Pretty good pizza. It has better reviews than other pizza places that I think are better. But overall good experience. Their garlic knots are especially good and have a nice flakey crisp to the outside. read more

Generally, the food is great. Just a few instances where the staff/kitchen has made errors. They always fix the errors when they occurred however! read more

I normally love love love fusaros pizza and I normally eat it THERE. I tried delivery today. Not only was it a good hour late, I received an ice cold, soggy, and UNCUT pie!! I also ordered fries, which were cold and chewy as well. read more

Food is good, but the phone answering system is terrible. You're hung up on or put on hold without anyone saying hello or "fusaro's". Extremely unprofessional. Told the employee, and kinda got attitude. She said thats how the phone works. I hope they change it. When there are a dozen pizza places to choose from, customer service counts. read more

This place is the WORST for delivery! They promise an hour for delivery but I have waited 1 1/2 hrs and more at times. I order from here a couple times a week and spend ALOT of money here only because their food, in comparison to others in the area is not terrible. Unfortunately I'm going to need to find another place that appreciates my business. This is an ongoing problem with this place. Last week I waited well over an hour for 2 salads and requested a call back fron the owner who never called. This week I'm waiting well over 1 1/2 hrs for a salad and a wrap. NOTHING that takes 1 1/2 hrs to put together and I live 10 min from the place. Very disappointed in this place and there is absolutely no customer service. Kids are running the place with no comprehension of what customer service is. VERY VERY POOR SERVICE. Disappointed is an understatement. They have lost my business. read more

Great place for pizza, wings and sandwiches! Their bbq wings are by far the best! Best pizza place around!

The best pizza and wings around. There calzones are amazing. Never had bad food here. I order here prolly 5 times a month and I live right down the street. read more

We have been here twice and both times we have livery he food. It looks like a pizza place and is a pizza place. But the dinners are awesome as well. We sat outside with pups and and enjoyed Chicken Mimma. Baked ravioli and chicken cacciatore. Service was first class!! It looks like they have very nice catering menu. read more

Outstanding. Slices were awesome and service was great. Staying at nearby holiday inn, read review DNS decided to try it. Brought kids, everyone ordered something different and all lived it. Added touch was as we were leaving the staff gave the kids to go cups for drinks and offered to top then off. read more

I love this place. Food is always good and it's the best pizza around. Calamari is great & their subs are delicious. We've tried many of there dishes & we were never disappointed. read more

Great gluten free pizza! Delivery always fast and friendly :) they are always friendly and accommodating with questions re: gluten and allergy questions... price is comparable with other gf pizzas in the area read more

Great pizza, lots of variety and friendly folks.

Great food! Got margarita pizza, calzone and chicken parm dinner and all three exceeded our expectations. Would highly recommend this place, this will be my only spot for Italian food! Thanks read more

Had two bad experiences at Fusaro Pizza. The first one was right after their grand opening, and the food and service was terrible. Well to be fair, we thought we'd give it another try as some times it takes a while to get their act together. Big mistake. Again the food was awful and the management needs to take a course in customer appreciation. Would never go back to this place as we like to eat where food is edible and service has standards. read more

Pizza is ok but not the greatest. Ordered half pineapple and half peppers and they messed up the ordered and the counter girl blamed it on me even though one of the cooks heard me say what I wanted on the pizza. The pizza was then remade and it did not look appetizing and was made half assed. But the cheese fries are great read more

We ordered a couple pies and wings. We were told it would take an hour. After 75 minutes we called to see where the delivery was and they weren't sure, but said it would be there "soon". About the 85 minute mark the delivery showed up. The pizza and wings were lukewarm. I wanted to call and let them know, but my wife didn't want me to. So begrudgingly I had lukewarm food. I bet it would have tasted better. We will try them again because think they deserve another try. Potential is there.... read more

best owner and best pizza ever. the pan pizza is amazing and every time i come home i always come get it. the owner is the son of Naples pizza down in barnegat. it's awesome. come here and don't listen to any of these negative reviews!!!! if you want your pizza delivered faster COME PICK IT UP! the reason it takes longer for delivery is because this is the busiest pizzeria in Manahawkin and they deliver all the way to barnegat, 72 to 70 & LBI! read more

basic pizza. Nothing special. just fill your stomach when hungry pizza. Naples is better.

Best food always ! I always enjoy their buffalo chicken wrap and my husband and step son choose their pizza

While the pizza itself was good, we were told our street doesn't exist, which it does....and waited an hour and a half after being told no more than 45 minutes. Food wasn't hot when it arrived. read more

Placed an order for pick up recently. Large mushroom pizza, eggplant parm entree with spaghetti, and mozzarella sticks. This was on special, so we got all this for under $25 plus a salad & only had to wait 20 minutes to go pick it up (so awesome!). The eggplant parm was plentiful & delicious. Mozzarella sticks were yumm. Pizza was meh though & the only reason I didn't give 5 stars. The toppings were too concentrated in the center, which made for very soggy slices of pizza. Bottom line, I would def come back for the amazing service I received from staff & even risk ordering another pie from here since everything else was so good! read more

Food is usually okay, I guess it depends on who's working ... it's hit or miss BUT delivery time is TERRIBLE, every single time!!!! Always over an hour and sometimes cold. They really need to work on delivery. I order from here a lot but I'm ready to take my business somewhere else read more

These guys make a really good NYC pizza....once in a while. I guess it has something to do with the person making the pizza. But, so far, it is one of the best in Manahawkin, NJ and we order from them almost every Friday night. They deliver and that is definitely a plus, but most Fridays it is at least an hour wait. That itself is a testament as to how much people like their food. But, the delivery people don't understand that you can't put a hot pizza on a slanted car seat. That causes the cheese to slide. However, we still love this place and give them a salute for making great pizzas, subs, Stromboli's and anything else you order. Probably better if you pick your food up yourself. But, we're lazy so... They still do a good job. read more

My fiancée and I recently received one of their menus in the mail and figured why not give it a shot, considering we aren't too crazy about the other pizzerias in our area, and this place is our absolute favorite. Their bacon chicken ranch sandwich is hands down the best I've ever had, and the chicken parm vodka pizza was out of this world. Fusaro's pizza will be the only pizzeria we order from for now on! read more

I love Fusaro! The best pizza, and the best boss ever. As a long time employee, still my favorite place to eat. Best staff, best food, and not just saying that because I'm an employee! My family chooses their food for almost every family event, and every football Sunday. It's always nice to go in and see everyone so passionate about our jobs, even on our days off! I'd say it's the busiest place in Manahawkin for pizza... so please be sure to give some extra time! You won't be disappointed, it's well worth the wait!!! read more

To start, we called to make a take out order and the lady on the phone put us on hold with out even asking "can you hold please?" Like a normal restaurant would. They did that two times and then when they took the phone call they spoke at the speed of light and rushed to get off the phone. I don't even care if the food is good. It starts with the customer service and this place is one of the worst I've experienced. read more

Could do a little better on portion control, there's no such thing as too much food but if they cut the portions down just a bit it would be more cost efficient for said business and not so overwhelming for my belly read more

This place was disgusting!!!! My food was cold and the delivery driver took a long time and had a nasty attitude!! Don't go there choose another pizza place!!! I would give them NO STARs but I had to pick one. read more

Very good pizza . Not many places deliver to LBI and they do! Fast and friendly place. Try the grilled shrimp topping it's delicious.

The pizza is definitely different than mass-produced chain brands but I just don't care for it. I think it's the sauce...just doesn't do it for me. I would not tell anyone NOT to try their pizza, but I can't heartily recommend it either. read more

Best specialty pizzas in town. Buffalo chicken pizza is delicious and their chicken parm is to die for!

Pizza is good but please don't order anything else. I got a buff chicken cheesesteak and a cheesesteak on 2 separate occasions. They can't even bother to chop up the steak. It's just a slab of meat. Garlic knots were undercooked and just had a layer of cheese to cover it up read more

tried delivery for the first time and what a mistake. i was told it would be 45 minutes yet delivery took an hour and 15 minutes. my reward for my patience was cold tasteless pizza what a waste. read more

Whether it's stopping for a slice after the beach or take out dinner, we have only had great food at Fusaro's. Their caller id shows my name. I have long been in customer service and it feels great when some one says your name during your order. Love the chicken parm. read more

The worse service that you can imagine when ordering for delivery or pickup via phone. It doesn't matter who takes your call they will not get it right. Too many times now and I have decided to never go back to this business ever again. They also will burn or under cook your pizza. Classic lack of organization and communication with the employees and that about sums it up no matter how good the food might be. read more

I don't know why I keep giving this place a chance. When you wait 40 minutes on a Tuesday night only to not get your total order and then you call and get an attitude. Then when they bring back the missing item they ring the doorbell and leave it on the doorstep. How unprofessional and rude! I don't care if it was only a bottle of soda, the reason it was bought was to have it with dinner. And to top it off it was a warm bottle. To me that's a slap in the face of the customer. Don't offer delivery if you can't get it right! read more

the grandmas pie is a-ma-zing. staff always looks like they're having fun. best pie in manahawkin