I really don't understand the bad reviews at this place has gotten. This place has everything I expect from a Five Guys restaurant: the burgers are tasty, the service is fast, and they have everything on the menu that I expect to see when I come into one of these restaurants. The fries were super crispy, but they were good enough. And, the drink mixer machine had all selections available. This location is also very bright, and everybody I talk to here was friendly. I mean, everybody. I was just passing through, but I will definitely stop here again on my way back. read more

I got food poisoning the last time I eat from there. I was really messed up about it because I have always loved five guys and even though they are a little on the high side of the burger joint, I have always loved eating from them. But after the last time and getting badly sick from there, i am so scared to eat from five guys again. read more

Only place I will eat a burger from, almost like homemade. Plenty of toppings, fresh, fast service, and always friendly.

Love Five Guys, but they really need to clean the embedded dirt on their tables and chairs.

It took 3 tries, but I was finally able to order here. The first time I came it was one person in front of me and after 10 minutes, their order still was not processed. I went to Chipotle next door. The same happened the second time I came here two weeks later. I went to Chipotle next door. The third time another two weeks later, I was first! I don't know if it was me or them, but I was able to get my order in and paid for in 60 seconds. The burger was made just as I ordered, and was hot, fresh, and great. I'll be back! read more

Their burgers are SO good. Price doable. Everything is great!!!! When you bandy for bovine this is your place. I appreciate how hard are staff works to make sure everyone has a great time. . Delicious double read more

Prices are insane but the employees are very friendly. The food is tasty but idk if it's worth the 30 minute wait!

The fries were to salty, orders were wrong, the bun was too soggy on my burger the meat was too dry, and my bun was smashed!!!

The door says they're open till 10... The sign says they're open... But the door is locked!!! Did they close early? Bad for business... read more

Five Guys - a restaurant with open signs in the window - Burgers Near Me - Michigan City, Indiana

Burgers: tasted great, cost a lot for that level burger joint. Fries: some of the best. Grilled cheese: I want my $4 back. My 2 year old didn't even like it. I feel cheated for buying an inside out hamburger bun with rubber cheese. Bathrooms needed some actual cleaning attention. Staff was great and friendly. read more

Came in for quick pick up. John was super polite and the burgers are always the best. Fresh fries yumm.

We were in town for vacation and stopped by for lunch. Fries were perfectly crispy, burgers were juicy and the flavors all melded together well. Though we had a very large order, they got it all right. Great job Guys! read more

We went for lunch with a large group (including kids). They were incredibly accommodating and patient while taking our order. Food came out quickly and everyone was happy with their meal. No complaints here! I was particularly impressed with staff who didn't give the usual "hate this job" kind of attitude. Will be back next time i'm in town. read more

Super friendly staff and great food. Outdoor seating was nice. We'll be back again!

Awesome service and awesome food- what else can I ask for? The burger is really high quality for quick service restaurant. The coke favor machine and free peanuts are extra bonuses! read more

The burgers and fries are great, and I loved my Oreo milkshake! The staff was friendly and accommodating, and the service was pretty quick. Can't ask for more! read more

What happened to this place!?! Seemed like they had a good staff when they first opened... they would clean the grill between every few sets of burgers, the fries were always cooked great, and the service was excellent. Now it seems like they don't ever clean the grill. I pick crap out of my teeth from the burgers, the french fries aren't blanched, it seems like they're trying to cook them all in one go, so they are limp and greasy and gross. This place is too expensive to not cook everything properly. It was decent when they first opened. After several bad visits though, it's hard to give it another chance. read more

The employees there are very nice and upbeat, I know working with the public is not easy but they are some of the nicest staff that I have dealt with. read more

Horrible service, rude management, mediocre food, and bloated prices. The manager insulted and berated me over the phone after they screwed up my order. Called my wife "negligent" because they pushed her away when it was busy. read more

Went here during the lunch rush on a weekend and came away with a damn good burger and a hearty milkshake in a timely fashion.

Great service! Food was done quickly, and our order was accurately prepared. Restaurant was very clean. Can't wait to go back! Side note: If you're with a non-profit organization, they have a fantastic fundraising program. 20% return, and an additional $1 per milkshake sold. It's super easy...don't pass this one by. read more

Service is fast and friendly. Food is tasty, fresh, and you get large portions. I highly recommend the peanut butter milkshake. Our non-profit held a fundraiser at this location. We received 20% of our proceeds as well as $1 for every milkshake. What I liked about this restaurant was they held the fundraiser all day as opposed to other places that do it for 4 hrs. We made more because more people had a chance to participate. By far the best place to do giveback nights. Will be doing it again soon! read more

I love five guys and found they have opened a store in Michigan City! I'm rating it a 3 because it is not very clean. Everywhere you walk the floors are slippery(greasy) and the tables are dirty. I see no reason for this due to the fact that we came at 3:00 in the afternoon. read more

Ate here with the family and the service was quick, friendly, and professional. The burgers and fries were delicious as always. We'll be back! read more

This place of buisness is a joke, and gon a be gone sooner than later. First of all I was gired by there G.M and within a week of starting after online courses the G.M resigned and found outit was due to him losing, a $10,000 deposit so he had a choiceto be fired or resign. This location was left with 4 shift leaders all under 25 years of age. Lets just say every shift was a nightmare and not one rule was followed by leaders which affected the whole staff. I spoke out to CJ, and Chelsea the managers of seven stores and ultimately lost my job, due to being to honest and open and no one wanted to work with me due to my critizising of leaders and staff that failed the rules daily. This place of buisness will relocate sooner than later or just drop this location due to lack of responsibility. read more

My favorite go-to for burgers, always great service, never too long of a wait once your order is in. Always delicious!!!! I LOVE THIS PLACE!! read more

Five Guys delivered a very good flavorful burger with perfectly crispy fries. I was honestly surprised by how good it was. Service was friendly and, despite the peculiarities of our very large order, everything came out perfectly. Milkshakes were also a big hit. We'll be back! read more

I went in expecting the usual Five Guys burgers they're so famous for. Instead, I received a burnt cheeseburger. After I politely explained to them it was burnt, they reluctantly offered to make another, which I agreed to. Yet again, the "remake" was burnt. Definitely not a good experience. (The first one I've ever been to where the burgers were less than amazing). read more

5 Lame Guys. Not that there's anything wrong with being lame, I just don't want to have to pay for it. First visit to 5 Guys - I really wanted to like it. Had to convince family to try something different. Thanks for the stale, soggy peanuts while we waited for a long time. Slow, slow, slow service. Ordered everything specifically, ingredient-by-ingredient due to food sensitivity issues: everything came as an unidentifiable mess with, of course, things we didn't order and couldn't have. Glad I had to wait so long for the wrong food. Ate it anyway. Ate outside - which was necessary to escape the loud bad music. Of course, there are no garbage cans outside so we had to go back in to throw away the excess bags from what was not "to go". Don't they have trays? NO! Screw the trees - we're making them into bags for soaking up the grease. Burgers were mediocre at best; hot dog was lame. I guess we're not in Chicago, Toto. Maybe 5 Guys somewhere else is worthy of the "cult" following, but we won't be joining. thanks. you're going to need to find five other suckers. read more

This was a horrible trip, it's a shame they are the only location here, the manager needs to be seriously retrained, his customer service was awful and showed his lack of experience and lack of customer service skills! I only wanted to point out to him how dirty the lobby was especially the area I wanted to sit and enjoy my burger in. Needless to say I won't be back as long as the manager Aramis is there. I'm going to miss enjoying my burgers there but his attitude was just awful and caused this 5 guys to lose a loyal customer. read more

Great staff! Happy, welcoming, friendly. Great burger! Tasty, juicy, yummy. Great bathroom! Not gross, clean, very clean.

This is a great Five Guys! The employees are always very friendly and welcoming. The food is always hot and we have never had a bad visit. This location is way better and cleaner than the Valparaiso location. read more

Keep trying, as I like the place, the crew, and the peanuts. However, 4 of the last 5 times they have gotten the order wrong. Always take-out, there is a certain reluctance to unwrap the burger to see if they have gotten it right. So far, they are running 80% wrong. Come 'guys', do better. read more

Extremely tasty I particularly love their Cajun fries. They greet all of their customers with a smile and still returns with speedy service. I will always recommend five guys when looking for good food. read more