Edgartown Pizza

For people who have gone to the Newes in the past, I'm sorry to say that the restaurant has changed…read morethe chowder recipe. Disappointing!! It's still a good pub atmosphere but the food isn't the same as years past.

Be cool. The vibe is haunted tavern and the experience is consistent and traditional. Laidback…read morewhile maintaining classic comforts. Staff are hard working and busy, and will stop to help if you ask. Like I said, cool. Otherwise you might get haunted by a ghost. They keep the menu short so they can do it well, and I have never gone and had them not accommodate or change something for me. Family staples are aplenty, so check it out!

Inside

See all

Espresso martini (not great)

Atria

3.8(304 reviews)

0.6 mi

While on the island we were looking to enjoy a more elevated dinner on Saturday night in…read morecelebration of my birthday and Atria was recommended to us. The restaurant is a beautiful, elegant but cozy spot. The outdoor seating is absolutely beautiful for a nice evening. We were there right at opening and were seated outside fairly quickly! Our waiter was welcoming and pleasant. Wished me a happy birthday (multiple times) but nice. There was a cute birthday card at the table but nothing more (most high end establishments usually offer a glass of champs, but I digress ) The menu is moderate not overwhelming with too many options. How do you NOT start your meal with Oysters Rockefeller when they are on the menu? Great choice, they were creamy and delicious. I am typically not a pasta girl but something was calling me about the Mushroom Bolognese! So....I ordered it. Along with a glass of Filipa Pato, which was fabulous! The pasta was phenomenal and I don't use that word lightly, it was amazing. My friend ordered the Bobo's Two Pound Wok Fired Island Lobster and she loved it. She paired her meal with a Smokey old fashioned. No notes! So after a great meal we a bought the check and offer up two cards for our separate checks. Somehow our waiter ends up charging both checks to my credit card. I didn't realize it until the next day. How does that happen. An almost perfect review, but attention to detail matters. Would I return, absolutely! Go enjoy!

We came here one night to enjoy a nice dinner while on the vineyard. I was conflicted between the…read morelobster or the halibut and opted to try the halibut which did not disappoint. It came with lobster and vegetables which were all so flavorful. Our waitress was nice and took the time to walk us through the specials. We sat inside but the outside looked beautiful. This restaurant is perfect for a date night or girls night

Duck Entree

See all

Town MV

3.6(87 reviews)

0.3 mi

The food came out fast and it was good! The bartender was doing a triple roll as the waitress and…read moreshe did not miss a beat! In the place is a cool vibe

This is a year round restaurant that shares space with an adjacent hotel. There are both indoor and…read moreoutdoor seating and it can get quite busy during the Island's high season. Rather quiet and easy to find parking and a seat during the shoulder and off seasons. There is a fire place that makes it feel comfy during the cooler nights. The staff is always pleasant and efficient. many have been there for several seasons so they are full time islanders. The food selection is both American and a nice Asian menu. Plenty of choices. Consistent food and weekly specials.T

But

See all

Brussel sprouts appetizer

The Covington

4.4(160 reviews)

0.8 mi

We put our names in later in the evening on a Thursday night in August. We were notified of our…read moretable just as we had received drinks at a bar where we were waiting. We told them this and they said they would hold the table. We arrived about 10 minutes later and were seated immediately, outside at the last table along the wall. It was a perfect, quiet, spot for the 5 of us! Our server, Summer was amazing. So friendly, so accommodating and a great representative for the restaurant. She made the experience even better. We shared some apps and the halibut special which was amazing and HUGE. The five of us shared this incredible special. The fish was perfectly cooked and the accompanying potatoes, salad and aioli were perfect! This was our first time there, we have been to the Port Hunter before. We will definitely come back!!

Absolutely loved this spot for dinner. I had been wanting to try The Covington for a while but we…read moreare usually dining as a group of six and the restaurant is pretty cozy with mostly 2 and 4 top tables. I finally got a chance to dine there with a friend during my most recent visit in late May and I was really delighted. The service was friendly and our waitress gave helpful recommendations on the menu but the food delivery was on the slower side. For dinner we shared the sweet potato rolls, smokes cauliflower, bolognese and the halibut. Favorite dish was far and away the smoked cauliflower. It was absolutely outstanding. The flavors and textures were perfection. The halibut and the pasta were also both great. Cannot wait to come back and try their other veggie dishes, mushroom ragu and pork chop which also looked very tempting.

Dining room

Fresh-baked, delicious butter for the bread service

See all

Street view

Wharf Pub & Restaurant

3.7(246 reviews)

The chowder fries are fantastic!! A local friend told me to come here specifically for the chowder…read morefries and this was excellent advice. Wow! So good!! Friendly service. Lively ambiance and busy place. Pretty warm inside as far as the temperature. I didn't feel any AC or breezes. They have a bar one side and a restaurant on the other. The bar was packed and everyone looked like they were having a great time. They have an ATM machine too.

Great menu, sat quickly for a late lunch, and delightful server who answered all our questions…read moreabout town. We didn't feel rushed whatsoever which was a welcomed surprise. The strawberry salad is out of this world. The addition of pickled red onions adds a refreshing tang. Would have been great with grilled chicken on top, but I wasn't hungry enough for it. Some of the better fries I've eaten! Great crunch! Don't skip em. Husband loved the fried chicken sandwich (hard to mess up, but it has happened). Pricing is really competitive and portions were good. We'd go back.

The main event room with JAWS on the TV.

Don't order the pulled pork. It is terrible. Sweet potato fries were like soup.

See all

Modelo

Detente

4.4(117 reviews)

Dined here with two friends on a recent Friday night in May. We made our reservation with only a…read moreweek to spare and as such were only able to secure an outdoor table. It was still quite chilly outside but we were sandwiched between two heaters which made it very manageable. Our waitress was wonderful and service was incredibly prompt which I appreciate because I have noticed that service on the island is generally more relaxed (i.e. slow). For appetizers we shared the baby gem salad and the pork bolognese. Both good but the pork bolognese was a small but mighty star. Pasta was perfectly al dente and we really enjoyed the goat cheese with the pork. For our mains we ordered the pork chop, halibut and mushroom lasagna. The portions were large and we were all satisfied with our orders (though the pork chop was quite salty). Enjoyed this enough that I would for sure come back.

We sat outside and it was a great outdoorsy vibe. The service was great, attentive to clearing the…read moretable for the next course. The food was delicious and fresh with the seafood and beef having a very flavorful taste to it.

Bar

Charred Baby Gems

See all

The bar

The Port Hunter

3.9(261 reviews)

0.8 mi

The service is stellar. The ambiance is upscale yet comfortable…read more The food is not quite as good. We ordered raw oysters 4/5, fried calamari with banana peppers 3/5 (more calamari less banana peppers, even though the peppers was the tastiest part), chicken sandwich 5/5, and catch of the day scallops with risotto 4/5, and Dubai cheese cake 3/5. Good cocktail, beer, and wine choices.

If you are looking oysters this is your spot! We shared a dozen of their most popular oysters and…read morethey were delicious! Good service. They were busy but still very attentive.

Bar area

Octopus

See all

Inside

Rockfish

4.2(236 reviews)

Delicious food and very nice inside! My wife had the lobster roll, and it was buttery and full of…read morehuge clumps of meat! My chicken bahn mi was excellent. So many flavor profiles with the acid, spice in the mayo, and tender chicken. I also love shoestring fries. Wonderful meal in Edgartown!

While strolling edgartown, was looking for a place for some lunch and saw Rockfish on the corner…read more From the outside, the place looks very nice. Went in right when they opened and inside looks like your typical nice pub. Hostess was friendly and sat us upstairs immediately. Service was good and both food and drinks came out quickly. Food was nice and hot so you know it was cooked fresh. Started with a blackberry whiskey smash which was perfect. Ordered fish and chips, clam chowder, cheese pizza and mac and cheese. All were very good. Only thing I would not get again would be the fish and chips. The fish just had too much batter. Felt like all you were eating was batter. Overall a good place and would certainly go back.

Upstairs full beautiful bar

Mac n cheese with braised short rib

See all

Seafood Shanty

3.3(773 reviews)

1.0 mi

Food was delicious, server was a wonderful person. Atmosphere was fun, relaxing time with friends…read morewould highly recommend this to everyone.

Visited on a weekday with no reservation and was easily seated at the second floor bar area. A…read moreshort wait for service but once I was greeted the service moved pretty quickly. I was able to order a drink and lunch in which both arrived promptly. The Mahi sandwich was fresh and the fries were crispy. It was the perfect lunch portion. I visited again during my stay on the island for lunch and chose to be seated in the interior of the restaurant which was very clean and had a great view of the dock and boats going by. The staff were very courteous. My lunch companion had the lobster roll which she said tasted fresh, was packed full of lobster and had a buttery toasted roll. I would definitely visit again because it was easy to be seated even on crowded days, the lively atmosphere and consistently good food. $$ There is limited street parking nearby

Bar

Cold lobster roll and fries

See all

Outdoor seating

Lucky Hank's Restaurant & Cafe

4.1(207 reviews)

0.3 mi

This restaurant is a hidden gem. It's as if you're eating in someone's home. It's that good and…read moreabsolutely welcoming and delicious. One meal is better than the next. Dinners are amazing. Great menu. Breakfast also outrageous.

Excellent food and service! It's really cute, like a cozy house. Indoor and outdoor seating. They…read moreserve breakfast, lunch, and dinner. I definitely recommend coming here for breakfast. My boyfriend enjoyed his Eggs Benedict and I loved the Cod Cakes & Eggs. The cod cakes are homemade and really special. I had a latte to drink and it was tasty. The toast was very fresh and I loved the raspberry jam that came with it. The home fries were great. I sat outside and really enjoyed my experience. Relaxed and welcoming atmosphere.

Housemade Granola Bowl

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

8 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Shelly B.

4

9

0

8 years ago

Amazing food, so many things on the menu, delicious. The best thing about this place is that the owner will come over to your table to make sure that you're happy and that your food is delicious. That's something that you just can't find today very often read more

Keith F.

0

6

18

12 years ago

Ordered a fish sandwich and a double cheese burger , terrible both tasted like they were frozen , also ordered 2 house salads the lettuce was brown and it was the white or worst part of the lettuce . Will never eat there again yuck . read more

David C.

0

2

0

8 years ago

Don't waste your money! I would be embarrassed to own this place. Food is garbage, thrown together without a care for presentation. How people still eat at this pig slop amazes me... read more

Eric C.

0

1

5 years ago

They should never ever serve pizza again. That was awful. Now I know why they don't display the pizzas out front. Puke

Joe L.

0

7

0

11 years ago

I don't say the F word very often but this place sucks ass. I don't like the food or the people working there.

Bill P.

0

12

2

9 years ago

Too doughy breadey not enough cheese Like bad Ellios CxcxcxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxcccccccccccccccccccccvC read more

sera v.

0

6

0

15 years ago

The pizza is so delicous and so is the pasta plus its all in a great price range.

Kathleen O.

80

72

7

9 years ago

I like the food on their menu but I don't go for the pizza. Owner is very sweet.

Edgartown Pizza - pizza - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Edgartown Pizza also viewed

Island Fresh Pizza & Subs

3.6

(26 reviews)

This was a terrible experience. The pizzas are wildly overpriced and are lower quality than if you…read morebought a frozen pizza. Avoid at all costs and don't believe any of the reviews.

Made us the wrong pizza which I went ahead and accepted. But, the pizza I accepted did not have the…read moreingredients listed. Need to do better!

Giordano's Restaurant

3.6

(236 reviews)

PROS: Food was good, atmosphere was decent, Annie the waitress was friendly, place was clean,…read moreprices are fair, menu variety plentiful, and they had a bar CONS: Hostess was a bit uptight and the service took forever OVERALL: They aren't the fastest but they're still a good restaurant for you to come to

Cash only! No credit…read morecards, no debit cards, and no digital currency! lol Pizza by the slice at one counter. Sandwiches and fried food at the other counter. A few beverages as well. Seems to be the only spot to pick up a slice in the area. Cheese pizza was very tasty and came out quick. Chicken tenders were made from processed homogenized chicken, so make sure you know what you're buying. This is not fresh all white chicken breast or an actual identifiable piece of a chicken - let alone the tenderloin. It's like a McDonald's chicken nugget... Processed meat pressed into a mold. Having said that it was hot and reasonably tasty with the honey mustard sauce

Pizzeria Gemelle

(48 reviews)

A great pizza option in downtown Nantucket that has limited seating, a fun vibe and solid…read moreneopolitan style pizza. Not large, but enough for 2 people (especially if you have a side salad). I ordered about 7 pizzas online and they did add a mandatory 20% tip and they don't pick up the phone, so you couldn't even order via phone. And then when picking up said pizzas, which was quite a lot to carry, there was no offer to help carry them, paper plates, napkins, etc.. And, some of the pizzas were not cut through (and when they do cut the pies, they only cut them in 4 large slices). Again, just some customer service opportunities, especially if you're going to force a 20% gratuity on orders, but not really offer any great service. So, there it is. Nantucket prices, for solid pizza. Ordering online wasn't the best UX, but you get what you get, sometimes.

Pizza was very mediocre. And the clerk was a little entitled. Total came to $6.42 and I gave $7,…read moreand he didn't give me the change. I was planning on putting the change in the tip can anyway, since I hate carrying change, but to automatically assume that and not give the change is a little messed up.

Palio Pizzeria

(264 reviews)

Best pizza in the area. When we first moved to Hyannis almost 20 years ago, this was EASILY the…read morebest pizza in the mid-cape area. The cape was a pizza desert filled with crappy frozen crust greek-style joints. But over the years several pizza places have opened that make some great pizzas. But Palio's still holds up, everything is home-made, and well-made: really good sauce, nice crust, quality cheese and other toppings. They're stingy on their sauce, so ask for extra sauce unless you like it on the dry side. They're usually pretty efficient too, even during the peak summer months. It's a pizza joint, so don't expect much in the way of atmosphere, but sitting outside on a warm summer evening watching the crowd with a slice and a beer is pretty sweet. Oh, and they sometimes have musicians playing, bonus!

We had a great experience with Palio Pizzeria takeout. We ordered 2 large pizzas (cheese &…read moremeatball), chicken tenders & 3 salads (Caesar, Greek & spinach) . The food was delicious. The pizza was NY style with lots of flavor & huge slices. The salads were fresh & tasty, but on the small side. The atmosphere inside was fun & inviting with a cool bar style vibe. The staff was friendly & helpful. Our total bill was $94 & we fed 7 adults & 1 child.

Pizza Barbone

4.4

(601 reviews)

This is one of the best meals we had during our visit to Cape Cod. The ambiance was superb, the…read moreservice excellent and the food delicious. We got their special vodka sauce pesto drizzle pizza - for which they use Italian flour and a traditional Neapolitan oven. I also loved how clean their bathrooms are and it's the first time I've seen a switch you can turn on if the bathroom isn't up to standard. That level of hygiene and attention to details regarding customer experience defined our entire experience here. Highly recommend!

I know the goal is to eat seafood when you come to the cape, but Barbones is a must stop. The pizza…read moreis amazing, service is awesome, and the restaurant is very clean and organized.

Simply Divine

(381 reviews)

Very pleasant nice atmosphere. My dinner arrived promptly exactly how I ordered it and it was very…read moregood.

BEST CHICKEN BROCCOLI ALFREDO EVER!! It was so good that I spent the entire meal saying how good it…read morewas. This place has a fabulous menu, spacious seating, and a wonderful hostess named Leah that helped me change my order when indecision struck 1 minute after I ordered! They were open on Labor Day which I appreciated and had both indoor + outdoor seating available with no wait. I appreciated that they brought a bottle or water to our table so we didn't have to flag anyone down for a refill until we were almost finished. ** They have rebranded as Little Rosa!!

Fella's Take Out

3.4

(5 reviews)

The buffalo chicken pizza is loaded with toppings. The crust is rather thin but a generous mix of…read moretoppings and cheese . I'd say it's more tasty then many other pizza shops on MV.

We are always looking for good Q on Martha's Vineyard and Fella's gets it right. This BBQ is…read moresauced so if you prefer dry rubs and long smoke time, it's not for you. The sauce is sweet, and vinegary with a nice finish. Tonight was BBQ night with legit chicken, ribs and pulled pork. Moist chicken and fall of the bone pork ribs. The pulled pork had big chunks and sweet sauce. Meals come with corn bread and another side. The cole slaw was not over dressed but had a bit too much celery salt. Enjoyed our meal, we will be back.

Eat Fire Pizza

4.6

(7 reviews)

So good! Delicious. Sooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo good.read more

I don't wanna be this person, but I have to be- close to $50 for 2 small, personal sized pizzas in…read moresconset the other evening. While we may have asked for lighter crust, it was pretty raw with almost a cardboard texture for base. I feel like their pizza is slightly inconsistent, because I've eaten it before, and have loved it.

The Rock Wood Fired Pizza

(15 reviews)

The pizza was great, with many unique choices. The ambiance was a bit loud, but it's good music.read more

My first time going to " The Rock" IT was Saturday night at…read moreprime time We had a lovely table and ordered drinks and Brussels sprouts right away This way, we had something to eat knowing that the pizzas would take time to cook and the restaurant was quite filled at the time we were ordering It's a fun place with tons of TVs so take a pic of what you want to watch the music was just right ,we could have a conversation as as well as listening to music in the background. We loved the chef Lindsay ( or was it Linda) taking the time to come to our table and introduce herself to us. Nice touch. Sam, of course was the one that ran around to many tables, accommodating our needs as well as several other tables. good job Sam Yes, I give it five stars. Yes, I will come again either alone or with others Jackie S

Rockfish

4.2

(236 reviews)