Top shelf pizza and wonderfully friendly proprietor and staff. Fantastic authentic pizza, perfectly…read moreseasoned and inventive varieties. Best pizza in Gettysburg to be sure, and a competitor that would hold its own anywhere.

Food was delicious- we ordered "to go" and the staff were very personable and friendly!! We ordered…read moremozzarella sticks, white pizza, and cheese pizza. Ingredients super fresh on the white pizza. Loved the crust. Can't wait to go back and try more items!!! A Must Stop when you are in Gettysburg!

Tasty, authentic pizza. Such a cute pizzeria! Service was excellent. Love the Pay it Forward…read moreprogram...you can pay for a slice and drink for someone who can't afford to buy it. I love to support mom & pop businesses rather than big conglomerates. This is a pizzeria well worth checking out!

The prices on the menu on the website are way out of date. A cheesecake is no longer $7.50, it's…read more$11.00. A can of soda is no longer $1.50, it's $2.75. Also there is a $5.00 delivery fee that goes to the restaurant, not the driver. So count on adding a tip for the driver.

Have always considered Golden Crust one of the best pizza and sub shops in the area. Even now after…read moremoving out of red lion when I want a great sub and pizza I drive to Golden Crust.

They had decent food. Service is usually pretty good. They have a great variety of beerread more

I ordered at 11 am. With an expected delivery of 11:55 to 12:10. My tracking updated and pushed it…read moreto 12:28. Unfortunately it did not arrive. After going through the online ordering, I was informed of technical issues, and that they had finally started making my order at 1 pm. That is just not acceptable, and I decided to cancel my order. I would give zero stars but yelp doesn't go that low. There was zero communication on the shops end and I had to actively pursue action to even get my pizza made, which I find disappointing considering its a pizza shop. However I did receive a refund so all I lost at the end of the day is a place im willing to eat at.​

They have quick service and his hands down the best pizza around. I have never had a bad experience…read morefrom this place. I would highly recommend trying it out.

PIZZA IS FIRE, BUT dont even think about expecting it a second sooner than the time you are told, &…read morebest be vigilant about reading that menu slowly, carefully and fully (author suggests preparing flash cards until you can PRECISELY recite the phone number and operating hours by memory, and are familar enough with the flow of the menu, it's diff sections, and at a minimum, the ingredient lists of your favorite, go to items. Basically, once you feel comfortable enough to be vocal about EXACTLY how you want your order prep'd, THEN you are ready. Until then, continue to recite directly from the menu, &/or rely on those flash cards when ordering. If you are wondering why such caution is given, please read each of the following DISCLAIMERS/WARNINGS that are directly copied and pasted from the menu. there are no less than FIVE, as you may confirm yourself by simply clicking on the link or going to the website provided on yelp,, or simply see below: DISCLAIMER: Please carefully read the ingredients of the item you want to order. If you have any preferences ask your server PRIOR to ordering (EXAMPLE: If ordering a calzone that comes with ham, mozzarella, ricotta & pizza sauce, you cannot complain if it contains 'pizza sauce' unless you specified for 'no pizza sauce'.) The crust of our pizzas are brown. Ask for light baked if you prefer it to be more white. Prices are shown for menu items only, every customization might occur in a price change. We make fresh food and some items may take different cook/preparation times, therefore they may be served at different times. Mistakes are possible, so if the food you have been served is incorrect in any way, please let us know right away and we will replace it -- to replace the food, we will need you to return the incorrect order back. Since we make fresh food to be consumed immediately, we cannot consider complaints the next day or any day after. All times of food preparation is estimated, not guaranteed. Grill and kitchen might close earlier than closing time (pizzas and cold subs available) NOTE: All food is prepared upon ordering... please allow 20-30 minutes (minimum) for our chef to create your meal. --(AUTHOR'S NOTE: beginning to see a pattern here...)-- MENU HEADER: (literally, like its their motto) we are not a fast food restaurant If you are in a hurry please consider that... --(AUTHOR'S NOTE: ok, these people must have been SERIOUSLY wronged in the past by some cranky customers... This town has like 600-700 population, who generally have quiet/polite dispositions , and "tourists" are def not culprits...what the heck happened here??!!)-- 4th & FINAL WARNING: (note how this includes yet another disclaimer regarding time of preparation etc. Directly following the food allergy warning. same paragraph, as if to say "yo, im including this here, right under the "possible death by peanut oil" disclaimer, just to emphasize how frickin' serious we are, about you understanding that WE ARE NOT A FAST FOOD RESTAURANT!" : - Rocky's New York Pizza Cannot Ensure That Items Do Not Contain Ingredients That May Cause an Allergic Reaction Please Consider This When Ordering. All food is prepared upon ordering...Please allow at least 20-30 Minutes (MINIMUM) for our chef to create your meal. Items may take longer than the estimated time given when you are placing your ordeR.

We drove just over 45 minutes to try this place out, and we were not disappointed. My wife…read moreoriginally saw one of their Steak and Cheese subs on Facebook and I knew I had to try it out. We had to wait a little while once we got there as they don't always open on time since they close so late. Once we got inside, the lady behind the counter was very nice and helped us order. I got the 10oz Steak and Cheese with Cooper cheese and some extras on a seeded roll. My wife got a pizza with pepperoni and banana peppers. The tables are numbered so they bring your food to you. It took a little while to get, but like one of their signs says, "This isn't fast food." Overall, we were very pleased with our meals. I would definitely go here again and would love to try out their deep dish pizza.

I have had their subs. the subs are well seasoned and meaty. they are my "go to" when I order at…read morePaesano's. staff are courteous and helpful with any questions one may have. they also have specials that are tempting.

Family owned and run sub and pizza shop. They also have meals and portions are always perfect…read more Staff is friendly and cordial. Price is also right.

Lived in york for 8 years now. Dont know how I didn't know of this place until now. Mom and pop…read moreshop. Very good!

Don't buy a gift card from Paesano's pizza in Jacobus! They won't honor the card unless you have…read morethe receipt from the last purchased in order to determine the balance?!?!? There was about $70 remaining after we used it once, but since we didn't have proof of a balance, they wouldn't even try running the card! That is stealing money right from your pocket!!! What a let down!! Very disappointed in the way they do business!!!