Great food. Always fresh and made to order. Reliable, prompt and polite service. Easy delivery options!

Really great pizza! We had several flavors and they were all great. Excellent crust and great sauce.

We've been coming to stay at Point Pleasant Beach for 16 years. We stay very close to this place. Every year we eat here at least four or five times for lunch during the week. Earlier in the day, we got pizza and drinks. Then later in the day, my husband and my daughter decided to walk to the beach. They stopped really quick there to use the bathroom. My 13-year-old daughter was turned away from using the bathroom because it was "customers only." I understand you can't be letting everybody use the bathroom all day long but a 13-year-old girl? Needless to say, you have lost our business. I cannot recommend this place anymore. That is bad for business. read more

Fast service , fresh and clean food , very kids friendly . Highly recommend, especially with picky kids

Delicious pizza and super quick delivery. We ordered a pizza to be delivered to our hotel room after spending a nice day at the beach. The pizza not only was very good, and made to our specifications, but it also arrived quickly. We ordered via Grubhub. We would definitely order from this spot again in the future. read more

This is a great place for lunch and or late nite dinner. Lots of items on the menu to satisfy any choice and or desire. Price is great considering being on the Jersey Shore here in Point Pleasant. The Cheese Steak was great as well as the pizza. read more

DiMatteo's Pizza And Pasta - Chicken Parm...deeeelious... - Pizza Near Me - Point Pleasant Beach, New Jersey

My fiancé, who is born and raised in Brooklyn, and swore by Brooklyn pizzas his entire life, ordered the Margherita Pizza from DiMatteo's tonight. After the first bite, he said it was the best pizza he's ever had. And I agree! The pizza was delivered piping hot (even though we are about 6 miles away) with fresh ingredients (tomatoes, basil, etc.) with just the right amount of sauce and cheese, with thin, perfectly crispy crust that you don't even want to leave any of them uneaten. We weren't planning to have a big dinner but ended up finishing the entire pie. We are already planning to order some pizza again tomorrow when his parents come visit from out of town. Thanks DiMatteo's for the delicious pizza! read more

DiMatteo's Pizza And Pasta - Margherita Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Point Pleasant Beach, New Jersey

Unfortunately this is hands down the worst pizza we've ever had. Cheese was flavorless and crust was more crumbly than chewy. Ranch was nasty. The girl who took our order was nice so giving two stars instead of one. read more

Best pizza in the beach!! All summer long never disappointed. Quick deliveries. Love the sauce and the the Sicilian pizza is always our favorite!!! read more

They have great pizza & amazing wings! Pizza was cooked to perfection and they're wings are always crispy.. Their chicken alla matteo has such amazing flavor, the plum wine sauce was perfect and the grilled chicken was cooked nicely, and wasn't dry (sometimes people can over cook it, but not them!) read more

See all

this place is pretty good! menu wise they have a few options for everyone. they have a gluten free pie i saw on there menu. vegan option wise they have salads and a veggie wrap. the veggie wrap is pretty good. i've never tried one of there salads tho. the reason for 4 instead of 5 stars is just because they don't have many vegan options. as well as one time i got the wrap i found a piece of chicken in the container (it wasn't in my food but it was right next to my wrap). i didn't call because i didn't want a problem but that really did gross me out. but my coworkers come here almost every day and they say there food is amazing. they always get there specials of the day and there pizza and they say it's amazing always! there not too pricy as well which is great. definitely recommend trying!! hopefully they get more vegan options soon :) read more

Unfortunately this review is not a good one, the 2 stars are for quick delivery (about 30 min from time I ordered) and the lady over the phone was super nice. We ordered the margarita pizza, The pizza was under cooked and the sauce was mediocre. The crust needless to say wasn't "crusty" and was very bland. That's my first time ordering from them as I am not a local ,hopefully they will step up their game. read more

Disgusting. Accidentally ordered three dinners from this place as we were unaware they changed owners. This used to be Cuzzin's Pizza and they had quality food. This place is not the same and FAR from it. Sauce is bland. Every pasta dish ordered was overcooked. Gnocchi had the consistency of glue, penne fell apart on my fork as I tried to choke it down. My son has never said "no" to spaghetti and meatballs, and even he asked to be excused from the dinner table while eating. The service was good if that means anything, but honestly, until they change the menu (or learn how to cook) no use in ordering from here. read more

Have been ordering from this place for 5 years, but will NEVER order here from again. We had friends over this evening and ordered two heroes, only to find that the sandwiches were completely empty with little to none meat at all. After calling to ask if we can have new sandwiches sent (since we assumed that it must have been a mistake), we spoke with a worker who couldn't have been more rude and awful - telling us "it is what it is" in a very nasty way, using profanity to boot. Really disgusting service, would not ever recommend. Actually embarrassing . read more

DiMatteo's Pizza And Pasta - Pizza Near Me - Point Pleasant Beach, New Jersey

First time at this splace. Ordered a plain cheesesteak over the phone.No onions,peppers, mushrooms etc. Just a plain cheesteak. They charge extra for those things. Charging extra for onions? Anyway,I get out to the car, open up the styrofoam box, no it wasn't wrapped up in foil and I got a very skimpy steak sandwhich without cheese.I take it back and they argue with me. They insisted this was their plain cheesesteak. I said "no, if it doesn't have cheese on it,it's just a steak sandwhich" .Unbelievably, we go back and forth about this. They finally relented and offered to make it the right way, but after working in a restaurant and seeing what the kitchen does to food that's sent back, (spit ,lots of it ) I said no. I got most of my money back. They kept the tax. read more

DiMatteo's Pizza And Pasta - They called this sandwhich, without cheese mind you, a plain "cheesesteak" - Pizza Near Me - Point Pleasant Beach, New Jersey

Good solid neighborhood pizza, sandwiches and dinners. I just ordered the Veal Marsala and it was delicious. Served over linguine with garlic bread. Delivered no contact during Covid 19. Great service. Delivery guy was super nice. We both gave each other a thumbs up! Tip on delivery at least 20% support local business read more

Absolutely great pizza, and VERY quick delivery times. Just got a Margherita pizza - best I've had in the area! Kudos!!!

excellent pizza and service! We had the Chicken francese pizza, pepperoni, sausage, Sicilian, veggie, and plain pizzas. All were absolutely delicious. The Chicken francese and veggie were the best we have ever had!! Highly recommend! Thanks! read more

Nice place for a quick slice, which we grabbed and took to the beach. Service was quick.

Terrible service, rude and nasty. Delivery driver wanted a bigger tip and got upset. Manager was nasty. Always some kind of problem at this place. Low class. Don't waste your time here. read more

I work near this restaurant so I order from them quite often throughout the week, and I have never had a bad experience. No matter if I'm getting a sub, a pasta dinner, or one of their pizzas, I'm left happy and full. read more

When first changed from Cuzzins, I was not a fan. Gave them another chance a few months ago and have not been disappointed since! Good quality cheese on the pizza and their garlic knots are the best I have Ever had. read more

This is one of my favorite places to eat for lunch. However, they recently switched ownership and the food has been over cooked . It could very well be the transition stage but no one likes burnt food. Overall the food is very tasty! read more

If I could give this more stars I would. My favorite take out place! Everything here is delicious. My husband and I order here almost every weekend. Their chicken vodka parm is out of this world! You won't be disappointed. Staff is always friendly and delivery service is great. Thank you Dimatteos! read more

Came here for the first time. The service is amazing. Just good people. I even dropped a quarter without noticing and one of the kind employees picked it up as he was walking out and handed it to me. Seems like a place where customer service comes first read more

This is my favorite pizza place in Point Pleasant! It's in the perfect spot a block from the beach. If I'm in the mood to indulge I go for their Sicilian slice and a few garlic knots and I'm never disappointed. Their wraps are an awesome alternative to pizza- they're always so filling and delicious for a reasonable price. Definitely check out DiMatteo's it will for sure be your favorite spot to eat!! read more

This is my every day pizza spot. The staff is amazing and very accommodating. Theres an array of specialty slices daily, amazing pasta dishes and the subs are great too. Love DiMatteo's read more

I gave this place 1 star. I ordered lunch from there today as I work down the road from this restaurant and I was not happy. My lunch was burnt on the bottom and the girl was very rude on the phone as she cut me off mid sentence. Then when the order was picked you could tell she was bothered by it. I will not be ordering from there again until their customer service can be addressed. read more

I had lunch at DiMatteo's last week and the pizza was excellent! The staff was super friendly and the place was nice and clean! I highly recommend!!! read more