Ok, so i'm originally from Buck County and have since moved to San Francisco. I was recently back to visit my sister, and my brother-in-law suggested that Croydon pizza was the best pizza in the area. I called immediately and ordered a large pizza and a chicken Parm sandwich for our group. Once I got a taste of the chicken Parm sandwich, there was no way anyone else was touching it. It was delectable! The chicken was quality, and it was very tender. The roll was soft in the middle and crunchy on the outside just as it should be. The next day, I was kind of hankering for it again so I called and ordered another chicken Parm sandwich. It was every bit as delectable as the day before. Flash forward two days and I decided I can't go back to the Bay Area without having pizza considering SF pizza is not that good. I ordered the Sicilian. Oh my God! It was the best pizza I have ever eaten. It had to have weighed 20 pounds. I am not kidding you. It has 20 large pieces and it was only $26!! in San Francisco that pizza would cost near $100 bucks. I told my brother-in-law that it was the best pizza I've ever eaten in my life and that is 100% true. The people who work here are smart and amazing and very helpful. Next time I come to town, I'm heading straight for Croydon Pizza. A++++++ read more

Croydon Pizza - Chicken Parmesan sandwich. None like it anywhere!!! - Pizza Near Me - Croydon, Pennsylvania

See all

I've been crossing state lines since 1999 for their menu because it's never been a cookie cutter pizza shop, it's all fresh ingredients assembled with love. read more

The food is fresh and delicious! Fast service given from the employees and are very friendly. They have lots of space for seating and are pretty much clean. read more

I'm letting the local secret out. This is hands down the Buffalo chicken pizza in the world. I've tested it in multiple states, countries, and nothing compares. Pay the price. You can't even put in words how good it is. The perfect order is one large buffalo chicken pizza and 2 pepperoni bites. Don't second guess it and please stop reading this so you can go INDULGE. The last hidden gem in the USA. read more

Croydon Pizza - Large Buffalo Chicken Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Croydon, Pennsylvania

This is our go to for pizza place. Love their white pizza with broccoli and garlic. The food is always good and on point. Never had anything bad from here yet. read more

Was at my brothers house when he ordered this pizza- he basically lives down the block from it and was raving about how great their pizza was. He called and picked up and it was ready within 15 minutes which was surprisingly fast. He came back with a white pizza that was half plain white and half with spinach tomatoes and broccoli for my parents. He also ordered a plain cheese for my daughter and his kids. The pizza smelled so good as soon as he entered the house with it and it looked good when the box was open. The crust was nice and fluffy and had bubbles like I like it! The pizza was overall okay- the only thing I didn't like was when I was chewing the bottom crust it was hard to chew. You had to really work your jaw to get through the bottom crust and chew many times! If maybe they changed the way the bottom crust is the pizza would be perfect! Just the right amount of cheese and sauce. read more

Croydon Pizza - White - Pizza Near Me - Croydon, Pennsylvania

See all

New to the area tried to order something and the guy who answered the phone was very rude. Thought I'd give this place a try but I'll take my business somewhere else. read more

Every Friday we order our pizza from there. I go there and it's always ready for me, and it always delicious. Had there wings are awesome too. They are friendly and very reasonable price wise. I m always smiling while leaving there. Try it you won't be sorry.! read more

Best Buffalo chicken pizza on the planet, has like a half pound of chicken on it. Everything else has been consistent for 30 years. Shouldn't steer you wrong with any type of pizza-place type of food. They sell to-go beer as well. read more

I now live 30 minutes away, but still love any opportunity to get back and have the BEST Pizza ever! Nothing beats a slice of their Pepperoni right out of the oven with a side of Mozarella fries! The crust is perfectly thin and crispy, and the sauce isn't sweet. If you have the time...dine in so you know what I mean! read more

Croydon Pizza - You will be ruined for all future Pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Croydon, Pennsylvania

The interior reminds me of a 90's era Taco Bell with it's turquoise paint job and wooden booths. It makes me nostalgic in here, and though they're peddling pizza and not cheap tacos, I can dig it. As far as pizza goes I actually really like their pies here. They're filling with just the right amount of cheese to sauce ratio. They are salty but not overly so, and though the dough is a bit thick they aren't very sweet in either the bread or sauce. The pizza itself gets a four out of five stars from me, it's tasty but not out of this world. That said, I would definitely have it again. On the other hand the garlic knots are atrocious. They're not cooked very well and smothered in oil. Usually the problem with garlic knots is that they're lacking oil, so the problem here is a very unusual one. It's too bad that too much oil can ruin them as well. So in short, I'll be back for the pizza and will skip the garlic knots. A decent joint. read more

I really don't understand the appeal of this place at the office. I've jumped on the Croydon take-out bandwagon twice already...and both times I've been left unsatisfied, the latter being more. It's a standard pizza shop, with offerings of pizza alongside sandwiches, entrees, strombolis, etc. The first time I got an Italian hoagie which woulda been great had the bread not been stiff and stale...the bread is a crucial part of the sandwich! The second time I ordered the petite pizza with pepperoni and garlic. Upon the first bite, the cheese came right off the pizza...ugh. Then, to make things worse, it just didn't taste that great. To say something good about this place though, the girl who attended me at the counter was nice and friendly. She even helped me carry some of the massive take out order into my car. Fortunately and unfortunately, I will not choose this place again if it were my choice... read more

Croydon Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Croydon, Pennsylvania

Orders a pizza like an hour ago had to throw it away it wasn't all the way cooked,I will definitely never order from you again!!!!!! Waste of money!!!!?? read more

Croydon Pizza is a great little mom and pop neighborhood pizza shop. The menu has all the typical food you'd expect: pizza, sandwiches, fries, salads, etc. You can eat or take out. Not sure if they deliver to all parts of Bensalem. My family's favorite item though is their focaccia pizza. It's a large pizza of focaccia bread sandwiching the best grilled chicken salad ever. The bread is so well seasoned, you can eat it by itself. The salad is seasoned well too, not too overdressed. The slices are HUGE. Definitely give this place a try if you're in the area. read more

Best local pizza shop in lower bucks. The Buffalo chicken pizza SLICE has around 8 ounces of chicken on it, no joke. HIGHLY RECOMMEND. same quality for 20 years read more

I hate this place!!! First they fat shame me and my friend by saying "Are you girls gonna eat all that?" when we order mozzarella sticks, cheese fries and a SALAD. Second they put olives in my friends salad (shes allergic) after she said SHE CANT HAVE OLIVES ON THEM. They were extremely rude and Im never going back. read more

Best pizza in Philadelphia, period. Amazing service, great people, and most importantly, delicious pizza. This is my go-to place, even since I have moved further away. Highly recommend the buffalo pizza and sicilian. read more

Stumbled across this gem, such good pizza!!! From jersey but when I'm in the area def have to stop in!! read more

Croydon Pizza - Yummy!!! - Pizza Near Me - Croydon, Pennsylvania

If I could give zero stars I would....... my husband ordered a cheesesteak, pizza and chicken Caesar salad for us. They screwed up the cheesesteak and had mushrooms on it when it was supposed to be plain he had to go back and get a new one the steak tasted like dog food and hard to chew I don't know if they didn't care because it was getting close to closing. Then the salads had hard to chew chicken in it croutons were stale then to top it off since when does Caesar salads have black olives in it never. The food was horrible and when I got home from work at 10pm there was no one there lights were out already so I couldn't call and complain. All I can say it WAS A WASTE OF DAMN MONEY FOR SOME SHITTY ASS FOOD. THANKS ALOT CROYDON PIZZA FOR TAKING MY MONEY FOR FOOD THAT I COULDNT EVEN ENJOY read more

This place should be avoided. One day for lunch, me and my wife stepped in here only to watch the owner snatch a plate of pizza out of one of his own employees hands because she was trying to call the man over who bought the slice but had walked away. He then left it on the counter for at least 15 minutes. Then he yelled at other coworkers like they were trash, and treated the customers like we were bothering him, instead of giving him our money. This place does not deserve your hard earned dollars. It certainly won't get anymore of mine. As for the food...meh. There is better in Croydon. read more

I love this place. Pizza and a show. The owner is like the soup nazi of pizza. The pizza is good, and it's fun to watch the newbies panic when the pizza nazi yells "NEXT!!!" Seriously I don't know why the other reviewers gave it such a bad review. The food is good. The owner can be gruff when there is a huge line. The fact that there is a huge line speaks to the food quality. read more

I've eaten at Croydon Pizza 3 times and after each time I become more convinced I'd rather be ordering pizza from somewhere else. What I don't understand is why they only sell 2 kinds of pizza by slice. Do locals from Croydon only ever order Buffalo Chicken or plain slices, and nothing else? When I first noticed that, I asked if they could just put one topping on a plain slice and charge me extra. And I kid you not, they absolutely refuse to make any changes to their plain slices of pizza. HUH?! How complicated or difficult is it to just charge me $.50 extra for some sausage on my plain slice! Why is my only other option to just order an entire sausage pizza when I only want 1 slice?! OR anything other than a Buffalo Chicken slice. And to only sell 2 slice varieties, you would think that their plain and Buffalo Chicken pizza would constitute to being AMAZING, right? WRONG. There is nothing special about the pizza I've eaten here, nothing to make someone from Levittown or Bristol or anywhere other than Croydon, travel all the way there to eat. I mean, their Buffalo Chicken pizza is GOOD, no doubt about it. But nothing that YOUR local joint can't also do or do better. To be clear, I've only ever ordered their pizza slices NOT a fresh-made pie, so I'm reviewing Croydon Pizza solely on that. You could say that's not fair, because fresh will always be better than reheated slices that sat on the display for x-amount of time. However, I've had good slices (WITH toppings) and pizza from so many other places, so why can't Croydon do it too? Unless you really love plain or their famous Buffalo Chicken, look elsewhere for good pizza by the slice. BTW, this low rating and review has nothing to do with the fact that I'm not from Croydon. Sorry guys :P read more

The best Pizza on earth. No kidding. I have lived everywhere all over the United States and have been to Italy. No one makes pizza like Croydon. If anyone gives it less than 5 stars they clearly do not have taste buds. The only pizza that comes close is NYC pizza. If you stop in you won't regret it. read more

Great mom and pop shop. Absolutely great pizza. Stopped in from a meeting on my way home and I wish I bought more to bring home to my family. The pizza selection at the counter was different. I tried their thick crust and buffalo chicken slice. When a place has a line and you see older people working there, all respect and best wishes sent their way. I'm so glad to have stopped by this place, seems like the owner was there and joking with his regulars, he made me feel at home. There's a pizza shop I have in my town with that mom and pop shop feel. Thank you for a walk down memory lane since I'm far away from home. Will be back again! read more

Best pizza around, period. Even beats out places inside the city. People who say otherwise clearly think places like Papa Johns or Pizza Hut are good. read more

Croydon Pizza - Large pie, extra cheese and mushrooms....amazing! - Pizza Near Me - Croydon, Pennsylvania

3 WORDS. BUFFALO.....CHICKEN......PIZZA. I've probably eaten at over 2,000 pizza shops and this shop by far has the best buffalo chicken pizza across the nation. I've continued to test to see if this buffalo king could be matched or defeated and it can't. The sauce is not to hot and the cheese complements it well. The chunks of chicken spread throughout is always a generous portion. When you sink your teeth into the first bite it's like traveling to heaven and back to then being sent right back as you take your second bite. I'm here to tell you that you will never taste anything better than this. Please if you have never , go THERE NOW. Ok time to relax and finish the review. They also have a large selection of other items. I would recommend getting one of their pizza bites that are displaced in the front window. I could eat 15 of them. Don't forget to grab a 6 pack on your way out as they do sell beer! Old Croydon for life. read more

Croydon Pizza - a pizza in a pizza box - Pizza Near Me - Croydon, Pennsylvania

Pizza is ALWAYS good, but got a cheesesteak and OMG, it was like those nasty pressed minute steaks from the grocery store. Why??? What happened to using real steak? read more

Their buffalo chicken pizza, that my girlfriend got is their best menu item and can compete with any buffalo chix pizza. The fries are above average. I ordered the buffalo chix chz steak on a pizza dough roll. It is pretty good but always seems to be lacking in buffalo sauce. read more

Love this place. The pizza is always fresh. The cheesesteaks are great and have plenty of meat. The service is quick too. We come here all the time for takeout. They also have cold beer so we stop before going out to the marina. read more

Terrible customer service would not deliver to place of business four minutes away due to the fact of Township lines.

Croydon staple. It's fast, it's consistent and it's convenient. Love this place and staff is super friendly. Just a great neighborhood pizza place. read more

I've been frequenting Croydon Pizza for years now, and their food is pretty good in my opinion. Their menu is fairly extensive so if you're a picky eater, you'll surely find something you like. If you like eating in, you'll love to eat there. You'll find most of their staff to be very friendly, except the owner, who always walks around with a chip on his shoulder and treats his employees terribly. He isn't the friendliest of people but, fortunately for others, he doesn't stick around too much. I once paid for food with a $20 and he gave me change for a $10, and when I confronted him about the matter, he exploded with rage like a little child, as if I was attempting to steal from him. Once I pointed out that the money in his hand was indeed a $20 bill, he apologized up and down--but by then it was too late. Additionally, I've also witness him be so abusive toward his own employees that one girl was reduced to tears. I would give Croydon Pizza a higher rating because of their fresh and tasty food, but the owner is a complete jerk, so for now, I'll give 'em 3/5. read more

This place is a gem! If you are looking for the real deal pizza this is the place you need to go. Owned and operated by real Italians, you cannot go wrong. Everything is a great especially the buffalo chicken pizza! Give them a try you won't be disappointed! read more

I used to live in Croydon, and ironically didn't really "discover" Croydon Pizza until after I moved. They were always a little more expensive than the other pizza shops in town, and being that they serve cheap beer, tend to attract some uncouth clientele. As a result, my family never really ordered from them. At some point, quality became more important to me than quantity, and I found myself there after a recommendation. Long story short, they have the best traditional pizza shop pizza I have found since my childhood in the 80s. I'm sure it won't be to everyone's taste, but I now go out of my way for a slice or 3. I usually just get plain, because it is so good, but they also have an amazing buffalo chicken pizza. The front case is filled with delicious looking specialty slices and creations, beckoning your taste buds to try them all. read more

We had food catered from here for a business meeting. Great pizza, huge slices that were all very heavy with toppings. Great stuff! I will order from here if back in this part of town. read more

Great homemade chicken soup Italian style. Pizza is outstanding. All ingredients are fresh good quality.

Besides from the Croydon Pizza serving out the best pizza in town, their Chicken Focaccia is deliciously amazing! And it's a nice switch up in between pizzas;) read more

Croydon Pizza - Small Chicken focaccia pie from Croydon Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Croydon, Pennsylvania

See all

Order from here every Friday spend about $40.00 a week there. Ordered last Friday got delivery and they messed up my order I called back to see if they can send me out what I ordered the owner is in the back ground screaming damn Americans he gets on the phone n tell me he will take care of me next week I said I don't eat what u sent. He tells me to come get it then. So I go to get my money back n he has a attitude with me and throws my money at me. this place will not get anymore of my hard earned money. read more

As a proud Tennesseean, I must admit I'm not an expert on cheesesteak. I can't say if this place has the best or not. However, I think this one was awesome!Had some pizza as well and it was delicious. read more

Small portions, crappy attitude from the employees, Food was blah. I saw a lot of mouse droppings in the bathroom. Will not eat here again. Stay away from this overpriced place. I guess the extra high prices is for extra mouse turds. They literally charge extra for everything. Want ketchup on your cheese steak 25 cents. Fried onions 50 cents. Check your receipt What a joke. Count your change too cause they will try and rip you off. read more