place an order online for pick up. The only option was cash once I arrived in the restaurant I was told it would be an up charge because I placed a to go order and the price difference was also two dollars more although it's just two dollars. it's the principal, when I spoke with the cashier about this she told me it's just one dollar and to let it go. I told her that they could not be falsely advertising prices online and then when you go to pay they up charge you with no explanation would not be returning just off of principal alone. Food was OK. read more

Arrived at the restaurant at 2:00. We were immediately seated and placed our order. It was a little slower than normal, but we very much enjoyed the chips and salsa while we waited. The food arrived very warm and just as we ordered. We all had lunch specials and were being stuffed even with take home boxes. The service could have been better. They weren't too busy but refills were 't provided. A spare napkin would have been nice, but our server was MIA. Also parking was a bit difficult as the store next door is being remodeled and they've got a couple of containers in the parking lot. read more

See all

Cool atmosphere with plenty of tables and booths, or bar seating if you prefer. Service is friendly and fast. I generally get a basket of chips and salsa within a minute of sitting down and get drinks ordered right away. Food is always great, and there are plenty of options to choose from. Food usually comes out within 10-15 minutes and has been my consistent go to for Mexican food for the last 5 years. read more

Improve integrity!!! I was not only over charged, but the tip was extremely generous, without my doing! The waiter knew he did that to me because when I called there was no argument. Then I went in, and the waiter gave it to me out of his own wallet. If you go here, check your bill, the cost of your food and drinks, and especially how much is tipped because they will tip their selves. As far as the food, the waiter even said it was not authentic, so for an overcharge, overtipped, non authentic food. You do the math... literally do the math!! read more

Service was amazing. Well we were the only ones in the restaurant, so we felt cater too. Fast service. Simple, Mexican food but delicious. They have seasoning down pack. If you need a quick Rita, or a fajita, stop by El Rodeo. The venue is old, rustic but presentable, pleasing. read more

El Rodeo No 16 - Coronarita - Mexican Near Me - Noblesville, Indiana

See all

If I could do 4.5 stars, I would. But 5 stars this place does not deserve. Had the steak and cheese buritto...possibly the best buritto I ever had, though it needed more pico, which they brought. Also had an ultimate margarita and chips /salsa. Both were good, but not great. Margarita needed more booze, less sour. Chips were spot on, but salsa lacked flavor and heat. Doctored it up with some salt, hot sauce, and some extra picco to turn it into a fabulous dish. It should come that way from the kitchen. Service was very fast and friendly. Would come back again in a heartbeat, though I may sit at the bar and teach them how to make a 5 star Margarita. read more

See all

So happy to finally try this place! I got the classic margarita and it was amazing. Literally the size of 2 margaritas. Food was great and in a good location on mall strip located by shops and other food places. Service was great and everyone was nice!! read more

El Rodeo No 16 - Classic Margarita - Mexican Near Me - Noblesville, Indiana

See all

This place is pretty much what you'd expect: totally okay food at a reasonable price. The service could've been better. Even though my son said he wasn't ready to order yet and we were still waiting for one more person, the server was in a rush to take our orders and asked what I wanted. I said (again) that we needed a few more minutes, but instead of leaving and coming back a few minutes later, he moved on to taking the next person's order. He ended up taking half the table's orders to the kitchen before our side of the table was ready to order. So of course, their food all came out first, and they were halfway done eating by the time the rest of our food came. The food, very much like the service, could've been better, but overall it was fine. The molcajete was fantastic! But the guacamole was bland (It was badly lacking in salt, cilantro, cumin, and lime and was completely mashed to death.), and the Ultimate Margarita was weak and watery. Overall, this place is nothing to rave about, but totally acceptable. read more

See all

I ended up here randomly while waiting for my daughter at Urban Air and I wish I hadn't. I honestly feel like I wasted $30 and really really wished I had went elsewhere. I came to El Rode all the time years ago but the one near me is closed......Anyways I came here making it use to be one of my favs and figured it would be a safe bet. I ordered the shrimp and enchilada and it came out exactly as the description said it would. The only problem is it lacked taste and flavor. I felt like I was eating a glob of cheese, drowned in oil topped with shrimp, onions and mushrooms. The rice had so many vegetables in it I know they added a can of mixed vegetables to the rice and for me it was a turn off. I will say the staff was very friendly even though our particular waiter was always hard to find. Personally I would skip this place but if you're in the area and starving.......it will work! read more

El Rodeo No 16 - Chips and salsa - Mexican Near Me - Noblesville, Indiana

See all

Haven't been here in a long time. They've redone the booths which makes the place light and clean. The one thing I used to love about this place is they are so fast. I got the burritos Roqueta which were delicious, I love getting this meal because I always have lunch for the next day. My husband got a dinner combo with burrito, taco and beans and rice. We both enjoyed our meal. The chips and salsa were also good too which I remember from last time the salsa wasn't good. read more

See all

1 star. I've never met a chimichanga that I didn't like... until today! The customer service was really lacking too, but that's not even the reason for the 1 star! I usually judge a Mexican restaurant by the chips n salsa. If the ships b salsa are delish, then my meal will follow suit. Well, the chips n salsa were not stellar. So, I should have known not to go any further. But oh no.....I went ahead and ordered, anyway. The food lacked flavor! All of the food! The chicken was dry and bland. The queso was just a wet white substance, zero cheese flavor. The rice was dry and flavorless. The salsa was watery and had no chunks of anything - it literally tasted like tomato juice. Yuck! I ate a few bites and was ready to go. It wasn't even worth the calories. Then I had to wait almost ten minutes to pay my check. There was no one to be found. I will not return. read more

I came here on a Friday night and was surprised by how busy it was! We were sat pretty immediately & got frozen margaritas. Holy moly they were big and delicious!! I absolutely recommend the strawberry one. The best part of a Mexican restaurant is 100% the chips and salsa. They were fantastic. Our waitress even brought over extra chips :) I got the fajitas- they were nice and hot. You could hear the sizzle from a mile away. It was great! read more

VERY fast service. Typical Mexican food. It's not gonna be the best Mexican you've ever had but definitely not the worst.

Excellent food, vast menu, great service and fast service!!! We are frequent visitors here

We love El Rodeo! It is one of our favorite Mexican restaurants in the area and honestly both locations near Noblesville are great! Good food, drinks, service, and prices. It is also well decorated and is a good ambiance for a Mexican restaurant. Keep up the great work! read more

Never will i eat at this place again! I ordered CHICKEN burritos and received these disgusting chunks of pork! I should have took it back immediately! It was practically impossible to chew and tasted horrible!! Never again! read more

El Rodeo No 16 - Disgusting chunks of pork when I ordered CHICKEN! - Mexican Near Me - Noblesville, Indiana

I have eaten here consistently (2 to 3 times a month) for four years. We dine in but mostly carry out. We have had perfect service EVERY SINGLE TIME. The food is always delicious and the service is fantastic! They are wonderful people who take pride in taking care of you. I would highly recommend eating here. Thank you for taking such good care of us! read more

This restaurant is located in a strip mall so parking is easy to find. I've heard that Noblesville location is better than the Fishers location and after trying out both places, I agree on that. Shrimp dish was tasty but beef dish wasn't that impressive. Their chips and salsa was good. Service was good. They were attentive most of time. They have kids menu so it's kids friendly restaurant. Overall experience was good. read more

See all

Food was wonderful and hot. Service was prompt and attentive. My Sprite was super super good well carbonated! Great job! See you soon!

Ground beef enchiladas, quick service at lunch, and have some super hot jalapeños. I do recommend this place read more

El Rodeo No 16 - Beef enchilada's - Mexican Near Me - Noblesville, Indiana

We have been LONG term patrons of this restaurant. We have participated in ordering both lunch, and dinner and have ordered multiple items off of the menu. Always the service staff have been hospitable and provided great personal service. Juan and the team of both servers and bussers do an outstanding job. In the 4 years which we have been visiting the restaurant the food has taken a slow steady decline to now it has become a joke. What originally attracted us to El Rodeo was it's authentic regional Mexican flavors and presentations. Having spent 20 years working in California and dining on the regional specialities we thought we had found a great restaurant. We were even more impressed when the restaurant undertook a renovation project in the past year. They created a restaurant with a lighter color palette, updated booths and a more current ambiance. As the restaurants image improved the the food product continued to slide. Last evening was the final straw. When reading the menu descriptions and looking at what was served we have made the decision not to return to a restaurant which earned about $85.00 per week from us time 52 weeks a year. My wife order the number #4 a beef taco, beef tostada and a beef enchilada. She received essentially the same item featuring ground beef and tacos 3 ways. No shredded cheese topping, or diced tomatoes, pico de gallo, no rice or beans. We're offered. No chopped cilantro. Why go out to eat this bland food we could have been prepared at home while watching the game. The beef filling which used to be flavorful with cumin and oregano was just basic ground beef with a few spices. My cheese quesadillas had no shredded lettuce, diced tomatoes or pico de gallo, just tortillas and melted cheese for $7.00. When we asked to speak to the manager he was not available. I requested the owners name, allegedly they were not able to contact him, no phone number or email address. When asking the waiter the manager cook in the back of the house had unilaterally made these cost reduction decisions. In my view; short term you will reduce cost and save money, long term the remodeled dining room will be empty of customers as their customer base will find a Mexican food restaurant that serves food that meets the customers basic expectations. If I could rate the restaurant with no stars I would. We would not serve this food to our dogs. The serving sizes are de minimus. How much does it cost this restaurant to add lettuce diced tomatoes and shredded cheese to a dish. Horrible. We will not return! Michael and Joyce Watz read more

My first time in and the service was great and the burrito Loco was fabulous. We also enjoyed the Queso dip and fresh chips. Drink refills were prompt and the meal was delicious. My daughter had the 3 tacos and they were so flavorful. We will be back! read more

The food was amazing with the service being unbelievable! They were helpful all the time and making sure everything was just right. They had lights right above you so it felt like your own little date night. The ambience was amazing because of the lights. read more

They're finally open for sitdown service! Today is their first day since the lockdown. We've been waiting to return for 2 months because we love the food and the staff. It's always a good meal with friendly service. I just had the Chile Colorado which is my favorite. All the staff is in face masks, every other table closed, paper menus and no amenities on the tables but the same good food. Please return to keep them all employed. read more

The carry out is the second time in two weeks and it's been great! Tonight we learned they even serve margaritas to go! Yes. You read that right!! Margaritas to go!!!! Haha. The staff here is great and always friendly! Tonight we got 6 chicken tacos and salads and queso, and man was it good! Really great experience! They have a fiberglass screen up over there counter and are being really safe! They are cranking out food and being great about it! I'd ask consumers to not use coupons!! They are all hurting, let's spend the extra few bucks to help business and TIP big!!!! read more

El Rodeo No 16 - Margaritas to go!!! - Mexican Near Me - Noblesville, Indiana

A nice late dinner! The salsa is very flavorful and not too chunky. I had the chicken chimichangas. I would recommend it!

No stars. Small portions. No lettuce tomatoes or shredded cheese on tacos. Just ground beef on taco shell and tortillas.

We typically come here once a week because it is just that good! That people here treat us like family and go above and beyond to give you good service. You can really tell how hard they work in the kitchen and in the dining room! read more

This is THE Mexican spot. I've been to many Mexican restaurants in different cities and states, and this one has always been my favorite. The salsa is the best. Great flavor. Seems like it's been the same recipe for years, and I'm glad it hasn't changed. Great with the chips and good to mix in with the rice. Favorite dishes are the burrito loco, shrimp enchiladas, enchiladas super rancheras, and fajitas. We've never really had anything bad to be honest. Lastly, the staff is awesome. I've seen many of the same faces over the years, and they just nail the service side of things. The food comes quickly, they follow up with you throughout your visit, and they are just very pleasant people. 5 stars!! read more

My fiancé and I have been coming here since we moved to the area. It's safe to say, we are regulars (especially since COVID lol). I can't say enough how much we love the staff. They are all so sweet and always give superb service. We love the ultimate margaritas! All of the food we've had has been excellent as well. Give it a try! read more

Dined in for lunch around 12-1. Not very busy, socially distanced tables. Our server was very polite and had our food out quickly. Tasted great!! I definitely plan on coming back again :) read more

We enjoyed our first take-out from El Rodeo, we look forward to dining-in in the near future !!! The food was tasty and remained warm in the travel to and from picking up our order read more

I'd give a 0 if I could. Terrible service, food is as mediocre as it comes, no chip refills, or even drink refills without constantly trying to flag down the waiters and having to ask for services that should be implemented and executed for each and every customer. Owners should entertain the idea of hiring some real fucking staff, don't bother folks. read more

This is my go to Mexican restaurant in Fishers. The food is excellent and the staff couldn't be more friendly. I feel like I'm family every time I eat here. Highly recommend this restaurant. Everything is awesome!! read more

AS A LATINO WHO CAME HERE WITH MY FAMILY I felt discriminated and judged because the other tables were getting a better experience. The waiter forgot the name of my plate and said "plate with whatever on it and walked away". WILL NEVER COME BACK AGAIN. They see hispanic family and already assume we won't leave a good tip. read more

Before Covid, we were in here to eat a lot. Recently we ordered a carry out. We purchased several dinners and therefore requested more salsa to go with each. The person was very irritated with this request and told us we would have to pay extra. This was confusing because usually it's per dinner NOT per order. The tiny salsa provided was hard to share among several meals. Plus the portions provided for each meal were stingy. The beef was stringy and hard to chew. One piece, in fact was impossible to cut due to the grissle and was just thrown out which was irritating since there was so little there to begin with. We will not be returning. There are several other similar restaurants happy to provide good customer service and food. read more

Excellent fresh food. Amazing ambiance and I like the arrangement as well as a separate section for bar adds to the whole vibe. Super friendly staff. Definitely recommend! read more

I love their micheladas here! Perfect amount of spice. I wish I knew their recipe they use in the mix. read more

El Rodeo No 16 - Grande Michelada! I love these from here. - Mexican Near Me - Noblesville, Indiana

Called in for take out and one burrito was spot on basically because there was no adjustments but the second one was a disaster when specifically requesting no onions , pineapple or beans ... the only thing they got right was no beans and the food was for someone heading out to work or needed to eat and go ... and the. The whole thing is mostly wrong .. no time to get it right by the time drive ll the way back . What a disappointment. They need to learn the word No in ENGLISH!!! read more

El Rodeo No 16 - Tropical burrito when I specifically said no PINEAPPLE AND ONIONS - Mexican Near Me - Noblesville, Indiana

I have nothing good to say about our dining experience except that we did t have to wait for a table...probably because it's so awful nobody returns! Staff was rude! Took forever to be acknowledged and get our drinks. Thank goodness we weren't took thirsty because they never offered to refill our empty drinks. I ordered #15 and said burrito and enchilada and I would like white sauce instead of red sauce on the burrito. I was given a burrito and taco and he rudely told me I ordered #13 and actually argued with me over it. The chips they brought to the table were the end of a bag...basket was full of chip crumbs. Never brought more chips or salsa, we had 2 adults and 2 kids. 1 small cup of salsa and I broken up basket of chips was not enough. When we received the bill it seemed high. The special board indicated $2 off kids meals and $1 off combo meals...so we should have had $6 off total. The rude cashier said oh he only took $1 off, fixed it although it was still incorrect. He had charged for the 2 kids drinks $2.39 each when they are included with their meal. She then argued with me over who had the soft drink and told me my son was too old. I pointed out my older son was indeed 16 and he drank water, however my younger 2 kids were under 12 and had kids meals. After getting the bill somewhat close I paid and left. My son was up all night sick we believe he has food poisoning. There are lots of Mexican restaurants to choose from this one I would stay FAR away from!!! Bad service, bad food, long wait for bill, and overcharged. read more