As someone without an Eataly back at home, this was a fun market to browse and a convenient spot to buy fruit and ready-to-eat foods. Everything was nicely presented and seems of good quality; I wanted to eat all the foccacia sandwiches and pizza slices I walked by! Their m pre-packed veggies and proteins were super convenient and tasty. The shrimp salad was pricey but the shrimp pieces were big and perfectly cooked, simply dressed in olive oil and herbs. I came back an again for their broccoli rabe as well, nicely textured with a slight heat from the chili flakes-- so tasty even cold! Patrons can also sit down and enjoy a freshly made meal in the store too. The seating is right in the middle of the store, so one might get brushed by shopping baskets. There was a cafe and gelato spot as well. The workers were friendly and cheerful :) There's a self checkout that people seem to forget about near the checkout counter. And they have cooking classes too! Whether you're a curious cook looking for fun ingredients or just hungry, Eataly is worth spending some time to check out! read more

I adore Eataly because of the space, the vibe, and the people watching. They have a new cafe area that is glorious. I go there often. I struggle to enjoy the food, which is kind of bizarre. Their gelato tastes like it is held together with a non-dairy thickener like guar gum. Their $22 rotisserie chicken is no where's as tasty and tender as the $10 rotisserie chicken at Whole Foods. Their pizza slices are creatively and beautifully crafted, but the vast majority have only a very slight coating of tomato sauce which you cannot taste, and little to no mozzarella. I don't enjoy their $10+ slices nearly as much as the $4 slice down the street. Everything that I order there looks better than it tastes. To be fair though, I have not had a sit-down meal there in a long time. Several years ago I did order a roast beef sandwich at their carving station, and it was nearly 50% hard white fat. WTF. I feel like I just can't win when I try their food. But I LOVE going there so I keep trying. When all is said and done, I love the place. Sometimes they have music and/or tastings, which are fun. So more recently, I just buy a yogurt or cappuccino and enjoy the space. read more

First things first: this restaurant/market is HUGE and a little overwhelming, but in the best way. They have so much to see and enjoy, including watching their cooks prepare fresh, homemade pasta. They have so many little stores within the larger store. We ate lunch here and enjoyed it very much. We had a reservation but didn't need on at noon on a Tuesday. Our server was very nice, although she disappeared a few times. The kids meal is yummy and a great value. read more

Eataly - Flatiron - Tagliatelle alla Bolognese - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

As a born and raised Italian from the south, it's hard to find a place in the USA that doesn't make me cringe when they call their recipes "original" or "traditional". I've been coming to Eataly for various reasons throughout the years and finally I was able to try La Pizza La Pasta with some friends a few weeks ago, and I can tell you; I was soooo surprised! The carbonara was so creamy and the guanciale was crisp to perfection. The aperol spritz was perfectly done. The ambiance was cute. The service was great. I don't know what to say!! And the market part of Eataly may be a bit expensive, but the quality is all there. I get my meats from here every week. :) perfect place to find imported goods and snacks, too. read more

Eataly - Flatiron - Carbonara - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

I've never seen the store quite like this one. I feel like I was in Italy. Fresh foods to buy like a grocery store, but then also had a few restaurant opportunities inside. We opted to buy a number of things for the store and just taste them at our table. Everything was imported from Italy and it was a true Italian experience. From the produce to the cheese to the breads and pastries, this place was impressive. The staff are very nice and helpful. If you come in here, plan to stay for about an hour it's that cool of a place. read more

See all

Eataly is a must stop any destination I go where they have a location, including Italy! This location is everything you want. Plenty of food options, desserts, pantry and food staple shopping, fresh produce, restaurants. Overwhelming in a good way. This visit I went to the pasta cafe restaurant in the back and ordered the classic carbonara. It was savory and filling. I also ordered the arugula and tomato salad for some lighter bites to round out the meal. Salad I would not order again (a bit plain) but served its purpose as a break from the richness of the pasta. read more

See all

Despite the hoopla, I suspected this wouldn't be my kind of place. And I was right. I don't know how you differentiate this restaurant from other places to eat within the Eataly space. The menu seemed over-priced with fancy names and descriptions for basic stuff, but we decided to stay, all opting for the $25 lunch. (A la carte costs more.) You get a dish, plus one of three sides. Here's what each of the three of us chose: *** Crema di piselli (pea soup) *** Pizza zucchine & stracciatella (individual pizza that looked and sounded better than what was executed) *** Insalata Di Barbabietola (nothing-with-nothing salad; my choice) Our sides were: ** mediocre arancini described as "crispy riso scotti rice, Granarolo Pecorino Romano, DOP, black pepper." Eh. (What's DOP?!) ** Patata Fritta -- fried "hand-torn" russet potatoes. (A better choice.) Our overly-exuberant server asked what kind of bread we'd like, giving us a choice of two. Would've been nice if she mentioned that for four lousy slices and an unseasoned dish of olive oil we'd be charged $5.50. We assumed -- bad assumption -- it was gratis. Eataly is interesting to wander through. You can buy bread, produce, meat, prepared foods. But if your tastes align with mine, go elsewhere for a sit-down lunch. When I mentioned Eataly to my non-Yelping foodie daughter, she agreed. "I don't particularly like it either," she said. read more

See all

A friend of mine met me at Eataly: La Pizza and La Pasta last night and it was a nice meal, beautiful decor and vibe. I only ordered spaghetti aglio e oglio ($21) and it was quite good, but not the best I've had. read more

Eataly - Flatiron - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Stopped by the pasta counter for a quick bite and a glass of wine. The fresh pasta concept and open kitchen make for a fun atmosphere, and the quality of the ingredients stands out. read more

Eataly - Flatiron - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

We went to have dinner at Eataly. We tried the Tuna Tartare and Buttersquash pasta with Lager. The food was delicious and the portion size was sufficient for one. Enjoyed our meal here. read more

See all

O M G I can't hardly believe how much I enjoyed the panini that I had at Eataly for the first time today. I ordered the FARCITA MORTADELLA and had it warmed, with a regular lemonade. Between the taste and the Italian music playing in the background, I could have sworn I was back in Rome or Florence. It was just a brief stay that created a delicious and lasting moment. I can't wait to go back. Oh, and I came on a Sunday, so the feel was extra special. All of the employees that I interacted with were kind, helpful and gracious. It's a tad overpriced, that's my only criticism. read more

Eataly - Flatiron - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

I came to this location again to try some of the mini versions of cream puffs. Four for $10- truly filling. The whipped cream and chocolate whip were delightful. Light. The chocolate chocolate small square mignon, great consistency, melting slowly, delectable. The service at the counter fast. This area of Eataly is order--and-find-your-own-seat self service. The interior is okay, but a bit dark. I sat by the door. It was very crowded. A lot of tourists. Some locals on computers. read more

See all

What a store! Let me just say it looks smaller than it is. Holy smokes it's like never ending maze. People everywhere, but in a good way. I'd say make sure you have time and patience for this spot. They had various samples of cheese and meat. The smells in this place are fantastic and I wasn't even hungry. I kept my take homes simple-- spicy popcorn and pistachio cookies. I haven't tried the popcorn yet, but thought the cookies were just okay (not much pistachio flavor). read more

Eataly - Flatiron - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Another great meal here. I think IL Pesce is my favorite of the restaurants in Eataly Flat Iron District. I shared the following with my friend: Ostrich Dozen Pesce - these were a dozen oysters from Maine. They were actually really good. Tasty. We each had a glass of different white wine. Pictures of the bottles are shown. The wine was very smooth not too dry. Insalata di Mare Pesce (Seafood salad) - that was ok. Needed more oomph for our taste buds. Octopus salad - two nice pieces perfectly made and absolutely delicious! The rustic bread was sooo good. Served cold though and wish it was warmer but still tasted good. Dipped in olive oil. I ate two big slices. Wow so good. The tonnarelli ai Gamberi... which is muscles, shrimp and lobster. Very delicious! I don't want to share again. Urbani black truffle pasta. I really needed more, but considering I had so much bread I didn't think it would be a good idea, but it was really good. Desert - tiramisu is something that I never order because I have always found it typical and boring. I opted to forgo dessert and so friend ordered the tiramisu. I was encouraged to try a bite. WOW! It was out of this world. It came with some type of cellophane wrapped around it, and when it was removed, there was all this creamy goodness floating down the sides of it. It was not boring. I was completely hooked. I think I ate most of it with the very delicious cappuccino that was served to me. I would like to go back soon just to have the octopus and the tiramisu. 5 stars for yesterday's meal! Oh and Armando was friendly and serviceable this time. I think he may have been my waiter when I last visited a year ago. PS: if you don't dine here, go and experience the store. It's a big market with everything Italian. Love it here. I think you'LL find it interesting. read more

See all

There is plenty to see and eat at Eataly! From multiple restaurants on site, to fresh produce, fish and meat there is something for everyone. During this visit, I stopped at their coffee/pastry bar for an espresso martini. For $18, it had fresh espresso and was small but good! The seating area was very crowded as it is on most days with tourists. read more

Eataly - Flatiron - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Nice meal with friends. I enjoyed my steak and potatoes it came with. Friends liked their pasta only one said it was a tad salty. I also picked up bread on the way out downstairs. And it was delicious!! read more

See all

An nyc staple! Great location lovely food, nice rooftop also great for a grocery store run since they have the finest Italian selection.

If you're in the neighborhood definitely visit. Great assortment of Italian specialties, fresh pasta meats and mozzarella. Feeling hungry or in need of a snack? Lots of sit down and quick grab items available. The place is not inexpensive and I'd say definitely geared towards being a tourist destination. While you're there, be sure to pop over to Madison Square Park for a beautiful stroll. read more

Eataly offers a little bit of everything. From groceries, to fresh meals, bakeries, coffee spots, restaurants, bars, and plenty of space to sit and enjoy time with yourself or with others. It was a "one-stop" spot for almost anything Italian food-related, with lots of Italian products for purchasing (appeared to be imported from Italy), it was kept clean, the staff were very nice, and the energy in there overall was great. My husband and I grabbed a cappuccino and a pistachio loaf pastry at the front café near the entrance, and both were 5 stars (delicious). Then we walked toward the back where the restaurants and bars are and tried the gnocchi with meat sauce, which was delicious and very fresh. (Apologies that I missed to taking photos of the menus at each place.) If you're in the Flatiron area, definitely stop by Eataly. There's truly was something for everyone. read more

Eataly - Flatiron - Gnocchi from one of the bar top restaurants inside toward the back - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Came here for a quick work lunch with the team. Service was quick as expected in midtown when going for lunch. Noodles were great and cooked to our specific firmness preference read more

See all

As with their other locations, Eataly serves as both an Italian Market Place and an Eatery, all within a single venue. This is perfectly situated in the Flatiron District of New York City. This site features numerous restaurants, including the Amalfi Rooftop. Additionally, there are several cafes, takeout meals, a gelato bar, pizzas, and a selection of meats, seafood, cheeses, pastas, sauces, and other delicacies. This is a remarkable experience located directly across from Madison Park, which should be enjoyed when visiting New York City. read more

See all

If you don't have time to read my review let me tell you one thing! I drove 4 hours each way twice in my Birthday month to eat there. Isn't that enough? So stop reading and find your way to the closest Eataly to you and they are expanding!! But before your start your trip to the closest Eataly, remember this! There is no better Eataly store than the Flatiron Flagship store in the U.S. !! ( I heard that West Palm Beach location is competing! ) To all Elites, Yelpers, Foodie friends and followers in the DMV area ... please pray that the rumors are true and Eataly will be opening in Tysons Corner sometime soon!! ( at least a year :( ) ... What I love about this location is that the ambiance starts from the outside!! Once you get in, you feel the warmth of Italy with the crowds! You feel like you're in an Italian town or Italian Paradise!! If you think I'm crazy to drive 8 hours and twice in one month to eat, my friend!! Sorry, you're wrong! :) I saved a round trip flight + hotel to Italy to eat there! ;) plus I didn't have to use my vacation days! Both my trips were on Sundays were it's very easy to park outside! If you never been there before let me give you a quick tour! This Eataly is like a bunch of market stations, grocery store ( with all its departments), a few bars, a few restaurants and one rooftop bar and restaurant. - Caffè Lavazza & Caffè Vergnano both offer amazing coffee drinks, small bites and pastries. - La Pasticceria: monoporzione(single portion) desserts. Authentic Italian quality!! You won't feel tired or bloated after eating it!! - IL Gelato: Gelato shop which I believe it's Venchi brand but I'm not sure. - Pizza Alla Pala: Roman-style pizza by the slice. - Focacceria: Italian sandwiches in Focaccia bread .. premium toppings only! It can be heated if you want but in my opinion not all of them should be heated up. - Rosticceria E Panini: Rotisserie-roasted chickens, freshly-baked bread, roasted vegetables, and a variety of hot and cold Italian panini fill the store with an irresistible aroma that draws guests to Rosticceria e Panini every day. TRY THE PORCHETA PANINI!! At the grocery section you will French premium items, imported items and authentic Italian items only! The best and most rare cold cuts and cheeses! Fresh pasta! Pre cooked meals! Fresh Italian bread ( so many kinds!!) In between all of that you will find the restaurants and bars which makes it interesting to sit in the coziness of the other shoppers, products and stations around you! The ambiance and neon signs takes it to a whole different level. I tried La Piazza ! the vibrant heart of Eataly NYC Flatiron! Under the red neon signs of Eataly and right in the middle! I also tried the roof top ( Serra) which seems to run a seasonal popup and when I was there it was the Amalfi! And I was really transported to the Amalfi!! Lemons everywhere! The carbonara pasta from the brunch menu was unbelievable! The real carbonara made with guanciale, egg yolks, Pocorino Romano cheese and NO CREAM!! There are a few more restaurants that I didn't get the capacity try but it's the Bar Milano, Il Pastaio di Eataly, Il Pesce, Il Patio di Eataly, La Pizza & La Pasta. Some of the menu items are mutual between all of them while a few items are unique to the spot .. I'll say check the menu, either go for the unique item or if your item is available at a few of them then pick by ambiance and availability! That was my rule! I took family size pre-made lasagna, eggplant parmigiana, family size Tiramisu and Panna cotta and everything were more than amazing!!! A tip that no one will tell you! The white plastic containers for Lasagna and Eggplant parmigiana are oven safe but you have to wrap it in foil! I forgot the instructions but I remember it was so hard to find and that's the only negative point but once I found it and applied it, the food tasted exactly like fresh! I also took Focaccia rossa, spicy Mortadela ( picante) and spicy Emilia salami, and cheese and made amazing sandwiches at home! ... anyone is asking which kind of cheese? A unique cheese that reminds me of the Roumi cheese from Egypt ( Roumi cheese is very unique to Egypt and the funny thing that Roumi means Roman!!) .. the cheese was called Piacentinu Ennese. Piacentinu Ennese is a distinctive Sicilian sheep's milk cheese from the Enna province, famous for its striking yellow color and flavor from saffron and black peppercorns, offering a mild, savory, and slightly spicy profile, traditionally handmade using ancient methods and aged to varying degrees. INSIDER TIP ;) ASK TO JOIN THE AMBASSADOR PROGRAM AT THE CUSTOMER SERVICE BEFORE YOU JOIN !!! Try it, vote for the review , message me, or compliment me with any comment or question, and don't forget to ... Pray for me ;) All my 2026 reviews are gifted to my beloved & wonderful father Sami Wahib Tawadros 01/07/1955 - 12/08/2025 read more

See all

Pastries were just alright definitely some are better than others. Coffee was great with the special decal at the top of our cappuccinos. Great place to come for a small conversation with coffee. Not worth the price but it works. read more

Eataly - Flatiron - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Had the best dinner at the Amalfi pop up on the roof of Eataly! Was lucky to not have to wait and have fantastic service. The north side cocktail was delicious - the botanical/fig gin was so unique! The focaccia was perfect and the entrees were delectable. Loved how the restaurant was surrounded in greenery and twinkling lights too! read more

See all

My friend and I visited Eataly during their Restaurant Week, where you can enjoy one antipasto and one entrée for $34 it was such a great deal. We kicked things off on the rooftop with happy hour cocktails before heading downstairs for dinner. I chose a buttery pasta that paired beautifully with a glass of bubbles, while my friend felt her pasta could have used a bit more sauce. Overall, it was a fun night out and a nice way to experience Eataly's restaurant offerings at a great price point. read more

See all

My wife and I needed a quick late morning pick me up after walking through the city so we stopped by Eataly since we have had good experiences at their locations in Los Angeles where we are from. In all this location is no different than the ones back home. It did feel a bit smaller than what I'm used to for Eataly, but still filled with a fine selection of treats and foods. Customers were constantly coming and going, often leaving with bags full of supplies. We had come for tea & coffee. After seeing the pistachio croissants, I knew I had to try one. We put in our order and then stepped to the side. The person working the counter gave me my tea while a barista worked on my wife's coffee. The woman gave me my tea and then took the next customer's order. I assumed that my croissant would come with the coffee, but sure enough, it didn't. So, I had to get back in line and remind the woman that I had ordered one. She promptly apologized and grabbed one for me. Thankfully I was in no rush, but I was also surprised that it was forgotten. Especially considering that the coffee bar wasn't busy at all. In all, if you're willing to pay a bit more for items, Eataly is worth checking out. Is it anything that is going to change your life? No. But it's fun to visit and you can easily find high quality ingredients that can punch up your meals. read more

Eataly - Flatiron - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Loooove coming here! I decided to get a sandwhich for lunch one day and it didn't disappoint. They have so many options too and you'll never get bored Not only is it great for meals but also for getting groceries. I always come here a lot to get things to make a charcuterie board with my friends I enjoy how there's lots of different stations too. The interior is decorated in a cute way and makes you feel like you've transported to Europe! Everyone is always super nice and helpful too whenever trying to find items or to make the shopping experience more smooth read more

Eataly - Flatiron - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

What's not to love about Eataly!? I wish it was here when I went to Baruch. I would have missed class all the time for sure getting lost in all the food, bad enough to already had Madison Square Park. Between the delicious food from decadent desserts, succulent sandwich and amazing imported Italian food, Eataly is truly a treasure trove. It's always so lively in here and it makes it even harder to decide what to get to eat. My go to is a quick slice to eat in the park. Whenever navigating here, the staff is always down to help answer any questions I have. And as hectic as all the sections are it seems like everyone still operates very smoothly. read more

Love love love! One of my favorite places in the entire U.S Lots of eateries and fresh Italian produce to choose from. I have enjoyed the pasta trio with a lovely glass of vino. I enjoyed making my own fresh charcuterie board and sitting outside in the perfect weather to enjoy it with great company. Staff are always knowledgeable and professional. They are quick to make sure you have a great experience. read more

Eataly - Flatiron - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Their Panna cotta is in my dreams every night. Add some extra berries and you have an unbeatable dessert. read more

Eataly - Flatiron - Bear chocolate milk in the world. Especially good with panna cotta alla frutta - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

I've been to the other two Eataly locations in the city in the past, but my husband finally checked this one out when we were staying in the Flatiron this past weekend. If you haven't been to an Eataly before, it's a market that sells everything Italian food: fresh pasta, dry pasta, meat, fish, cheese, dried and cured meats, breads, desserts, candy, and more. It has a few restaurants and bars inside as well. It's a great place to do some shopping. Or you can have a meal or a drink. The store is beautiful. We visited twice - once in the morning and then we returned in the afternoon to grab some items before we went to the train station to head back to Baltimore. If you're there to do some shopping and you're a little stressed out by chaos (like I am), I suggest you go earlier in the morning or in other off hours (like weekdays). When we were in the store around 3pm on a Sunday, it was so packed, you could barely walk with your hand cart! But the morning was great - calm, relaxing. It's a great store. I'm jealous of people who can shop here all the time. read more

See all

Hunger got the best of me and we stopped in. Large selection of flatbread pizza and sandwiches. Also a good selection of desserts. Plenty of workers behind the counter so the large line went very fast. Staff was helpful and quick. The place was clean for the amount of people coming and going. Pizza was amazing! read more

If you haven't been to an Eataly, you're missing out! It's all things Italian and almost evening is prepared fresh. It's kind of like a grocery store but more even. There's a sit down restaurant inside as well and a cafe right by the entrance as well. It can get busy here so be ready for somewhat of a crowd. You can get fresh made pasta and most of the to to go stuff is prepared the same day as well. read more

See all

If you love food even a little, Eataly in the Flatiron Building is an absolute must-visit. Step inside and you're instantly transported to a bustling Italian marketplace packed with energy, incredible aromas, and more delicious options than you can fit into one visit. Whether you're dropping in for a quick espresso, sitting down for a luxurious meal, taking a cooking class, or shopping for specialty Italian groceries, Eataly truly delivers. The quality is consistently excellent, from fresh handmade pasta and beautifully curated cheeses to pastries, sauces, and pantry staples you won't find anywhere else. I could live in their food hall! The food hall is great for a grab-and-go moment, while the cafés feel like a treat without being overly formal. There's always something new to discover, and even a casual stop can easily turn into a full-on culinary adventure. Bottom line: If you're in NYC and love good food, Eataly Flatiron deserves a spot at the very top of your list. Go hungry and enjoy. read more

Eataly never disappoints--especially when it comes to gelato. Smooth, rich, and perfectly balanced in sweetness, the gelato here continues to be a standout every single time. Tried the lemon cake this time and it was a pleasant surprise. The flavor was refreshingly zesty, with a hint of complexity that made it more than just your average citrus dessert. The sponge was light and airy--just the right texture to complement the bright flavor. Whether you're popping in for a quick scoop or browsing the bakery for a treat, Eataly always delivers on quality. read more

Eataly - Flatiron - Lemon cake - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Had to make the pilgrimage to Eataly NYC while visiting. Three stars for the restaurant food but would give 5 for the whole overall experience. Amazing amount of hard to find anywhere else products was the star of the show. We dined at la pizza la pasta at was just ok. We tried to make a reservation a week ahead of time for IL Pesce for 7 but were told they don't take reservations for party's over 6 just to see a party of 8 wining and dining. Oopsie! Service was friendly but came with a few hiccups like missed entree,missed cocktail and overcharged on the bill for an extra cocktail. I've had better Italian food in the north end of Boston. Would recommend "the Experience" though. read more

Eataly - Flatiron - Grabn'go's - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

I purchased a couple of pastries from La Pasticceria inside of Eataly. There were so many options to choose from and everything looked delicious. I wanted one of each, but decided on a slice of the Caramello and the Terracotta. The Caramello was caramel dessert and had what seemed like a chocolate mousse. The layers surrounded the mousse tasted like caramel and almost had a pudding consistency. Overall, it wasn't a bad tasting dessert just not my favorite. The Terracotta intrigued me because it looked like a cube of chocolate and I wondered what was inside. The outside layer of chocolate was divine. Absolutely delicious. As you keep eating, you'll taste a caramel center towards the bottom and a dark cookie like crust. This was my favorite dessert. I didn't expect it to blow me away like it did. I highly recommend trying this dessert. read more

See all

I stopped by Eataly near the WTC and tried two pasta dishes from their quick-serve counter. Service was fast, portions were decent, and both pastas tasted better than expected--fresh and flavorful. Great option if you're in the area and looking for a casual, affordable meal without sitting down. Bonus: They also sell aged steaks, seafood, and Italian cold cuts in the grocery section--sometimes with discounts. Worth a look if you're shopping nearby. read more

Eataly - Flatiron - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Had the lunch special 25$ at Eataly La pasta and La Pizza restaurant. It was delicious The food including A pizza with zucchini and burrata Spaghetti alio olio Arrancino starter and Toast with butter lemon zest and anchovies were superb!! Highly recommend it Mon to Fri only read more

Great food! Rooftop isn't as pretty as other restaurants but it wasn't crowded either! read more

Eataly - Flatiron - Rooftop - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all