This place was very good. We got the deluxe Pizza very fresh, very flavorful. Very nice employee's. I would love to go back and try some other things.. read more

First time coming to this New York pizza place, I got the supreme pizza and the loaded Garlic knots, both were delicious and the price was fair for the amounts and flavor, will definitely be coming back!!! read more

Decicco's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Yulee, Florida

See all

We ordered a pizza and calzone. Great crust- crispy and good chew. We ordered to go- hot and fresh. Quality was excellent. Portions were generous- the calzone was huge!! More than enough for 2 people. Interior was small- 7-8 small tables. Counter service. We feel it's a great to go option unless you go at off times to sit and eat. Highly recommended read more

Atmosphere was pleasant and clean. Service was above average with curiosity about what I thought of their pizza. We ate outside and enjoyed the fresh air even though the pizzeria is in a shopping area because it is located on the end with lots of seating (even along the side of the building) only reason I gave 4 stars instead of 5 is because I like a super thin crust. Will go back read more

Meatballs and pizza sooooooo good. Never ever do I have to make meatballs again. Meatballs are sooooo great. Finally a Friday go to when you crave Pizza. Jersey good. read more

This establishment is exceptionally clean, and the manager and staff are notably friendly. The pizza is outstanding, and the salads are consistently fresh. If you reside in Yulee, Wildlight, or even Jacksonville, please consider visiting with your entire family. read more

Closest to New York Pizza you can find in the area. If you think Domino's is good pizza, this is not the place for you!

If I could rate the food, service and atmosphere at 6 stars, I would!!! Outstanding customer service in a family style setting with AMAZING NY style pizza and calzones!!! They even have vegetarian and gluten free options! The owner, Chris, personally takes responsibility for the quality of food that is made and will make sure it is up to their high standards of quality food! Absolutely phenomenal customer service, with people that actually care whether or not you are satisfied. They are very busy, due to the high volume of customers that walk in and order and call for takeout, so just understand that it may take a little bit more time to make your food. Plan in advance. They also have pizza by the slice, with a wide variety of toppings to choose from. Overall, the best NY STYLE pizza in the area, hands down!!! read more

Decicco's Pizzeria - Pepperoni and extra cheese (which probably wasn't necessary) pizza!!! Absolutely delicious!!! - Pizza Near Me - Yulee, Florida

Just moved to Fern. Asked neighbors for the best pizza recommendation. Decicco's won hands down and didn't disappoint! Will be my go to but will try other local parlors but until I find better Deciccos is it! read more

We ordered 7 pizzas from DeCicco's today and they were ready in 30 minutes! When I went to pick them up they carried them all to my car for me and were genuinely nice people. Got them home - still hot and everyone loved it! Great pizza and great customer service! Will be back! Thank you again :) read more

Service okay. Pizza is burnt and dried out so I can't say about the taste. Not sure if I'm going back anytime soon. Maybe will give another try. read more

Decicco's Pizzeria - Dried out and burnt. Couldn't really appreciate the taste. Not sure if I'll be back. Maybe give it another try. - Pizza Near Me - Yulee, Florida

See all

Love love love, we go once a week. The smoked brisket pizza is soo good! Beats all other shops in Yulee and Fernandina. Skip Black cat and go here. read more

The pizza is delicious. The system for picking up is a little confusing. The place was packed. read more

Decicco's Pizzeria - Deluxe pie - Pizza Near Me - Yulee, Florida

I was told that when you leave NJ you spend the rest of your life looking for good pizza. My search has ended! It's great pizza. The thin crust...the delicious sauce...the white pizza...etc read more

Picked up pizza for a long all day road trip up the east coast. The restaurant was exceptionally clean and organized. They were really busy but was able to get helped right away. They had all the expected pizza condiments on the table, unlike other places. I wish we had time to sit and eat, but even on the road, the pizza was amazing and the left overs reheated well! This is a place that understands CRUST IS EVERYTHING! Without a great crust, pizza is subpar. We only had the Neapolitan NY style, but if we are ever back in the area, will try the Sicilian thick crust. The toppings were generous and top quality. It's a new place and wish them the best! read more

The pizza tasted like eating a piece of cardboard and was way overpriced. I had been told the place had good New York style pizza and I found out it didn't. read more

The cheese pizza and the margarita pizza at this place are decent ... Is it tri-state area quality pizza? I would say still not even close (we are from NJ close to NY), but I will say it is the closest tri-state area quality it in the area (Considering most of the other places in the area are FAR from tri-state area quality). What I will say is don't get "Mikes Alfredo" pizza, it is absolutely disgusting!!!!! It was like $26 and it totally went to waste, we couldn't even eat it. We expected the normal chunks of grilled chicken that all pizza places put on their pizza, but this was some kind of nasty shredded (what I surmise was canned) chicken and it was literally all over the pizza, including under the cheese, so there was no way to pick it off. It literally tasted like dog food. Will will def never order that again, but we will be back for the margarita and plain pizzas. read more

Hands-down best pizza in the area. Fresh, thin crust, and clearly very good ingredients make up these pies. The customer service is awesome too. This place has not been slow since I've been coming, and they have been consistently good since they've opened. Give them a shot. read more

If I could give 6 stars I would. Have you ever been to a place and wish you'd known about it before? This is DeCicco's! They're new to the area. The only thing better than the food are the owners! Highly recommend!! read more

We stopped in this evening, hadn't ever eaten with them before, but had seen all amazing reviews online so we had to try it. We got a hot honey pepperoni pizza, with the hot honey on the side and are glad we did be honey had a bit of a kick, but the pizza was delicious- the dough was so thin but crispy!! We had our puppy with us but were welcomed at a table outside and Rosario, the lady we met at the counter and has the best personality made sure the pup had some cool water. She was so sweet and made sure we had everything we needed. We will definitely go back bc there were multiple item on their menu that we took note of. For those who haven't been there before it is the type of place where they have a display case and you can choose just a slicer or two and they put it through their oven and you get a hot fresh slice instead of having to get the whole pizza. But you can get a whole pizza and they make it for you right then. It is in a pretty busy plaza in an area that is blowing up in new living spaces and businesses and is definitely a cozy type of place not super big, but it was very very clean and everybody there was very nice. Side note- they missed the Hot honey on the side and accidentally put it on so we got the original pizza and the one we ordered, so we dropped the extra to our local firehouse and multiple first responders had heard of it but hadn't had the chance to try it and were so excited to get a free pizza. read more

If I could give 10 stars I would couldn't ask for a more authentic New York style of pizza! Can't find anywhere better, plus the service is amazing and so welcoming, and the owners are the best they really make you feel like family!! read more

Excellent pizza, the loaded garlic knots are incredible but not as good as the fresh hot zeppolis. Great place with excellent service. We thoroughly enjoyed our dinner and will be back soon. read more

Delicious New York style pizza! Amazing crust and sauce! Best pizza in town. Great friendly service. Super busy! Order ahead for take out! 100% worth it! read more

Love the crust that cracks when you fold it. Great flavor on sauce and holds up well when bringing back home. Our new go to pizza place

Super authentic New York style pizza. At last, been searching for a great pizza place since moving down from Northeast. This place is the real deal and the staff is super friendly! read more

Like most people that live in Florida, I grew up in NY, and this is just like being back in NY. The pizza was great, and I'm looking forward to trying other things on my next visit. All the employees are great as well. I wish nothing but great success for this restaurant. I hope that my grand kids will take their own kids here just like I have, and they love it as well. They love pizza here and always ask for it every weekend. Updating my post and like every other time I ordered food from here it's been nothing but exceptional food and service. Thanks to everyone at DeCicco's. read more

Hands down best NY Style pizza in a 200 Mile Radius from Yulee. They have all authentic style pizza's - Pin Wheels are amazing

What an amazing addition to a growing area. The owners and staff are such friendly people. My family and I want to try some of their other items as we've only gotten the pizza, calzone, and meatballs but it's so difficult to stray away from those because they're so freaking good! Can't wait to be back very soon! read more

Great food, portions and service. Everyone inside was very friendly andbthr food is authentic New York style!!!

Pizza is awesome. I've had the plain cheese, sicilian, and grandma pie so far. I can't wait to try the trio and the vodka sauce. Staff is always friendly too. Great addition to the area. read more

Great NY-style pizza spot! The crust is crispy with a nice chew, and the garlic knots hit the spot. Staff was friendly and service was quick, even during a busy lunch hour. Solid choice for takeout or a casual bite. One star off just because seating is a bit limited, but the food more than makes up for it. read more

We moved here from Brooklyn, New York and I will tell you that if you've never had New York pizza this is the real deal The pizza is excellent especially the buffalo chicken. Got a nice little kick. The calzones are made to order. Nothing sitting around calzone is definitely big enough for two people and do yourself a favor and get the Zeppoli's for a dessert it's fried dough with powdered sugar absolutely delicious. this is not a chain place. This is a family own joint. read more

Decicco's Pizzeria - Buffalo chicken - Pizza Near Me - Yulee, Florida

This place has PHENOMENAL Pizza and service! The owners are great people and have a LOVE for what they do! You will NOT regret it and may have a new addiction; the Buffalo Chicken Pizza (and White Pizza) are unbelievable. read more

After hearing about their pizza, we finally tried it tonight and it lived up to everything I have heard! I moved away from Long Island, about 7 years ago, and haven't had a good slice of pizza since then. We are SO happy to have a REAL pizzeria only 15 minutes away! Keep up the good work and THANK YOU! read more

I absolutely love coming here! Not only is their pizza absolutely delicious but they are so incredibly kind and generous. And always put forward the effort to make sure your taken care of, but also to get to know you. Genuinely the best people. So kind hearted. Plus good food?! What could be better read more

They have gluten free pizza! This is a takeout place since it is so small. Closest to a true NY style pizza.

As a northerner I'm constantly scolded by the locals when I say there is no good pizza in the area. Finally we have a worthy place to get quality traditional pizza....Decicco's! I'd go 5 stars if it was just a bit more on the crispy side, but after all it is NY style so I'm not complaining and I'm sure I could request a more done crust. I can't wait to try there other styles. This is THE ONLY place from which I will order a pizza in Nassau county. It was even good as a reheated leftover. I hope they stick around and thrive. read more

Decicco's Pizzeria - 1/2 cheese,1/2 meat - Pizza Near Me - Yulee, Florida

So she told me it was no more pepperoni slice pizza so I'm siting there waiting for something else and all I see is her bringing slice after slice of pepperoni out like I'm confused did I need to get 10 slices or better to get some too smh never returning. read more

Phenomenal family owned business!!! You must give it a try!! Great to have such great tasting pizza in such a convenient location.

I have eaten here several times. Let's start with the good food I have tried so far. * cheese pizza, calzones, mozzarella sticks and wings were all phenomenal. Nice undercarriage, delicious, and everything you could want! I Ordered over the phone for to go and received my order in the estimated time they stated. Service was quick and friendly. Now for the bad: * Chicken parmesan pizza- while the flavor is delicious the pizza itself was so floppy/ soggy it was not enjoyable to eat. On a separate occasion I ordered a pepperoni& chicken pizza this was also floppy and soggy with zero undercarriage. Beef patty was also soggy- I had to air fry it when I got home for it to be eatable. It was delicious tasting but again it was so soggy. I would not order any pizza that had toppings as that seems to be the issue. I will also say it is BEYOND hot in there. I stood there for a few minutes cashing out and i was roasting! read more