price - $70 including tax and tip food - 5/5 service - 3/5 ambiance - 5/5 i got their spaghetto pomodoro and their margherita pizza. both dishes were super good!!! i can really taste the creaminess of the pasta and the crispiness of the pizza. i was really surprised at how good the burrata was on the pasta! the service was okay as the waiters checked up on us twice. it seems that they gave better service to other tables so that was a little bit disappointing. i tried asking where the bathrooms were located and if you know then you know. the bathrooms are super hard to find!!! everytime i asked i felt like the staff were getting annoyed which did not make me feel welcomed. on the other hand, the food and ambiance were really nice inside! if you don't care about the service then you can try this place out but if you do then maybe check out a different restaurant instead. read more

Eataly - SoHo - Spaghetto al Pomodoro, Margherita Romana Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

I sat down for a quick lunch on a weekday afternoon. Unlike the other Eataly locations in Manhattan, this Soho outlet is mostly patronized by office workers and locals. It is the newest of three venues so everything is sparkling, even on a snow trudged winter day. The variety and choices of Italian imported goods is astounding. Service in the spacious restaurant was quick and professional, as the lack of crowds is refreshing. I had the lasagna. Unlike some Italian restaurants, the bread does not come with the meal, and I passed on it. The lasagna was unlike any I have had in the states, and it must be due to the ingredients. It was not browned (the way I am used to) but was rich and very flavorful. Walking through the market section of Eataly I noticed in the refrigerated section, the same lasagna is available to purchase and heat up at home. That will be my next purchase! read more

Eataly - SoHo - Dining area - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Today was my anniversary and I had a great time with our server Jose, he was great, professional and very knowledgeable on the menu. We felt so comfortable with him. He made us feel so welcome. And he is just a great vibe. Food was delicious like always, Most definitely will be back read more

Eataly - SoHo - Focaccia breads, my favorite - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

The food is amazing, we wanted to cool off from the heat and we walked in to be seated. You can sit outside but we preferred inside. The staff is professional and courteous! It was a great experience and I'm looking forward to returning to try other dishes. read more

See all

I thoroughly enjoyed Eataly in SoHo. Eataly was a beautiful restaraunt with many options to choose from. It was raining and we ran into the restaurant. We sat at the bar to enjoy a drink. We were greeted by the bartender and he was very friendly and helpful. He gave us great suggestions on what to eat. I tried the split pea ravioli which tasted very fresh and a great spring meal. I will definitely like to return here for another visit! read more

See all

the ambiance was beautiful, the food is delicious, and no reservation is needed!! not to mention that tiramisu was the best i've had in a while. it's worth every cent paid for. the workers were the sweetest ever. she recommended us some amazing wine. i would definitely return! read more

See all

Enjoyed this nice and light caprese sandwich. I liked that the ingredients were fresh and not stale, especially the bread, which was crusty on the outside and soft on the inside. read more

Eataly - SoHo - Caprese Panino - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Came in with a reservation through resy, and me and my partner shared a pizza and pasta. I was genuinely surprised by the cacio e pepe, as I'm not usually that impressed with others, but this pasta was pretty flavorful, albeit a pretty small portion. The pizza was just okay in my opinion. We got a pizza with creme fresh dollaps, salami and basil. It didn't taste like much, and we dipped it into the pasta sauce to give it better flavor. I also felt like the service wasn't very good it took forever to get service and when we finished the meal, they asked if we wanted to see the dessert menu. I said yes, but then they never brought it out until we flagged someone from the front of house staff (not our waiter) to get the menu. Also they need a closer bathroom. It's really hard to get to this bathroom and not ADA accessible. I did not see an elevator as it's on a lower floor on the other side of the store in the Italian imports section... read more

See all

Not as large as other Eataly's, especially their Vegas location. Dined at the restaurant and was very satisfied with our meal. We had their MARGHERITA 'A RUOTA DI CARRO' pizza. That had to be one of the best pizza I ever had. I couldn't believe how thin the crust was. So tasty. I highly recommend their pizzas. We also had their Fettuccine Alfredo. The pasta was cooked al dente and was so good. To finish off our lunch we had the PANNA COTTA AI FRUTTI DI BOSCO. Great way to end our meal. The only knock, they need a hostess to greet and seat parties as there was nobody there. read more

See all

While in NYC for a short vacation, my wife and my cousin and I were roaming through SoHo on this past Sunday afternoon. My wife and I had been to the Eataly on the Las Vegas Strip at the Park MGM, so we figured it would be a similar experience. We walked in at 3pm on Sunday and were able to get seated right away, the restaurant was pretty full. We split a fried calamari appetizer and a mushroom pizza while we had some drinks, I had an Aperol Spritz and my cousin had a couple Italian beers. The good came out quickly and hot, and the staff were responsive to our needs. The place was busy but not super crowded or too loud, aside from the restaurant there is a whole market area for purchasing food to go or stocking up on authentic Italian culinary supplies, their dried pasta is more expensive than the generic pasta you buy at a supermarket but I have a feeling it'd be much better. I'd try it again, maybe next time we're in town. read more

Eataly - SoHo - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

It's one stop shopping here at Eataly in Soho. Great place to shop. Cookies were on sale. Got a few batches of wafers and Italian snacks. We had already had lunch earlier. Went to get a Cappuccino and the Lemon Blueberry Cookie. Nice to take a break from shopping. Lots of tables and chair to dine here. Staff very helpful and even security. Definitely, be back to try the pizza and pasta. Lots of prepared meals in the fridge and packed ready to go. Two floors and to this Eataly-Soho. read more

Eataly - SoHo - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Fettuccine had a good cheesy and creamy flavor but was served not hot enough. Server Hector was not super attentive at all. He came up to the table like 10-15 mins after we sat down "Hey do you know what you want to order" or something along those lines and only saw him again at the end of the experience after a little wait to ask for the check and when he dropped the check initially and to give it back after ringing it, he didn't say a thing...very strange experience. read more

Eataly has an abundance of selections ranging from pastas, baked goods, desserts, pizza and grocery items. The Soho location is well maintained. It's always clean and staff are available to assist if needed. I got pizza take out from the front of the store. There are many options from meat to vegetables or just cheese. The portions are decent as well. It was hard to choose because I like different toppings. Settled with the classic Margherita, added the Massese which had spicy salami and the burrata and prosciutto. Staff does ask if you are dining in or to go and whether to heat up or not. Pizzas are flavorful and though more then average in price, the flavor definitely makes up for it. My favorite was the salami. Though a bit spicy, that mixed with the tomato sauce made a good combo. Burrata and prosciutto, a bit salty but still good. You cant go wrong with the classic Margherita. Clean restrooms on the lower level. read more

See all

There is a restaurant, café, and small grocery area. Came by for the tiramisu festival, they had some for sale in the bakery display case and in their grab and go refrigerated section. It was a much smaller selection of everything really compared to the Westfield location. We tried their lemon flavored and pistachio flavors (it was expensive at $10+ for a couple of bites). FYI, there are bathrooms in the lower level. read more

Eataly - SoHo - Ambassador program - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Went for the tiramisu fest: 3/5 pistachio- very nutty but where are the layers & the coffee? 2/5 lemon- so sweet, when something is lemon flavored, it's expected to be at least somewhat sour, this especially had no layers & no coffee read more

See all

Overall I tried dining at this eataly to try it out but I think it's better to just browse around and shop. I tried the tuna tartare, espresso martini, short rib puree, and tiramisu. Out of everything I was pleasantly surprised by the espresso martini and tiramisu which was really good! The others were just okay and on the pricy side. I like browsing in the market area to see what they have and sometimes they have unique items! There's also a fridge area and there's 2 floors! read more

See all

The place was so amazing, it was one of the biggest restaurant we ate at all week! I would definitely go just for the vibe. Food was such an experience especially with them presenting fettuccine Alfredo with the cheese wheel. We got our food pretty quickly, but it did take a while to get finished up to receive the check. We used this night to catch up with some old friends so it was exactly what we needed. read more

Eataly - SoHo - Romana Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

The ambiance and lighting were top tier. So whimsical and romantic both in daytime to sunset to nighttime vibe. The staff were also all very kind and accommodating and helpful. Came during their restaurant fest 2 course deal for $26. Chose the bruschetta and kale salad as appetizers. bruschetta was the best thing here! Kale salad was too hard and chewy, raisins were a nice touch though. The main course pizza was surprisingly big size which was great! The thin chewy crust with minimal flavor was not my style though. The cacio e pepe pasta was great at first but then was really just plainly flavored pasta, cooked a bit too hard, with too much saltiness flavor to it. The $6 small bites of fried rice and cheese ball had a nice fried exterior but needed another dimension of flavor inside which could've been done with any meat. Also got the mini tiramisu which was definitely veryyy small but the flavor had such a rich coffee flavor if you like that. Overall was a good experience but sadly not a favorite. read more

See all

This is the place to come for all things Italian - especially food and drink! Definitely if you're visiting NYC, plan a stop by here (there are other Eataly locations around the city too). Inside the Eataly building here in SoHo is a full blown market - think Balducci's or an Italian themed boutique-y Whole Foods. Fresh meats, produce, fruit and a bakery. Then tack on a latte and coffee bar and miles of fresh made pastries beautifully laid out in display cases (see my vids). A beautiful and shady outside dining area with large shade umbrellas. And then a full service Italian restaurant serving housemade pasta THAT TAKES ONLINE RESERVATIONS (through Yelp - easy peasy!). We strolled in on a Saturday late morning and the restaurant was packed with brunch-goers. The aroma in the air of fresh pasta, garlic and herbs and seasonings was to die for. Duly noted for our next visit! We opted for a more quick and easy grab and go pastry and a hot latte. Lots to see - the place is massive. Plan to hang out, browse, shop, take a load off (in the summer; it's a great place to beat the heat!) and spend a couple leisurely hours perusing or pop in for a quick in and out. Definitely a must see when in NYC! read more

See all

Stopped by the market to pick up pasta to cook. Got some black squid linguine, the high quality was obvious and elevated my quick easy dinner. I hate to cook, so I need all the help I can get. Also one of my go-to spots for buying gifts, you can't go wrong with a special bottle of olive oil. read more

A friend was visiting from the West Coast and we met in SoHo. I had suggested Eataly as it would be less crowded on a Saturday evening. We sat on the patio and perused the menu. We chose two dishes from the $26 Taste of Napoli prix fixe menu. Mortadella E Pistacchio on sourdough bread and Spaghetti All'Arrabiatta. I had a cappuccino when I arrived. No bread was given before our meal. We drank a bottle of Pelegríno. The server didn't offer us cheese which I requested. The food was fine but the pasta was lukewarm. We didn't finish it and skipped dessert. Slowly lots of customers started coming so the atmosphere became more jovial. I like all three Eataly's and this one is the smallest read more

See all

Pros: I love the aesthetic of this place--it has such a great vibe! There's a solid variety of beverages and entrées, plus plenty of seating. The space is large and open, making it a great spot for bigger groups. I ordered the Pinot Nero with the pomodoro, which was a nice pairing. Cons: I felt like the dish that I ordered lacked flavor--it seemed like something was missing.. in addition to that, I also felt that our server wasn't very attentive, and I often had to track him down for things like cheese, water, and the check. read more

See all

I love this location. They have the best tiramisu I've ever had, and their coffee is incredible. Moreover, the service was beyond professional, and I truly enjoyed my recent dinner. Their pastas are wonderful, and the drink list is just right. The interior space is both stunning and intimate. Five stars for a lovely experience. read more

See all

Dined here for lunch with my daughter. I knew we didn't have much time-- we went with the Spaghetti and a pizza. Me both were under the impression the spaghetti would come with red sauce, which instead had Alfredo. The pasta was okay, the pizza was great. The service was excellent, our server constantly checked in on us. The ambiance was pretty laid back and both had adults and a few tables of children. Eataly has a large market both downstairs and upstairs, which was not too crowded. However, I was in a rush and didn't have any time to stop and really look around. This location is much better than the location that was in Westfield near the World Trade Center. I would definitely to this location, in the future, and hopefully run into the same server. read more

See all

We ordered the Calamari, Le Tagliatelle, Spaghetto Alla Carbonara e Tartufo, and we received a free Margherita Verace pizza from a holiday promotion. The calamari was delicious but the portions were inconsistent. Tables around us had ordered it as well, we unfortunately had far less than others. I felt like I was eating fried zucchini with bits of calamari. The tagliatelle was bland and not memorable. It needed additional cheese to save it. The carbonara was decent. The flavors were good and texture of the meats was delightful. The Margherita pizza was average, the tomato sauce was sweet but other than that it was nothing to rave about. The service and ambiance were terrible. Food arrived slowly. No cheese was offered when pasta was served. We had to ask several waiters for it. Received the cheese after 10 minutes. We also asked for chili flakes for the pizza. The flakes never arrived. I saw the table next to us getting the flakes even though they didn't have pizza. They looked confused. A fellow diner dropped her purse and the hostess walking by stepped over it. She then led other patrons over her bag. It was such a bewildering scene to witness. Service was just disappointing. Slow to serve, fast to give bill. Ambiance was bad. Restaurant is connected to the market. The restaurant should consider preventing shoppers from going through the main section of the restaurant if they are not dining. What's the point of having separate entrances? People in full winter gear stomping by diners. Kitchen is also far from the restaurant. Servers have to walk through the market to bring food in. Overall, it was a negative experience. read more

See all

I've eaten at a couple of Eatalys, including in Flatiron, in Italy and in Japan. The restaurant here really steals the show - it's sleek, pretty modern, but still fits with the Eataly aesthetic - and seems to be the prime reason people come here. For us as well. We were a table of four and had four amazing wines. They have something to fit everyone's taste buds. Food is great as well - the pizza is fantastic and the dough is really good. The calamari and the burrata were great as well. The only draw back was service - the place was pretty busy and you can definitely see the waiters running around a bit. They did a decent job of keeping up with our table. There was also some conflicting info we got about certain dishes and wines from two different waiters. Other than that, no other issues! read more

Eataly - SoHo - Marguerite pizza, calamari - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

In my seemingly endless expedition to find the best grocery store chicken on the planet, I was shocked about how many people in the comment mentioned Eataly's bird. I remember Eataly having the juice in the 2010s, but feel like I haven't heard a peep about them since 2020. Their Lemon flavored tissi ran $16.90, which is STEEP for a bird. I grabbed the chicken and took it right outside Eataly, as they had a few tables there, primed to sit and rawdog a tissi. Overall for the price, this one was disappointing. I scored it at 7.5/10, which is right in the middle of my rankings currently. The breast was just so dry, as I needed a sip of water after the first bite. Tough. The Lemon flavor felt like a La Croix, as there was just a small hint of flavor. 7.5 may seem high, but it wasn't a bad chicken. It tasted fresh. I wasn't mad at it, but it just wasn't great. 7.5 feels perfect to me, and at the end of the day I have to trust myself. IG @jnov_ Tiktok @jnov__ read more

I usually go to the Eataly in flatiron and this was my first time in the SoHo location. The food is just as good and maybe even better. There is just one Italian restaurant but they make everything delicious. The arancini is always a solid choice if not a must order even if just getting a snack. High quality pasta and good vibes! A great place to stop in for a bite and a rest while and after shopping! read more

See all

Was finishing up my shopping in SoHo and bumped into Eataly. I'm so happy I did. Upon entering, the restaurant was very airy and inviting with a lot of space and the music was not too loud- perfect to have a conversation. I came here for a late lunch, and I was seated without reservation promptly. My server was an absolute delight. The food came out very quickly. I ordered an aperol spritz which was fabulous. Then, I ordered the chicken Milanese. This was probably one of the best ones I've had for I didn't need to use the lemon since the flavor was so good. Lastly, I had the Italian parfait which consisted of yogurt and fruits and granola with honey on top. It was scrumptious. My server was so kind and gave me the aperol spritz on the house. This restaurant is lovely for any occasion, and I would definitely return to try the pastas! read more

See all

Centrally located in SoHo. Very pretty decor. Good selection of drinks and food. It's an Italian marketplace, restaurant, deli, pizzeria and bakery all in one roof! read more

Extremely rude counter service, and clearly too overrun with tourist traffic for their own good. The patio outside has signs indicating that you can order inside and have food brought out to you. I proceeded to do so before taking a call, and was then curtly informed after paying and almost being double charged that there is in fact no table service to the patio. I checked back inside every few minutes, but no one would indicate when or where my order was. read more

Food was decent. The spotlight of the night was the tiramisu dessert. Everything else was just okay. Our service was slow. And while we wait the fire alarm went off. But my review is only about the food. Not the ambiance. That they can't control. read more

See all

What do you do after a day of bopping and shopping around SoHo? You forget to make a reservation and then panic add your name to a bunch of lists that all have a 45+ minute wait. Eataly was the first to have a table for us and there was so much to love about our visit. Firstly, like all Eataly locations, the space is gorgeous. From the dining area to the market and bakery, it's beautiful and feels like a special place. We walked around a bit while waiting for our table, picked up a few groceries from the top and bottom level and marveled at all of the *quite expensive* Italian goods. We picked up everything from a bag of dried pasta to an Italian toothbrush to a canned seltzer and continued our walk around outside until we got a text that we had a table. Even if you don't have plans to stay and eat, Eataly is a fun place to browse and shop, even for a couple small things. We skipped drinks since we were just here for lunch and went straight to entrees. While my friends loved their dishes, I was not a huge fan of mine. I got the Le Tagliatelle bolognese and it just did not have any flavor. I am never one who adds salt to a dish (a mountain of parm, sure), but I added quite a bit to this one. My friends gave it a try and were also surprised at how bland it was. It has wonderful reviews here on Yelp so maybe it was just a fluke serving, but I wouldn't return for it. The space is gorgeous, so it is worth a visit. If you plan on eating, maybe stick to a glass of wine and a pizza or some apps. Buon appetito! read more

Came here for the first time while shopping in soho. The service was extremely slow, however the food was really good and we were seated promptly with no wait time. read more

See all

While walking around we saw Eataly and decided to stop in for coffee This location is really nice, smaller than the other one I knew but the same great food and service. read more

Eataly - SoHo - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

I visited this location 24 hours after visiting Eataly in Boston, MA, for the first time ever. Anywhere you see the sign for Eataly, consider it the sign of happiness and joy! You're safe here, and mostly nothing here will disappoint you! I believe the brand brainwashed me but with nothing other than their freshness and deliciousness! Lol In this location I only spent 5 minutes! I think it's a mini location compared to their other locations ? Or it could be me who didn't explore it enough! I literally got an Espresso, Latte for my cousin, and 2 desserts ( Tiramisu del Nonna and Panna cotta ) The store looks amazing inside and outside! The staff at the coffee was nice and I really liked the Baristas! They were very nice! Please be aware of negative reviews describing this place as expensive!! It is expensive but for me expensive could be justified if it's worth it and it's definitely worth it! Try it, vote for the review , message me, or compliment me with any comment or question, and don't forget to ... Pray for me ;) read more

Eataly - SoHo - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

My husband and I dined here this past weekend after we checked out the Coca Cola Spiced Pop up nearby. I've always wanted to eat at one of the Eataly locations and I got lucky that day. We browsed through the market area within Eataly where one can buy pastries, order coffee, or buy Italian products like pastas, sauces, gelato and more. We had dinner in their restaurant. I ordered the Il Pollo Alla Milanese and Margarita pizza and my husband ordered the Gli Agnolotti. He enjoyed his dish very much. We both enjoyed the margarita pizza a lot. The pizza was flavorful and yummy. I wish I had more of it. The pollo alla Milanese was alright. I think it would have treated better with the aioli sauce but I couldn't have the sauce because it was made with raw eggs. They substituted the sauce with marinara instead. Next time I'll stick with the pizzas. The ambiance was really nice. The wait staff were really helpful and answered all of our questions. I wouldn't mind dining here again and trying other dishes. read more

See all

My brother and sister in law were in town while stopping over on their way to Paris. We decided to eat at Eataly. First the great. The service was spot on. No matter who came by the table and a request was made of them, the request was fulfilled immediately. No "this is not my table, I'll let your server know." Kudos for that. Next the ambience. Place was a little loud despite it only being half full at dinner time. Or half empty depending if your a half full/half empty visionary. Lastly, most of our dishes we pretty good. I had the pasta with white clam sauce and other assorted shell fish. My brother and sis shared a pizza and a Caesar Salad. I also partook in a Caesar Salad. Here's where the deficiency comes in. Caesar did not make this salad. Lacking was shaved cheese, anchovies and croutons. The dressing was trying to resemble a Caesar dressing but fell very short. Some of us actually like authentic Caesar Salad that includes anchovies but most places leave it off the salad. Yes, worth going to but not a repeatable dining experience. read more

Eataly - SoHo - Had to ask for the cheese separately. - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

I went in for a glass of wine and the gratuity was put in for me at 20%. I would have left more but since it was added in by the bartender I left and complained to the manager on duty. This implied that was not going to tip...this was horrible service indeed... read more

I had one of the best meals at this Eataly location. The beet salad and the Neapolitan pizza with a drizzle of honey was magnificent. The service was impeccable. It's a bummer that this Eataly location doesn't get as much love as Flatiron and I actually think is so good for a lunch or brunch on the weekends - after all it's in SoHo. read more

See all