Tried one of Reno's newer pizza spots that's been getting some local buzz, and it definitely has that laid back Midtown hangout feel. The space is compact, super casual, and the arcade games give it a fun neighborhood vibe that makes it easy to settle in. We went with two 18 inch New York style pies, the Midtown and a Tomato option. First impression, you can tell they're using solid ingredients. Everything tasted fresh, which is always a good sign. Where it lost me a bit was in the bake. Parts of the Midtown came out a little too dark, with a crust that leaned more crunchy than that classic foldable, chewy texture. The flavor also skewed on the saltier side with a bit of extra oil. The Tomato pie was the vegetarian pick, and options are a little limited if you don't eat meat, so just something to know going in. This one had a lighter, slightly sweet flavor with a hint of spice, but it didn't have as much depth as expected. The toppings were chopped pretty fine, which changed the texture, and it ended up tasting more like a simple cheese slice than something super herby or garlicky. Pricing sits in the $20-$30 range, which feels a little high at first, but these are full 18 inch pies so you are getting a decent amount of food. Still, for that price, you want the bake to be more consistent. Overall, it feels like a spot that's close to hitting its stride. The foundation is there with quality ingredients and a cool concept, but refining the crust would really pull everything together. I would be open to giving it another try down the line, especially to see how it evolves. read more

See all

Super delicious new pizza spot. The girl who took our order was so sweet. The deli is my favorite out of the three slices we got. The inside is small but plenty of outdoor seating which is perfect for the upcoming warmer months. Our usual date spot is Press Start so i'm glad there's finally a great food spot right next door. read more

See all

Quick, easy, cheap Reno style pizza. Staff was helpful with suggestions. Vegan and gluten free options were available and done perfectly. Seating was very limited inside the location itself but more is available in the attached bar (press start) read more

Our first time here on a weekday for lunch. Parking on the street was plentiful at this time of day but I imagine at night it's a different story. Inside seating is very limited and only one table outside so unless you're doing takeout it would mean eating standing up. But the pizza might be worth it. The thin crust tasted very good. I ordered the Tri-State with pesto, garlic, pecorino and vodka sauce - it was a little messy but good. The plain cheese pizza was solid and so was the Midtown loaded with red sauce, pepperoni, sweet sausage, hot soppressata, mushroom, onion bells, and olives. We will definitely be back! read more

See all

Wow! This thin NY style pizza is delicious!! My new favorite! Love the plain cheese pizza and the classic pepperoni pizza. My only suggestion would be sturdier paper plates for dine-in orders as it soaked through 2 regular paper plates and likely would have ruined my clothes if I had set the plate on my lap. read more

Incredible exceptional pizza. Best by the slice. From owners of Art Town pizza. Tons of ingredients on whole pizza.

Amazing pizza. Slices are huge and inexpensive. Staff is super friendly. Small space inside but has a large patio outside. Connected to Press Start so you can play games while you wait. read more

Finally, a worthy NY style pizza spot in Northern Nevada. I had high hopes for this place as it's the same ownership as R-town and they make a solid Detroit style pizza - they did not disappoint. As a former New Yorker (Brooklyn), I can say this is the best NY style pizza you'll find in the area. And yes, I've tried all the other places. 100% will be going back, again and again! The only thing I would change is the cook time. If the base could be almost the same doneness as the crust it would be near perfect. read more

Such good pizza! The pepperoni was the best I've had in Reno. Reasonable price for a slice (~$5)

Amazing New York style pizza was really kind staff. Garlic knots are BOMB! No seating inside so make sure to take to go!

I wanted to like this place. I wanted to support a new business but the pizza was terrible. Burnt and tasted old. And they ask if you want ranch and then without telling you charge a dollar. The counter person acted like we were bothering them. Just not a good experience. And expensive . 2 slices and 1 drink 17.00 read more

Amazing pies! We tried the Gabagool, the Brighton, and the Deli and all were 10/10. The ranch was crazy good, heavy on the dill which I personally love. The staff was very welcoming and polite and answered all our questions. The barcade attached (not sure if this is a separate business or not) was really fun too (sign said 21+ after 7pm on a Friday). The only "downside" is that there's not a ton of seating inside so make sure to plan accordingly if you want to dine in. Looking forward to coming back and trying their other slices! read more

Nobel pie should be terrified... This is absolutely the best pizza I've had in Reno. Staff was amazing and the food was even better. read more

Went here tonight and honestly, it was a pretty big letdown. My entire reason for stopping was to surprise my wife with something new. I ordered two Midtown slices and two white pie slices. While I was waiting for mine to be heated, three different people came in after me, ordered single slices, and somehow got their food before I did. They first brought out the Midtown slices. I asked about the white pies and was told they were "heating up now" and would be ready shortly. About 10 minutes later, they finally called my name.  Once everything was ready, I took the order to go and headed over to my wife's work. My car was parked right across the street, and as I drove off, I opened the box and grabbed a Midtown slice. The crust was warm, but the toppings were almost refrigerator cold. Eating a cold slice from the refrigerator at home is one thing, but getting one like that just minutes after leaving the restaurant is pretty sad. As for the white pie I've seen on TikTok, it was basically garlic cheese bread with lemon on it. It was good but not something I'd ever order again. When I dropped the pizza off to my wife, I explained what happened and told her to make sure she heats the pizza up before eating it or she would likely be disappointed. When I got home, she texted me and said she heated the Midtown up in the microwave for about a minute and said it was perfect, she said the dough was really good and the toppings were excellent.  Even though this was my experience, I would definitely go back and give them another try. Mainly due to me being an R Town Pizza guy. However please note that that's the only reason why I would give them a shot again. As for recommending them to someone, I think I will hold off for now and wait until I give him another try. read more

So excited to see another NY style place in Reno (from the R Town owner, so it had to be good)! We tried the Gabagool, Deli (not pictured), Tomato, and Brighton. The Deli was our favorite, but all were flavorful, came out hot, and delicious! 10 minute wait to get our slices, and the staff were very friendly! There is standing room to eat your slices. Excited to come back and try the White Pie! read more

See all

I have had pizza in every corner of this country. I have slaved over fermentation and the perfect dough, and have had old Italian mentors but this is some real deal stuff. When you take a bite of something so iconic and it manages to make your face hurt from the smile it brings you know you have taken a trip back in time. I can't imagine that I will be filling a pizza craving anywhere else. A thank you is an understatement and the wonderful staff that and culture you have cultivated is something that should be seen and recognized. read more

So good I can dismiss the bad ranch. Every slice we tried was so tasty. I got 2 slices to begin with and had to go back for two more even though I was full. read more

Yup just as I thought, the pizza is great. Got the deli slice and it's one of the best New York style slices in town. The dough has a great chew, meat is high quality and the sauce is perfection. Also got garlic wings. They were ok. Not crispy enough and not a ton of flavor. The garlic knots were pretty good. I will definitely go back to get more slices. Awsome edition to the pizzia scene in Reno. And definitely in my top 3. read more

GREAT pizza!!! RUN don't walk to this new establishment! Pizza is everything I want in a pizza-fresh ingredients, flavorful crust and satisfying chew-just right. very friendly staff, plenty of parking. Will be going back soon! read more

Came to support a new company with a couple buddies riding bikes and giving it was a little bit late but we wanted to support a local business the long hair dude behind the counter was super rude and basically made it sound like he didn't want our business so we left went down to Noble pie and had good pizza and good environment read more

I don't normally leave reviews but i felt compelled to after a my second bad experience. As stated in some other reviews the dude with the long hair behind the counter was extremely rude for no reason. My first experience with this place was the pizza was great, the experience on the other hand was one of the worst. The staff are not friendly at all, we were hungry and decided to eat our pizza at the little table/bar inside. half way through our meal an employee came and grabbed our pizza that wasn't finished to throw it away. they were not busy at the time and there was plenty of room for other people, it was very weird. The second experience i had was the attitude of the guy with long hair behind the counter just being rude to customers and treating people with zero respect even his fellow coworkers and blatantly ignoring questions. I like the pizza but the attitudes i could deal without, doubt ill go back again, there are plenty of other places to get a good pizza. read more