I loved this place, was a great addition to the area until the service went to shit. I used to go here 1-2 times a week, loved the food and drinks but the service went from so so to the worst I've seen. The last and final time I was there the service was so bad that we ended up canceling the diners we had ordered (over an HR into waiting) and just paying for the one drink we got, even though we had ordered more. This place isn't cheap but the food and drinks were worth it. Sad to say I would never go back. It's a shame, was one of my go to places but the service ruined it. The waitress was always rude, she waited on us almost every single time we were there, I've never had such shitty service from one person. I'd go back if they fired her. I'm giving this one star because I have to, otherwise it would be zero. read more

I find the food very tasty, especially the chicken and waffles. The beer selection is great. But the wine is overpriced. The staff is nice but took away my plate before I was done. It's clearly trying to be the former Twin Lights Tap House in Highlands, but lacks the warmth and atmosphere. read more

We checked this place out after visiting Carton Brewery and the appetizers were delicious. We got the fries, wings and meatballs....GET THEM! This place also has a great beer selection with a lot of local craft beers. The only reason I didn't give this place 5 stars is because the service SUCKED. There was definitely employee drama.... read more

Been here a few times. Great beer selection, good food, and decent service. Definitely get the truffle fries.

The perfect little gem in the area. I'd heard good things about it and I definitely wasn't let down. It's got a great atmosphere and a nice decor, starting with the non-nondescript exterior (no sign). It gives you the feeling of entering into somewhere special that not everyone knows about. We stopped in for lunch and to have some drinks and were impressed from the start. They had 30 craft beers on tap, with a good selection of options for whatever you're in the mood for and the bartender said they are constantly changing. As an added bonus, they have a good amount of local brews to choose from too. I ordered the shrimp po boy and my wife had their CBS burger with truffle fries. Wow. Both were fantastically made and tasty. Definitely a spot we'll be coming back to again. read more

Great restaurant minutes from the marina! My kids devoured the fish and chips. I had the crab sandwich which was delicious.

Went for light dinner & a beer. It was a Sunday so the football crowd was there. Nice place, loud but not too loud. Cleared out pretty quickly after the game. Food is quite pricey for a pub & the muscles I got were mediocre at best. My rating is based on the fantastic craft beer selection or it would have been lower. Service was pretty poor at the bar even though it was slow after the game. No reason for me to go back except for the beer. read more

Looking for a dinner to go ordered two chicken pot pies for $20 each got a piece of cold filo dough with a small plastic dish of heated up frozen peas and carrots with a few shreds of chicken to pour over the dough. We just threw it away. They should be ashamed of theme selves calling this chicken pot pie for $20 a shot. read more

Nice atmosphere. I didn't get a chance to try the food, but they have a big beer selection. Wines were expensive and slim pickins. Didn't seem to be "allergy" friendly, no gluten free beers or gf food selections. read more

I love this cozy little place despite its oddities. The beer selection is great and if you pick the right item off the menu the food is great too. They also have tasty cocktails which is nice. However the inconsistency in the food earns them only 3 stars in my book. I've had some of my best and least enjoyable meals here, but I always keep coming back for the atmosphere and the staples like the Mac & cheese and roasted chicken. The food is also pricey. This doesn't look like the kind of place to get a $40+ steak. The elusive nature of this place was at first frustrating (no name, no phone number, no apologies) but that's since gotten better and we've learned not to go here for holidays, special occasions, etc. It's more of a last minute "let's try Gaslight tonight" thing, and that's okay. There's room for improvement but there's something special about this place. read more

As good as it gets. Everything on the menu is guaranteed amazing. Ranges from fish and chips, to steaks, to chicken and waffles. The calamari salad is to die for- I crave it everyday. Also, the tuna pizza is the best thing I've ever tasted. If you want a casual, laid-back place with a fun atmosphere and amazing appetizers and dishes, you should come here. read more

This is one of my favorite local spots. Atlantic Highlands is quickly becoming a great hotspot for food and drink. My SO and I love hitting up Carton Brewing for a flight of this weeks new beers and then heading over to Gaslight for some snacks and of course, more beer. I'm sure that the other reviews have mentioned the great selection of local craft beer and small batch whiskey. The food is also great. On our last visit, we had the special burger which was topped with mushrooms and horseradish. We almost had to order another, but we were insanely full from the oyster appetizer and Fish & Chips. The oysters are outstanding. If you like beer and classed up pub food, stop here after your visit to Carton. read more

I'm not really into craft beers but the wait staff helped me find a couple I enjoyed. The oysters and cheesesteak were out of this world. Great food, drinks, and service. Pretty impressed being it only opened not too long ago. read more

As with the reviews I read below the food is OK... Not great. I agree with the notes on the staff but have to add the responsibility lies with the management. As at the sister restaurant, Copper Canyon if you sit at the bar you are fine. Try to get a table and the staff is pressured to rush guests out, selectively seat people and tell patrons that they need to leave to free up a table. Sad part is the wait staff are only doing what they are told and trained. Any attempt by the staff to go the extra mile and heaven forbid be kind to diners and they are punished or their hours are cut. I will no longer go to either of these restaurants on principle. read more

A huge variety of beer and great food! We were regulars when we lived in Atlantic Highlands. Highly recommended.

Great atmosphere, fresh food made in house everyday and a large beer selection ! They have great specials on the weekends with some great products grown locally! read more

I wouldn't go back for the food, that's one thing they need to work on. Tried to help them correct the problem (worked in F&B 7 years) for future orders and all I seen was the cook come out and give a dirty look. Wasn't even a big problem to fix, atleast for what I I had ordered. The other members part of my party also weren't impressed with the food. However, I have been back to try beers there (no food). They do have a pretty good selection. read more

I really loved this place, always has a great beer collection and the food is even better.

I've been to Gaslight many times since opened...as I live locally and support town businesses. I think the food has gone downhill...tho still a popular enough place to have a simple burger and beer. The tuna sushi pizza app is reliably decent. Waiter recommended the special on Saturday of aged beef tacos...two of them for $20...the beef was flavorless and dry, not juicy at all....seemed like deli roast beef cut in matchsticks....the horseradish sauce was overpowering in quantity, the apple made no sense, lacking any tart flavor or crunch...overall they were disappointing....the regular menu tacos are better. read more

I really enjoy this place. I've always loved this location and Gaslight serves the right food and drink to mesh with the ambiance and decor of this space. Everything is just really enjoyable. It's comfort food with great beer and an intelligent, attentive, well informed staff. There are very few places in the area that serve Chicken and Waffles so that right there gives it something unique not to mention the incredible selection of beer and bourbon cocktails. It is a little bit on the pricey side for the kind of food but I have been there a few times now and have always left satisfied. read more

The food and the service were amazing. I would have eaten the sushi tuna pizza all night!!! We all shared appetizers and salads. Everything was top notch. One of my new favorite spots. read more

Went for dinner and the beer. pricey for mediocre food. ordered a craft beer and really enjoyed it. I ordered another one and they said they have to get it from the basement. 15 minutes later they said they do not have that beer but do have something similar. Finally got the second beer and it it was cloudy and no head and tasted awful and was flat. Leaving a bad aftertaste. I told the waitress this was not good and not like the other beer. She took it away, the full glass of beer, and when we got the check we were we were charged for the beer that we had sent back. The waitress then told us its a craft brew and even if it was bad we have to pay for it. thats the policy! terrible policy and terrible customer service. read more

Love this place but stay away from the seafood linguini. Terrible. Everything else is great though.

Beer beer beer!!!! And the food is amazing to! Octoberfest beer is now my favorite and the chicken and waffles are not so bad either.

Came in for the first time last week. Had such a great experience! This place is a hidden gem. I'll definitely be back for more!!!

Was in need of a great summertime meal before heading over to WindanSea for music out on the deck and wanted to have something more interesting than Thai (which is good) or Memphis Pig Out (always a standby) and walked down to the Gaslight for our second dinner there. First time, was surprised at the varied menu and the delicious burger and the fantastic truffle fries. Husband ordered that this time and the fries were just as good. This Saturday night, had the amazing chicken tacos (still thinking about them) with a grilled cob of corn. Corn was perfect with cilantro butter and covered in grated cheese. The chicken was spicy and that was offset with cool slices of pickled radish and avocado. Washed it all down with a killer cider beer as we watched the Mets game on the large screen TVs. Could not have been better (well, maybe, the Mets lost that night...) read more

You can't order anything if everyone in your party isn't seated. I guess if you're the owner you can make up any nonsensical rule you like. You also really piss off your customers with your obtuse, unhospitable rules. read more

Nice bar with great atmosphere and personable staff. We started with the calamari salad which was amazing! I had the burger which I asked for rare and they delivered it perfectly. My husband had the fish and chips which was a generous portion, super moist on the inside and crispy on the outside. He wasn't crazy about the sauce, tartar would have been better. Beer selection was good. Sit at the bar if you like to interact with the bartender! read more

If not for the beer selection, I'd give this place 2 stars. Wait staff always seem like they want to be somewhere else. Food is good but overpriced. Love the building and decor. Been to gaslight 5-6 times but won't go back for food, would only head back for the beer. read more

To say that our experience at Gaslight was exceptional would be an understatement. For starters, our server Allie was attentive and very friendly. My wife and I shared the hanger steak and it was one of the best steaks I have ever had in New Jersey. Allie, recommended that along with our wine pairing and appetizer and we could not have been more satisfied. Bottom line, Excellent Service, Top Notch Food and Beautiful Atmosphere. Can't wait to be back. read more

Never in my life have I been at a "gastropub" that will not let you sit down and have a beer. You can only drink at the bar not the empty tables. The worst part is the hostess finds joy in telling you you cannot sit down and have a beer "but feel free to go to our sister restaurant next door". What stinks is the beer is good the food is good and most of the staff is friendly. read more

Great beer selection. Also great service. Patrick, our waiter was great! Hubby and I had grilled oysters, grilled shrimp salad and C.B.S burger. Yum! read more

I love this place. Great space in historic building. Great quality food. The staff really cares and makes the experience relaxing and fun. Decided I would make my " local pub". Large selection of tap beers. Love grilled salmon burger, sushi pizza, grilled corn, polenta with mushrooms, chicken pot pie. read more

The bar is called gaslight! But only because there is a picture of an actual gaslight outside in the front, it is not written...... Once you get past the confusion there you can go inside and enjoy one of the many craft beers they have to offer or liquor too if that's your thing. This bar has a speak easy vibe with a touch of hipster. The hipster part mainly comes from the fact that the name of the bar is not words, it's a picture. I tasted a number of items on the menu to say the food there is delicious! Especially - the sushi pizza, garlic shrimp, Brussels sprouts and the chicken and waffles. It is a casual setting with tvs above the bar. The service was fantastic. Patrick, our waiter was very knowledgable of all the beer on the menu and more importantly extremely patient in helping our table order the perfect beer. Overall I had great experience. One thing to note is they do not recommend bringing children and they do not have room for strollers. Oh well, I'll still go back! read more

Gaslight - So many beers ! - Gastropubs Near Me - Atlantic Highlands, New Jersey

FANFREAKINGTABULOUS!! So many delicious craft beers to chose from! The wait staff especially our server Timmy was AWESOME! And the food! Omg the food was EXCELLENT! I've can not recommend this place enough! Best addition to Atlantic Highlands! read more

Been here what seems like countless times now. Such a great craft beer selection, excellent food. The chef does everything gourmet style, and it's exceptional. Great job updating the taps frequently with local brew and seasonals. So happy to have found a local tavern I can call 'home'. read more

Great craft beer choices, around 30. The food is phenomenal. Grilled oysters app are unbelievably delicious. We try to come here whenever we are in the area. Pretty cool and laid back. Great staff. read more

Great dining experience. Food was amazing I would heavily recommend the chicken and waffles and the tuna sushi pizza. Plus a big menu including local carton craft brew and many other micro brews. Look forward to coming back again. read more

Bartenders are worthless. Definitely not trained on prompt customer service. Have witnessed several patrons leave due to slow bar service. Meanwhile two other employees in plaid shirts (male) keep wondering around doing absolutely nothing. Management would benefit from being on site. Staff is not competent enough to be left unsupervised. read more

Great ambiance -slow, awful, exceptionally rude bartender 4pm 2/12/17. Very unprofessional. Establishment would be well advised to better screen and train personnel. read more