Think of this review as a classic example of comparison & contrast. Yes, this review is a bit delayed, but after returning from Chicago, a city known for its pizza, I feel that I can reasonably claim that Chicago pizza doesn't compare to the masterpiece of culinary perfection served at Gelati & Peccati. Cuisine: 5/5. Full disclosure, I'm not a big pizza aficionado. In my experience, pizza usually either tastes over-processed or it lacks flavor--especially in the U.S. This was certainly my experience in Chicago. Large, dull slabs of dough, lacking in one iota of flavor, to the point where me and my European colleague kept pouring pepper on the pizza in the futile attempt to summon flavor out of the pizza. Up until my special experience at Gelati & Peccati, (sorry, I can't recall which slice I ordered), the only memorable pizza experience that forced me to reconsider my anti-pizza opinion was in Perpignan, France. And to be fair, this isn't an apples to apples comparison, as nearly every item of food in Europe tastes better than the over-processed poison served in the uniquely American hell-scape of chain restaurants and fast food joints. Note: there are many caveats to this claim, which include but aren't limited to Mexican food, Brazilian food, Thai food, Texas Brisket, Soul Food, and anything that isn't saltine cracker-bland AF. That said, the slice of heaven served at Gelati & Peccati is nothing but flames, and it stands in stark contrast to the banal slabs of dough purporting to be pizza in Chicago. Look, it's simple: I could actually taste each ingredient. Yes, the cheese tasted like actual cheese, and the veggies and sauce actually tasked like--food. This was just the paradigm shift that I needed when it comes to eating pizza in the U.S. I will definitely return the next time I pass through SD. Ambiance: 5/5. The woman working the ovens that night delivered authentic/energetic Euro vibes as she danced to EDM while preparing our pizzas. Definitely felt like we weren't in the states, which was refreshing. Much thanks! Buen provecho. read more

Gelati & Peccati - Gelato Near Me - San Diego, California

My daughter and I came here for a sweet treat after our Mother's Day brunch. We shared a medium cup with coffee hazelnut with salted caramel and banana walnut brownie. These 2 flavors were the perfect combo! It's interesting how the shop sold gelato and pizza. There was a large assortment of different types of pizzas that looked quite tasty, but we were stuffed. We were very happy with our gelato though! The space was rather small, but there was a long hightop table along the wall inside and stools, as well as some small tables and chairs in the front of the shop. It's not the prettiest place, but the gelato was good. read more

See all

AMAZING gluten free pizza!!! You can even make a handful of pizzas vegan as well. The gluten free crust is fantastic: thick, airy, good crispy outside. The toppings on their pizza are creative and wonderful, from prosciutto to hot honey to potato! The prices on their pizza (especially the slices) is unbeatable. I would come many days in a row for these slices. The crew was always so kind about accommodating for my gluten free slice. They would ask for a little extra lead time which is totally cool, and make it without sour faces!!! I know it's annoying but it's greatly appreciated. Very small shop but I like how they squeeze in bar style seating. They have some tables outside to catch some sun and take in the North Park views. Open late for those late nights! read more

Gelati & Peccati - View from the small patio area - Gelato Near Me - San Diego, California

This place is a must when in north park. So many to choose from. My personal favorite is the red sauce with tomato's , chili flakes , mozzarella & balsamic extra toasted. Service is always quick & the same gentlemen tends to be there. Very nice. Cute little hang out spot for a quick bite. I'd definitely be back. read more

I'm gonna be honest: I've been here multiple times and have never once bothered to check the actual Yelp reviews lol, but it makes sense to why the ratings are up there. Although I still have yet to try their hot foods, especially their pizza flights, I can only speak on my other experiences. The gelato always tastes fresh and consistent here and the people working behind the counter are always accommodating. It's a bit out of the way in North Park, compared to all of the other eateries and restaurants near 30th, but the trek is still worth making. I know not everyone thinks of Gelato & Peccati when they're looking for their ice cream/gelato fix in San Diego, but I'd recommend! read more

Pizza had flys in it! When I walked into the store, there was a big big fat flying flying around all of the pizzas multiple different ones well one of employees just watching the fly go from one pizza to another then I look over and see this little fly on a completely different pizza I was so grossed out I couldn't even eat it anymore read more

Gelati & Peccati - Flys in pizza - Gelato Near Me - San Diego, California

Definitely one of my favorite dinner options in North Park! I'm here in the area for shows at Observatory fairly frequently, and this is on my rotation of spots when I need a quick dinner. The crust is great because it's light & fluffy inside, crunchy outside. It also is a little healthier because it's lighter on cheese and sauce, heavier on fresh toppings. I love that they have tons of choices. This time I had mushroom, pepperoni, cheese, and hot honey. It was delicious, with tons of mushrooms. My friend enjoyed his jalapeño pepperoni and regular pepperoni as well. Their gelato is great too. My usual is the cherry hazelnut, but I usually try a tester of some of the seasonal flavors. Limited seating, either inside on the wall or a few tables outside. When I'm eating by myself, I usually get it to go. read more

Gelati & Peccati - Gelato Near Me - San Diego, California

A great spot for a quick but delicious slice of pizza! They have so many unique options and flavors, and a great display of their offerings at the window. I tend to gravitate towards pizzas without tomato sauce, and they had plenty of choices. I got one with tumeric and ricotta, and it was delicious and one slice was a perfect snack. The cashier was very friendly and warmed up the pizza for me, and there was casual counter seating where I enjoyed my pizza. They also serve gelato, which I definitely want to try next time! It's located in a popular walkable street in Norrh Park, and even open late for those who are there for the nightlife. read more

Gelati & Peccati - Tumeric pizza - Gelato Near Me - San Diego, California

See all

Diavolo was super spicy for me. The turmeric ome was good! It was flavorful and had some rasp jam for sweetness and added depth! the artichoke spicy one was also really good and i liked the taste. i liked it more than the diavolo! Its a small cozy and casual shop with counter seating and some outdoor seats! You go in and order the pizza and they will heat it up in the pizza oven for you. pretty quick and efficient. read more

Gelati & Peccati - Gelato Near Me - San Diego, California

See all

Still the best pizza and gelato joint in town! You get the most awesome pizza cooked on a cedar board followed by sweet tasty gelato - what's not to like? Seating is outside and extremely limited. And little to no seating inside - this place is still packed. Great service as well - they are fast with the rush hour crowd. This is truly one of my favs!! read more

See all

I really appreciated the quick, friendly and helpful service! There is mostly seating outdoors and some inside but fairly limited. The pizza looked really beautiful, and was individually heated up. I didn't have a chance to try the gelato but I would definitely have it another time! A great spot for a quick bite. I got the 3 slice and 1 beer combo which totaled $22, so not a bad deal! read more

Pizza by the slice with this many options? I honestly can't think of many places in San Diego that do it this well. And they have gelato too, what more could I ask for on a hot sunny day? There's seating inside, mostly high-top tables, and plenty of outdoor seating along the sidewalk. I also loved the little netted door they have to keep flies and bugs out. I decided to get the vegan arrabbiata slice to go, and wow, it was absolutely delicious . My only regret is not ordering a second slice. Of course, I couldn't leave without trying the gelato. Choosing a flavor was honestly the hardest part because everything looked so good. After sampling a few recommendations from the staff, I went with the coffee hazelnut, and it did not disappoint. One thing I really appreciated was the portion size. The small gelato was actually small, not one of those giant servings that somehow counts as a small. It was the perfect amount and left me satisfied without feeling overly full. Between the pizza, the gelato, and the friendly staff, this place was a winner for me. I'm already looking forward to coming back and trying more of their pizza slices. read more

Gelati & Peccati - Vegan Arrabbiata Slice Pizza - Gelato Near Me - San Diego, California

See all

The pizza looked good with a variety of choices. I came here for gelato though. I had a small cup with a choice of two flavors. I went with my go to pistachio and also something interesting- olive oil, orange zest, & agave. The pistachio was average. I sampled the olive oil and liked it, but the scoop I was given was melty. Meh. read more

Gelati & Peccati - Pistachio / Olive Oil Orange Zest and Agave - Gelato Near Me - San Diego, California

So glad I stopped in here the other night and will definitely be returning! I swear I've walked by many times before and never noticed it. On this occasion, it was the pizzas displayed in the window that caught my attention, not to mention that I wanted dessert. In addition to the outdoor seating, they have seating against the wall of this cute compact restaurant. It's more of a rectangle with the enticing pizza at the front and gelato options towards the back. They have an amazing variety, some of which I would never have thought to combine before, let along put on pizza. Im also a huge fan of this style of pizza - packed with toppings and a square crispy crust. Another plus is their vegetarian and vegan options. While it was hard to choose, I went with the pepperoni/mushroom/mozzarella/honey pizza and the sausage/potato/rosemary pizza. So delicious and was surprised they gave 2 squares (I was only expecting 1). To add to the experience, they heated up the pizza and delivered it on a wooden slab. Lastly I got my dessert in the form of snickers gelato, perfect way to end the meal. Everything was 5 stars for me including the service, variety, taste and quality of the food and its cute cozy atmosphere. I will be back to try other combos! read more

See all

i got the jalapeno & pepperoni pizza that also has dollops of ricotta cheese. pizza was unremarkable and just fine. dont get me wrong, it was good but there's so many other better places to visit. there is an option for everyone but i do believe prices were a bit steep. it's super small inside, much more of a grab and go! read more

Gelati & Peccati - Gelato Near Me - San Diego, California

See all

Very nice pizza and customer service here! The variety of pizza and gelato to choose from were great, ready to eat right away. The gentleman was kind and patient with my friends and I. I chose the mushroom + sage pizza and would get it again. Definitely recommend this place for a nice lunch with friends or a quick stop for a snack. *Matcha in picture is from a different local shop read more

Gelati & Peccati - Mushroom + sage pizza with others * matcha is from different local shop - Gelato Near Me - San Diego, California

Don't let this tiny, nondescript, no frills hold in the wall pizzeria and Gelateria deter you! THE PIZZA HERE IS AMAZING!!! Not sure what the crust it is, but its got that Roman square style thick crunch that doesn't exist anywhere else San Diego. As on their website "Simply Natural Roman-style Pizza al Taglio. A variety of one-of-a-kind pizzas...". The toppings and styles change daily it seems, with at least a dozen different tempting choices. I've had a variety of them, the mushroom is always favorite. The meaty ones are fantastic too. About $5-6/slice. read more

See all

The pizza toppings are so fresh and I'm partial to the mushroom, pepperoni, and fresh mozzarella, though they have a lot of amazing flavor combos such as mortadella and ricotta among many others. The prices are affordable, the service is friendly, and they reheat your slices to order. I rarely get the gelato but there are a lot of flavor options if you craved dessert right after your delicious, savory pizza. This is basically a one stop shop with the only drawback being that they don't have a ton of seating for larger groups. read more

One of my favorite pizza and gelato places in all of SD. Their pizza is always good and they toast it to perfection before we dig in. They have all the classic gelato flavors as well. This is a staple in north park and will always come back whenever I get the chance for a quick bite read more

Cute and fun spot for gelato, gourmet pizza and spirits with late night hours. We enjoyed the gelato outside the store and took back our pizza to heat up at our Airbnb, delicious! read more

See all

After an event, we stopped by Gelati & Peccati and had an amazing experience with both their pizza and gelato. The pizza is sold by the slice, with a wide variety of options, including vegetarian, vegan, and meat-based choices. They even offered to drizzle truffle oil on my slice before putting it in the oven and asked if I preferred it soft or crispy. Once ready, the staff brought it over to us at the small bar seating area. The pizza was absolutely delicious! Afterward, we enjoyed some gelato, which was just as incredible. The flavors were rich and authentic, making it the perfect way to end the meal. The atmosphere was relaxed, and the prices were very reasonable for such high-quality food. Whether you're in the mood for a quick bite or a casual evening out, Gelati & Peccati is a great choice. They also offer a selection of wines, beers, Italian drinks, and water. I highly recommend stopping by for some delicious pizza or gelato--you won't be disappointed! read more

See all

I absolutely LOVE the variety of pizza slices this place offers. If you're someone who gets excited by options like I do, this is heaven. I'm big on variety -- and they truly deliver!! Their pizzas range from savory to sweet, so there's truly something for every mood. Whether you're craving a classic, something bold and creative, or even a sweeter twist, they've got it. Walking in feels like being a kid in a candy store. I want to try everything. It's impossible to pick just one slice. And let's not forget -- they have gelato to go hand in hand with your pizza. The perfect sweet finish after something savory. The quality matches the selection -- fresh, flavorful, and satisfying every time. This has easily become one of my all-time favorite pizza spots. If you love having choices and trying a little bit of everything, this is your place. read more

Food is amazing. Best gelato and different kinds of pizza slices. Gelato is interesting flavors and different than others.

Very kind staff. They allowed us to try several different flavors. Gelato was creamy and delicious. A little too sweet for me but still yummy. I was hoping for a coffee espresso flavor to combo with my amaretto but they didn't have one at the time. Biscoff was still delicious read more

Gelati & Peccati - Amaretto and biscof cookie crunch - Gelato Near Me - San Diego, California

We came here for pizza after grabbing drinks and we were all really pleased with our food. There are so many pizza options available and I love that they are displayed so you can see them visually. The man taking our order was very polite and kind as he took our order and helped us figure out which one we wanted. I chose one that had mushrooms, pepperoni, and hot honey and one that had mashed potatoes. The pizza was warmed up in the pizza oven which made them so good! The one with mashed potatoes was a little plain for me, but my friend enjoyed it. Overall, I would come back for their pizzas and would love to try their gelato! The seating is sort of like bar seating, but facing the wall. read more

Gelati & Peccati - Gelato Near Me - San Diego, California

See all

I appreciate this from a business owner perspective lol. What a great business model. Who doesn't love ice cream and pizza?! It feels like a well run mom and pop store. Their pizza is outstanding and when you're finished eating, you can stay and get gelato for dessert. I also like the one in North County because parking is easier. read more

Very nice, friendly people. It's dark inside. I guess it's a spot for people who are hungry after leaving the bars. The gelato are a hit but the pizzas were a miss. The pizza slices looked good but the flavors weren't for us. read more

See all

Cute, little pizza shop in the heart of San Diego! We visited this place on a Saturday and luckily got seating despite them only have 2-4 in-house tables. (I believe they have a few 2-seater ones outside too though) My friend and I got the Ricotta Mortadella Pistachio pizza slices and they were delish! Great for people who don't want too intense of a flavor and/or want a similar taste to bologna or salami. read more

Gelati & Peccati - Ricotta Mortadella Pistachio - Gelato Near Me - San Diego, California

This was my second time coming here. The service is always great. The selection of the flatbreads are also great! Inside the restaurant, there's not much space and it's very narrow... but it's super cute! The reason why I'm giving this a four star instead of five is because it was just a bit bland. I definitely come here again to eat, but something was just lacking flavor. I definitely eat here again though. read more

This place is exceptional. I went to the one in Escondido and it's also great but this one has a great ambience. Excellent service. Great selection of some of the best pizza that you're gonna find. Also some of the best gelato I've had. With unique flavors and quality ingredients. Highly recommended. read more

Gelati & Peccati - Gelato Near Me - San Diego, California

Wow. First time here. Pizza was great. Service was good and sitting outside was a delight. Enjoy! read more

Gelati & Peccati - Gelato Near Me - San Diego, California

See all

This is for the gelato here. It's closer to ice cream. Not good. If they advertised as ice cream, might have been better. read more

Gelati & Peccati - Gelato Near Me - San Diego, California

See all

A whole window filled with 20 different pizza slices caught my eye, and I knew I had to walk inside! Margherita Pizza: 5/5 Margherita pizza is simple and delicious. The tomato sauce is one of my favorites I've tried. The drizzle of olive oil on top was a great addition. The crust was warm and fluffy. Service: 5/5 There was only one man working when we came in, and he was so kind. He answered our menu questions and gave us samples of their gelato! Ambiance: 4/5 The inside looked clean. There is a public restroom and a few small seats. I do wish there were bigger tables to eat at, but I know the space is limited. Overall: The selection is crazy here--you should definitely give this place a try! read more

Gelati & Peccati - Fresh Margherita Slice Pizza - Gelato Near Me - San Diego, California

See all

I don't think words are needed to describe perfection. The pizza is absolutely what I love. Great texture, taste, and creativity. The staff are extremely friendly. Christie is lovely. The restaurant establisment might be small but it is inviting. I particularly enjoy the decorations of pizza holders and ice cream cones on the wall. Loved everything about this place. Absolutely eat and enjoy this restaurant. read more

Gelati & Peccati - Tacchino & Margerita Pizza with a Diet Coke - Gelato Near Me - San Diego, California

Great Roman style slices, with crisp and airy crumb and delicious toppings. Recommend the meatball, piccante, mortadella, and diavola.

Incredibly friendly staff! Incredible pizza slices with a grey array of flavors and options! Bold and yet comforting. Awesome vibe and open late in North Park! This place has it all! read more

I love that it's open late night! Many great options for some pizza and also great gelato flavors! There is some indoor seating but it can be busy. Staff is super nice and service is quick read more

Gelati & Peccati - Gelato Near Me - San Diego, California

See all

Stumbled across this pizza and gelato spot while bar hopping in north park. WOW the pizza was amazing. There was a small line when we got here. It is open until 1am. Didn't remember which one I got but it was crispy and so much flavor and lots of ricotta cheese. Definitely coming back. read more

Gelati & Peccati - Gelato Near Me - San Diego, California

UPDATE. Was on a pizza hiatus from this place and I'm glad to be back. My first review of this place was when it first opened. I've been here countless of times for my pizza crave. But then the last visit (back in 2022) I refrained my business due to the fly issues inside the restaurant. Recap: there use to be a ton of flies, stepping on the pizza as you order, I had brought this to the staffs attention and got no kind of response. I messaged their IG account and was left on read. No response. I have returned after a 2-yr hiatus and saw a door screen - which does prevent those pesky flies from coming in and stepping all over the pizza! That made me happy. PIZZA tasted nearly the same but something about the quality went a little down. I ordered my two usual and they didn't wow me as they use to. In addition, I asked "no oil on the pizza" (they always add oil on the pizza after warming it up and serving) and they didn't listen. I got oil on my pizza. Still a good pizza, I love the crust and the variety of flavors. Gelato is amazing here. Quality just fell a hair short in my opinion. read more

See all

I stopped by to get ice cream next door and noticed this place. The pizzas displayed near the window looked so good, I had to try one! They sell by the slice as well as in combos. I got one slice of Lussuria (really two slices when they cut them) and was not disappointed. The place is nicely decorated and even has a complimentary self serve water station. I'm saving this spot and will try their gelato next time. Parking can be a little bit difficult here. read more

See all