Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Fresh Island Fish Co

    5.0 (1 review)

    Fresh Island Fish Co Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Fresh Island Fish Co

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration
    Photo of Bill J.
    59
    61
    253

    6 years ago

    They had ice filled chests full of fresh fish both whole and filleted we enjoyed our purchase of mahi-mahi.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Seafood 2,498 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Tante's Island Cuisine

    Tante's Island Cuisine

    3.9
    (592 reviews)
    0.9 mi
    $$

    Despite being tucked away in the corner of a hotel, Tante's gives real local Maui vibes. The food…read morehas homecooked warmth and friendly Auntie service. We've been coming here for years and I've always enjoyed my experiences here, but last night I had a dish that compelled me to write a review. The oxtail soup which is listed as a favorite is a dish I've been eyeing for a while, but it's usually been too warm for me to crave it. But last night was the night. I'm getting over a cold and it's been raining off and on for weeks. The bowl arrived at the table with a plate underneath - smart move because it takes some work to eat oxtail soup. Armed with my fork and spoon, I went at it. The first taste floored me. It was perfectly seasoned and I could taste the fresh ginger, the broth was a beautiful brown color, there was plenty of napa cabbage and it came with a dish of a scoop of glossy steamed rice and steamed carrots, zucchini and broccoli. Our waitress offered to bring over condiments so I went for the soy sauce - sprinkled on the rice and veggies, I noticed that the veggies might have had a little sesame oil flavor on them so that made me happy. A spoonful of rice dunked into the broth with some of the tender fall of the bone oxtail meat, and a little crunch of the napa cabbage and I was in absolute heaven. I tasted my husband's pork adobo and that was equally as delicious as always. But that soup - that's what really did it for me last night and stays with me today. I walked out of Tante's with a swollen and happy belly and a fresh, tiny piece of ginger stuck between my teeth...a treat for later.

    We didn't expect to find this gem in our hotel. I had earned a $30 credit for my stay with Expedia…read moreso we decided to stop here for dinner and we were happily surprised. The food was great and so was the service. The prices were good and the portions were generous. I had shoyu chicken and my husband had ribs. Neither one of us were able to finish ours and we wanted to because it was delicious. The meat just fell off the bone. I did order a piece of cake to go. After getting back to our room I realized it was an ice cream cake so even as full as I was I tried to eat some cake before it all melted. The had the place decorated all up for Christmas. The lady that waited on us was super nice and kept our drinks filled. I love that attention.

    Photos
    Tante's Island Cuisine
    Alii breakfast
    Alii breakfast
    Tante's Island Cuisine

    See all

    Tiffany's

    Tiffany's

    4.2
    (902 reviews)
    2.4 mi
    $$

    Everything went well!!! Food was excellent!!!!!!…read moreTomahawk steak was a great special and I loved the flavor of the crack seed braise... Service was above and beyond what I expected (been awhile since I've been there) Look forward to their next occasion of specials in the near future Ambiance was completely worth the wait (arrived early before the reservation) Thanks to a no show...wait wasn't too long Look forward to another great meal for a good deal that made it even better than my previous experience a couple of years ago ...check it out for yourselves...there will be no regrets...Ryan the bartender was helping with our table, awesome, friendly, & great service...everyone were an amazing team...from the host/hostess (Brandon/Teri; to the chef and cooks involved!!!! Appreciated a great lunch from a great restaurant 5 TIFFANY'S RESTAURANT and their hard working staff

    We found Tiffany's Restaurant from a recommendation by a local, and that recommendation absolutely…read moredelivered. One of the biggest struggles in Maui is finding really good places open for lunch, so this spot instantly earned bonus points for that alone. The second the food started hitting the table, it was game over. Everything we ordered was ridiculous. Not "pretty good." Not "solid." Straight up 10/10 across the board. We started with the poke and it was FIRE. Super fresh, packed with flavor, and one of those dishes where everybody at the table suddenly goes quiet because they're too busy eating. Then the crispy pork belly came out looking like something a chef would enter into a competition. Crispy outside, tender inside, topped with onions and greens, sitting in this rich sauce that made me want to lick the bowl in public and risk embarrassment. The honey walnut shrimp was unreal too. Crispy shrimp covered in this glossy sweet sauce with candied walnuts on top. Dangerous food. The kind where you keep saying "one more bite" until the bowl is empty. The kimchi fried rice was another standout. Smoky, spicy, savory, loaded with flavor, and honestly some of the best fried rice I've had on the island. Even the fries were somehow amazing. How do you make fries memorable? Apparently Tiffany's figured it out. The restaurant itself has a really fun vibe. Busy but relaxed. Staff was super friendly, attentive, and seemed genuinely happy to be there. Portions were generous, prices were reasonable for Maui, and every dish looked like it was made by someone who actually cared about food instead of just trying to turn tables. Locals told me this place was created by the same chef behind Tin Roof, chef Sheldon, which made complete sense after eating here. You can tell there's real creativity and flavor behind everything coming out of that kitchen. This ended up being one of my favorite meals of the trip. If you're in Maui and want incredible local food without the super touristy resort vibe, Tiffany's is an absolute must-try. I hear that if you want dinner here you will wait. The place is packed for dinner. Try to catch it for lunch instead. Open for lunch on Saturday s only.

    Photos
    Fried Mahi
    Fried Mahi
    Local Greens Salad
    Local Greens Salad
    A proper looking spread

    See all

    A proper looking spread

    Fresh Island Fish Co - seafood - Updated June 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...