feeling and environment. You pick your table and order your food and drinks. The view is super dope and the atmosphere is amazing. Boats docking like cars at drive thru lol. Great spot and scenery to switch up and enjoy yourself in the summer. Drinks are mediocre, so don't expect nothing fancy lol. Overall, great spot to hang out and grab drinks with friends. It has that city island feeling in the Bronx, but with that Long Island feeling. If you don't want a wait a hour wait time to get in claudios and just want a grab drink and appetizers I would recommend Crabby Jerry's. read more

I came here for lunch on a Sunday afternoon with a group of 5 people. I originally wanted to eat at Claudio's Waterfront next door but the wait for a table was an hour so decided to come here. I'm actually glad we did because it was less crowded and the tables were more spread out (social distancing due to COVID-19 times). There was no wait for a table here. You order at the window in the front and they call you when your order is ready to pick it up. We all ordered lobster rolls. The lobster roll had a good amount of lobster in them and the lobster tasted fresh. It came with pickles, coleslaw, and a bag of chips. The bathroom was not clean though and during COVID-19 times, all places need to be clean. It was still really nice to eat on the pier over looking the water on a hot summer day though. I still prefer Claudio's but this place will do if there's a long wait. read more

Crabby Jerry's - Lobster Roll - Seafood Near Me - Greenport, New York

High prices food and drinks. Ordered 2 fish bowls (which was not the size of a fish bowl maybe one glass) and the bartender filled it with ice until he couldn't put anymore ice in the bowls. Drinks were good but way too much ice. Food was just okay, definitely not worth the prices. 2 fish bowls, fish and chips and a lobster roll was $105. Won't be back if I'm the area again read more

So I now understand their 3 star rating. It's overpriced mediocre seafood. I can't say I didn't like my fish and chips but the quality and price don't match. Some in our party of 8 were unhappy with their food, others thought it was good. I'd say see for yourself since It's a nice waterfront location. The staff is amazing!! Everyone from the host/hostess that helps you get a table to the young people taking your order were amazing. read more

Crabby Jerry's - Fish and chips - Seafood Near Me - Greenport, New York

See all

The food and drink was yummy, but the price was hefty. The whole restaurant is right on the water. We sat at the bar, which was crowded but since it was lunch a relatively quiet and enjoyable crowd. My main complaint was the volume of ice in the drink. I got the fishbowl which was really just an odd shaped glass no bigger than usual, and overflowing with ice. I know drinks are pricier out east but this was just frustrating to look at them upcharging for your expectation of a bigger drink and getting the same. Good tasted good at least! May return but only to eat, not drink. read more

Food was not bad and I did not have a problem with the pricing considering Greenport is a resort town and I would expect to pay a bit more. What percent exactly would one expect you to tip considering you walk up to a window to order your food and then come back when your buzzer goes off to pick up your food once it is ready? When I ordered and was presented the bill to pay with my credit card, the lowest suggested pre-calculated tip was 18%. I foolishly chose this option instead of a customized tip for whatever amount I deemed appropriate. Won't make that mistake again. I would think a 10% tip (at most) would be appropriate. 4 out of the 5 entrees that I ordered were missing either the cole slaw or chips that they were supposed to come with. That's what happens when it appears that most of your staff appear to be teenagers who could probably care less. read more

Overpriced basic seafood dishes, definitely not worth it. Much better options in the area

Fix your website to reflect the proper hours of operation. When someone drives two hours to enjoy your restaurant, they would like to find it open, consistent with the hours posted on the website. Epic fail. And to have staff recommend Claudio's as a substitute? A completely different restaurant now. read more

Cajun lobster roll is magnificent! Best I ever had!!! Scenery is the best and live band as well read more

They wait at Claudio's Clam Bar was too long, so we went across the way to Crabby Jerry's instead. The tragedy is that by the time we walked all the way around the dock to get there, our table at the Clam Bar was ready. Oh well. Crabby Jerry's is way more low key. It's fast casual - you order/pay at the front, then grab a table. You can go to the bar in the middle for some drinks under a separate tab. Their menu is pretty extensive, and they've even got dishes for non-seafood eaters. My brother-in-law and I both got the tempura crab po boy. He didn't want spicy mayo on his, but I did. We made sure to tell them this. Then when we got our sandwiches, his had two bottom buns, and mine had two top buns. Took us a while to figure out that they messed up the order and instead of redoing the sandwiches, they just swapped out the top buns. Which meant I ended up with twice as much mayo, and he had to eat two bottom buns. Not a good look. The rest of the food was okay. The fried seafood platter was more quantity than quality. The fries were also meh. The oysters, however, were very good, especially the sweet slushy mignonette. The mussels marinara were also acceptable. The drinks at the bar were also stiff as all hell. They had frozen drinks (a Dark N Stormy, and a Strawberry Fro-Groni), and both were suuuuper strong. My sister had to water down her Dark N Stormy. I got a rum punch, and it was delicious. A bit strong, a bit sweet. But it got the job done. Definitely not the best seafood I've had, but it gets the job done. Sitting on the dock and eating seafood, while enjoying the beautiful views and sea breeze! read more

We're locals and this is our favorite lunch spot in the summer. Dog friendly, good food, amazing views and Hannah and Evan are the BEST bartenders! No better place to spend a few hours on the weekend. read more

love it so much here, the staff are the coolest people i've ever met! can't beat the view, and hannah and evan behind the bar really seal the deal for me. read more

Evan is the best bartender at crabby along side Hannah as well them two is the dream team at crabbys!

This place has really gone downhill. $32 for the smallest liberated roll ever. I used to love going to the wineries and then going here for dinner...now I'll never go back again. Don't waste your time or money here. read more

Crabby Jerry's - Lobster roll - Seafood Near Me - Greenport, New York

I'm English and have lived in the US for 11 years and have travelled all over the country in this time. This is by far THE BEST fish and chips I have eaten in the US. The fish was wonderful. The batter was delicious. Will be back for more! Now you just needs to get mushy peas on the menu! Great food. Great views. Great people. 10/10. read more

Solid lobster roll - ordered warm which was the right call and the steamers were excellent. The location and atmosphere are excellent if you're looking for waterfront views. read more

Crabby Jerry's - Lobster roll - order warm (not salad) - Seafood Near Me - Greenport, New York

See all

We had the fish and chips. They were delicious. The staff was very nice and the atmosphere is so nice. read more

See all

8 of us walked in and sat at bar on a Saturday nite early May and ordered food and libations. Bartenders were attentive and willing to please. Ordered food (clams, oysters, chowder,salads, burgers and fries and drinks) No problem. Had a nice experience. Enjoy! read more

Crabby Jerry's - Seafood Near Me - Greenport, New York

We came here mainly for the view and to satisfy a fried clams craving. This is an order-at-the-counter, go-find-a-seat-on-your-own and we'll-call-your-number kind of place. But the line to place your order moves at a snail's pace, and I can't understand why. It's a limited menu after all, what can be so complicated? On this particular summer Saturday, it was overcrowded and overrun with tourists, and noisy from the cigarette boats docked alongside with motors left running, which detracted from the overall experience. I waited about 25 minutes in line to order, and in another 10 minutes, our number was finally called. The food, unfortunately is pretty low quality...mostly fried and not very tasty. The lobster roll is skimpy, the bun isn't toasted and it's not quality lobster meat. The clam strips are dense and rubbery. And the value: way overpriced for everything especially the lobster roll ($24.00?!). Also note, I am guessing the deep fryer hasn't been cleaned in a while: we both got a sour stomach after eating here. Maybe it was the clams. So, would I ever go back? No. Not for a meal. Not ever. Maybe it would be a more pleasant experience during the week or shoulder seasons for a drink at the bar only. The waterfront ambiance is very nice. read more

Crabby Jerry's - Lobster roll and clam strips. - Seafood Near Me - Greenport, New York

This place was clean, nice and service was efficient. It's a bit expensive but location and environment makes up for the price. This is a walk up and order so the wait service is not really a thing. The food was good at best. The clam chowder was super thick. The Mahi mahi was lacking in the Caesar wrap and the fried fish were heavily breaded and extremely thin. The taste was there but the food needed more zest. read more

Crabby Jerry's - Fish and chips - Seafood Near Me - Greenport, New York

See all

It's just not what is used to be. Tiny portions for a big price. Drinks in crappy plastic cups. Just feels like they are banking on the view and don't really care about good service or decent food. Too bad because it used to be great. read more

Didn't get a chance to try the food or drinks. It's a great spot with amazing views. However, we sat at the outdoor bar. Waited 15 minutes and the bartender with a major man bun (not that there's anything wrong with that, I just want management to know who it was) ignored us. He clearly didn't want to be there. Moved so slow. No greeting. We walked out. He didn't even notice. Went to Anker rooftop. Immediate service. Augustine was very attentive. Excellent food. Don't go to Claudio's or Carrby Jerry's. Go to Anker. read more

Knowing Crabby Jerry's is super touristy, our expectations were very low going in. I guess they weren't low enough. This was some of the worst food we've ever had. We split the seafood platter. I know it says popcorn shrimp, but come on!!! And that triangle of "flounder"?!?! I will say the band was great. They didn't skimp on the alcohol in the drinks and the place was spotless. I was very impressed with the manager who continually circulated and explained to her staff what the expectations are. It's been a long time since I've seen staff get trained. Hopefully she concentrates on the food next. read more

The location, the drinks and the music make the vibe at Crabby's but now with no music I can honestly say it's not the same! Big mistake in my eyes! I think locals will flock to other establishments where the music is (besides CLAUDIO's) along with views and good energy. It took my husband and I over 20 minutes to get a drink at Claudio's last weekend. We ended up back at our beloved Crabby's with our beloved bartendersPlease consider bringing back the music!!!! read more

Food is ok but overpriced. Great bartenders Evan and Hannah. Very disappointed with no TVs and no bands this year. Poor decision.

The lobster roll for $39.00 was dry, limited lobster meat, and expensive. Maybe chicken tenders are a better choice.

The seafood tower was great it wasn't a tower at all it was on one dish. For the price 60$ it was a decent size. A whole lobster , 6 clams, 6 oysters, 15 shrimp and tuna tartare. I would get this again. We've been here before and we enjoy it every time we come back. read more

Crabby Jerry's - Seafood Tower - Seafood Near Me - Greenport, New York

Great location and view. No waitress service/ that's a good thing. Easy order and pickup. For $22 a salad should not have bacon bits. read more