Cancel

Open app

Search

Croydon Pizza

3.8 (49 reviews)
InexpensivePizza, Italian, Salad
Closed 10:00 am - 8:45 pm
Updated over 3 months ago

Order Croydon Pizza Takeout or Delivery

Croydon Pizza Photos

Business Info

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Croydon Pizza

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Large Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Tyler B.

I'm letting the local secret out. This is hands down the Buffalo chicken pizza in the world. I've tested it in multiple states, countries, and nothing compares. Pay the price. You can't even put in words how good it is. The perfect order is one large buffalo chicken pizza and 2 pepperoni bites. Don't second guess it and please stop reading this so you can go INDULGE. The last hidden gem in the USA.

White
Dana S.

Was at my brothers house when he ordered this pizza- he basically lives down the block from it and was raving about how great their pizza was. He called and picked up and it was ready within 15 minutes which was surprisingly fast. He came back with a white pizza that was half plain white and half with spinach tomatoes and broccoli for my parents. He also ordered a plain cheese for my daughter and his kids. The pizza smelled so good as soon as he entered the house with it and it looked good when the box was open. The crust was nice and fluffy and had bubbles like I like it! The pizza was overall okay- the only thing I didn't like was when I was chewing the bottom crust it was hard to chew. You had to really work your jaw to get through the bottom crust and chew many times! If maybe they changed the way the bottom crust is the pizza would be perfect! Just the right amount of cheese and sauce.

You will be ruined for all future Pizza!
Nicole Q.

I now live 30 minutes away, but still love any opportunity to get back and have the BEST Pizza ever! Nothing beats a slice of their Pepperoni right out of the oven with a side of Mozarella fries! The crust is perfectly thin and crispy, and the sauce isn't sweet. If you have the time...dine in so you know what I mean!

Brian L.

I really don't understand the appeal of this place at the office. I've jumped on the Croydon take-out bandwagon twice already...and both times I've been left unsatisfied, the latter being more. It's a standard pizza shop, with offerings of pizza alongside sandwiches, entrees, strombolis, etc. The first time I got an Italian hoagie which woulda been great had the bread not been stiff and stale...the bread is a crucial part of the sandwich! The second time I ordered the petite pizza with pepperoni and garlic. Upon the first bite, the cheese came right off the pizza...ugh. Then, to make things worse, it just didn't taste that great. To say something good about this place though, the girl who attended me at the counter was nice and friendly. She even helped me carry some of the massive take out order into my car. Fortunately and unfortunately, I will not choose this place again if it were my choice...

Yummy!!!

See all

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

16 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Jim C.
47
55
3

14 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

12 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

14 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 3
Oh no 0

14 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 2 of 2

Ask the Community - Croydon Pizza

How are their buffalo wings?

Lately there apparently is some wing shortage, I am sure they will blame COVID, cops, guns or Trump.

Don’t See Your Question? Ask Away!

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Pizza 29,031 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Salvatore's Cucina

Salvatore's Cucina

4.2
(147 reviews)
5.6 mi
$$

Fun fun night the six of us had for dinner the night before the predicted snowstorm/blizzard. Our…read morefirst time at Salvatore's. Our friends are regulars and knew the staff. What made it fun was the maître D...Ira, and the owner too. They bring the personality of the place which adds a special welcoming touch. Our Server, Brayden was timly and right on. The bus guy was very sweet as well. We appreciated the staff. When we first pulled up we were not impressed with the small strip center and worried the place looked empty and drab. Turns out the dining room is to the left of the door and the first room is basically a fast food take out area. Reminded us of Aldo's in Holland...if you have ever been there. The dining room was basically a no frills kinda place but much nicer than the other side. Love a byob and we had more bottles than people...party time! (Cheers). At the end of the meal Salvatore gave us complimentary choclate lemoncello...amazing. Soooo...the food itself. We started with calamari and also the antipasto. Perfect for sharing and all delicious. Calamari was a good one. I ordered the chicken française, which was even better as leftovers the next day since it marinated in the sauce. Hubs enjoyed his veal Marcella. In fact everyone enjoyed everything. Overall, we all left feeling full, satisfied, pleased and very happy. It was a good time! Thumbs definitely up on this place.

Dining here is delightful. Everything we try is wonderful -…read morelast night we were treated like royalty and offered free wine. The Chicken Florentine and Caprese Salad were fresh and delicious. Love the "new" dining room, too.

Photos
Dining area
Dining area
Stuffed Shells
Stuffed Shells
Wine

See all

Wine
Fratelli's Italian Restaurant

Fratelli's Italian Restaurant

4.1
(111 reviews)
4.0 mi
$$

I was recently at a soccer tournament in New Jersey and was looking for a local restaurant where I…read morecould take all of my coaches out for dinner. That's when I came across Fratelli's Restaurant, and it turned out to be one of the best dining decisions I've made in a long time. From the very first phone call to arrange a reservation for a large group, the staff was incredibly kind, friendly, and accommodating. Right away, I had a feeling I had made the right choice. When we arrived, we were immediately impressed by the level of service. The staff had prepared a beautiful table for our group, and from start to finish, the entire experience was exceptional. I'm disappointed that I can't remember all of the servers' names because they truly did an outstanding job. Every one of my guests commented on how delicious the food was. My chicken dish was outstanding--easily one of the best meals I've had in quite some time. The quality of the food, combined with the exceptional service, made for an unforgettable evening. I can't thank the staff enough for everything they did to make our experience so enjoyable. I hope this message reaches the chefs and everyone working behind the scenes because they are incredibly talented and should be proud of the work they do. I'm not sure when I'll be back in the area for another tournament, but one thing is certain: anytime I am nearby, I will absolutely be making a reservation at Fratelli's. A huge thank you to everyone for providing such an amazing dining experience. If you're looking for a great restaurant, Fratelli's is a must-visit. You will not be disappointed.

I've driven past for years and never stopped by or knew anyone who tried it…read more They Sat our table of 4 immediately even though we didn't have reservations and they had a large private party in the back room. The entrance when you first walk in is a little uninviting. They had a partition screen blocking the view of supplies. It is where you wait when speaking to the hostess. The outside of the building does not do it justice. The restaurant was nicely decorated and clean. All of the servers and staff were friendly and professional. Service was quick. I had the eggplant parm. It came with spaghetti which was ok. I usually substitute veggies or another type of pasta. I just didn't ask for some reason so not sure if they offer that. I really liked the eggplant. It was breaded but still crispy with the cheese and sauce. Their sauce is chunky and a little sweet. It was a really nice portion and took 1/2 home. I tried some of the pasta Al forno with sausage, meatballs, penne, etc. Delicious! I definitely recommend that dish even after just a few bites. The entrees come with soup or salad. The salad veggies were fresh and it was a good size. I tried the pasta fagiole soup but wasn't a big fan. It was underwhelming - lack of seasonings and it could have been hotter in temperature. One thing I thought was odd was our server never asked us if we wanted to order anything to drink. Gave us a pitcher of water and that was it. I know we could've asked if we really wanted soda or tea but just thought it was odd to go right into the food order. Overall I would go back. I think a reservation is good suggestion for the weekend. And they have a gluten free menu if you need it!!!

Photos
Fratelli's Italian Restaurant
Chocolate cake
Chocolate cake
D-Eggplant Parmigiana

See all

D-Eggplant Parmigiana
Toscana 52

Toscana 52

3.5
(559 reviews)
5.2 mi
$$

Came here for dinner with six friends before a show at Parx Casino back in April. We had a…read morereservation since it was a Friday night and we had a large party. It worked out so well! We were there for an hour and a half and enjoyed drinks, appetizers, dinner and desserts! Our server was great and was on top of everything we needed or wanted!

I have driven by Toscana many times and was excited to finally have the chance to try it out. Sadly…read moreit was not as great as the other reviews lead me to anticipate. All of the issues were food related, not service. I ordered the chicken parmesan. My friends order the salmon and the seafood manicotti. My friend's salmon was perfect, the rest not so much. I could not cut the chicken parm with my knife, that is how tough it was. I demonstrated this to our server who offered a steak knife but I declined. The chicken was just as hard to chew as it was to cut. My friend's seafood manicotti was very fishy and clearly not fresh seafood. She ate half of hers and ended up just not finishing the rest. The server did offer to get us other options but we had a show at parx and didn't have time to wait for new entrees. I do think this location is beautiful. The garden room where we sat was lovely and the waterfall outside was a beautiful view. The prices were a little higher than most local Italian places. Between the higher prices and the food issues I described I probably will not return.

Photos
Behind the bar area
Behind the bar area
Bruschette
Bruschette
White Russian

See all

White Russian
La Strada Italian Restaurant

La Strada Italian Restaurant

4.3
(130 reviews)
8.8 mi
$$

I was just recently there for a bridal shower and the ambiance of their private room was perfect…read morefor this occasion. It's bright with natural sunlight. The wait staff was friendly and attentive, the food selection for this private event was also pleasing to the pallet and eye. (Salmon, eggplant, chicken parmigiana, and a pasta dish)

The venue is absolutely charming. I love an old Victorian home and this is a cool place to dine in…read more We sat in the middle of the main dining room which is tastefully decorated save for the plastic flowers on each table. The menu is Italian, the alcohol situation BYOB. Service was nice. The gentleman taking care of us made several appreciated gestures such as helping me with my coat, giving us an ice bucket for the white wine and well timing each course that we enjoyed at a leisurely pace. I started with the soup of the day of lobster bisque. Smoothly and creamy. I enjoyed it. There was calamari for the table. We all agreed we'd had better. The chili sauce was nice and it was fried crispy enough but still chewy. Mains included a bland chicken parm served with penne. Nothing to see here. There was also a chicken saltimbocca that was okay. The chicken was tender in both dishes. I had the sacchetti with added shrimp. The sacchetti was filled with ricotta and served with a butter sage sauce. I would surely get this again. For desert we had the limoncello cake. Delicious! Overall, even with the cute setting the ambiance is a little stale. The crowd is heavy on the geriatric side. All that's missing is a little classical music in the background. If you're looking for a vibe uh no. A quiet place to take grandma, yes.

Photos
Beautiful set up
Beautiful set up
Rigatoni ala Vodka
Rigatoni ala Vodka
La Strada Italian Restaurant

See all

La Voglia Italian Restaurant

La Voglia Italian Restaurant

4.6
(225 reviews)
12.4 mi
$$

Another double date with our foodie friend's pick…read more And wow what a pick! A beautifully decorated (both outside and inside) quaint restaurant, with a visible pizza oven. We shared a literally beautiful antipasto for an appetizer. It boasted fresh mozzarella balls, eggplant, artichokes, sweet red peppers, prosciutto, and olives. We had a good and soft loaf of bread with a yummy olive oil and balsamic dip too. Our meals were ALL tremendous! We had pasta dishes - gnocchi marsala and fettuccine with clams - EXCELLENT! I had plenty of sauce left to dip the soft bread into :) The other couple had octopus (appetizer) and seafood atop squid ink pappardelle pasta. They loved their dishes as well. Of course we didn't have room for dessert, but our chocolate wine and other wines were definitely sufficient. BYOB's are great and money saving. This place is a bit of a haul but I hope to get back in the future !

We had heard about La Voglia and decided to try it out! We went on a Friday evening and it wasn't…read moretoo crowded. The restaurant has a warm feel to it and is decorated nicely. They serve a delicious homemade bread that's warm when it's brought the table. In addition, it's accompanied by a dish of olive oil, with balsamic vinegar and what I believed to be a spicy dusting of pepper. It was a little too spicy for me - however, I did like the addition of the balsamic as a change from just olive oil. I would skip the pepper though, unless you like spice. We ordered the Polpette as an appetizer; it's a 'tradition' of mine. If meatballs are on the menu, I will always order them. These lamb, veal and beef meatballs were very good, and the marinara sauce they came in was excellent! The sauce is actually a 'roasted pomodoro' gravy - which is an 'intensified' version of a classic Italian sauce. It's made by roasting the tomatoes at a very high heat and almost caramelizing them. A little feta was added to the sauce, which really highlighted those meatballs!! We split the order - as 5 meatballs is quite a large appetizer! We decided to share two entrees - the Beef Short Ribs and the Lobster Ravioli. I always ask if the short ribs are lean - our server responded they were very lean...and they were. Soft, tender and very flavorful large chunks of beef, with a deliciously rich gravy with mushrooms on a bed a creamy garlic mashed potatoes! It was a superb dish! The website said the Short Ribs were the restaurant's most popular meal. Next, the Lobster Ravioli. The dish was a very 'delicate' one, with a very subtle brandy cream sauce. It had chopped jumbo shrimp and peeled cherry tomatoes with the raviolis. While the sauce tasted fine, it needed 'something' - we added pepper which helped. The raviolis were good - we couldn't taste lobster in the cheese of the raviolis - we assumed it was there. The chopped shrimps though provided a nice additional seafood flavor. I like my raviolis tender - the kind that almost melt in your mouth. The pasta here was firmer - a little more 'al dente', but it was fine. We ended our meal with the Chocolate Mousse. Served in a martini glass, the mousse had a velvety texture with a deep dark chocolate flavor. It was very rich yet light and fluffy; a good choice for dessert!

Photos
Easter decor 2026
Easter decor 2026
La Voglia Italian Restaurant
PEI oysters

See all

PEI oysters
Georgine's

Georgine's

3.2
(206 reviews)
1.4 mi
$$

First and last time I'll be eating from here. The food is really just ok. The chicken parm was so…read moreovercooked and the cheese was hardened on the chicken. The Shrimp and Scallops Provençal wasn't horrible, the flavor was good and the scallops were fine, but the shrimp had a very off putting taste to it. I could only eat the scallops. For the prices paid, I'd expect better quality. This was just not the greatest and due to that I won't be ordering from here again.

For everyone who's been missing Georgines Jr's I'm so glad to report that it's back, and renamed…read moreGeorgine's Express! Georgines Express is now open directly across the parking lot from the original Georgines location! Same low prices with some changes and menu additions. I've attached the new menu in photos. Items like chicken parm still come with two sides or pasta but there is now a small and a large version. There are fewer side options but my favorites are still on this list! It's no longer cafeteria style, you order on a kiosk but tell your sides to the counter person once you order. I got the small chicken parm. It was still a very nice portion size. Sides came in small containers instead of the sectioned platters previously offered. Rice pudding and their famous cheese dips are available in the refrigerated cases. They still have a beer take out section but have added alcoholic slushies to go! They look yummy! The inside eating area is small. There are some video games and lottery available onsite as well. Unfortunately it is uncomfortably warm inside. I do not recommend eating onsite, I think this is more of a to go kind of location. I felt bad for the employees, I really hope they upgrade their HVAC. It's going to be awful inside during the 100 degree heat wave coming this week and also can't be good for food to sit in the heat. I'm so glad to have this more affordable and to go version of Grorgine's back.

Photos
Georgine's
Vanilla ice cream Crepe , topped with strawberries
Vanilla ice cream Crepe , topped with strawberries
Triple chocolate mousse cake

See all

Triple chocolate mousse cake

Croydon Pizza - pizza - Updated July 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...