Meh pizza at best! One reviewer said her orders have never been wrong in the bunch of years she's been going there, my first attempt there last night had me walking out with an incorrect order. Ordered a simple pepperoni pizza with onions, only to get home and find out it also had friggin chicken on it too. Asked for both pizzas we ordered to be well done, that didn't happen either......went home and finished them in our oven. Hmmmmm The pizza itself rivaled a cheap frozen pizza, both the thin crust and regular crust we ordered. Won't be headed back to this place anytime soon or possibly ever. Lastly......"handed" the cashier my credit card so she could swipe it, do you think she'd have the common sense to "hand" it back to me? Nah......she looked me in the eyes and dropped it on the counter between us. Had a $5 bill out to tip her but that quickly went back in my pocket. I guess I see it as a respect/customer service missed opportunity. read more

Excellent Greek style pizza. Had the meatball pizza. Nice big slices of meatball with just the right amount of sauce and cheese. Pleasant counter help. read more

This is the best tasting pizza around! They season their pizza so deliciously, that I always end up eating more. Their sides are good too. Sadly, they don't deliver which makes me want to throw a temper tantrum when we want pizza but don't want to go out. The upside is that the people are very friendly. So glad we accidentally stumbled upon this place. read more

Good owners, the wait is usually not too bad, clean eating area. The food is good, I usually only get a salad. Pizza is average but good. Nothing crazy but a good place to get late dinner. I like that the salad comes with a wrap, it usually rips tho. The Italian dressing is good and they put a LOT of cheese on the salads. read more

This is it. This is the pizza I had been searching for. It's thin, it's cheesy and it's greasy. It's exactly what I want with a beer on a Saturday night. I actually day dream about this pizza. For the last few years, I've been looking for that go-to pizza place. I never found it in Stoughton, and once I moved to Milford, I didn't have my hopes up after trying a few other places. Don't get me wrong, the pizza elsewhere is good enough, but it's not this. This is the style of pizza I grew up with. It's delicious! I don't know if I'll get around to trying the subs or anything else on the menu, but I'm sure if I do, I'll like them. read more

Great place, very popular. Difficult to order by phone because of this; the line is constantly busy. Don't be put off and keep trying because it's worth it. Pizzas and subs are the best in Milford. My husband likes another Milford shop slightly better for their salads but that's fine with me. I always want to order from here and usually do get my way!! read more

Let me start by saying that I love the subs here. Every sub my family has gotten here has been not only delicious, but huge. Their small would be a large anywhere else. We tried their pizza for the first time last week, however, and it definitely wasn't on par with the subs. There were so many toppings on the pizza that it was kind of mushy and impossible to hold the slice. Also, their mushrooms were definitely canned, and not fresh. We'll definitely keep coming here for the subs and to try new things, but we're going to keep looking for a new favorite pizza place. read more

I've been here about 3 dozen times. They have about 10 sandwiches in large size that are $5 which is awesome. All their prices are awesome and the quality is much higher than what you would expect for the prices they charge. There's been 2 times I've been there when the wait was unreasonable, but that was only when they were busy on a stupid level for huge sporting events, and only happened twice out of at least 3 dozen visits. It's a small business so that's reasonable and occasionally happens with small businesses. These guys are great, top 3 for favorite pizza places in the area! read more

Pizza wasn't great. I called ahead and still had to wait 15 minutes. Service was very unorganized, every body was trying to do every job.

Quick and easy delivery, fantastic cheese pizza! I've been a loyal customer for years. Hands down Milfords best pizza!

Food is OK if you want to wait over an hour for it to be delivered. Tried to call to ask where our food was and got the busy signal over and over again. Unbelievable to wait so long for pizza. Not impressed with this place. read more

The food is good... if you actually get your order. We have gone multiple times, hoping each time they would step up their game, but no. Every time they either screw up multiple orders, or just straight up "forgot" to give us food. Only this one last time were we offered a refund, and only for the item they "forgot" to give us, and there's been nothing more than a slight "Oh, sorry" from whoever has taken the order. We have done this both in-store and over the phone, and every time we get the same results. After time and time again of trying to let them redeem themselves, it's safe to say we will NOT be returning, and encourage people to look in their bags if they ordered more than 2 separate items to make sure they're actually all there. read more

Hands down the best pizza place around. The five dollar large subs are unbelievable. Great value for the money. Portions are generous. House made chicken salad is really good. Pizza is consistently tasty and correct. read more

This guy works too much but he does a great job. I think the owner makes every pizza that comes out of here. Not crazy about greek pizza but good quality. read more

Nice pizza. Crust wasn't that great but overall taste was good. Waited for almost 15 mins to pickup pizza. They have lot of options to choose from menu and are easy on pocket. They can still improve their crust a bit. We ordered veggie pizza with our own customization and they made it perfectly the way we wanted it. read more

This place is my favorite place in town to grab a sandwhich. Ever since I moved I make it a stop everytime I am home in town. I always get their Cesar wrap or Italian. The staff works so hard and makes some damn good food!! read more

I am perplexed at how people give pizza places glowing reviews for mediocre to bad pizza. This place wasn't bad, but it certainly didn't live up to some of the reviews here. the pizza was a standard, extra greasy, greek style pizza. It was okay, but still disappointing. We also got two gyros, which were okay, but nothing spectacular. The subs looked good and certain ones were only $5, $7 with chips and a drink, cheaper than some McDonalds meals and probably a lot better. I might give them another shot for the subs, but i was not impressed this time. read more

Love this place! I've had salads, wraps, sandwiches, pizzas all great! But my favorite are the calzones! Everyone is always friendly too! read more

Garden Pizza - Delicious cheese calzone!! - Pizza Near Me - Milford, Massachusetts

This place is fantastic. I ordered a pastrami and swiss. The sub was stacked with meat, I'm assuming at least a 1/2lb. Their prices are great. My large cost me $6.25. If your looking for tast food, huge portions, and better than fair prices then this is the place to go. BTW, the line was out the door on a Wednesday at noon. Apparently it isn't a secret how good this place is. read more

I couldn't think of a negative comment if I tried. Friendly staff, great local joint with subs that make me beg for more. Not too pricy, and get everything worth your dollar. read more

The pizza which should be the Gold Standard in Pizza - Price and Quality hits it on the mark. Greek style pizza this place is one of the best in the town of Milford if not one of the best in the country. The wait staff is AWESOME!! They know you by name. read more

i called to place an order and because i was in Bellingham, 1 town away they would not deliver to my work. I even said to the guy I am right down the st from you. He said we dont deliver to Bellingham. I am about 2 miles down the road, close than most of the places the probably deliver to in Milford. Very bad customer service. I mean come on at least look it up on your gps to see i am very close to your restaurant. read more

My family has been going here for as long as I can remember, and I can honestly say EVERYTHING on the menu is delicious. Maria and family are so great, and the food is truly made with love. read more

I have been going there since I was a kid. Great pizza and great subs. There food is alittle greasy but I personally like it that way. Great family owned and operated shop that have been in business for a very long time. One of my favorite places to eat read more

In the world of sub and pizza shops, Garden Pizza is, by far, the best in the area. Their pizza is very good. Its the classic round Greek / Italian style pizza and its excellent. But, what sets this place FAR apart from the rest, is their sub sandwiches! They are absolutely FANTASTIC! Nice and fresh, always loaded up, huge and simply delicious. This is our go to place all the time. You will have a small wait every now and again, but that's because the place is packed with people. That should tell you how good it is! BTW, the Subway shop next door is always empty! So if you want the best subs in town, come here for sure! read more

food is not bad... the new delivery guy is pretty rude and my sandwhich wasnt even wrapped and i ordered a red gatorade not a ginger ale.

The pizza here is terrific and is offered at a very decent price. Whenever we order out this is always my number one choice. I am a big fan of the linguica pizza but I do not think you could make a mistake ordering form their toppings menu. read more

This place rules!! Good prices and even better food. I go to this place constantly and am always pleased by the food and service. Get the chicken parm calzone with 1000 island dressing on the side. Zza rules read more

I love this place... this is the ideal pizza and sub shop. I get the sense that it's a family operation. There are always the same people working there. Everyone is very friendly! The food is great! Lots of selections, and the serving sizes are very generous. And overall... it's a very clean place. read more

There are no shortage of pizza places in/around Milford, but Garden is the best. Friendly staff who know how to handle the dinner rush. Fresh, tasty ingredients. Generous portions (their small subs are jammed with ingredients) and an all-around good meal. Garden has been there for years, and it's no surprise to me they're still doing well even after a Subway opened right next door. read more

You can't beat their prices , on the $ 5.00 large subs , you get what you pay for, and then some . Tomorrow will be pizza night , and their pizza are about the best the town of Milford has to offer . Pat Fahey read more

Really good. It is what it is. Good food, at a good price. We had the barbecue chicken pizza - so good. It is just affordable good quality food. read more

Garden Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Milford, Massachusetts

Fave pizza restaurant there food is great and I totally recommend there feta mozzarella no sauce pizza

This place deserves/is a 5 star pizza/sub shop. Preferred choice. Girlfriend hates me cuz all I eat is garden pizza.

this is where my love for pizza stemmed from. growing up as a kid, i would visit my grandparents who lived right around the corner from this place, so we would frequently get it. the pizza is really fresh and delicious- i am a huge fan of their pepper and onion pizza. quick service as well. it has been years since i have had their pizza, but i can remember exactly how good it tastes :) read more

Average not great tasting, not enough " home made sauce" that heh brag about, rude on the phone, takes forever to deliver. Giving two stars for the service. Pizza was very average. read more

Probably my favorite pizza place to get delivery from. Always very fast and the food isn't too greasy like some other pizza places in the area. I usually order the buffalo chicken calzone, which is made with delicious grilled buffalo chicken, the perfect amount of melted mozzarella and I also get extra blue cheese dressing on the side for dipping (they have a great homemade blue cheese dressing with big chunks of the blue cheese in it, not some packet of kens dressing like alot of other places), or I will order the Gyro, if you not familiar with the Gyro it is basically a flatbread wrap with lamb, tomatoes, onions and a delicious cucumber sauce. I have tried many Gyros and Garden has by far the best, not the biggest so if you have a big appetite like myself you might want to order 2, I think they are only about 5 bucks each. They also have chicken Gyros that are absolutely delicious as well. I personally prefer the lamb due to the fact that I am part Armenian and grew up with my mother and Nana cooking all kinds of homemade Armenian dishes in which lamb was the main ingredient. Whether you order a sandwich, calzone, or just a plain cheese pizza, Garden is definately a solid pizza place where you get your moneys worth, on top of great, fast service. Enjoy read more

The pizza is inconsistent here. Sometimes it's good, sometimes it's so thin and greasy they you pick it up and EVERYTHING falls off. The salads and dinners are usually pretty good. Not sure if I recommend them for pizza. read more

Their calzones are the best around. Get the buffalo chicken you won't be disappointed

I will start off by saying two things: Milford does not really have any good pizza delivery places, and I'm not a fan of Greek pizza, so I'm biased on that front. Sorry guys, I come from an Italian family, I like Italian pizza. But, for Greek Pizza, Garden Pizza is pretty good, and their subs are pretty good too. Not great, but good. Staff is very friendly, and the place is always busy, so someone must like them. I would definitely go there again, but they're not my #1. read more