We went in out of curiosity - because we have driven by so many times. Ordered a small ham and onion pizza to go, but sat at the counter and watched tv. It was a very lazy Sunday and the place was empty and we just talked to the team. Out comes our pizza and instead of leaving, we just had our first taste there. WOW! It's the kind of neighborhood pizza joint that offers kid and family friendly food at reasonable price! It's laid back, family friendly, no frills, approachable. I can see why visitors SHOULD order food to take back to their rentals or picnic on the beach and feed the groups. Seriously hungry people's, crazy tourists coming to rattle our town! Get your sand filled shoes over and grab some really legit grub. Not fine dining. Family dining. read more

We orderes take-out. Phone service was great. Previous people that rented out the cottage must they used it because he knew exactly where to go which is A+ in my book... My son had a steak and cheese grinder which he absolutely liked. I ordered a chicken and a beef taco Along with the nachos grande And my son's friend ordered steak and cheese quesadillas Great price points for everything. ... Reason why I didn't give it 5 stars.... Only 4... The Mexican wasn't 5 stars. Reminds me of when my white friends have taco night... Very basic and bland. Even when I ordered hot / spicy sauce. Nacho chips were very generic. Like " white people taco night" But overall it is what it is.... Great for being in that area and you need to have takeout and tacos and pizzas. What's on the menu... read more

Craigville Pizza & Mexican - Mexican Near Me - Centerville, Massachusetts

See all

Some of these negative reviews must be from some tough crazy busy summer months! Because Craifgville Pizza has been 5 out of 5 every time for us! I usually get a pizza and a salad, but I enjoy their subs/apps once in a while. Friendly, affordable, local takeout. Can sit and have a beer too! Relaxing spot to grab a cold one after the beach. read more

We ordered delivery when we arrived on the Cape. The food arrived quickly and was correct. The Mexican side of things was not great at all. Commercially made guacamole and smothered burritos - we didn't realize they would be covered in sauce and cheese. The fillings tasted prepackaged - the chicken and steak for example. The pizza was ok so we gave it 3 stars instead of 2. read more

Well what can I say after years and years of going to craigville Pizza and having a delicious dining experience in recent years they've had a quality control problem in the kitchen . This evening one of my roommates went to craigville pizza and got a chicken quesadilla the quesadilla came with a choke size chicken bone chunk but I guess that's what's to be expected from a rundown Roach Coach establishment such as this one read more

We finally tried this restaurant. We have been meaning to for quite some time. We were greeted by a very nice person who sat us when we arrived. Ordered the Kelly crust pizza with three toppings. The crust was good but not a lot of any of the toppings on the pizza. I like pizza with a bit more tomato sauce than this had. My wife had a sangria which tasted watery. The service was very good and the pizza arrived very quickly. We want to try this place again but will order Mexican food and beer next time. read more

Really delicious food at a unique place. Servers are very nice and friendly, food is really good, and it's an institution in the area! I recommend getting the Kelly crust is too Ure a fan of garlic! read more

Craigville Pizza & Mexican - Italian cheese dip - Mexican Near Me - Centerville, Massachusetts

See all

Definitely not a burrito. It was suggested by someone who goes there about once a year. What I say about that is , after a year you forget why you haven't been back there for Mexican food. I don't know about the pizza or Italian food. Sorry. I'm not going to go back anyway. I have my pizza place and my burrito place on Main Street in Hyannis that is as authentic as you can get on Cape Cod. read more

Stupid wait time. Waitress was nice enough but too long for the food and not worth the wait ! Pizza was barely "OK"...

A few months ago I ordered a chk Greek salad and it was so delicious. Tonight was sadly a different story. It was so bad. Little dry cold pieces of chicken, one cucumber end piece, one olive, NO Feta, no onion , loads of lettuce only and runny no taste dressing. The pita was the best part. I was so sad. read more

Kids love the pizza, chicken nuggets french fries. Couple of old school arcades to keep them busy whilst you wait

Food has gone down! Ordered beef fajita couldn't even chew the beef and the rest of it was subpar! Greek salad was all lettuce with two cucumbers, two tomato's, two olives and ! Used to be good! Delivery was fast though hence the two stars! Won't go back! read more

Ordered takeout n delicious always!!!! Sour cream with anything almost is amazing!!! Lol read more

The worst service on earth. Orders aren't ready when arrive. Save your money and time - look elsewhere!

Of course it's a Greek takeout joint with sweet sauce pizzas, toasted hoagies and... Mexican selections. Because, of course. The craziest part? The food's really solid. Like, reeeeeeally solid. Italian sub is $9, sized to split and warmed to toasty perfection. Salami, gabagool, provolovovo, pepperogoni and ham, lettuce, tomato, pickles, hots. It was a mighty fine iteration. Wife got a pizza and I had to steal a slice (okay, two) - loads of cheese and pineapple, with a minor qualm to the not-so-crispy "crispy bacon." As mentioned, the sauce is on the sweeter side, which may be divisive, but on the plus, you get your choice of crust: Sicilian, thin, regs or a garlic, rosemary, parm baste. If your hesitant on the latter, fear not - table shakers has the same blend for your seasoning needs! While I didn't partake in their TexMex, they do a burrito lunch special and $2 tacos. A part of me wants to say "stick with the pizza and sandwiches" but I don't know, their kitchen is crushing whatever they're sending out, so take a chance. #yolo read more

Craigville Pizza & Mexican - Italian Sub - Mexican Near Me - Centerville, Massachusetts

See all

I was staying in the area for the weekend and decided to try it out. So good i had it the next day as well.

Consistently good food and service throughout the 40+ years I have been going here. Came back to Hyannis after a long hiatus and went for dinner and was pleasantly surprised by a beautiful large salad with truly delicious grilled chicken. Always have looked forward to hitting the spot after a long day at the beach for some delicious pizza read more

Excellent House special pizza. Special order was god too. Must be too many New Yorkers reviewing.

The pizza was great! Their veggie pizza was loaded with veggies yet the crust wasn't soggy like most veggie pizzas. We also enjoyed a pepperoni pizza, two pasta dinners and a burrito. My son loved the burrito. read more

Great subs ready in 14 minutes!! Highly recommend hot and delicious as always. Thank you

We ordered the Popeyes Pizza, thin crust and took it down to the beach for a beautiful sunset dinner. Tessa was great over the phone, service was great and the pizza was superb! Will do this again for sure. There is a reason that they're still in business after so many years. Highly recommend. read more

delicious pizza. the pasta and tacos are quality too. Play the Ms. Pacman while you're there. If you're 30-something and on your way back from surfing at Craigville...hit this place up and loiter in the parking lot. Be sure to blast Van Hagar's "hot summer nights and my radio" from your Jeep. read more

Craigville Pizza & Mexican - an arcade machine - Mexican Near Me - Centerville, Massachusetts

The tacos are superb. The pizzas are very very good. They make a garlic chicken wings to die for. The place is very casual. They have take out. Ì recomend them for a tee and jeans night out. read more

Pizza was one of the best I have ever had. Fast and friendly delivery service too. Give it a try. You won't regret it.

Ordering online is easy. Unfortunately, sitting in the parking lot and waiting a half hour after the order is supposed to be ready it's discouraging. read more

What's for dinner tonight? Pizza or Mexican? How about both! As the name suggests, this place offers pizza and fajitas and fajita pizzas. We got jalapeno poppers, cheese fries, cajun fries, and a nacho as starters. The cheese fries were the best I have ever had -- the cheese was thoroughly melted on super crispy and perfectly seasoned fries. The nachos came with salsa, sour cream, and guacamole. The salsa ended up being more sweet than spicy but it was delicious! I'm pretty sure it was a bought-in salsa, but I really liked it. The pizzas looked great but I didn't have any of that, I opted for a burrito. I am accustomed to the Chipotle or Qdoba burritos, so I was surprised to find my burrito in a small baking dish with melted cheese and sour cream over it. I keep an open mind, and really enjoyed the burrito anyway. The shredded chicken was juicy and flavorful, eaten with a fork and knife. The wait was a bit long and in hindsight, I would have liked to just order out. But service at the table was attentive and friendly. Being able to get beer with your pizza and burrito is nice if you're away from home, but if you are staying in the area, I suggest getting food to go and hang out at your place. read more

Craigville Pizza & Mexican - Mexican Near Me - Centerville, Massachusetts

Iv never had anything bad from here before but the food is a little disappointing and they are usually very busy so the food takes a long time to come out. I recommend the Buffalo chicken wings!! read more

Went there for dinner. The kitchen is overwhelmed in summer, took a very long time to get food. Servers seemed overwhelmed as well, could use a couple more. Food was good when it came. I do have one issue. They have video games in the proximity of the diners. Three young children were out of control screaming loudly, banging on the machines patrons were upset with such behavior, spoiled ability to enjoy dinner. No one did anything, not wait staff, management and especially parents that didn't seem to mind to misbehaving children were ruining the evening for everyone. Kinda a sign of the times. read more

This place is SO SLOW. Every time I order from here it takes forever, even if they're not that busy. Also the pizza isn't that great. Not bad, but you can probably get the same if not better at other places on the Cape in half the time! They really need to work on their time management skills. read more

I grew up on the Cape and their Fiesta Pizza is still my favorite. I get one every time I visit home. My kid's favorite pizza (short of the ones we got in Italy) is the pepperoni. I Work in NYC now but their slices of pie don't even come close to Craigville's. Don't let the bad reviews scare you. There's a reason the locals always vote it one of the best on the Cape. read more

Craigville Pizza & Mexican - Fiesta Pizza & Pepperoni - Mexican Near Me - Centerville, Massachusetts

Every time I get food here, it has been wonderful. Love the calzones, Sicilian pizzas, Italian dip and antipasto! I recommend it to everyone I know. Care is taken on each and every order. Staff is welcoming and make you feel like family. Delivery is always fast, friendly and efficient. Try it and you will always call back ! read more

I should have listened to the bad reviews. Tables were dirty far too long for the amount of people waiting. So many cooks in the kitchen yet we couldn't get our food promptly, correctly, and for one - at all. Cheese on the table had mold in it. read more

The food was okay, nothing special and I've definitely had better. Our waitress Was SMOKING OUTSIDE while we were waiting for our orders to be taken. The service is so slow even when it isn't busy. Also the food takes longer than normal to come out, yet they have so many people in the kitchen and not a waitress be found? Also just a heads up the cheese fries are pathetically disgusting read more

Very upset with my service here. Ordered 3 subs and they said 35 minutes. I got there at 30 min and they said 10 more. I ended up waiting 1 hour 20 minutes for 3 subs!!! I went in 5 times to check and they just kept saying 10 more minutes. They didn't care about my order at all and were only worried about pizza orders. While I was waiting, I watched the delivery man make 3 separate deliveries!! Ridiculous. It was 9 pm at night and my family was starving! Also see attached picture for how little meat they gave me, even after that wait!!! read more

Craigville Pizza & Mexican - Steak sub - Mexican Near Me - Centerville, Massachusetts

The pizza both times we went this week was excellent! The service was not bad, and there was no wait. Would highly recommend and we will be back next time we are on vacation. read more

I have grown up in Hyannis Cape Cod and have always loved this place, ESPECIALLY their pizza. I always ask for extra pineapple and they slay it for me. However, I recently got a Greek salad from here, which is another one of my favorites. I went in for a bite and nearly broke my tooth on an olive that still had the pit. I actually chipped part of my tooth. I have never had a pit in an olive in a salad before, this was very disappointing and felt very careless to me. read more

Fail....tried the Slice App for a delivery. After completing the order I was called To let me know they did not have any of the whole wheat pizzas from their web site...OK, no biggie, Ill just have a Mexican Pinata Pie instead. One hour later the driver shows up and hands me other stuff, no Mexican Pie..? Apparently he delivered stuff to the wrong houses...total fail. Manager gets a big fat ZERO from us for running a circus of incompetence. read more

We had alway enjoyed Craigville Pizza until recently....we ordered our dinner and it took over an hour to get it and the young server was bitching and bossing everyone around like she was the owner and not to mention her shorts were so short that her ass was hanging out! Never again and I will never recommend the place! read more

Upon entering, you feel like you jump right back into the 70's. This is definitely a place for the locals, in particular the teens/tweens/college grads/ local drunks. The menu looked amazing and it was hard to decide what to get. Greg and I ordered a buff chicken calzone, and a small cheese pizza and had about a 20 minute wait. We took a walk, and sat at the Pacman game, which also probably hadn't been played since the 70's. It was a great spot to people watch and try and guess everyone's age. We probably were the only people who were summering and not full timers. It was the top 5 pizza's I've ever had... due to the very thin crust, the "bubbles" and the perfect amount of sauce and cheese combo. I guarantee the rest of their food is delicious and I can't wait to go back and try more. They deliver to my house in Osterville so we will definitely do that next time!! I loved the original and old school feel.... and loved that they serve mexican and pizza! read more

Definitely a locals dive. It is what you would typically expect from an old school diner that hasn't been updated in years. Old arcade games immediately catch the eye to your left as you enter. Nice friendly service. Majority of seating is booths with some limited bar space. It was fairly crowded on a Saturday winter night. The atmosphere is fairly upbeat. Bottled beer is available. I can imagine some long waits in the summer. There is a fairly extensive menu. The feature is obviously pizza and "grinders". I prefer the moniker hoagie, but most people will recognize the description of the different subs. They also have mexican and all the usual diner fare. I think this may also be the source of their problems. In trying to diversify their menu, they probably didn't expand the kitchen or cooking staff too much. We waited awhile for the food and again I could see it being worse in the summer. The pizza was awesome. Thin crust style, very cheesy, and a little sweet. I recommend their meat lovers pizza which they call the Hercules. The other highlight is the garlic bread. Fairly simple, but tasty. Everything else seemed basic and unimpressive. Clearly, there isn't a gourmet chef back there. Nevertheless, I wouldn't hesitate to return for their pizza. read more